Harry Reid Proposes Power Grid Take Over By Feds


Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D, NV) has just proposed that the federal government should take over the power grid in the country so that it might string power lines all across the land. At least that would be the outcome if his new proposal comes to fruition.

Reid wants created by federal fiat new “special power lines to carry renewable energy.” Further, he proposes that these “special power lines” be placed where the federal government says they should be placed. He says that to do this the Federal government would “be able override states” in the placement of these power lines.

The Federal government would be able override states and direct where the lines would go and who would pay for them.

It would be defacto control of the entire power grid by order of Congress.

But the plan raises many questions: how is it the American way to have Congress override states and force companies to build things they did not wish to build? How is it Congress’ place to say who should be forced to pay for these projects? Since when did Congress become civil engineers so that they are able to undertake such a project?

It’s the hubris of Congress on display once again.


Category:

RSS feed

10 Comments Leave a comment

I Don't have many good words for Harry Reid

oklahomajon Friday, March 6th at 6:49AM EST (link)

I don’t have many good words for Harry Reid I think of him of power hungry person and that is putting it mildly so I guess had move on before I write something I regret Oh well have great day yall

 

So how does this affect all the private power companies?

NeoKong (Diary) Friday, March 6th at 7:49AM EST (link)

It sounds a little like something Hugo Chavez would come up with.

So let’s see if I understand this correctly.
The gov.t controls the education system.They are trying to control the banking system.They want to have controlling interests in the auto industry.They want to take over the healthcare industry and regulate the drug companies and insurance providers.
Now Harry Reid wants to control the national power grid and nationalize that.

How are they not socialists…?

Follow me on Twitter.

You forgot to mention oil and gas

civil truth (Diary) Friday, March 6th at 10:28AM EST (link)

The administation and Congress is just itching for the opening to take over the oil and gas companies. At that point, why bother with elections; no one will be able to campaign against the government lest they become another of the “disappeared”.

The greatest evil…is conceived and ordered (moved, seconded, carried, and minuted) in clean, carpeted, warmed, and well-lighted offices, by quiet men with white collars and cut fingernails and smooth-shaven cheeks who do not need to raise their voice. Hence, naturally enough, my symbol for Hell is something like the bureaucracy of a police state or the offices of a thoroughly nasty business concern. -C.S. Lewis

http://www.gmsplace.com/

 
 

Preparing

DerKrieger (Diary) Friday, March 6th at 7:49AM EST (link)

For the push back against the eco-marxists anti-energy plan of powering the US on sunshine and hot air.

“In questions of power, let no more be heard of confidence in man, but bind him down from mischief by the chains of the Constitution.” – Thomas Jefferson

“I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents.” – James Madison

Whenever the legislators endeavor to take away and destroy the property of the people, or to reduce them to slavery under arbitrary power, they put themselves into a state of war with the people, who are thereupon absolved from any further obedience.” — John Locke, 1690

 

The Senator DOES realize...

fmaidment (Diary) Friday, March 6th at 7:54AM EST (link)

…that one electron is pretty much just like another, doesn’t he?

“Special” power lines are a joke of a concept. If there’s economical power available and consumers of that power near enough to it, the power companies will build their own power lines. They don’t need the Feds to tell them where to build.

Were I a power company exec and someone in Congress told me where to build my power lines, I’d tell him, “Tell ya’ what. YOU write the checks and spend my company’s money. Just remember, there’s laws in my state against check fraud.”

Follow Me on Twitter

“I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it.”
– - Thomas Jefferson, to Archibald Stuart, 1791

Right on.

evanm (Diary) Friday, March 6th at 8:32AM EST (link)

Consider:

Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) issued Order No. 888, directing utilities to file Open Access Transmission Tariffs (OATTs), breaking the host utility’s monopoly on the transmission system and allowing any electric marketer to use the host utility’s transmission lines for a cost-based fee.

So, right now, there are companies whose sole purpose is to locate electric transmission lines along the cheapest, most convenient route. These companies were created by regulatory fiat; FERC said they have to exist, because “monopolies are bad.”

So now, Harry Reid proposes we replace the whole thing with… a government monopoly. Awesome.

 
 

Harry Reid is Correct

tedpomeroy (Diary) Friday, March 6th at 7:55AM EST (link)

This is interstate commerce. Just like the railroads etc. It is good to see a return to the Congressional job description.

Some States have been irresponsible. Mario Cuomo’s New York comes to mind. Actually decommissioned a nearly completed nuclear power plant on Long Island and told the utility to write it off on their Federal Taxes, Now Long Island and NYC are stuck in a continual power shortage. They have blackouts every summer. They even pulled down part of the Grid in New Jersey back in the summer of 2003.

So this is ok in a Federalist sense. When we take back Congress some real good can be accomplished.

But in the meantime

ehosterman (Diary) Friday, March 6th at 9:07AM EST (link)

we’ll have power lines to nowhere instead of bridges. This is already regulated by FERC. Congress has no business telling industry what to build.

 
 

I AGREE. SO MANY CASUALTIES. ANOTHER FED ATTEMPT TO USURP STATE RIGHTS.

Rod_Patrick (Diary) Friday, March 6th at 9:41AM EST (link)

Besides electric power, this GIGANTIC MONOPOLY that Harry Reid is intending to create at the federal level will surely have so much economic power against the states.

Besides failing the Anti-Trust test, this one will further shun PRIVATE SECTOR INVESTMENTS in the electric power market.

Usual suspicion: This move has a covert agenda of limiting the entry of financial feasible clean-coal and even natural gas projects in favor of the renewables, which the diary has mentioned.

Remember the fiasco of the “STRANDED COSTS” during the period of dergulation and privatization in the power industry? Do we want to repeat that?

Finally, how can we be so sure that such Huge Government-controlled company will be different from the fate of Fannie and Freddie?

 

In concept I think this is a good idea

gardenstateeric (Diary) Friday, March 6th at 11:11AM EST (link)

If I want to bring in power from West Virginia to NJ, I’d have to cross PA to do so, but what incentive does PA have to facilitate the transfer on local rights of way? A federal siting law is probably a good thing. I doubt the execution of this concept by Reid will be useful in the slightest, but that said, perhaps something good could be salvaged out of this later. Does anyone doubt that the real purpose here is to ship Nevada solar across the Mojave into the LA basin over the squaks of enviros? Let these guys eat each other for lunch over this, no skin off my nose.