Premium

The Distasteful and Unseemly Calls and Jokes for 'Proof of Life' on Mitch McConnell Should Stop

AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite

The ill health and decline of Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-KY) have been the subject of inquiry and conspiracy, with very little concern for his years of public service or his dignity. After McConnell was rushed to the hospital on June 14 after what was reported as a cardiac arrest, McConnell remains hospitalized, and the mystery surrounding why, along with the number of people clamoring for answers, has ramped up considerably. The senator's staff and family have chosen to remain opaque about his condition, so the internet has gone crazy with conspiracy theories, independent investigations not based in fact, and parody/humor, much of it beyond the pale.

It is clear that Mitch McConnell and his wife, former Secretary of Transportation Elaine Chao, don't want to be transparent. Agreeing or disagreeing with that is perfectly fine and warranted. Making a mockery of a man who is seriously ill or potentially on his deathbed is just downright gross.

As RedState reported, due to these recent internet conspiracies about McConnell and the state of his life and health, Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-SD), Senate Majority Whip John Barrasso (R-WY), and political consultant and close friend of McConnell, commentator Scott Jennings, issued X posts on Tuesday with similar updates on McConnell's health.

As far as I am concerned, it should have been left at that until we hear otherwise. Instead, it has inflamed more suspicion, bad jokes, and even greater craziness. Like this one from a very knowledgeable influencer with the handle of "So Cal Irish Girl."

Mmmkay....

Reports are that Mitch McConnell is brain dead and being kept “alive“ on machines… Goal: To screw President Trump on the SAVE act… It makes sense now why his wife Elaine Chao fled the country to China. They must’ve paid her pretty well to leave… What kind of blows my mind is the old friend of Mitch McConnell Scott Jennings (CNN) … I don’t watch that channel. Jennings is actually all in and reciting the same lie that about six other people have recited since the beginning of the week.!! 

It all has to do with a bill and screwing America! 

@LeaderJohnThune @SenJohnBarrasso

 And others have all had pretend 20-mins conversations with someone impersonating Mitch… (Brit Hume can sound like Mitch McConnell I bet!!) or… who is impersonating him…. 

I also heard this morning that Mitch McConnell’s daughter his oldest daughter… Has completely deleted her X account… Scrubbed it clean before deleting it… Why would she do that?

Why hasn’t she putting an update to his health? To let All his followers know that he’s doing well… 

Well enough to talk incessantly with several people while in the ICU!

IDK any hospital that would allow a patient in the ICU … with tubes down their throat in the hospital for a month to talk on the phone for 20 minutes several times a day!! 

#biglie

Those "reports" about brain death came specifically from Laura Loomer. The other stuff is the conspiracy theories pushed by most of the right-wing influencers who want to balloon their X payments. None of these revelations are based on any credible evidence. 


Read More: The Only Thing More Mysterious Than McConnell's Illness Is His Wife's Jaunt to China to Meet With the CCP

The Rumors on Mitch McConnell's Condition Have Been Greatly Exaggerated


Facts: Consistent bits of information from McConnell's family or staff, even as little as McConnell is resting comfortably and doctors are attending to him, would have avoided much of this. For whatever reason, McConnell, Elaine Chao, or his staffers decided they did not want to go that route. 

That, again, is their choice. McConnell sits on three Senate committees: Appropriations, Agriculture, Nutrition and Forestry, and he chairs the Rules Committee. The last meeting of the Rules Committee was in December, and from my brief perusal, there are no urgent or life-threatening decisions being placed on hold due to McConnell's absence. 

I am all for health transparency when it comes to the president, heads of state or a city, the military, and law enforcement. A chain of command and order must be maintained, people need to know who is in charge, and informing the public about any health change, concern, or incident is part of maintaining safety and the public trust. This is why the 2024 disappearance of President Joe Biden's Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin was dangerous and especially egregious. Austin was hospitalized for five days for treatment of prostate cancer, but didn't bother to inform the White House that this was happening. What made it even worse is that Kathleen Hicks, the Deputy Secretary of Defense who should have taken up the reins while Austin was incapacitated, was on vacation in Puerto Rico. This was a legitimate clutch-the-pearls and demand accountability moment. Sadly, neither the legacy media nor the White House thought this was of any great concern.

But in terms of national or local congresspeople and senators? They are not under obligation to regularly update the general public on their health. KY Gov. Andy Beshear has requested McConnell's office update his constituents on his health status, and that is appropriate, because McConnell serves the people of Kentucky.

On Wednesday, Gov. Andy Beshear sent a letter to the office of U.S. Sen. Mitch McConnell requesting an update on his health and well-being amid growing concerns around the Senator’s ability to serve.

“Over the last several weeks, Kentuckians have grown increasingly concerned about the health and well-being of Sen. McConnell. As Governor – and a fellow public official who understands the commitment we’ve made to the people we serve – I am requesting the Senator provide an update on his current health status,” said Gov. Beshear. “Allowing speculation to continue in the media is not fair to the Senator or to Kentuckians, and my hope is that this provides him the opportunity to share the information in a transparent manner, direct from the source. I wish him a safe and speedy recovery.”

But even with this inquiry by Gov. Beshear and the updates given by the GOP leaders to whom McConnell directly sits under and a close friend, people continue to remain unhinged, froth at the mouth about accountability, and are getting downright nasty. 

Most surprising was the response from Meghan McCain, media personality and daughter of the late Sen. John McCain (R-AZ). It was a while ago, but in 2017, McCain was diagnosed with a glioblastoma brain tumor. McCain was a gadfly and a showman who loved the spectacle of public office and used it to his advantage. So, it was no surprise that he made his diagnosis and his treatment very public. Despite being out of pocket for the last eight months of his life, McCain remained a sitting senator until his 2018 death. 

McConnell is not McCain, and he is acting from his own desire for dignity and privacy. It has been apparent, especially as McConnell's health has quickly declined, that he did not like being a public spectacle. Since resigning from Senate leadership in 2024, McConnell has remained in the background and off camera as much as possible.

Daughter McCain first put out a snarky post along the lines of the jokes surrounding McConnell's health. Bad Jennifer: I saw it, but didn't make a screenshot, so I cannot confirm exact wording. But know that it wasn't particularly funny or nice.

In light of John McCain's health history, former staffer to McConnell and co-host of the "Ruthless" podcast Josh Holmes rightly called Meghan McCain out on it, reminding her how McConnell treated her father.

WOW. McCain was immediately chastised, deleted her post, and then apologized. But not without making further comments about her family's choice to disclose their father's condition.

But that's the point: It was their choice to make, and it fully aligned with McCain's and his daughter's very high public profile. Once McConnell stepped away from GOP leadership, for the most part, he stayed away from the limelight. Beyond his Senate legacy, he is essentially just another sitting senator.

McCain then opined about her regrets since Sen. McCain has passed and her sincerity that she hopes Sen. McConnell is doing alright.   

McCain concluded the matter thusly:

Does he? I disagree. The only people who can legally release health information or "proof of life" are the senator himself or his designated family, and for whatever reason, they have chosen not to. That is their right, and just because you are a formerly high-profile senator doesn't mean you can't attempt to maintain your dignity or your privacy.

I do agree that all this is macabre and unseemly, mostly in part to the way others are acting and reacting to it. But bad for democracy and embarrassing? That's for the citizens of Kentucky and the Senate GOP leaders to decide. 

Recommended

Trending on RedState Videos