Jessica Walton says her eyebrow appointment at Karimi Brows in Alexandria ended when the owner, Fatana Karimi, told her to leave. Walton is Jewish and Israeli-American. Karimi later posted part of the argument herself.
Walton said she and Karimi had spent much of the appointment talking about Afghanistan. Walton had recently finished a novel partly set there and told Karimi about the Afghans she had interviewed, as well as their shared interest in Afghan poetry and food.
— Gary Weiss (@gary_weiss) August 15, 2026
The trouble started, Walton said, after she described the novel's Jewish half-Israeli character and mentioned that she was Jewish and half-Israeli herself.
Karimi told her to leave, according to Walton.
"Get out of my shop."
"Excuse me?"
"I can't provide service to an Israeli. It's against my political beliefs. You need to leave immediately."
Walton says Karimi also told her there was “no such thing as Israel” and described Israel as Palestine stolen by Jews. Karimi's own video starts later, after the two women were already arguing, so those remarks aren't on the clip.
Writer Gary Weiss posted Walton's account Friday and also pointed to the video Karimi had released from the salon.
The shop owner is proud of her behavior. https://t.co/NmUM1DNGhb
— Gary Weiss (@gary_weiss) August 15, 2026
In the video, Karimi tells Walton that she had signed a photo-video release. A few seconds later, Karimi says Walton “kept saying Israel” and was “talking about politics.” Walton says she thought they had been talking about Afghanistan.
KARIMI: "You can defend it as much as you want, but this is my business."
WALTON: "That's totally fine. But you should give me my deposit back. And if you don't, I'm going to have to take legal action."
StopAntisemitism picked up the story and posted video of the encounter, describing it as a Jewish customer being thrown out over her ethnicity. The group also offered to help Walton find legal representation.
Fatana Karimi, owner of Karimi Brows in Alexandria VA, kicks out a Jewish client over her Israeli ethnicity.
— StopAntisemitism (@StopAntisemites) August 15, 2026
Attorneys - our DM’s are open, we’re happy to connect you with the victim! pic.twitter.com/0hf9reDAtA
Karimi posted her own version on the business's social media. In it, she accused Walton of “forcing heavy political debates” and said she had repeatedly asked to keep the conversation neutral.
Karimi also uploaded a longer video explaining why she ended the appointment.
In that video, Karimi says she tried several times to get the conversation back to eyebrows. She says Walton kept returning to Afghanistan, including 9/11 and Afghan political figures, before the discussion eventually got to Israel.
Karimi said Walton told her about the two main characters in her novel, a Muslim Afghan refugee and the son of Jewish immigrants. Karimi says she liked the premise, but told Walton:
"Everything sounds beautiful except for the Israeli part."
Walton later mentioned that she was Israeli-American herself. Karimi said she initially ignored it because some Israelis oppose the Israeli government.
The argument eventually turned to whether Israel is committing genocide in Gaza. Karimi ended the appointment.
She later explained what Walton could have said instead:
"It would be different if you said something like, 'Yes, there is a genocide. I don't support what the Israeli government is doing.' Yeah, I would have slid by."
Walton could have stayed if she had agreed with Karimi on that point.
Karimi also mentioned she had an Instagram post saying she wouldn't serve Israel supporters, and there's a "Free Palestine" sticker in the salon. Walton says she never saw either before she booked.
Karimi's official site says the business exists to provide personalized eyebrow tattoo services in the D.C. area. The mission statement promises that anyone in the chair will leave with "confidence, hope, and feeling of sisterhood/family." The site lists men, women, LGBTQ+ customers, and "anyone" as the clientele.
Apparently, "anyone" needed some clarification.
Read More: Jewish Michigan AG Says She Is Unsafe at Her Own Democratic Convention
Virginia law bars discrimination in public accommodations based on religion and national or ethnic origin, among other categories. It applies to businesses offering goods or services to the public. Whether Walton pursues a complaint over what happened at Karimi Brows is a separate question.
Walton said she asked for her deposit back after the appointment ended. Her bank refunded the money after she disputed the charge. She also said she planned to contact civil rights organizations in the D.C. area.
Karimi's own explanation was that Walton “would have slid by” if she had agreed there was a genocide and said she did not support the Israeli government.
Editor's Note: Do you enjoy RedState's conservative reporting that takes on the radical left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth.
Join RedState VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member