THE ESSEX FILES: Kansas Is Right to Put Citizenship on Driver's Licenses

AP Photo/Angelina Katsanis

The Kansas House has drawn a clear line with House Bill 2448. The measure would require every driver's license in the state to list the holder’s citizenship status, with a different design for noncitizens, and it has passed the House over loud objections from Democrats and advocacy groups. Supporters say it is about election integrity and basic clarity in government records, and they are right.

Advertisement

This is not some sweeping crackdown on people who are here legally. Kansas already verifies legal presence when it issues licenses, and noncitizens can receive temporary licenses under current law. What the bill does is close a real administrative gap. Election officials and poll workers cannot always tell, from the license alone, whether the person in front of them is a citizen who can vote or a noncitizen who cannot. When a license looks the same in both cases, mistakes are predictable. 


RELATED: Watch: Schumer Gets Tripped Up Over Voter ID Question As Fetterman Remains Lone 'D' Voice of Reason

Trump Plans to Crush 'Horrible, Disingenuous Cheater' Dems With Voter ID EO to Lock Down Midterms, Beyond


Critics point to studies showing that noncitizen voting is extremely rare and argue that the bill is a solution in search of a problem. They are right that the numbers are small. A 2016 review of 42 jurisdictions found suspected noncitizen voting at about 0.0001 percent. Kansas officials themselves say they are currently prosecuting only two noncitizen voting cases, with a handful of others under review. But that is not an argument against the bill. It is an argument for dealing with the problem while it is still manageable. 

Advertisement

Republicans backing the bill make a simple point: Everyone agrees that only citizens should vote in American elections. If that principle is taken seriously, it is reasonable to give the people who run elections a clear, immediate way to know who is eligible. Listing citizenship status on the primary piece of identification we all carry is a modest step toward that goal, and it is far less strict than some of the alternatives now being floated at the federal level. 

Opponents lean heavily on rhetoric. One Democratic legislator compared the proposal to “freedom papers,” invoking the documents carried by freed slaves before the Civil War. That is a charged historical analogy, but it falls apart under scrutiny. The state is not demanding new documents from a disfavored class; it is placing a neutral, factual notation on a license that already exists. A noncitizen lawfully living and working in Kansas will still be able to drive, still be able to identify themselves, and still be protected by the law. 

Advertisement

The concern about profiling is more serious, and it deserves a serious answer. Lawmakers should be clear that immigration status is not a free pass for fishing expeditions by law enforcement. That is a matter of training, oversight, and, if needed, explicit statutory limits on how the information can be used. The right response to possible misuse is not to keep the government guessing about who can vote. It is to set rules for conduct and enforce them. 

Kansas has been down this road before. A previous law that required proof of citizenship at registration was struck down because a federal judge found that the burden on eligible voters outweighed the evidence of fraud. This bill is narrower. It does not add new paperwork at the ballot box or block anyone from registering. It aligns existing ID practices with the basic fact that citizenship matters in a constitutional republic. 

In a state that has already shown it takes election security seriously, adding citizenship status to driver's licenses is a careful, incremental move, not a radical one. It respects the franchise by protecting it, and it respects voters by trusting them with the truth on the card they are already required to carry. 

Advertisement

Editor’s Note: Republicans are fighting for election integrity by requiring proper identification to vote.

Help us continue to report why Democrats oppose such obvious measures by joining RedState VIP and using promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.

Recommended

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Trending on RedState Videos