In a world where “legend” status is assigned to most anyone who has managed to extend their allotted 15 minutes of fame into as much, or as little if you prefer, as 20, it can be difficult to remember that there are indeed those walking among us who are truly deserving of the label. Paul McCartney is one such individual. The world has been chasing him and his three compatriots in The Beatles since the 1960s without once catching up to his brilliance, and his post-Beatles work, either with Wings or solo, has easily brushed aside the critics as it has cemented his place as the 20th going into the 21st century’s greatest writer of popular music. He could have stopped after “Yesterday,” written and recorded in the mid-‘60s, and his place in history would be secure. Fortunately for us, McCartney has never rested on his laurels. He has not always hit the mark. But far more often than not, he has enriched our lives with his gift.
McCartney will turn 84 in June 2026, an age at which almost every musician has long since hidden themselves and their understandably time-ravaged talents from public view. However, The Rules That Guide Such Things don’t apply to every living legend. McCartney released his 27th post-Beatles record, “The Boys of Dungeon Lane,” on May 29, 2026. It is a sprightly romp that artists half McCartney’s age would be hard-pressed to match for energy and tunefulness.
McCartney has, for decades, presented an immeasurable talent for crafting instantly comfortable, cliché-free melodies with chordal and harmonic structures constantly stepping outside the expected norms of pop music. Nothing has changed on his new record. The overall tenor is lean rather than lush, with instrumentation and vocals kept low-key and always focused on the melody. The total effect is pop rock at its best: colorful, joyfully moving, and eminently soothing.
Lyrically, McCartney has his eye on yesterday and today. While dealing with relationship-based topics comes naturally for him, and the songs dealing with said topics are delivered with a mature point of view — no silly love songs here — it is when McCartney takes a look back that he reaches peak wordsmithing level. Viewing the past not with gooey sentimentality but a wry fondness for what once was, on songs such as “Days We Left Behind,” McCartney recalls friends and times now living only in memory, yet still fully alive.
McCartney’s voice is understandably weaker than in decades gone by, yet still warm, clear, and easy on the ears. The days of primal screams are long gone, but what remains is more than satisfactory. And look ma — no autotune! Real voices and instruments only.
In a world where musicians seemingly feel compelled to make everything a massive statement and every song a sloganeering-laden workout, it is utterly refreshing to have a true master of his craft finding contentment in talking about shared experiences of life and love, realizing no statement is grander or has more impact than a simple “I love you.” “The Boys of Dungeon Lane” makes no pretense of being grand social commentary. It is an album for and about normal people, affectionately recalling what once was while enjoying what is good in the present day. Paul McCartney has offered us a 47-minute, 14-song slice of nonstick sentiment, delivered with style and a smile. For this we can indeed be thankful.
Support independent, conservative journalism devoted to bringing you the facts about politics and culture without fear. Your VIP subscription will keep RedState rolling in its efforts to supply truth with which to confront the mainstream media’s bias and falsehoods. Not only will you be helping us, but you will also gain access to in-depth reporting and knowledgeable commentary you will not find elsewhere. Click on this link to join today!
Join the conversation as a VIP Member