Megyn Kelly spoke to top urologist Dr. David Samadi about former President Joe Biden's shocking, aggressive prostate cancer diagnosis, who pointed to one part in the announcement that puts the timing into question.

During the Sirius XM "The Megyn Kelly Show" podcast, Kelly asked about comments made by oncologist Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel, who said on "Morning Joe" that Biden's form of cancer doesn't just "develop in the last 100, 200 days." 

Dr. Samadi not only agreed with Dr. Ezekiel that it likely wasn't just discovered, but said the comment in Biden's cancer statement, about it being "hormone sensitive," proves the diagnosis can't be new. 

"This has been cooking for many years, and someone like him, he's had at least 30 to 40 years of PSA (Prostate Specific Antigen) history," Dr. Samadi said, as he explained a patient can go on for "many years" as long as the "hormone is sensitive." Otherwise, he said the patient has to undergo chemotherapy, where the outcomes are "very poor." 

WATCH THIS: RENOWNED PROSTATE CANCER DOC @drdavidsamadi SAYS THE STATEMENT ON BIDEN’S CANCER HAS A ‘TELL’ THAT HE’S BEEN GETTING TREATMENT FOR MUCH LONGER THAN ONE WEEK. pic.twitter.com/KeMGsOKlZL

— Megyn Kelly (@megynkelly) May 19, 2025

"So, if it was just a week ago, they had the prostate nodule, within a week, they did the biopsy, and they got the disease so very quickly, within all one week, based on the story that they're telling, they've been able to do the staging part and find out if the cancer is spread to the bone or not, but you have to give the injections and see if the patient responds," he added.

"We don't know what his PSA is," Dr. Samadi continued. "If the PSA starts to go down, then that's when you know that he's hormonal sensitive. I don't know how they will be able to give all of this information, from diagnosis to treatment, to all of that within one week. This story doesn't make any sense. I got so many phone calls and questions about the fact that how can someone be great a year ago and within a year he will have stage 4 with metastasis..."

Dr. Emanuel on MSNBC said that Biden likely has had the cancer since the start of his presidency in 2021.

As our sister site Townhall reported:

"Oh yeah. [Biden] did not develop it in the last 100, 200 days. He had it while he was president, he said. "He probably had it at the start of his presidency in 2021. Yes, I don't think there's any disagreement about that." 

Biden was the president of the United States. The health of this person is checked every year. He's at an age where a prostate exam is done annually. Did the White House medical staff not know or miss this? Doubtful. Emanuel isn't a fan of the test regarding accuracy, but he also added that if Biden had taken it, there would've been obvious signs of trouble (via RCP):

A group of top medical experts also cast doubt on the timing of recent somber news involving Biden's diagnosis, as RedState reported: 

Dr. Howie Forman, a professor of radiology and biomedical imaging, public health management and economics at Yale, finds it "inconceivable" that this aggressive cancer was not being followed before Biden left office.

Forman indicated that the cancer being at this advanced stage would have been monitored "for some time before this diagnosis."