Gavin Newsom and California Democrats love to strut like peacocks, crowing that California has the fourth-largest economy in the world. Sounds impressive, if you ignore reality. But Californians living paycheck to paycheck know this is not Fantasyland.
The truth? Ordinary people are struggling to survive in a state where their political leaders fail them at every turn.
Yet, Newsom and his cronies consistently taunt Texas Governor Greg Abbott and Florida Governor Ron DeSantis. They puff up their chests, paint California as the gold standard, and sneer. They brag about “superior” governance, but the rankings scream otherwise.
Yes, California has a massive GDP, roughly $4.1 trillion. However, GDP is size, not substance. It does not put a roof over a family’s head, fill a gas tank, or stock a grocery shelf. It does not measure real opportunity or upward mobility.
And it certainly does not capture crushing costs, sky-high taxes, or shrinking opportunity that leaves everyday Californians footing the bill while elites sip wine in Napa and tech moguls cash out in Silicon Valley.
The fourth-largest economy? On paper. In the real world, it is a hollow brag. A smoke-and-mirrors victory lap for failed leadership.
The Cold, Hard Numbers
Back in May, U.S. News & World Report released its Best States rankings for 2025, a massive survey that crunches dozens of data points to measure how well states are actually performing for their people. This is not about vanity metrics like GDP.
It is about whether states are delivering on what matters most: health care, education, jobs, infrastructure, public safety, opportunity, fiscal stability, and quality of life. But not all categories are treated equally.
Health care and education carry the most weight, followed by economies, infrastructure, and opportunity. Fiscal stability, crime and corrections, and natural environment all factor in, too. In other words, these rankings reflect the daily realities of ordinary people, not the empty talking points of grandstanding politicians.
So how did California fare against the two states Newsom loves to mock?
- Economy: California #32 | Texas #2 | Florida #1
- Education: California #24 | Texas #25 | Florida #2
- Fiscal Stability: California #42 | Texas #12 | Florida #9
- Infrastructure: California #35 | Texas #18 | Florida #15
- Opportunity: California #50 | Texas #48 | Florida #47
- Overall Ranking: California #37 | Texas #29 | Florida #6
Boom! That is the reality check Gavin Newsom never wants to talk about.
California, the so-called “fourth-largest economy in the world,” ranks near the bottom of the barrel when it comes to delivering results for its people. It lags far behind Florida, which ranks in the top 10 overall, and even Texas, which Newsom routinely mocks, comes out ahead in almost every meaningful category.
The numbers do not lie. California is big, yes, but big does not mean better. And when you look past the smoke and mirrors, it is clear that Florida and Texas are eating California’s lunch on the metrics that actually matter to working families.
GDP Brag ≠ Quality of Life
California’s economy is not some evenly spread powerhouse. It is a glittering hall of mirrors built on tech and a handful of elite sectors. Sure, those industries make headlines and generate jaw-dropping numbers, but most Californians are stuck in low-wage jobs, gig work, or flat-out unemployment.
High GDP? Maybe. Real opportunity for the people who actually live here? Not a chance.
GDP looks great in a press release, but it does nothing to pay the bills. Californians are crushed under rents they cannot afford, taxes that bleed their paychecks dry, and living costs that race far ahead of wages.
A massive economy means nothing if the people cannot survive in it.
Newsom’s own push for higher gas taxes and strict housing regulations has made filling a tank or finding an affordable apartment a daily struggle for millions.
Meanwhile, he struts around like a peacock, tossing out trillion-dollar bragging points, while the state budget tells a different story. Five out of the last seven years, California ran a deficit. Texas and Florida?
They balance their books and post surpluses; a level of fiscal discipline California could only dream of.
Texas and Florida prove that states can grow their economy and deliver a better quality of life to their citizens. They create jobs, keep taxes manageable, and build pathways for people to thrive.
California? It pretends to know how, but the numbers and the lives of everyday residents say otherwise.
Big GDP, Negative Results
California has the resources and the potential for everyone to thrive. But under Democrat leadership, that potential has been wasted. Decades of rising costs, crushing taxes, and political mismanagement have left ordinary residents struggling. Families have watched their wages stall, rents soar, and neighborhoods crumble while Newsom brags about GDP and plays political tit for tat.
Real achievement means leadership that works for the people, not the elites. It means policies that create jobs, lower costs, restore safety, and expand opportunity. It means actually delivering for communities that have been ignored.
California Democrats talk a big game. But their record?
Broken neighborhoods, busted budgets, and betrayal of the people.
Editor’s Note: Do you enjoy RedState’s conservative reporting that takes on the radical left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth.
Join RedState VIP and use the promo code FIGHT to get 60% off your VIP membership!
Join the conversation as a VIP Member