Bernie Wants Bigger Social Security Checks. Guess Who Gets the Bill?

Nov 16, 2026 1:00 PM
Premium
Advertisement
Bernie Wants Bigger Social Security Checks. Guess Who Gets the Bill?
AP Photo/Andrew Harnik, File
VIP

Why on Earth would anyone ever take Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT), that daffy old Bolshevik from Vermont, seriously? What he doesn't know about economics would fill the Vatican Library. The man honeymooned in the Soviet Union, and has spent his entire political career trying to make the United States more Soviet-like. Honestly, wouldn't he have been happier if he had just remained in the Soviet Union in the first place?

This is a man who has never done an honest day's work in his life — but now he has plans on how to fix Social Security, which is headed for a major logjam. And, as you might suspect, Comrade Bernie is going back to the same old well: raising taxes, which he describes as "making the rich pay their fair share." There's just one problem: What he is proposing, as usual, will only make matters worse.

Annual Social Security benefits are scheduled to be cut by $6,000 on average when the trust fund exhausts its IOUs in the fall of 2032. Senator Bernie Sanders (I-VT) wants to send Social Security beneficiaries another $2,400 a year instead. In a viral post on X, he promised to expand benefits and extend the program’s solvency for generations by “scrapping the cap” and demanding wealthy Americans pay their “fair share.”

Eliminating the payroll tax cap wouldn’t even cover the benefits Congress has already promised, let alone fund a benefit expansion. Imposing a 12.4 percentage-point increase in the marginal tax rate for highly productive workers would, however, discourage work, reduce investment and innovation, and potentially make it harder to access medical care. Sanders is promising to expand already outsized government checks without acknowledging what his tax increases would cost Americans.

Sanders’ broader proposal also calls for additional taxes on investment and certain business income, so eliminating the wage cap isn’t his only proposed funding source.

There's another problem: The payroll taxes for Social Security are capped because the benefits are capped. Bernie, no doubt writing from a polished desk in one of his three expansive dachas, doesn't seem to understand what that means, any more than he understands mathematics.

Social Security’s 12.4 percent payroll tax currently applies to earnings up to $184,500. This taxable base amount will rise to $192,300 in January because it grows with average wage gains across the economy. 

Eliminating the cap would impose the payroll tax on every additional dollar of wages above it. Calling that “fair” ignores both how Social Security’s benefit formula works and the broader tax code. While higher earners don’t pay payroll taxes on earnings above $184,500, they also receive no additional benefit credits above this threshold. For example, someone earning $184,500 and someone earning $300,000 are treated the same under the benefit formula. This is also a common practice globally, with many developed countries imposing tax caps at lower earnings levels than the US.

Look, the upcoming collapse of Social Security won't be fended off so easily. Bernie Sanders is, once again, revealing his profound ignorance of all matters economic. 

Aside from the structural problems with Sanders' proposals, there is the matter of incentives, which the Left never has and never will understand. Higher taxes, be it for Social Security or anything else — and Sen. Sanders has never seen a tax rate hike that didn't send a shiver of delight up his back — always have a chilling effect on productivity. That's how incentives work. In recent years, we've even seen proposals that would establish a 100 percent tax rate on income over a certain level, and one doesn't have to be Milton Friedman to figure out what effect that would have on the builders and achievers that make an economy run.

Here's the real problem with Social Security that Bernie isn't addressing, and to be fair, almost nobody seems to want to talk about: The system itself is structurally unsustainable in our aging population.

In 1940, for every recipient receiving benefits, there were almost 160 people working and paying into the system. In 2013, that ratio had dropped to 2.8. Right now, it's estimated to be about 2.7. And the program itself has expanded to include not only seniors but disability payments. That's a major problem. 

Social Security's retirement and survivors trust fund is projected to exhaust its reserves in 2032. Unless Congress changes the law, incoming revenue would then cover only about 78 percent of scheduled benefits. Bernie's solution won't help. Nothing the Left proposes will help, because they are not addressing the core issue: Demographics. 

The one thing that might save the system? Make the system an actual retirement fund. Every dollar every taxpayer pays into the system goes into an account with their name on it. They manage the account. They decide where it's invested, within (presumably) certain limits. Look, I'm 65; I made my plans for my senior years on the basis that Social Security won't exist, and if it does, fine, it's a bonus. But if I had been able to take the money the government extracted from me by force of law for all those years and just stuck it in a mutual fund, I'd be retiring with seven figures in the bank. Personally, I'd rather see the entire thing privatized, but that's a topic for another day.

This is a multi-generational ripoff, not to mention a golden opportunity for fraudsters. The time for band-aid measures is gone.

I would recommend that Bernie Eliasovich Sanders read a few books on economics, but that recommendation would be water off a duck's back. If the man were capable of learning, he would have done so by now.

Recommended

Trending on RedState Videos