Democratic hypocrisy on Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac.


This is a copy of a letter from 2004 House Democrats and sent to then-President George W Bush. In it, the signatories complained that the administration had taken a hard line with ‘housing-related government sponsored enterprises’ (GSEs) such as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac by insisting on emphasizing fiscal prudence and responsible lending over increased affordable housing access. The relevant section?

We have been concerned that the Administration’s legislative proposal regarding the GSEs would weaken affordable housing performance by the GSEs, by emphasizing only safety and soundness. While the GSEs’ affordable housing mission is not in any way incompatible with their safety and soundness, an exclusive focus on safety and soundness is likely to come, in practice, at the expense of affordable housing.

Needless to say, this letter more or less completely subverts the narrative – lovingly created during the 2008 campaign, and kept up ever since – that the entire housing meltdown was really the (racist) Republicans’ fault.  Barney Frank is particularly outrageous, here: he’s gone from being Freddie Mac’s most devoted patron to calling for its dissolution without once explaining (or apologizing for) his own role in the mess.  Which is a strategy that worked fine in 2008; but it isn’t 2008 anymore.

Several additional thoughts on the matter:

  1. I think that we have established by now that the unprincipled expansion of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac – fueled by Democrats (including Maxine Waters, who is under investigation right now for using TARP money to bail out her husband’s residential loan-happy bank), by the way – is incompatible with promoting ‘safety and soundness’.
  2. I’m pretty sure that having our GSEs in a state of perpetual bailout is doing even more to hurt access to affordable housing.
  3. The signatories of the letter are, to the best of my knowledge, either all still in Congress or have had their seats taken by another Democrat.  This should be repaired: there is a list below.

Moe Lane

Hypocrite District 2010 GOP Candidate Website
Artur Davis AL-07 Don Chamberlain www.donchamberlain.me/
Mike Ross AR-04 Beth Anne Rankin http://www.bethannerankinforcongress.com/
Raul M. Grijalva AZ-07 Ruth McClung www.ruth4az.com/
George Miller CA-07 Rick Tubbs www.ricktubbs4congress.com/
Barbara Lee CA-09 Gerald Hashimoto www.geraldforcongress.com/
Anna Eshoo CA-14 Dave Chapman www.davechapmanforcongress.com/
Michael M. Honda CA-15 Scott Kirkland http://www.kirkland2010.com/
Sam Farr CA-17 Jeff Taylor www.taylor4congress.com/site/
Brad Sherman CA-27 Mark Reed www.markreedforcongress.com/
Maxine Waters CA-29 John P. Colbert www.johncolbertforcongress.com/
Lucille Roybal-Allard CA-34 Wayne Miller www.waynemiller34th.com/
Nancy Pelosi CA-8 John Dennis www.johndennis2010.com/
John Lewis GA-05 Fenn Little www.fennlittle.com
Jim Marshall GA-08 Austin Scott http://www.scottforga.com/
David Scott GA-13 Mike Crane www.craneforcongress.com/
Sanford D. Bishop GA-2 Mike Keown www.mikekeown.com/
Luis V. Gutierrez IL-04 Israel Vasquez www.israel2congress.com/index.html
Danny Davis IL-07 Mark Weiman www.weiman2010.com/
Dennis Mooore KS-03 Kevin Yoder www.yoderforcongress.com/
John Olver MA-01 Bill Gunn http://www.billgunnforcongress.org/
Richard E. Neal MA-02 TBD
James McGovern MA-03 Brian Herr www.brianherr.com/
Barney Frank MA-04 Sean Bielat www.seanbielat.org/
Martin Meehan MA-05 TBD
John F. Tierney MA-06 Bill Hudak www.hudakforcongress.com/
Michael Capuano MA-08 None
Stephen Lynch MA-09 TBD
William D Delahunt MA-10 TBD
Steny Hoyer MD-05 Charles Lollar www.lollarforcongress.com/index.php/home /
Sander M. Levin MI-12 Don Volaric www.volaricforcongress.com
John Dingell MI-15 Robert Steele www.robsteeleforcongress.com/
Betty McCollum MN-04 Teresa Collett www.collettforcongress.com/
Lacy Clay MO-01 Robyn Hamlin http://www.hamlinforcongress.com/
Bennie Thompson MS-02 Bill Marcy www.billmarcyforcongress.com/
Bob Etheridge NC-02 Renee Ellmers www.reneeforcongress.com/
David E. Price NC-04 B.J. Lawson http://www.lawsonforcongress.com/
Melvin Watt NC-12 Greg Dority www.gregdorityforcongress.com/
Brad Miller NC-13 William A. Randall www.randallforcongress.com/
Donald M Payne NJ-10 Michael Alonso www.michaeljalonso.com
Robert Menedenz NJ-13 Henrietta Dwyer http://www.dwyer4congress.com/
Steve Israel NY-02 John Gomez www.gomez2010.com/default/index.cfm
Carolyn McCarthy NY-04 Frank Scaturro www.frankscaturro.com/
Gary Ackerman NY-05 TBD
Gergory Meeks NY-06 Asher Taub www.taubforcongress.com
Joseph Crowley NY-07 TBD
Edolphus Towns NY-10 TBD
Carolyn Maloney NY-14 TBD
Charles Rangel NY-15 Michel Faulkner www.faulknerforcongress.com/
Joe Baca NY-23 TBD
Marcy Kaptur OH-09 Rich Iott www.voteiott.com/
Earl Blumenauer OR-03 Delia Lopez www.dlopezforcongress.com/
Robert A. Brady PA-01 Pia Varma www.votepia.com
Chaka Fattah PA-02 Rick Hellberg www.rickhellberg.mypoliticalsite.com/
Paul E. Kanjorksi PA-11 Lou Barletta www.loubarletta.com/
Patrick Kennedy RI-01 John Loughlin www.johnloughlin.org
James Langevin RI-02 Bill Clegg www.billcleggforcongress.com/index.php
Ruben Hinojosa TX-15 Eddie Zamora www.elect-eddiezamora.com/
Charles  A. Gonzalez TX-20 Clayton Trotter www.trotterforcongress.com/
Chris Bell TX-25 Donna Campbell http://www.drdonnaforcongress.com/
Robert C Scott VA-03 Chuck Smith www.chucksmith2010.com/
James P. Moran VA-08 J. Patrick Murray www.murray4congress.com/
Jay Inslee WA-01 James Watkins www.watkinsforcongress.com/
Jim McDermott WA-07 None
Nick Rahall WV-03 Elliott ‘Spike’ Maynard http://www.ilikespike.org/

Crossposted to Moe Lane.


Category: , ,

RSS feed

23 Comments Leave a comment

Frank can smell a subpoena re Fannie/Freddie. . .

msctex (Diary) Wednesday, September 8th at 5:35PM EST (link)

. . .and is working on a narrative of complete and total innocence, and blissful unawareness of all he did so much to put into motion.

I’d love to see him in prison, but we may need to make special arrangements.
Perhaps a woman’s prison.

Frank would want to be in a don't ask, don't tell prison. nt

Common_Cents (Diary) Wednesday, September 8th at 7:19PM EST (link)

Obama=Golfer in Chief, Leading from, behind, the Back Nine.
Leaders don’t create movements. Movements create leaders. Get involved. Your future depends on it.
Govt “invests” YOUR tax money for POLITICAL return rather than economic return.

 

Welcome to Obama's AmeriKa

greyhawk Friday, September 10th at 7:50AM EST (link)

This morning on Red State, they were talking about how the Radical Muslims through Violence and Threats of Violence have Cowed Us Down Once Again. This is the same thing they have done in France, Denmark, Germany, England and other European nations, and now they are bringing Their Radical Threats of Violence and Acts of Violence To America. The following are my comments to this: Thanks–Jerome

“So folks, welcome to the Kinder, Gentler America since we elected a president who is revered by Radical Muslims the world over, revered by Communist Dicatators the world over, revered by the Russians because he took down the nuclear shield that was in place in Eastern Europe as a reminder to the Empire Building Russians that they better not dare invade their neighbors.

Now, we are going to go the way of France and England and other European Nations where they have allowed Muslims and Their Sharia Laws to supplant their civil laws. Where Rule is By Violence or Threats of Violence.
Is it not pathetic that if you threaten to punch your next door neighbor in the nose that your neighbor can go and file a charge against you and you will be arrested for making terroristic threats, but if you are a Terrorist Religious Cult, you can Threaten To Murder American Citizens, and our government Does Absolutely Nothing, and in fact appeases the Radical Muslims.

The Muslims have basically laid down the gauntlet that says: “If any American or Anybody Else dare Offend Us, We Will Terrorize You.” And, what is really sickening about this is the fact that our own government and mainstream media is on the side of the Radical Muslims, and will use all the power of the U.S. Govenrnment and All the Power Of The Mainstream Media to Squash Anybody or Any Group that dares challenge them.

Welcome Folks to the New United Fascist States Of America. Fascism defined means “No opposition allowed.” This, my friends, is what our government has just told us. Also, look at what they are doing to Arizona and other States Who Dare Defend the Legitimate Laws of the Land.

Better wake up folks and rally Conservative Voters on November 2, 2010. At the rate the Obama-Pelosi Regime Dictatorship is moving, there may never be any elections ever again. If they will not tolerate basic First Amendment Rights of Speech and Expression, how long do you think they will tolertate the rest of the Bill of Rights and the U.S. Constitution, which one of the Communists in the Congress, Al Cee Hastings recently said when he was asked about the constitutionality of the Socialized Medicine Bill which they call Obama Care, Hastings replied: “What, the Constitution?? WE, The U.S. Congress do not care anything about the Constituton.” Al Cee Hastings was speaking for All of Congress and the President of the USA.

If you care about your freedoms and you do care about the Constitution, you need to get Out The Vote and Take America Back, and Totally Ignore the Mainstream Media, because they have just shown us how far they will go to Aid and Abet Our Enemies while Squashing A U.S. Citizen who dares express his Displeasure with Islam and With This Government and the Obama Regime. That little preacher in Florida had 50 members. Who would have ever heard of this guy had it not Been for The Mainstream Media and Our own Government Who Made it An International Event. Whose Side Is Our Government On?? Whose Side is our Mainstream Media on??? If you have been paying any attention at all at what is going on in America, you already know the answer to this question. Thanks—Jerome Ennis

greyhawk

 
 

Fannie and Freddie

jsanzone (Diary) Wednesday, September 8th at 5:49PM EST (link)

Are almost entirely responsible for the housing bubble.

But don’t overlook FHA (which few politicians dare touch) which has basically taken the two-steps-away government endorsement power of Fannie and Freddie, and made it even more direct.

Even if they eradicate all of them, there is still a Senate/Congressional majority (which has in the past included many Republicans who will still be there after November) that believes in “affordable housing” and federal involvement in the housing market.

If we’re going to fix this problem (i.e., prevent another disastrous government-made housing bubble), we must go to the root of it. The era of government-underwritten mortgages must end. If Fannie and Freddie (and the FHA) aren’t enough to change minds on that, I don’t know what is.

http://www.2010blog.net
20/10 Blog

 

Great Stuff, Moe; Thanks [nt]

Locke (Diary) Wednesday, September 8th at 6:40PM EST (link)

5

ywhyvon1 Wednesday, September 8th at 7:01PM EST (link)

Socialist with fork looking for Socialist with pork pie-unknown

 
 

Frank should be in prison.

NeoKong (Diary) Wednesday, September 8th at 7:57PM EST (link)

The damage he helped to cause cannot be measured.
Add to that Maxine Waters, Gregory Meeks and Artur Davis and many others.
I do not know why the Republicans do not pound Democrats into the ground with this as they are the ones most responsible.

Follow me on Twitter.

DemocRATs

oldmarine Thursday, September 9th at 10:06AM EST (link)

These same morons think they can manage 1/6 th of our economy under the guise of Obamacare.These socialist that aided and abetted the Fannie and Freddie fiasco should be in prison.

DemocRATs Franklin Raines and Jamie Gorelick under slick Willie’s directives to increase sub prime loans, both took millions in bonuses that the tax payers paid for and have no conscience .

The socialist that signed the letter and ringleader Frank and Waters should be in prison.Fannie and Freddie was nothing more than a cash cow for Democrats.The government needs to shut them down and raze both agencies!

 
 

They not only saw the financial meltdown coming

deano64 (Diary) Wednesday, September 8th at 7:59PM EST (link)

they welcomed it the day it did come. It gave them thier financial deform bill which gave them more fascist like control over the banks (more then they already had anyway). The law is very damaging to small to mid size banks and it puts us one step closer to nationalization of the banking system. Think “1st Statist Bank.”

Precinct Committeeman before it was cool.

“The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public’s money.”
Alexis De Tocqueville

 

A problem I have observed but have never seen mentioned

Locked and Loaded (Diary) Wednesday, September 8th at 10:36PM EST (link)

is the negative effect on rentals. The people who were placed in houses they could not afford should have been renting instead. Consequently, I have seen numerous apartment complexes under-rented, falling into disrepair, closing, you name it. Say what you will about this type of housing, it has (had?) a role to fill, and the apartment owners have been adversely impacted in a big way by the actions of these agitators. Home-wreckers is what they are.

 

I don't understand..

BoatFoot (Diary) Wednesday, September 8th at 10:38PM EST (link)

Why isn;t this running in every Republican Ad in all Congressional Districts? That and “Pelosi and Reid took over 4 years ago… are you better off now?”

My Diary: http://www.redstate.com/jbristor/

My thoughts exactly

tlhanger Thursday, September 9th at 7:15AM EST (link)

Since all those top Democrats got money directly from this, remember the guy who was a leader in Obamas campaign? Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are the Dems downfall and because he backed off, it was Bushes too. Take the lesson and run with it and start serving subpenas to all those who prospered from the boondoggle. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac closing would be an asset along with closing the Dept of Education. Hope some canidate has it put altogether before campaigning and taking office.

Terry L Hanger

 
 

Curse you John McCain

6eorge Jetson (Diary) Wednesday, September 8th at 10:46PM EST (link)

Saddled with a campaign manager that had gorged heavily at the Fannie trough, McCain took the path of least resistance and only in passing mentioned Fannie & Freddie. The result in 2008 was that the Dems got to transfer their culpability in the housing bubble to the Republicans.

And in regards to the “failed policies of the Bush era”?

Fannie & Freddie subsidized housing risk: NO DIFFERENT

Interest rates were kept low to goose the economy: NO DIFFERENT

A sea of spending-induced deficits: WHAT WAS A STORM IS NOW A TSUNAMI

“We’re not going back to the policies that caused the housing bubble/crisis?” B.S. Obama. You are pursuing the exact same policies that sent the economy into the ditch.

 

"Democratic Hypocrisy"

davesinsanantonio (Diary) Thursday, September 9th at 6:35AM EST (link)

is a redundancy.

 

Price must be defeated in NC-4

vamoose Thursday, September 9th at 9:13AM EST (link)

David Price (D-NC), one of the hypocrites on the list, is in trouble, as he should be. A poll commissioned by the Lawson campaign in mid-August showed Lawson ahead 45.6%-45.1%.

A historical note: Price lost his seat in 1994 and regained it in 1996. He could be one of the few, if not the only Dem, to be unseated in the GOP tsunamis of ’94 and ’10.

Polling

edintexas Thursday, September 9th at 9:37AM EST (link)

“A poll commissioned by the Lawson campaign in mid-August showed Lawson ahead 45.6%-45.1%.”

Poll commissioned by Lawson (and released) shows Lawson ahead. Gee, there’s a surprise, By the way, what was the margin of error on that poll? Seems to me being ahead 0.5% should be well within any margin of error. I know a lot of carpetbaggers have moved south to NC, so just being even may be a tremendous gain – but half a percentage point is not much of a lead in this year.

 
 

Improvement

vamoose Thursday, September 9th at 10:19AM EST (link)

I can appreciate your skepticism. However, in 2008 a Lawson internal poll that showed him trailing Price 56-31. Price defeated Lawson 63-37 in the general election. The DCCC cannot take Price’s seat for granted and will be diverting resources badly need elsewhere in an attempt to hold NC-4. Would those carpetbagging yankees invading the Triangle be any kin to those that elected Christie and Brown?

 

The Real Estate industry has to take

ihateliberals Thursday, September 9th at 11:45AM EST (link)

some of the blame for the bubble bursting. While Fannie/Freddie were loosening the rules for sound lending the industry was quick on the draw to get as many houses sold as possible at any cost. Most of the problem with the sub prime market was the fact that the rules allowed people to buy property they cold not afford. By that I mean through creative financing a person that could only really afford a $150K property was allowed to get interest only loans on $500K houses. That should not have been allowed. The crash came because the day came when these people that were paying the interest only payments of a few hundred dollars a month turned into a few thousand dollars. Generally more than they made per month. AS these loans were being called people began to sell off their property and instead of just a few thousand doing this 100′s of thousands of people were trying to get out all at the same time. “POP” goes the bubble!

Who lost in all of this? Not the Banks. While they will cry the blues they actually made out like the bandits they are. As people were losing their homes the banks were getting bailed out. Bonuses were being passed around and the economy collapsed.

 

MA-9 running against Stephen Lynch

alpinejager (Diary) Thursday, September 9th at 12:00PM EST (link)

Vernon Harrison
http://www.voteforvernon.com/

Keith Lepor
http://www.keithlepor2010.com/

our primary is next wednesday

 

Maxine Waters is in the 35th CD in CA

Ron Robinson (Diary) Friday, September 10th at 4:35PM EST (link)

Adam Schiff is the incumbent in the 29th and John Colbert is running in the 29th to defeat Schiff.

________________________________________
Ron Robinson
Chair, AD 49 Republican Central Committee
California Republican Central Committee
PROCINCT Author/ Founder
The Precinct Project
Unified Patriots – How-To: Activists Taking Action!
Follow Ron on Twitter

 

Yet More Evidence of a Failed Policy and Politicians!

soquelbythecreek Monday, September 13th at 8:12PM EST (link)

An excellent find!

Compare and contrast this to the letter sent by twenty Senators in May 2006.
https://docs.google.com/fileview?id=0B7w9In9khv39Zjc1Y2M4OTEtNzE2OS00MTBhLWI0YTMtOTk0ODliZDcyMmIx

“We are concerned that if effective regulatory reform legislation for the housing-finance government sponsored enterprises (GSEs) is not enacted this year, American taxpayers will continue to be exposed to the enonnous risk that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac pose to the housing market, the overall financial system, and the economy as a whole.”

“They are mammoth financial institutions with almost $1.5 Trillion of debt outstanding between them. With the fiscal challenges facing us today (deficits, entitlements, pensions and flood insurance), Congress must ask itself who would actually pay this debt if Fannie or Freddie could not?”

“Congress has the opportunity to recommit itself to the housing mission of the GSEs while at the same time making sure the GSEs operate in a manner that does not expose our financial system, or taxpayers, to unnecessary risk.”

“More importantly, Congress must ensure that the American taxpayer is protected in the event either GSE should fail.”

See more of the documented Fannie, Freddie timeline going back to 1999

Blog: Fannie, Freddie, and You as Secret Santa
http://soquelbythecreek.blogspot.com/2010/02/fannie-freddie-and-you-as-secret-santa.html

@SoquelCreek

@SoquelCreek

 

And Many Members of the Congressional Progressive Caucus

soquelbythecreek Monday, September 13th at 8:28PM EST (link)

The following signees are also members of the far-left-wing Congressional Progressive Caucus. Nancy Pelosi gave up her membership when she became Speaker of the House.
http://cpc.grijalva.house.gov/index.cfm?ContentID=166&ParentID=0&SectionID=4&SectionTree=4&lnk=b&ItemID=164

Hypocrite District 2010 GOP Candidate Website
Raul M. Grijalva AZ-07 Ruth McClung www.ruth4az.com/
George Miller CA-07 Rick Tubbs www.ricktubbs4congress.com/
Barbara Lee CA-09 Gerald Hashimoto www.geraldforcongress.com/
Michael M. Honda CA-15 Scott Kirkland http://www.kirkland2010.com/
Sam Farr CA-17 Jeff Taylor www.taylor4congress.com/site/
Maxine Waters CA-29 John P. Colbert www.johncolbertforcongress.com/
Lucille Roybal-Allard CA-34 Wayne Miller www.waynemiller34th.com/
Nancy Pelosi CA-8 John Dennis www.johndennis2010.com/
John Lewis GA-05 Fenn Little www.fennlittle.com
Luis V. Gutierrez IL-04 Israel Vasquez www.israel2congress.com/index.html
Danny Davis IL-07 Mark Weiman www.weiman2010.com/
John Olver MA-01 Bill Gunn http://www.billgunnforcongress.org/
James McGovern MA-03 Brian Herr www.brianherr.com/
Barney Frank MA-04 Sean Bielat www.seanbielat.org/
John F. Tierney MA-06 Bill Hudak www.hudakforcongress.com/
Michael Capuano MA-08 None
Lacy Clay MO-01 Robyn Hamlin http://www.hamlinforcongress.com/
Bennie Thompson MS-02 Bill Marcy www.billmarcyforcongress.com/
Melvin Watt NC-12 Greg Dority www.gregdorityforcongress.com/
Donald M Payne NJ-10 Michael Alonso www.michaeljalonso.com
Gary Ackerman NY-05 TBD
Carolyn Maloney NY-14 TBD
Charles Rangel NY-15 Michel Faulkner www.faulknerforcongress.com/
Marcy Kaptur OH-09 Rich Iott www.voteiott.com/
Earl Blumenauer OR-03 Delia Lopez www.dlopezforcongress.com/
Robert A. Brady PA-01 Pia Varma www.votepia.com
Chaka Fattah PA-02 Rick Hellberg www.rickhellberg.mypoliticalsite.com/
James P. Moran VA-08 J. Patrick Murray www.murray4congress.com/
Jim McDermott WA-07 None
Nick Rahall WV-03 Elliott ‘Spike’ Maynard http://www.ilikespike.org/

Fact Check: Socialists in the U.S. Congress?
http://soquelbythecreek.blogspot.com/2010/08/socialists-in-united-states-congress.html

@SoquelCreek

 

I remember watching the hearings on C-Span.

klondike Tuesday, September 14th at 12:29AM EST (link)

This video captures those hearings beautifully:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_MGT_cSi7Rs&feature