Diary

Worker Participation Is The Writing On The Wall

We’ve been a little bit lazy, I think, over the last couple of decades. – Pres. Obama

Pres. Obama was talking about his government’s laziness in attracting foreign investment (hint Mr. President: less government efforts actually attract investment, not more), but he may as well have been talking about the US in general since he took office. Of course Americans are far from lazy, they just respond to market signals like taxes and regulations, and the percent of adults who now work or wish to work portends doomsday.


Worker Participation Rate (%) By Year (1976-present)
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics

Worker participation is the percent of adults (16 and over) who are either working or are seeking work. As the chart shows, workforce participation drops off during recessions because some people give up on seeking work and either retire or join a shadow unmeasured economy. Significant drops in participation can be seen during the 1980-82 recession, the 1990 recession, and the 2001 recession, but they all pale to the collapse of worker participation over the past three years. In all the years measuring this metric, there has never been such a dramatic collapse in the percent of people who contribute to the measured economy.

The difference between an adult who works and who does not is the story of the US’s recent troubles. Workers pay taxes and consume fewer public resources like Food Stamps, Medicaid, Section 8, and Unemployment Insurance. Workers support the retired through Social Security and Medicare taxes. The arc of worker participation over the past 35 years mirrors the rise and fall of US prosperity and global standing.

The dramatic rise throughout the ’60s and ’70s reflects women joining the workforce, and followed the Regan revolution of unprecedented prosperity, basically paying for an ever growing government budget and runaway entitlement programs. However, worker participation fell off a cliff almost immediately after Obama took office. Possibly a coincidence, but his brutal FDR-like rhetorical assault on private enterprise, his hyper-regulatory legislation, and his partisan pro-union policies sent a message to employers to stop hiring.

This is not to say that people outside of the workforce do not contribute. For example, a dual income family that once used daycare or a nanny for their children might decide that the mother’s after-tax income would barely cover the cost of these services. When the mother decides to leave the workforce, she takes the worthwhile job of daycare or the nanny, but now all of these parties are not reporting income and paying taxes. By burdening businesses with regulation, taxes, and now the mandate to provide health care, many people find a way to get by outside of the workforce system.

The baby-boom generation that brought the US such fiscal gems as Medicare is retiring, creating a powerful drain on worker participation. The boomers are about a quarter of the US’s population, and without their employment, the US simply cannot pay its bills. Either boomers need to work longer or the US needs qualified immigrants in huge numbers over the next decade; without a workforce to support the retirement of the boomers, the US cannot survive as is.

The US’s worker participation rate is falling to that of socialized Europe. What the world generally sees as European laziness may actually be a rational response to socialism that discourages workforce participation. The US federal debt is likewise approaching that of Europe’s failed economies such as Greece and Italy. US debt is as much caused by overspending as it is anemic economic growth, much like Europe. Rather than a warning that anti-capitalism and over regulation lead to ruin, Europe’s example is a role model for Washington and the Obama administration. If the US’s economy ever rights itself, look to worker participation as the key measure of the turnaround.

Shout Bits can be found on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/#!/pages/Shout-Bits/191627784211089