The Atheist Dodge

Nov 16, 2026 5:00 PM
Premium
Advertisement
The Atheist Dodge
AP Photo/Petros Karadjias
VIP

I used to spend a lot of time on Reddit. Years ago, it truly was the front page of the internet. Any news, opinion, meme, or interesting creation funneled through Reddit before it became mainstream in any regard. However, Reddit became so unbelievably soaked in leftism thanks to lopsided moderation that you could not venture into any subreddit without someone making anything about leftist politics. 

Not even the Bluey subreddit was safe. 

Nowadays, Reddit has become something of a meme in and of itself. It's now known as a nest of unapologetic and unrestrained leftism, so much so that you can always tell when a Redditor has entered any given conversation online because they sport two characteristics. The first is rabid leftism, and the second is militant atheism. You don't need to be right-leaning or even Christian to loathe their arrival into any discussion. You can hear the groans of others from miles away.

In any case, they've come to be the common caricature of atheists today. Pseudo-intellectual, arrogant, condescending, and actively looking for a Christian to mock. The funny thing about them is that these militant atheists (or anti-theists, as I'll describe them from here on) are way more evangelical about their beliefs than even the most fervent Christian. They're included in that joke about walking into a bar for a reason:

A vegan, an atheist, and a crossfitter walk into a bar. I know what they were because they told everyone in the first two minutes.

If you try to point out that they're far more fanatical and borderline religious about their anti-theism, they'll lose their minds. They'll immediately fire back that atheism isn't a religion because they lack belief, then call you stupid. I've been in this situation many times, and I was recently in said position again after I said atheism is one of the most fanatical and faith-based religions there is. 

I'll let you peruse the responses yourself, but they all follow the same line as I described. To highlight my point, however, I simply asked an atheist to prove God doesn't exist, to which I got quite a few more condescending responses telling me that the burden of proof is on the Christian, not the atheist, to prove any fact about the existence of a God. 

I call this the "atheist dodge," and it's another reason I can't find myself getting on board with the idea that there isn't a creator. 

The atheist dodge is, at its core, nonsensical. "Atheist" is Latin for "without God," which is somewhat declarative in terms of an ideological label. To adopt the label, you have to be of the mind that there is no god, which is a pretty definitive position to take. So, to take said position, you have to have very solid reasoning to believe that. 

The problem for anti-theists is that they've got a massive hurdle to overcome to take that position. They claim to base all of their beliefs on proven science, which, for starters, is a very slim column of info compared to what we don't know about our universe. They effectively limit themselves to a small amount of information that, from time to time, shifts with our growing understanding of the universe. 

Now, that massive hole of knowledge is a problem because it leaves a ton of room for the existence of a creator. Moreover, what we do know also leaves a ton of room for the existence of a creator. A god (whatever name you give it) could very well exist, and there are a ton of scientific circumstances where one would have to, including some very glaring ones such as "How did something come from nothing?" and "How did the universe defy the odds to get sentient, intelligent life?" 

Christians have faith (and can reasonably conclude) that there is a creator, but the anti-theist doesn't have the benefit of faith on an argumentative level. They've rejected all connections to faith when it comes to cosmic ideas, yet they know for certain that there is no god. An agnostic has the more honest position of saying, "I don't know if one exists," but that's not what the anti-theist's position is. There is definitely no God according to them. 

So you ask them to prove it, and in comes the dodge. 

They can't prove it. Too much opens up for the existence of a creator, and they don't have the information necessary to make their position concrete. Their only recourse is to declare that they don't have to prove the non-existence of a God they don't believe in, and it's up to the Christian to prove God does exist. 

This is effectively saying they are exempt from the debate of ideas or having to prove their positions. In fact, by putting all the burden of proof on everyone else, they've elected themselves judge and jury over everyone else's ideas. They decide what is true, so offer your evidence! 

I'll save you time. Your evidence will never be enough. They're not driven by truth, but I'll tell you what the dirty truth about anti-theism is. 

They have more faith in their atheism than you ever will in God. C.S. Lewis once said that an atheist can never be too careful in his reading, and it's true. Stumble across the wrong question or piece of information, and you'll fall into one of the many logical holes that point to a creator. You will stumble across the inevitable, which, at the very least, would force an honest person to admit that there very well could be a God. 

The anti-theist has seen them. He's fallen into a few. That's why he can't, under any circumstances, engage in the idea of proof. His entire ideological position would fall apart immediately. 

It's best for the atheist to just dodge. 

News Topics CHRISTIANITY | FAITH | SCIENCE

Recommended

Trending on RedState Videos