Welcome to coverage of the 105th week of Putin's splendid little war.
There isn't a lot to talk about this week. The lines are mostly stable. The gains made by the Russians are those I predicted two weeks ago.
The death of Alexei Navalny is creating photo ops in Russia.
BACKGROUND: Alexei Navalny's Death in a Prison Camp Was a Message From Putin to the World and to Russia
the courage required to show up for navalny’s funeral is worth our appreciation
— ian bremmer (@ianbremmer) March 1, 2024
pic.twitter.com/M75uoNHexp
one day after the funeral, thousands of russians lining up to lay flowers at navalny’s grave. dozens of arrests notwithstanding.
— ian bremmer (@ianbremmer) March 2, 2024
my respect and appreciation for their independence and courage. https://t.co/e9hFF02XLn
The Ukraine funding saga is still perking in Congress. It will more likely than not be resolved by March 22, when the Defense Department's continuing resolution will be passed.
BACKGROUND: Continuing Resolutions Frustrate Republicans and Call Speaker Johnson's Ability to Lead Into Question
The situation remains at a stalemate for the time being, but I don't think that will continue for much longer.
Here are some of my past updates.
Putin's War, Week 104. Second Anniversary of the 72-Hour Special Military Operation
Putin's War, Week 103. Avdiivka Abandoned
Putin's War, Week 102. Zaluzhny Is Out, Syrsky Is In, and the Ukraine Aid Bill Advances
Putin's War, Week 100. Missing Prisoners, Hungary on the Hotspot, and Shell Hunger Returns
Putin's War, Week 99. Not All Battlefields Are in Ukraine
Putin's War, Week 97. The Missile War Continues
Putin's War, Week 96. Blowback From a Sunk Ship as Russia Launches Largest Missile Attack of the War
Putin's War, Week 95. The Russian Air Force Takes a Beating as Disease Rips Through the Russian Army
For all my Ukraine War coverage, click here.
Politico-Strategic Level
Israel Takes a Side
Israeli UN Ambassador Gilad Erdan didn't leave much to the imagination in this speech to the UN General Assembly. He directly equated Russia's behavior in Ukraine with that of Hamas. He pointed out that the same drones that are attacking US shipping in the Red Sea and killing US troops in Syria are killing Ukrainian civilians. The one bit of his speech was the announcement that Israel is sending missile early warning systems to Ukraine. I'd bet those will be part of Iron Dome systems.
Extraordinary!
— (((Tendar))) (@Tendar) February 27, 2024
Israel’s ambassador to the UN, Gilad Erdan, delivered a speech in which he totally torched Russia. He not only announced that Israel is going to provide an early warning systems against missiles for Ukraine but also called Ukraine an “ally”. He also equates Russia… https://t.co/sA3a6DnKrr pic.twitter.com/HbrvawXxr8
The Israel-Hamas War has burned down the efforts of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to maintain good relations with Russia. Israel has only provided humanitarian aid to Ukraine, and Putin acquiesced to Israeli air strikes inside Russia's zone of interest in Syria. The war has allowed Russia to raise its profile in the region; for instance, a Hamas delegation was feted in Moscow. For more details, read "Netanyahu has finally realized Russia is no friend of Israel."
Solzhenitsyn Was Right
Thursday, Putin gave a speech to the Russian Federal Assembly addressing his war in Ukraine.
💬 President #Putin:
— MFA Russia 🇷🇺 (@mfa_russia) February 29, 2024
We did not start the war in Donbass, but we will do everything to end it, to eradicate Nazism and to protect our sovereignty and ensure security of our citizens.
🔗 https://t.co/4tgA8OPfVE pic.twitter.com/lOyOBpWwfc
This reference to "the war in Donbass" refers to the current war, not the war Russia started in 2014.
Soviet dissident Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn described the relationship between the citizens of the USSR and the government in this way.
We know that they are lying, they know that they are lying, they even know that we know they are lying, we also know that they know we know they are lying too, they of course know that we certainly know they know we know they are lying too as well, but they are still lying. In our country, the lie has become not just moral category, but the pillar industry of this country.
Some things never change.
Et tu, Tucker?
On the subject of "denazification," Putin seems to have lost the support of some of his most vocal backers in the West.
I guess Tucker Carlson isn't pleased with Putin's criticism of the interview and isn't planning to return to Russia anytime soon. Tucker said that Putin's claim that Russia is embroiled in the "denazification" of Ukraine is "one of the dumbest things" he had ever heard. pic.twitter.com/UNeqJfm2zx
— Julia Davis (@JuliaDavisNews) February 29, 2024
Several thoughts come to mind. First, denazification was one of the goals established by Putin on the day of the invasion. Has it taken Carlson two years to arrive at this conclusion? Second, why is the concept "one of the dumbest things" he had ever heard now, and he didn't say jack sh** about it to the guy saying it? Third, how much of this is related to Putin's put-down of their interview rather than any objection to the term "denazification?"
Speaking to Russian state TV, Putin said he had thought Carlson was a dangerous person, “because I honestly thought he would be aggressive and ask so-called sharp questions. And I wasn’t just ready for that, I wanted it, because it would have given me the opportunity to respond sharply in kind … But he chose a different tactic.”
Sweden Prepares to Send Gripen Fighters to Ukraine
Ukrainian pilots began training on the Swedish Gripen fighter in the late summer of 2023.
Sweden has linked the transfer of the Gripen to Ukraine to two events. First, other NATO countries have authorized the transfer of combat aircraft to Ukraine. Second, Sweden's accession into NATO. The US authorized the transfer of F-16s to Ukraine last year, and this week, Sweden cleared its last obstacle to NATO membership.BACKGROUND: Sweden Joins NATO After Hungary's Obstruction Abruptly Ends
The JAS 39 Gripen is designed to operate from roads with minimal offboard support with Meteor missiles. It was designed to fight Russia. It is a great fit for Ukraine and will definitely do well if Sweden ever provides them https://t.co/2hv1LaW5Lw
— Michael Bohnert (@mbohnert) February 27, 2024
Sweden has a lot of pressure to send Gripens to Ukraine sooner rather than later.
Compare and contrast the speed of the training program of Ukrainian pilots of the Gripen to those being trained on the F-16. The difference is not due to the F-16 being more sophisticated; the difference is a deliberate decision by Jake Sullivan and the other f***wits running our national security to slow-roll the training.
Operational Level
Biden Ponders Emergency Aid
Multiple sources report that Biden's national security midwits are considering using the remaining $4 billion in Presidential Drawdown Authority to send equipment and ammunition to Ukraine. This authority was approved by Congress last fiscal year but has not expired.
As Congress dithers on #Ukraine aid, DoD is considering using its $4.2B in leftover presidential drawdown authority, @NatashaBertrand & @OrenCNN reported today.@MarkCMontgomery & I explain why that's a good idea in this recent @defense_news op-ed:https://t.co/4a4emj80Ia
— John Hardie (@JohnH105) February 29, 2024
Russian Airstrikes Accelerate
The progress made by the Russian Army in Avdiivka and north of Bakhmut has been largely due to a marked increase in strike sorties supporting those operations. The primary weapon used is the 1100-pound FAB 500 gravity bomb equipped with the Russian knockoff of a US JDAM kit. This gives the bomb extended range and something that can be described as accuracy.
Many of 🇺🇦Ukraine's defence lines were deep, extensive & built over the past 10 years. One key stronghold that fell recently to 🇷🇺Russia was Avdeevka. It got blasted by hundreds of these FAB-500 bombs by 🇷🇺 (+ likely some bigger ones, 1000kg, etc). Much more of this to come! https://t.co/fDrNcVgWlQ
— Tony Norfield (@StubbornFacts) February 29, 2024
More Bad Days for the Russian Air Force
The Russian Air Force has lost a strike aircraft nearly every day for the last two weeks.
💥 Two more Russian Su-34s striker bombers shot down by Ukraine.
— Igor Sushko (@igorsushko) February 29, 2024
13 planes in 13 days:
1 x A-50U - $330 million
10 x Su-34 - $500 million
2 x Su-35 - $160 million
That's $1 BILLION in Russian planes lost in just 13 days. https://t.co/C7vD28pHma pic.twitter.com/KGPsWR0wDf
As I reported last week, the increase in losses seems to be related to the uptick in Russian air strikes using glide bombs.
READ: Putin's War, Week 104. Second Anniversary of the 72-Hour Special Military Operation
The launch profile for a glide bomb requires the strike aircraft to fly at a high altitude without evasive maneuvers as it sets up the launch. In a hostile air defense environment like that in Ukraine, this is not proving to be a great evolutionary strategy. Some of this is a direct outgrowth of Soviet strategy that never bothered to develop a SEAD/DEAD (pronounced "seed" and "deed") doctrine to penetrate highly defended airspace.
Starklink Saga ContinuesI've recently posted on the claim that Starlink internet terminals are used by Russian forces fighting in Ukraine. Starlink denied that was the case.
BACKGROUND:
Putin's War, Week 102. Zaluzhny Is Out, Syrsky Is In, and the Ukraine Aid Bill Advances
Putin's War, Week 103. Avdiivka Abandoned
The Starlink denial seems to merit a heavy caveat.
🚨 BREAKING: Chinese drone manufacturer DJI is openly selling Starlink satellite terminals on their website in Russia.
— Igor Sushko (@igorsushko) February 28, 2024
On February 15, 2024, @Starlink said it does not do business with Russia. pic.twitter.com/X9vrjvZoUm
Even though the Chinese drone manufacturer says it is not selling Starlink in Russia, a Russian DJI reseller company is clearly doing so. Despite what appears in the "Community Notes," you can follow the link to this Starlink order page. So, yes, you can buy Starlink terminals in Russia despite US sanctions and Starlink's denials. This leads to a second-order question. Why are we selling Starlink to a Chinese drone manufacturer?
Combat Operations
Close Quarter Battle Near Verbove
🌐 Place: #Verbove
— Jesse Pinkman (@ictusconfirmed) February 29, 2024
🗓 Date: ~26.02.2024
🇺🇦 Unit: 1 BOP "Jaguar", 14 BrOP NSU "Chervon Kalina"
📌 Geolocation:
📂 Description: Our soldiers destroy Russian fighters. Near the village of Verbove, Zaporizhzhia region. pic.twitter.com/8SI7MctEih
Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures
Drone vs. Drone Combat
More air to air combat https://t.co/Q6kO6PDmmk pic.twitter.com/MmIobmVHKo
— Andrew Perpetua (@AndrewPerpetua) February 29, 2024
More air to air combat. https://t.co/czTL20Uc7u pic.twitter.com/Z3UatPdNVw
— Andrew Perpetua (@AndrewPerpetua) February 28, 2024
Ground Suicide Drone Attack
Turn the video volume off; you don't want your day ruined by the music dubbed in.
Ukrainian "kamikaze" ground drone laden with anti-tank mines deployed to destroy a Russian fortification
— Euromaidan Press (@EuromaidanPress) March 1, 2024
Ukraine develops ground drones for laying mines, supplying troops, WIA evacuation, and conducting such "suicide attacks" on Russian positions.
📹 via… pic.twitter.com/BjcMQg1mls
Northern Front
Kharkiv
Kupiansk-Kreminna
The front in this area remains stable.
KUPIANSK AXIS / 1640 UTC 27 FEB/ RU attacks on Synkivka and Ivanivka broken up by UKR forces.
— Chuck Pfarrer | Indications & Warnings | (@ChuckPfarrer) February 27, 2024
Intel reports note RU reinforcements massing in the Kupiansk AO. pic.twitter.com/0A9ql0enGr
The Russians have started airstrikes on the temporary bridges supplying the Ukrainian front lines.
The front is moving towards Kharkov.
— Victor vicktop55 (@vicktop55) March 1, 2024
The destruction of the AFU pontoon bridge over the Oskol River near the Kupyansk-Uzlovaya railway station.
Almost all stationary bridges across the river have long been destroyed by us and the enemy, so the enemy is actively building… pic.twitter.com/N4k94qlxkk
Donbas
The Russian Army stepped up the operational tempo in this area, attacking all along the front. The Russians made small gains, but the intensity of the attacks indicates the minor offensive we noted before the first of the year to take control of the historical borders of the Donbas oblasts of Luhansk and Donetsk is still underway.
Bahkmut-Klishchiivka-Andriivka
BAKHMUT /2130 UTC 27 FEB/ Heavy combat continues as RU forces converge on Bakhmut. Ukraine breaks up 6 assaults on Ivanivske, Klischiivka & Andriivka. RU forces executed wounded Ukrainian soldiers at Ivanivske. pic.twitter.com/mNg0Th0D2X
— Chuck Pfarrer | Indications & Warnings | (@ChuckPfarrer) February 27, 2024
Avdiivka
As I pointed out two weeks ago, once the decision was made to abandon Avdiivka, there was no military reason to try to retain control of the Avdiivka Salient. The Russian advances are in concert with Ukrainian withdrawals.
AVDIIVKA AXIS /2325 UTC 28 FEB/ UKR units have withdrawn from Stepove & Sieverne as RU forces continue offensive operations. UKR aviation strike aircraft deployed JADAMs against Russian troop concentrations and HQ elements in the urban area of Avdiivka. pic.twitter.com/LSoKOQri5r
— Chuck Pfarrer | Indications & Warnings | (@ChuckPfarrer) February 28, 2024
BACKGROUND: Putin's War, Week 103. Avdiivka Abandoned
Southern Front
Zaporizhzhia
Robotyne-Verbove- Novoprokopivka
There is very little movement on this front. The Ukrainian Army had minor success in counterattacks to retake positions around Verbove that were lost last week.
#735dayofwar
— @BlogUkraine (@BlogUkraine) February 28, 2024
💬 Ukrainian and Russian forces stated that positional engagements continued near Robotyne and Verbove (east of Robotyne), - The Study of War#Zaporizhzhia #Ukraine #UkraineWar pic.twitter.com/wUhcWI0KoF
Kherson
The Ukrainian Army managed a minor expansion of the Krynky bridgehead, but the lines are mostly unchanged.
KHERSON AXIS /2245 UTC 29 FEB/ UKR forces break up Russian attacks on Krynky. Ukrainian JDAM-ER hits RU depot and headquarters at Chelburda. RU ballistic missiles target apartment buildings in Kherson, causing numerous fires. pic.twitter.com/YF6gKDXWWL
— Chuck Pfarrer | Indications & Warnings | (@ChuckPfarrer) February 29, 2024
This video gives a flavor of the battlefield. It is widely dispersed groups of 2-4 men, with neither side able to achieve the mass necessary for substantive gains.
Krynky, left bank of the Dnipro.
— Sharky 🇬🇧 🤝 🇺🇦 (@Jamie04381095) March 2, 2024
Close firefight, 2 🇺🇦 Ukrainian marines versus 4 🇷🇺 orcs of which only 1 orc survived to tell his comrades that invading Ukraine was a bad idea 💡 ‼️ pic.twitter.com/42Hkjp1zwZ
What's Next
There has been a noticeable decline in the quantity and quality of information from both sides in the last few months. That makes it difficult to catch a glimpse into what may be happening.
All evidence indicates the Russians are still pursuing the same goal postulated several weeks ago. That is their objective is to take the whole of historic Donbas before Putin's "election" in March. They will continue to attack all along the line of contact from Kupiansk-Kreminna in the north to Avdiivka in the south. The Ukrainians will not repeat the mistake of Bakhmut; they will yield ground to preserve men and equipment. There is a chance that the Ukrainian line will fail somewhere north of Bakhmut. I think the nature of the Russian forces (small bodies of light infantry) and the terrain (very few east-west lines of communication and a north-south network of unfordable streams and ridges), the depth of any Russian penetration will be limited and challenging to sustain.
What has become obvious over the last 4-6 weeks is that top-of-the-line Ukrainian armor is largely absent from the fight. We're no longer seeing video of the singleton tank raids that we saw in October-November. When they reappear, I hope they are not dribbled out along the front the way they were last summer.
I think we are about to see the Russians experience another round of the "shell hunger" they complained about when attacking Bakhmut. Indications are that North Korean shipments have ceased, which indicates the North Koreans have donated all the ammunition they are comfortable giving up. Future shipments will be from current production. This sort of follows the pattern of Russia relying on artillery ammunition from Iran during the siege of Bakhmut and on North Korean ammunition to take Avdiivka. There are a lot of bullsh** numbers floating around about Russian ammunition production where it is asserted that today's production is on par with that of the Soviet Union.
As I've said many times, a stalemate tends to help Putin because his only strategy is to convince the West to accept defeat in Ukraine. It doesn't matter how many men Russia has available for conscription; Russia's ability to arm, train, and supply troops is limited, as is its ability to get them to the right place on the front at the right time with the right equipment. Ukraine's strategy is to continue to convince the West that it has the will to win. When you throw in Zelensky's relief of a popular commander-in-chief, you have a political imperative to chalk up a win somewhere.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member