Essex Files: Payton McNabb Protector of Title IX's True Meaning

In a world increasingly muddled by progressive gender ideology, Payton McNabb stands as a beacon of courage and common sense. A young woman who has endured personal injury and public backlash, McNabb has emerged as a conservative voice advocating for the protection of women’s sports and sex-segregated spaces. Her story is one of resilience, faith, and an unwavering commitment to biological reality—a perspective that resonates deeply with those who believe in preserving fairness and safety for women.

McNabb’s journey into activism began tragically in September 2022 when, as a 17-year-old high school junior, she suffered a life-altering injury on the volleyball court. A male player competing on the opposing team spiked a ball with such force that it knocked her unconscious, leaving her with a traumatic brain injury, partial paralysis, and persistent vision problems. The incident wasn’t just a personal setback—it was a wake-up call. Today, McNabb still grapples with the lingering effects of that concussion, as she has shared in posts on X, but she has transformed her pain into purpose.

19-year-old Payton McNabb was severely injured by a man during a volleyball game -- left with a traumatic brain injury after he spiked the ball against her head.

President Trump was proud to sign an executive order to keep men OUT of women’s sports.pic.twitter.com/rEHYb6v9ww
— Rapid Response 47 (@RapidResponse47) March 5, 2025

That purpose crystallized further when McNabb found herself at the center of another battle—this time over privacy and safety in women’s restrooms. Confronted by a transgender-identifying male in a university bathroom, she stood her ground, declaring, “But you’re not a girl. … I pay a lot of money to be safe in the bathroom.” The individual responded by filing a Title IX complaint against her, but McNabb emerged victorious in the campus case. As the Independent Women’s Forum (IWF) noted, this win was not just a personal triumph but a significant moment in the broader fight to uphold sex-based rights under Title IX. For conservatives, her victory underscores a fundamental truth: Women deserve spaces where their safety and dignity are non-negotiable.

A man using the girls bathroom at Western Carolina University. Unreal pic.twitter.com/yPXXBN8Aqd
— Payton McNabb (@paytonmcnabb_) May 2, 2024

Finding Out: Trump Admin Yanks Funding to Blue-State University That Allows Men in Women's Sports

Now an ambassador for the IWF, McNabb is pursuing her bachelor’s degree while tirelessly advocating for policies that protect girls and women in athletics. Her efforts caught the attention of First Lady Melania Trump, who invited her to be a special guest at President Trump’s address to a joint session of Congress on March 6, 2025. Praising McNabb’s mission to end the “brutal unfairness” of males competing in women’s sports, Mrs. Trump elevated her story to a national stage. Reflecting on the honor, McNabb said she is still "extremely grateful" for having attended and getting the experience to meet key figures in the party, including second lady Usha Vance.

Yet, her stand has come at a cost. McNabb has faced fierce opposition from radical activists who seek to silence her. After attending the congressional address, McNabb said she felt “outnumbered” and “betrayed” by her university. But ultimately, McNabb said, "Even if you don’t think you’ll have a chance –– because we certainly didn’t think it was going to be easy at all –– we still went into it and we prevailed.” She also criticized those who blocked a federal bill aimed at safeguarding women’s sports, calling out the cowardice of lawmakers who bow to ideological pressure over the safety of female athletes.

From a rational person's perspective, McNabb’s fight is about more than just sports or bathrooms—it’s about preserving the integrity of God-given differences between men and women. Her injury at the hands of a male competitor is a stark reminder of the physical realities that no amount of progressive rhetoric can erase. Her bathroom confrontation highlights the erosion of women’s privacy when biological distinctions are ignored. For those who hold traditional values, McNabb’s activism is a defense of fairness, safety, and the natural order.

Payton McNabb won a Title IX victory after encountering a transgender-identified male in a women’s restroom at Western Carolina University.

NOT ONE MAJOR NEWS AGENCY REPORTED ON THIS. https://t.co/i1n4O9WYtM
— Margo (@MargoinWNC) April 6, 2025

Women like Payton McNabb deserve more than applause—they deserve our steadfast support. Her courage in the face of adversity, both physical and cultural, is a call to action for conservatives to rally behind her cause. As she continues to battle for the future of women’s sports and the sanctity of sex-segregated spaces, we should lift her up in prayer, asking for her healing and protection. In a society that often punishes those who speak the truth, McNabb’s voice is a clarion call to stand firm, rooted in faith and reason, against the tide of radical ideology.

Editor's Note: President Trump is fighting to dismantle the Department of Education and ensure America's kids get the education they deserve.

Help us fight back against Big Government waste and restore power back to the states. Join RedState VIP and use promo code FIGHT to get 60% off your membership.