There is a saying that is often attributed to being an ancient Chinese curse (it probably isn't) but regardless of its origins, the warning it sends is very plain: "May you live in interesting times." Hard times are interesting, to be sure, most notably so when one is reading about them in a history book, as opposed to living through them. We are, though, living through some interesting times right now; the nations of the Western world, meaning much of Europe, North America, and some other places, like Australia and New Zealand, are seeing a mass influx of people from the Third World, mostly Africa and the Middle East. This is inevitably causing some conflicts. And there is one thing, one defining characteristic, that characterizes these people: Islam.
Radical Islam is an overt threat. Not since the days of the Spanish Inquisition have we seen a quasi-religious movement with so many adherents willing to convert people by force, and yet, many in the American left seem unable to understand the problem.
No, they are too busy looking for white supremacists and Christian nationalists.
The clash of civilizations is a clash of faiths, but well-educated modern Westerners have adopted a moral anthropology that deludes them about the nature of the conflict. For good Europeans and Americans, religion is voluntary and indifferent to the law. The law, and the state, is concerned with individuals and their rights. Liberal Westerners do not consider this a mere Western belief, however, but the natural order and aspiration of all humanity. Thus, for the college-educated Westerner, the contest is not between Islam and some rival religion; it’s rather a struggle between freedom and tyranny, and because tyranny is unnatural, once a tyrant like Saddam Hussein is removed—or a tyrannical regime like Iran’s—the result will be a liberal democracy wherein Islam will have the same status as Christianity has in the West today.
That's a key misconception, and it's not completely limited to the left: The notion that liberty and property, of a society where people have inalienable rights, not granted by government, but with which government is prohibited from infringe upon. But most of the world doesn't see things that way, and the Islamic world, most of all, doesn't see things that way.
This is a charmingly Eurocentric conceit. In fact, the Western way of life is neither humanity’s default condition nor its inexorable destiny. The West once took religion as seriously as the Islamic world still does. What changed the West were a series of catastrophic wars among Christians in the 16th and 17th centuries, along with the development of new political philosophies that grounded society and government in principles other than those of religion. Thomas Hobbes’ Leviathan, first published in 1651, was pivotal. Hobbes saw a war of all against all, driven by man’s natural vainglory—including pride in his religious opinions—as the original condition of the species. To preserve life, Hobbes argued that everyone, and everyone’s religious opinions, must submit to a supreme earthly territorial authority: what we now call the state.
A fair point. But the state isn't necessarily an overbearing, supreme earthly authority. Our own Constitution places some strict limits on government, limits that the political Left are trying to wipe away. That's the one inevitable fact of history: Every civilization, every attempt at a republic (Greece, Rome) has eventually either succumbed to foreign invaders or descended into tyranny.
The thing is, what's happening now in the Western world, in this fundamental conflict that we are seeing unfold, isn't a clash of religions, at least, not entirely. There is that aspect to it; the mostly (for now) Christian Western world contends with the mostly Muslim Middle East and North Africa. That is, as noted, the great flaw in the views of people in the Left in the Western world; they do see this as a religious conflict, at least to a degree, but the antipathies are all wrong. During the late, unlamented administration of Joe Biden, we saw millions flood in from majority-Muslim nations, many illegally; and during and since that time, we've heard the American Left continue to carry on in a state of panic over the notion that there is apparently a white supremacist or a Christian nationalist behind every tree.
This is not only wrong, it's wrong-headed. Even as we see the "Queers for Palestine" and related unserious people shouting in American streets, we see gay people in Gaza and Iran thrown off rooftops. Too many people in the civilized world cannot identify the source of the conflict we find ourselves in. The Left in the Western world seems to be making common cause with the Islamists, and that won't end well for them; we can see all too plainly what will happen to the leftists that the Islamists take as pets until the battle is decided.
Islamism is the threat. It has been for hundreds of years, and it's growing more so — and the nations of the Western world have opened the gates.
I've been saying it and writing it for years. This is not and will not be a clash of civilizations. It's a clash of civilization vs. barbarity. It's a fundamental clash for liberty and property on the one hand, and slavery and oppression on the other, and it doesn't take a great intellect to understand what happens if the barbarians win.
We are, I think, approaching a Fourth Turning. The next few years may well set the course for humanity for the next century. And the modern world, the civilized world, will have the scales removed from its eyes one way or another.