Almost 600 Prop 50 Ballots Were Never Counted. Now California Could Destroy Them.

Six months after California certified the results of its controversial Proposition 50 redistricting vote, Humboldt County election staff found 596 uncounted ballots sitting at the bottom of a locked drop box. The election is over. The maps are drawn. And the ballots are almost legally required to be destroyed.

The county announced the discovery on Wednesday. The ballots were from the Nov. 4, 2025, special election on Proposition 50, the measure that stripped California's independent redistricting commission of its authority and handed map-drawing power directly to the Democrat-controlled legislature. Officials were quick to add that the uncounted ballots won't change the outcome. That's the part they want you to focus on.

Proposition 50 passed with nearly 65 percent of the statewide vote and was explicitly designed as a Democrat counter-gerrymander targeting Republican redistricting efforts in Texas. The new maps are expected to help Democrats compete for five GOP-held House seats. They'll be in place through 2030. The Trump administration sued California over them.

The county says the ballots weren't tampered with. The drop box was locked, and the envelopes were still sealed. That's the good news. The bad news is that 596 ballots made it through the entire post-election canvassing and certification process without anyone noticing they hadn't been counted. The county is now working with the California Secretary of State's Office to figure out if anything can still legally be done.

The county blamed a "miscommunication" among workers over whether the drop box had been emptied. In response, Humboldt County has implemented what it's calling a "lock out, tag out" procedure, a physical verification requirement for every drop box before certification, a procedure the county acknowledged was not previously in place.

Humboldt County Clerk-Recorder and Registrar of Voters Juan Pablo Cervantes issued a statement taking responsibility. He learned about the problem Monday night around 6 p.m.

“596 ballots were left uncounted. That outcome is unacceptable and runs counter to the core of what this office stands for.”

He was careful to note the fault originated with a worker, then accepted responsibility himself:

"While the mistake occurred after an election worker did not follow proper procedures, the responsibility for what happened ultimately sits with me. I did not have strong enough controls in place to prevent this, but we do now."

That's an admission worth sitting with. The head of the office responsible for counting every vote in a high-stakes election is telling you, on the record, that his controls weren't strong enoughInOn this election. In this political climate.

Within minutes of polls opening for the November special election, President Trump called the Prop 50 vote "a GIANT SCAM" on Truth Social. The White House pointed to California's universal mail-in voting system as "ripe for fraud." California officials called those claims baseless. Then Riverside County Sheriff and Republican gubernatorial candidate Chad Bianco seized 650,000 ballots from his county to investigate whether they were fraudulently counted. Democrats called it election denialism. His supporters called it oversight. Now Humboldt County is handing everyone more to argue about.

Officials have stressed that the newly discovered ballots will not change the result of the special election. But Cervantes acknowledged the failure still mattered because the voters who used that drop box did what they were supposed to do.

“We ask a lot of voters. We ask you to participate, to trust the process and to believe that your vote will be counted. 596 voters did exactly what we asked of them, and we fell short.”

There's a clock running on all of this. Under California law, ballots from the November special election were required to be destroyed six months after certification. Humboldt County said it is now pursuing “all legal avenues” to have the ballots counted before any destruction deadline is carried out.

Cervantes said the discovery showed the county’s safeguards were not strong enough.

“This discovery highlights why strong systems, redundancy and clear accountability must be in place at every step in the election process. In this case, those safeguards were not sufficient. That responsibility is mine and I am deeply sorry.”

The county said it will provide another update when more information becomes available. California has spent months insisting its elections are airtight. Six hundred uncounted ballots sitting in a locked box for half a year — on the most politically consequential vote on the ballot — is a strange way to prove it.

Editor’s Note: Republicans are fighting for election integrity by requiring proper identification to vote.

Help us continue to report why Democrats oppose such obvious measures by joining RedState VIP and using promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.