The safety of America's roadways has raised concerns in recent years, including reports of fatal accidents involving foreign truck drivers, in the wake of years of lax regulation of illegal immigrants receiving commercial driver's licenses (CDLs) under the Biden administration. While not every incident has led to deaths, some victims and their families have taken to court the brokers who pay trucking companies to haul their freight.
READ MORE
Deadly ‘Chameleon Carrier’ Scam Exposed After Illegal Alien Trucker Kills Amish Family Members
Update: More Illegal Immigrant Truck Drivers Nabbed by DOT After Latest Deadly Crash
A ruling issued by the Supreme Court on Thursday might lead to stricter standards within the industry:
BREAKING: The Supreme Court just issued an UNANIMOUS 9-0 ruling that freight brokers can be sued if they negligently hire companies with risky trucking practices.
— Libs of TikTok (@libsoftiktok) May 14, 2026
Time for companies to be held accountable for putting foreign truck drivers on U.S. roads. pic.twitter.com/YVq0b4dekE
In Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II LLC, the Court ruled that freight brokers could be held liable:
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled Thursday that freight brokers accused of hiring unsafe trucking companies can be sued after deadly crashes, a decision that could reshape accountability across the trucking industry.
— WFAA (@wfaa) May 14, 2026
https://t.co/UKEMZoeJrq
Here's what we know about the Court's decision:
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled unanimously Thursday that freight brokers accused of hiring unsafe trucking companies can be sued after deadly crashes, a decision that could reshape accountability across the trucking industry.
...
In Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC, the Supreme Court ruled that federal law does not block state lawsuits against freight brokers that arrange shipments with trucking companies involved in crashes.
At issue was the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act, or FAAAA, a federal deregulation law that the trucking industry has long argued protects brokers from liability in state courts.
Justice Amy Coney Barrett, writing for a unanimous court, said states still have the authority to regulate safety involving motor vehicles.
“A claim that one company negligently hired another to transport goods is not preempted by the FAAAA because States retain authority to regulate safety ‘with respect to motor vehicles’ under the Act,” Barrett wrote.
Justice Kavanaugh authored a concurring opinion, joined by Justice Alito:
Justice Brett Kavanaugh, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, wrote separately to say the case was “close,” but concluded Congress did not clearly eliminate those state-law claims. Kavanaugh acknowledged brokers’ concerns that increased litigation and insurance costs could ripple through the economy, but said the law still allows those lawsuits to proceed.
The case involved an accident in 2017, and the ensuing lawsuit a man who suffered serious injuries filed against the freight broker:
The case grew out of a 2017 crash in Illinois in which Shawn Montgomery lost part of his leg after a semi-truck struck his parked tractor-trailer. Montgomery sued freight broker C.H. Robinson, alleging the company negligently hired Caribe Transport despite safety concerns tied to the carrier.
The Supreme Court reversed a lower court ruling that had dismissed the claim.
The decision could have broad implications across the trucking industry as families involved in deadly crashes increasingly argue brokers should share responsibility when they hire carriers with histories of safety violations.
SiriusXM podcaster "The Dr. Phil of Trucking" provided a helpful breakdown on what he considered the good, the bad, and the ugly from the SCOTUS ruling for the industry:
🚨 SCOTUS just shook freight to its core.
— The Dr. Phil of Trucking (@dr_phil_truckn) May 14, 2026
Today the Supreme Court ruled 9-0 in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC… and with one decision, the rules of broker liability just changed.
Translation?
If you hire the truck……and that truck should’ve never been hired……and… pic.twitter.com/MvJp9YXwwv
🚨 SCOTUS just shook freight to its core.
Today the Supreme Court ruled 9-0 in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC… and with one decision, the rules of broker liability just changed.
Translation?
If you hire the truck……and that truck should’ve never been hired……and somebody gets hurt…
You may now get sued.
Full stop.
Here’s the GOOD, BAD, and UGLY of what just hit freight:
✅ THE GOOD safe carriers finally have leverage.
Clean inspections.
Clean safety records.
Real compliance.
Real maintenance.
“Cheapest truck wins” just took a punch to the mouth.
⚠️ THE BAD small carriers with a blemish?Brokers may pass.
One old crash.
One messy inspection.
One paperwork issue.
Could now cost you freight.
💀 THE UGLY Every broker email…Every carrier setup…Every “just cover the load” conversation…
Could now become courtroom evidence.
Insurance gets tighter.Contracts get nastier.Plaintiff attorneys just found deeper pockets.
My hot take?
This may do more to clean up trucking than 10 years of enforcement…
Or…
It may squeeze the little guy harder than ever.
Brokers…Carriers…Shippers…Insurers…
Are we about to see safer freight…
Or the biggest consolidation wave trucking has ever seen?
👇 I want the real people of trucking weighing in.
Who wins?
Who gets crushed?
Who’s next?
My guess...Shipper accountability is coming!!!
pay up!
With the Supreme Court weighing in, as the WFAA-TV reporting linked above notes, the case will go back to lower courts for proceedings consistent with the opinion, but the decision will impact litigation nationwide, since it removes the freight brokerage industry’s federal preemption defense:
The decision resolves a split among federal appeals courts. The Seventh and Eleventh Circuits had ruled that brokers were protected from those claims, while the Sixth and Ninth Circuits allowed them to proceed.
Whatever ends up happening, it's hoped that the ruling will help improve the safety of Americans on the road:
THANK YOU to the Supreme Court for protecting the rights of American families! The conservative court unanimously ruled this morning that brokers can be held accountable for hiring negligent trucking companies. Not only is this important for keeping families safe on the road,…
— Forward Lousiana (@goforwardLA) May 14, 2026
You can read the full opinion here.
Editor's Note: Do you enjoy RedState's conservative reporting that takes on the radical left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth.
Join RedState VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member