In recent years, a lot of digital ink has been spilled over the issue of allowing "transgender girls/women" - by which I mean, boys and men — to compete in girls' and women's sports competitions. The practice is brutally unfair to the girls and women involved, and the pushback, nationwide, is considerable and growing. Even in the blue wave midterm election we just underwent, at least four ballot initiatives barring this practice passed, in blue states, no less — and some of those state governments are already trying to figure out ways to subvert the will of the people.
In California, a state that proudly allows and even promotes this practice, the people of the Chino Valley Unified School District are pushing back as well, and what's more, they are openly defying the once-Golden State's Attorney General to do anything about it.
The Chino Valley Unified School District Board of Education approved a policy this week barring transgender athletes from participating in girls' sports.
California officials are pushing back.
The San Bernardino County district's policy blocks transgender students from competing on girls' teams and using girls' bathrooms and locker rooms. The policy also prohibits biological boys and girls from sharing hotel rooms during school-sponsored trips.
The vote came during the Southern California school board’s final meeting with Sonja Shaw serving as board president.
Shaw ran for California superintendent of public instruction and has been a huge opponent of transgender athletes competing in girls' sports. She continues to urge the state government and the California Interscholastic Federation to follow the federal law of Title IX to protect girls in sports.
California's state government itself is in defiance of President Trump's Executive Order 14201, which states in part:
...under Title IX of the Education Amendments Act of 1972 (Title IX), educational institutions receiving Federal funds cannot deny women an equal opportunity to participate in sports. As some Federal courts have recognized, "ignoring fundamental biological truths between the two sexes deprives women and girls of meaningful access to educational facilities." Tennessee v. Cardona, 24-cv-00072 at 73 (E.D. Ky. 2024). See also Kansas v. U.S. Dept. of Education, 24-cv-04041 at 23 (D. Kan. 2024) (highlighting "Congress' goals of protecting biological women in education").
This EO and related measures are still being fought out in the courts, and it's a sure thing that this California case will, as well. Sonja Shaw, in fact, made a show of tearing up a letter from the AG's office warning them against taking this radical step of, you know, not allowing boys to compete in girls' sports.
Ahead of the vote, state Deputy Attorney General Edward Nugent wrote a letter Wednesday on behalf of Democratic Attorney General Rob Bonta, urging the board to reject the proposal. Nugent argued the policy conflicts with California law.
“The Board should reject the proposal, or at the very least, delay the vote,” Nugent wrote.
Shaw argued that the policy ensures student privacy and safety. Shaw ripped up Nugent's letter during Thursday night's board meeting.
“I made a commitment when I was elected to stand up for the rights of girls. As long as I am a voting member of this board, I intend to honor it,” Shaw told The Center Square on Friday.
That's exactly what she's doing; standing up for the rights of girls. Now, the other side of this will wail about the "rights of transgender girls," that is to say, boys; that's a canard. These kids, who are boys by any scientific measure no matter how they dress or "identify," have exactly the same opportunities as any other young athlete — to compete in the league corresponding to their sex, which was determined genetically at conception. Another argument for California's policy is easily shot down; a genetic determination doesn't require an invasive physical exam, just a cheek swab. Millions and millions of Americans were expected to meekly submit to much more invasive testing than this during the COVID-19 scare.
Now, it seems certain there will be a legal battle over this, and we can only hope that the Chino Valley Unified School District Board of Education stays the course. They are doing the right thing, and it's worth fighting for.
Here's the argument of the other side:
“Unfortunately, in Chino Valley, the queer and trans communities do not have a voice. They will not be invited to the table … This is an attempt to continue to silence voices of the queer and trans community,” Frank Guzman, CEO and president of Pomona Valley Pride, told The Center Square.
Guzman also questioned the district's legal authority to implement the policy.
“I fully anticipate that the attorney general will challenge this, and that they will win because, unfortunately, Chino Valley repeatedly defies the law. And yet they're never being held responsible for that,” Guzman said. “I think that message was loud and clear through the election process, that the constituents want something different. They want new leadership for that district.”
Utter drivel and goo. These people have precisely the same voice as anyone else: The vote. The school boards are elected, and in this case, they are expressing the concern of the parents of girls who find themselves facing boys on the athletic fields — and in the locker rooms. The AG's office is already challenging this, but this will, I believe, ultimately fail. There is too much science on the side of sanity; there are physical and biological realities that cannot be denied, no matter how much people like Frank Guzman cry out otherwise.
Facts are stubborn things. In this argument, all the facts are on the side of sanity — the side of keeping boys out of girls' sports.