The COVID-19 pandemic has brought out the worst in the media, especially when it comes to how it covers the actions of Democrat Party leaders vs. Republican Party leaders. This has been demonstrated in no better way than the stark contrast between how the media treated Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis and New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo.
By the numbers, there is no arguing which state faired better. Under DeSantis’s leadership, Florida has had far fewer deaths per capita than New York, despite being subject to far fewer restrictions. New York, meanwhile, has been one of the states that suffered the most from the pandemic overall.
You’d never know that from how the media treated both governors, however. At every step, the mainstream press made DeSantis out to be a reckless, irresponsible governor who was out to get people killed with his freedom-based approach to the virus. Meanwhile, they heaped nothing but praise on Cuomo no matter what he did, even if what he did was kill thousands of elderly New Yorkers with his decisions.
Freelance writer Drew Holden compiled a very long list of incidents reported on by the press where the two leaders were put in similar situations. At every turn, you’ll notice a solidifying pattern of the press applauding and praising Cuomo and demonizing DeSantis to the point of absurdity.
As of today, NY’s deaths per 100k from coronavirus (188) is about double Florida’s (96). Florida and Gov. DeSantis seem to be doing something right in that regard.
But you would have no idea that was the case if you spend your days listening/watching/reading @MSNBC pic.twitter.com/IZlUQ31y6R
— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) December 31, 2020
Also very interesting the ways that @CNN chooses to humanize (or not) each governor’s response. pic.twitter.com/csO9Nxuxvh
— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) December 31, 2020
Both of these stories from @nytimes bill themselves as straight reporting.
Okay. pic.twitter.com/PVVcejWa8D
— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) December 31, 2020
These two from @NPR also capture the situation perfectly.
DeSantis gets fact-checked. Cuomo gets an Emmy. pic.twitter.com/xEVQrZgK9e
— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) December 31, 2020
Holden takes a moment to point out that the press is doing this despite DeSantis’s leadership keeping Florida far safer and that Cuomo’s response has been a marked disaster, noting that if New York was its own country it would have had the worst numbers in the world. He continues with examples thereafter.
I’ll pause here to drive the point home: by the most critical metric, deaths per capita, DeSantis has outperformed Cuomo enormously. Cuomo’s led one of the most disastrous crisis responses in US history.
If NY were a country it’d have the highest death per capita IN THE WORLD.
— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) December 31, 2020
@CNBC found a way to shoehorn in criticism of DeSantis in their reporting of a separate issue.
For Cuomo, they’ve got a nonstop feed for his pressers (this was just a small sample of all of the tweets). pic.twitter.com/r3mDhVYrtc
— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) December 31, 2020
I wonder if @Salon will revisit this first piece, because that Florida model was revised shortly thereafter and eventually proved entirely inaccurate.
Cuomo, on the other hand, gets elevated to some sort of religious icon. pic.twitter.com/aGh91vc8re
— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) December 31, 2020
I can always count on @VanityFair to act in bad faith. pic.twitter.com/1Vjg31Mzer
— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) December 31, 2020
@HuffPost really working overtime here huh.
For context, of the 300,000 people who have died from coronavirus, fewer than 600 of them are under 25. pic.twitter.com/1XdqmixuG4
— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) December 31, 2020
And speaking of double, we’ll double up, because @guardian had a lot of material to work with.
I mean. Cmon. pic.twitter.com/pROXY613Ia
— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) December 31, 2020
You may’ve thought that surely this is mostly a US phenomenon, but along with BBC and the Guardian, @Independent is here to remind you that that simply isn’t the case. pic.twitter.com/ROhsllU01r
— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) December 31, 2020
Holden finishes with a blistering denouncement of the media.
And that means that millions of Americans who have lost loved ones because of the terrible response from @NYGovCuomo won’t get justice or accountability because the media spends all their time attacking governors they don’t like since they’re Republicans.
And that’s shameful.
— Drew Holden (@DrewHolden360) December 31, 2020
“As I’ve said before, there are lots of factors to consider when determining which responses were appropriate,” tweeted Holden. “But if journalism is to be the first draft of history, we’ve got ourselves a miserably unfair draft to work with because countless outlets have operated in bad faith.”
“And that means that millions of Americans who have lost loved ones because of the terrible response from @NYGovCuomo won’t get justice or accountability because the media spends all their time attacking governors they don’t like since they’re Republicans. And that’s shameful,” he added.
As of this moment, Democrat-controlled states like California are showing an increase of COVID-19 cases that are rising off the charts. Meanwhile, DeSantis and Florida are currently far below in terms of current case rates, proving that the draconian Democrat approach of locking a state down and treating their people like prisoners is not just failing to be effective, but hurting the people even more.
(READ: Graph Showing Difference in Case Rates Between Florida and California Is a Wake-Up Call for America)
Join the conversation as a VIP Member