Four weeks before Wisconsin Democrats pick their nominee for governor, the establishment's plan just fell apart in a single afternoon. Lt. Gov. Sara Rodriguez, the candidate party insiders had quietly consolidated around, dropped out of the race on Friday after firing her campaign manager over a financial reporting shortfall that topped $1 million. By that evening, Milwaukee County Executive David Crowley, who had quit the race just a week earlier and endorsed Rodriguez on his way out, announced he was jumping back in.
If that sequence sounds like chaos, that's because it is. And it's chaos of the Democratic Party's own making.
Rodriguez had skipped a candidate forum in the state's rural Northwoods over the weekend, blaming a family emergency. A day later, the real reason came out: her campaign manager had been overcounting donations for months. She spent a week trying to contain the fallout before pulling the plug entirely, saying the financial mess had become an "ongoing distraction" she didn't want to drag into the primary. She also said she felt "deeply hurt and betrayed" by how the whole thing unraveled.
That's a remarkable admission to make in public, and it's not the kind of headline a party wants four weeks before a primary.
The Real Story Is Who Democrats Are Running From
But what makes this story even more wild is why Democrats are panicking now, especially when the state has been leaning blue in recent years: Wisconsin's Democratic establishment is terrified of nominating a Democratic Socialist, and they're willing to scramble their entire field to stop it.
State Rep. Francesca Hong, a Madison chef-turned-legislator running as an unapologetic Democratic Socialist, has spent months building momentum on the party's left flank. Moderate Democrats have watched that rise with growing unease, worried a Hong nomination would push moderate voters straight into the arms of Republicans in a state that routinely decides elections by a point or two.
Republicans clearly see the same opening. A GOP-aligned super PAC has already put money behind ads attacking Hong from the left, an attempt to make her look even more appealing to the very primary voters Democrats are trying to steer away from her.
Rodriguez's collapse was supposed to consolidate the anti-Hong lane. Instead, it blew it wide open, which is why Crowley is reversing course days after walking away over bad poll numbers, and why other establishment Democrats are reportedly floating the idea of Gov. Tony Evers stepping in to endorse him.
Mandela Barnes Smells an Opening, But His Baggage Hasn't Gone Anywhere
Former Lt. Gov. Mandela Barnes wasted no time trying to scoop up Rodriguez's supporters, telling them there's a place for them in his campaign. But Barnes carries his own electability problem into this race. He's the same Democrat who lost a winnable U.S. Senate race to Republican Ron Johnson in 2022, a defeat Wisconsin Democrats have not forgotten.
That history hasn't stopped him from framing his entry as urgent. He told the Associated Press he got in because "the moment is too urgent," pointing to the need to counter President Trump. Whether Democratic primary voters agree he's the man for that job, after his last statewide loss, is an open question.
Kelda Roys and Joel Brennan remain in the race as well, meaning Democrats now have at least four viable candidates scrambling for position with the Aug. 11 primary bearing down fast.
What Happens Next
Local Democratic officials are openly telling their own voters not to make up their minds yet. Paul Hambleton, chair of the St. Croix County Democratic Party, said as much after news of Rodriguez's exit broke, telling voters the race is "wide open right now" and urging patience over a rushed decision.
That's an unusually candid admission from inside the party. Nobody, including the people running the county operations, knows who's going to emerge from this mess.
Whoever wins the Democratic nomination will face Rep. Tom Tiffany, the Trump-endorsed Republican who is the likely GOP nominee, in a governor's race Democrats are counting on to lock down full control of Wisconsin's state government for the first time in a generation. With four candidates still standing and a fifth possibly rejoining, that outcome looks less certain than it did a week ago.
Editor's Note: Do you enjoy RedState's conservative reporting that takes on the radical left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth.
Join RedState VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member