By A. Matthew Ecsedy
When communism collapsed in Eastern Europe, something remarkable happened the very next day.
In Bulgaria, every communist politician simply declared themselves “socialists.” Nothing about their methods changed — only the spelling. That memory, passed down through families like mine from Hungary who fled communist regimes, is why I cannot accept the marketing of “Democratic Socialism” here in America.
Folks in small towns across America know the value of freedom. We know what it means to work hard, to build businesses, and to raise families without government interference.
Yet across the country, we are told that socialism is the answer to inequality, that government control will somehow make life fairer. I’ve seen what happens when people believe that promise. It ends in ration lines, silenced voices, more bureaucracy, and broken communities.
Socialism today is sold as compassionate, democratic, and modern. Strip away the shiny packaging, and you find the same old system of control where thought is not freely grown but groomed. Whether it’s called “Democratic Socialism” or “National Socialism,” the playbook is familiar:
- Blame opponents for every problem;
- Demonize free speech and open debate; and
- Scapegoat groups, whether Jews in 1930s Germany or Christians, capitalists, and conservatives today.
The tragedy of socialism is that its lessons cannot be taught in a classroom or explained in a pamphlet. They are learned through bitter experiences, through lamentation of poor choices.
Ask anyone who lived under communism in Eastern Europe. Ask the families who fled Cuba or Venezuela. They will tell you: once the government owns or controls everything, freedom disappears.
My parents taught me that the difference between communism and socialism is only in spelling.
Both systems crush initiative, punish success, and reward conformity. Both systems promise equality but deliver poverty.
Consider this. October 1950, Budapest, Hungary. The Hungarian State Police knocked on my grandfather’s door. When the door opened, they entered without asking permission, did not show any identification, no search warrant — simply said, “Inspection.” They proceeded to go through the apartment on Garay Utca 42, looking for contraband.
My grandmother sat and waited for them to finish and leave like normal, because this was normal in socialist countries. But on this day, they did not leave. They arrested her. Her crime? Hoarding. Early that day, she had asked to borrow sugar from several tenants to bake a birthday cake for my father’s 10th birthday. She was in possession of half a kilogram of sugar. That was enough to be considered a violation.
Small‑town America is not New York City, and rural communities are not Washington, D.C. But the ideas that take root in big cities eventually spread outward. If socialism gains ground in America’s cultural centers, it will not stop at the Hudson River. It will reach small towns, rural communities, and places like yours and mine.
Imagine government‑run grocery stores in your town where a simple driveway permit takes weeks. And look at what's happening after the Palisades Fire in California, where many families still haven't received permits to rebuild or are otherwise being hampered by bureaucratic red tape, 15 months after the fire. When government grows too large and too centralized, delays like these aren’t the exception, but the norm.
RELATED: LA Bureaucrats Threaten to Tow Pacific Palisades Fire Victims' Storage Pods
The political figures who embrace Democratic Socialism allowed ordinary families to be stuck in the bureaucratic maze, and the people making the rules insulate themselves from the consequences. During COVID lockdowns, Gavin Newsom had dinner at the French Laundry, and Nancy Pelosi visited a salon unmasked despite statewide restrictions. Critics have also long pointed to the tight, multigenerational ties among some of California’s most influential political families — connections that fuel the perception/reality of an elite circle operating above accountability and have ties through blood and marriage across the country. To many Americans, this is what modern “Democratic Socialism” looks like in practice: not equality, but an oligarchy feeding on the intellectually duped, easier to fool than to convince they’ve been fooled.
The National Socialists of 1930s Germany rose to power by demonizing their critics, silencing debate, and scapegoating minorities. Today’s Democratic Socialists may not wear the same uniforms, but their tactics echo the same dangerous themes. They point at Christians, capitalists, and Jews, declaring them the problem. They forget that in doing so, they mirror the very authoritarianism they claim to oppose.
History does not repeat itself exactly, but it rhymes. And the rhyme of socialism is always the same: promises of fairness, followed by loss of freedom.
Communities across America deserve better than recycled ideologies dressed up in new words. We deserve leaders who trust the people, not systems that control them. Socialism is not compassion. It is control. And control, once surrendered, is rarely regained.
As someone whose family lived through communism, I urge my fellow Americans: do not be fooled by shiny boxes and clever marketing. Democratic Socialism is still socialism. And socialism, no matter how it arrives, ends the same way — with freedom lost and regret gained.
-A. Matthew Ecsedy grew up in Southern California and served for 20 years in the U.S. military, living in seven states, one territory, five countries, and traveling to ten countries and two territories.
Editor’s Note: Every single day, here at RedState, we will stand up and FIGHT, FIGHT, FIGHT against the radical left and deliver the conservative reporting our readers deserve.
Help us continue to tell the truth about the Trump administration and its successes. Join RedState VIP and use promo code FIGHT to get 60% off your membership.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member