The Justice Department is now investigating the NFL’s media model, putting the league’s antitrust protection at risk as fans face rising costs just to watch games.
Federal officials are examining whether the league’s distribution strategy relies on anticompetitive practices that force fans into stacking subscriptions across multiple services just to follow a full season.
Fans now pay roughly $1,000 to $1,500 per year across cable and streaming platforms to watch every NFL game, according to estimates cited by lawmakers, a sharp break from when most games were available through a single broadcast package.
That shift rests on a legal structure that helped build the modern NFL and is now being tested directly by federal regulators.
The league’s media model depends on the Sports Broadcasting Act of 1961, which allows teams to pool rights and negotiate national deals without violating antitrust law, in exchange for keeping games widely available on free broadcast television and maintaining broad public access.
Today, that structure looks very different. The schedule is split across CBS, NBC, ESPN, and Fox, while additional games have moved to Amazon Prime, Peacock, Netflix, and YouTube’s “Sunday Ticket” package, forcing fans to navigate multiple platforms and subscriptions to follow a full season.
FCC Chairman Brendan Carr said officials are reviewing whether leagues have pushed the model too far, warning that moving more games behind paywalls could undercut the justification for the NFL’s antitrust exemption.
“We’re at a tipping point where these leagues can push it so far… that they undermine their ability to claim that antitrust exemption.”
Regulators are increasingly questioning whether the current model still meets the conditions that justified the league’s legal protections in the first place.
Sen. Mike Lee, who chairs the Senate antitrust subcommittee, has asked federal agencies to review whether the league’s approach still meets those conditions, signaling that the issue has already moved beyond regulators alone.
The Justice Department is now examining whether the league’s media model violates the terms of its antitrust exemption.
YouTube Wants up to $489 to Watch NFL Sunday Ticket on YouTube TV
The NFL argues its system still prioritizes access, noting that more than 87 percent of games remain available on free broadcast television, including all games in local markets.
That claim does not match how fans experience the product when trying to follow the full schedule week to week. A recent poll found that 72 percent of sports fans believe major sporting events should remain on free broadcast television, reflecting a growing gap between the league’s distribution model and public expectations.
The NFL’s ability to bundle media rights into massive national contracts depends on that 1961 antitrust exemption. Officials have warned that shifting too many games to streaming could trigger a broader reconsideration of those protections and reshape how those deals are negotiated.
For decades, that system helped the NFL maximize reach while keeping the product easy to find. Regulators are now deciding whether it still expands access—or whether it has quietly started restricting it.
Editor’s Note: Do you enjoy RedState’s conservative reporting that takes on the radical left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth.
Join RedState VIP and use the promo code FIGHT to get 60% off your VIP membership!
Join the conversation as a VIP Member