Democrat Narrative Trump Was Rebuked on Mass Deportations Gets Blown Up by New Poll

Nov 20, 2026 9:45 PM
Premium
Advertisement
Democrat Narrative Trump Was Rebuked on Mass Deportations Gets Blown Up by New Poll
AP Photo/Yuki Iwamura, File
VIP

Democrats have spent the weeks since their sweeping midterm victory crowing that Americans rejected President Donald Trump's deportation agenda. 

This mischievous argument has become central to their plans for the next Congress, with incoming House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries promising to reverse the administration's immigration policies and pursue legislation providing amnesty to millions of illegal aliens.

But a new national poll reveals a considerably different picture of what Americans actually believe about deportations. The results suggest that Democrats may be interpreting their electoral victory as a mandate for immigration policies that much of the country still opposes.

According to the latest Economist/YouGov survey, conducted November 13–16 among 1,628 U.S. citizens, 51 percent of respondents supported deporting all or most immigrants who entered the country illegally, with certain exceptions depending on the respondent's position.

Specifically, 23 percent favored deporting all illegal aliens immediately, while another 28 percent supported deporting most, with exceptions for those married to Americans or who have lived in the country for years without criminal convictions.

Another 41 percent favored deporting only illegal aliens convicted of serious crimes. Just 7 percent believed everyone who entered illegally should be allowed to remain, regardless of circumstances.

Those numbers dent the misleading claim that Americans have abandoned their support for mass deportations following the midterms. A majority still favors removing most illegal aliens, and the position that nobody should be deported gets little support.

The partisan breakdown is revealing. Among Republicans, 47 percent favored immediately deporting everyone, while another 36 percent supported deporting most with limited exceptions. Combined, that amounts to 83 percent supporting broad deportations.

Among independents, 19 percent supported deporting everyone and another 28 percent supported removing most. That puts the combined figure at 47 percent, compared with 43 percent who favored deportations limited to serious criminals and 9 percent who wanted everyone allowed to remain.

Democrats held radically different views. Sixty-four percent favored deporting only those convicted of serious crimes, while 20 percent supported deporting most with exceptions and 6 percent supported deporting everyone. But only 11 percent wanted all illegal aliens to be allowed to remain.

The survey's complete tables also showed that support for broad deportations was especially prominent among older respondents and those identifying as politically conservative. That's not a surprise. Those are the people most likely to find the current version of America to be nearly unrecognizable culturally. 

These findings damage the Democrat Party's post-election messaging that treats the midterm results as evidence that Americans rejected immigration enforcement itself. That's not true. 

Most voters rejected the status quo and protest-voted against the current presidential administration and the party in power. It's a midterm tale as old as time.

Jeffries made that argument explicitly during a November 17 press conference, promising to move quickly on the Dream and Promise Act when Democrats assume control of Congress in January.

"I can guarantee you that if that doesn't happen, we're going to move the Dream and Promise Act in the next Congress, early in the next Congress," Jeffries told reporters.

He said the legislation would begin reversing what he called the Trump administration's "violent mass deportation machine," claiming that voters had rejected it in the midterms.

This is an egregiously deceptive argument: Border patrol and ICE are tasked with removing lawbreakers. That doesn't entail asking people nicely if they want to leave. If those people turn out to be criminals, there may be force involved. That doesn't make deportations inherently "violent." And it doesn't make ICE tantamount to "Nazis." You wonder how many double-digit IQ voters buy this concocted narrative.

The Dream and Promise Act would provide a route to legal status for certain immigrants brought to the United States as children and people holding temporary protected status. It is one of several immigration measures Democrats have identified as priorities following their election victory.

Another proposal goes further in changing how existing deportation orders would be enforced. House Democrats are introducing the Protect Our Neighbors Act, which would establish a 10-year expiration date on certain final removal orders and create a potential pathway to permanent residency for qualifying individuals.

Under the proposal, people who have remained continuously in the United States without criminal convictions could eventually qualify for green cards even after receiving final removal orders. Currently, those orders do not automatically expire simply because immigration authorities have failed to carry them out.

Former acting ICE Director Todd Lyons testified earlier this year that approximately 1.6 million people in the United States were subject to final removal orders. Not all would qualify under the proposed legislation, but the scale of outstanding orders illustrates the significance of changing how they operate.

But the notion that people are unhappy with deportations in general is a false one. If anything, many Trump voters want the actual pace of deportations to increase.

On November 12, Immigration and Customs Enforcement announced that it had carried out more than 491,000 immigration arrests and approximately 483,000 deportations during fiscal year 2026, the highest annual totals in the agency's history.

ICE said the deportation figure exceeded its previous annual record of approximately 443,000 and represented a substantial increase over the Biden administration's final fiscal year. The agency presented the results as evidence that Trump's enforcement policies were delivering on his 2024 campaign promises.

But at approximately 483,000 deportations per year, removing 20 million people would take more than 41 years. That is not exactly a brisk pace.

The AP reported that the enforcement surge coincided with public backlash over some immigration operations, including large deployments of federal officers and confrontations with protesters.

The recent polling shows that public backlash is a lot more limited than the Associated Propagandists are making out.

Recommended

Trending on RedState Videos