My intel, like just about everything else I purport to know, is anecdotal. Life is stories, some only last a day, while others have more legs than others.
Sometimes Arab tea talk is like that sudden flush of a covey of birds up ahead in the thicket…the last ripple in a seismic event happening further away. But my Arab friends in the Balkans, who hear from their friends in Beirut, who hear in the street from Hezbollah, who hear from Damascus, or maybe Tehran (one never knows)…all over tea and whiskey…
…that it may get very ugly this week in Iran. As you know, tomorrow is the the last day of Iran’s ten-day “celebration” of the Fall of the Shah in 1979.
Some in Hezbollah worries that the regime may actually fall. Some in Paris worry that it won’t. I worry that once again, Washington won’t really care, assuming Israel will know when to take care of business, allowing both us and the world that congregates around One UN Plaza to breathe a secret sigh of relief while condemning and vilifying the authors of that relief. same oh, same oh.
Since September, both Bernie and I have written, with admittedly some tongue in cheek about the need for a third party (France) to break this cycle, both removing the Iranian threat and Israel as the go-to bad boy in the Middle East…and also denying Ahmahdinejab his end-time dream of Armageddon.
In November, 2008 I wrote a piece about the loss of cultural memory, a portion of which is pertinent here, and Iran. I wrote:
In 1978 the people of Iran lived under a benign despot called the Shah. He was a king with near absolute power, had a secret police, an army that jumped as his command, and a cosmopolitan Islamic nation that had the highest standard of living in the Middle East. Most of the people scarcely noticed the awful power the Shah possessed, for he rarely used it against them. The Persian people have the most mellifluous language in the world, even more so than Arabic, a delightful and gregarious personality, enjoy good food and wearing colorful attire. They loved to shop, ski, hunt, and sit at cafes drinking chai or kafe…and tell stories.
But there was something in their personality that made them feel that it wasn’t enough. Indeed, it wasn’t enough, but that is a different story. While they were the most modern of Muslim states, Barbara Walters insulted the Shah by telling him on national television that he was moving too slow on liberating women. She made him look petty to the world. Many Persians traveled abroad to get educations in pursuits for which there were no jobs in Iran. There was only oil and oil-related industry in Iran. And rug-making. Underwater basket weaving in the Persian Gulf was but a dream, several generations away from ever being a reality, although southern California universities had been giving degrees in that discipline for years. So, many young Iranians became disgruntled, and being young, took their anger out on the recently-belittled head of the nation without clearly thinking about the alternatives. (This is not intended to be an allegory about the most recent election in America, but it may fit. Time will tell.)
At the same time, as with all modernizing Islamic nations, there was an underbelly of disquiet among Muslims who generally dislike anything modern, especially the clothes women wore, with all those bumps and bulges that are supposed to be left unseen under Moslem teachings (sic).
End of story. In 1979 the Persian people invited back the Ayatollah Khomeini, who had been in exile in France, and very quickly a revolution established him as supreme leader, an Islamic Republic was announced, and all of sudden, almost over night, every woman in Iran was wearing a long black, loose fitting smock that went all the way down over the ankles.
I’m not sure when the women (and most men) of Iran actually began to regret that little foot-stomping fit they threw back in ’78. But we know they did at some time shortly thereafter. Only it was too late.
That was almost thirty years ago, and while the itch to be free of those drab rags and other restrictions over their public lives grows daily, the boot of oppression on their neck grows heavier and heavier with every passing day. Why this is so is because they invoked certain natural laws of totalitarianism that take on a life of their own. Even the French and Spanish pale when up against middle Eastern bureaucrats.
The point of this little excursion into ethnic teat-fits is why that 30 year mark is so important. You see, in Iran right now, over half the population have never known life without that black garb and the religion police. To them, life, while dull, is also normal. Iran is at a crucible, for every day a little bit of the memory of how things used to be dies out, replaced with a generation who has known nothing else. In another twenty years it will almost all be lost.
What saves Iran is her stories. All they have now are the stories…the stories told by mothers to daughters inside their homes, where they can still pull out old clothes from the wardrobe and play dress up and dream just a little. But at 30 years, even these exercises can become risky, for school children are taught to snitch out their own parents, just like they are in Berkeley, or to eavesdrop other school children to find out who’s having forbidden thoughts and dreams.
Right now Iran survives on her stories and dreams. Her future rests on those stories, for they are all they have. At least that’s how my side of the coin looks at it. Socialism, of course, doesn’t see things this way. But now you understand what the anthropologists mean by “survival-enhancing.”
The great fear here, of course, as it was after the last election in Iran, is that the people will once again take to the streets, and the United Nations (expectedly) will do nothing but huff and puff and issue statements, and the United States (out of character until recently) will defer and more or less tag along behind the UN.
For reasons that are beyond me the United States seems to have detached the popular desire of the Iranian people to be free and the regime’s headlong rush to become a nuclear military power. They are two issues which stand alone! And as long as Israel can be relied upon to have equal if not superior intelligence than we do, especially as to where Iran stands in nuclear development, the US feels it doesn’t have to budge from this detached view of reality.
What we do know, and what the Arab tea talk seems to confirm, the people of Iran know, and regime of Iran knows, even if Lady Disdain and the State Department don’t, and this is about to come to a head, a win or bust situation (much like some Americans already envision and dread here)…in which, without massive shows of world support, no matter what China says, the people will lose. It will be over. And Iran will slip into an abyss of even more total totalitarianism for the most part of another generation.
We know there are back channels, but unless “the people” are getting secret messages from our government, or through Michael Ledeen, this is about to become one huge blind roll of the dice. Imagine turning everything you own to cash and hurrying off to Atlantic City, and putting the whole pile on the pass line. Double or nothing. Crap.
This is why we believe a third party needs to step forward and become a game changer.
And this time, we are serious.
Aaron Gardner
Steve Maley
KnightsofMalta
France to the rescue!
6eorge Jetson (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 8:17AM EST (link)Is this a bizarro world or what?
I do not hold out hope that France will act....
penguin2 (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 9:15AM EST (link)Though maybe in the deepest level of of their security and self-interests, is the means and the will to move. Sometimes I get a sense of two Frances. The one that is placid, anti-military and indifferent to world events; other times I sense, just maybe, they have the fight and seriousness underneath, and the other is a facade.
Your words are serious, Vassar, and whether it is tomorrow or next week, or month, something will happen that sends out those ripples….Just as you note that a generation in Iran has known nothing but the current regime and oppression and bleakness, we also have a generation, that has known only one way of life. Unfortunately for us, the people here have known little of want or lack of freedom. The memory cards have been swiped of having to strive, and struggle and thus appreciate what we have. That which comes too easy is taken for granted. IMO, we have a whole generation with this mind-set, thus we are even further removed from the oppression of other peoples and are oblivious to our own danger.
I am afraid it will indeed be Israel once again, that makes the move, and saves us from our own and others isolationism.
“Arab tea talk” oh to be a fly on the wall, and of course if I could understand the language….Another favorite light read of mine is Agatha Christie’s “They Came to Bagdad” written in the 50′s by her, but still available. Strange how the books of so long ago seem almost prophetic now.
I am glad you have returned safely, though I am sure you had to shovel some snow upon your return.
Resistance to tyrants is obedience to God. – Benjamin Franklin
When Good stands up to Evil, Evil blinks. – Vassar Bushmills
Conservative Education: Suggested Reading List
Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots
Thanks, Lady P. Airports are no fun anymore...
Vassar Bushmills (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 11:37AM EST (link)…and all those swarthy-skinned people fiddling their worry beads.
Remind me one day to post a piece I wrote three-four years ago, about Europe’s riff raff terminals (really) where they steer all the people who wear drab clothes, or drab skins, from cities that have lots of 6 point Scrabble letters in their names. You never see people dgoing to Dusseldorf and people going to Skopye anywhere near one another.
They all do it…except America. Just one more reason…
About my point on France, I know it is unlikely. But the fact that a third party needs to do this is (I think) a correct assessment. But the Iranians, as are all totalitarians, paranoid as can be, and just imagine the consternation if a major media outlet picked up that a major political website in the US is recommending it.
Just the mere fact that France would have to trot out some minor foreign affairs deputy to say they aren’t considering any such thing would have a lot of heads turning. See how it works?
A perfect set-up, if you ask me. You read Ausonius’ piece on Chaos…this is how it becomes manifest..,. a single fly in the buttermilk.
Cheers
Israel Will defend themselves
Black River Wolf (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 10:03AM EST (link)Even without the Blessings of our WON.
The only other Game Changer that think of that has any kind of power (limited as it is) is Russia. And they would not be on the side of freedom.
The rest of the world will follow the UN like sheep,as they do with Manbearpig. The EU is just an extension of the EU in my mind.
And if Israel does protect itself from nuclear annihilation, they will be the ones the EU and UN will go after, while behind closed doors the EU will praise.
The PC police are too entrenched in the UN and EU to have them effectively do anything against Iran. Can not say anything bad about Islam, but Christianity, have at it.
“In my many years I have come to a conclusion that one useless man is a shame,
two is a law firm, and three or more is a congress.”—-John Adams
Vassar, do you have any sense of what the "punch"
janis (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 10:55AM EST (link)is supposed to be that will supposedly stun us in the West? I know they want to sound as menacing as possible, but I’d like to know whether they mean that they intend to so brutally suppress any dissent in their country that it will stun the rest of the world, or whether they intend to deliver some violence against the US or US interests in the Middle East.
Did anyone have any pertinent stories about that one? And it’s nice to have you home again!
Not a clue, Janis
Vassar Bushmills (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 11:27AM EST (link)Only read that today, myself. Over there I only get BBC and CNN World or whatever they call it. Coming from Khameini rather then Obama the Squirt tells us something, but I’m not an Iranologist in the least.
I’d be checking in on Ledeen, or maybe Drudge, who has some very good people who comment and post there.
Watch two things.........
Kenny Solomon (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 5:31PM EST (link)1. Israel’s skies for mushroom clouds and also at ground level for chem/bio.
My gut is telling me our good friends The Russians and/or China traded them some toys for oil….. no proof, just a gut feeling,
The ramifications to that are staggering.
China and/or Russia Yes, we did…….and you will do nothing, poseur president, nothing.
2. Foreign journalists in Iran.
They can get disappeared real quick-like.
————-
Now then, a c/p from my comment on Erick’s diary……..
When/if Israel moves to stop Iran, I have zero doubt in my mind that this administration will move on Israel and not just by cutting off all aid, recalling Ambassadors and Consuls. Remember that Harold Koh and Samantha Power are the chief cooks and bottle washers of The Middle East for The Dept. of State.
—————-
Let’s say that Israel does move……… and……. I don’t think I’m taking too big of a leap here – and POTUS shows his true colors (which are barely contained beneath the surface).
The wild card: Will anyone (other than Muslims) currently wearing a US uniform obey an order to attack Israel ?
Or does the US Military disobey a direct order from it’s C-in-C ?
What then……. either way ?
Could our Dictator In Training Pants really be that hell-bent ? I think he can.
Not disobey Kenny, but orders can be garbled...
nessa (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 5:41PM EST (link)…requiring additional time to retransmit and clarify errors of understanding. “Ohhhh, you wanted us to shoot down the Israeli planes, I thought you said refuel the Israeli planes. What? Well yes we did, not that much, less than nancy uses flying back and forth in a month. We didn’t give them any Grey Goose either. What? OK, we’ll be ready next time.”
“If you love wealth more than liberty, the tranquility of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, depart from us in peace. We ask not your counsel nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feeds you. May your chains rest lightly upon you and may posterity forget that you were our countrymen.”—Samuel Adams
Contributor to Unified Patriots
teh twitter
Garbled is good........
Kenny Solomon (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 5:53PM EST (link)But I’ve got a feeling these freaks of nature in the administration have their people right where they want them.
God help me if I’m right.
Did we just
Bedell Friday, February 12th at 4:02PM EST (link)get bluster? I’ve been in a cave for a few days.
Iran shut down gmail today
Beaglescout (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 11:48PM EST (link)Preparatory to the action tomorrow.
“A nation which can prefer disgrace to danger is prepared for a master, and deserves one.”
I've met the gaze of people you describe vassar...
nessa (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 6:12PM EST (link)…the ones who have lost even their dreams. It was outside Fallujah, Iraq in 2003. It was a frightening and moving experience. Old movies talk about the 1000 yard stare, that’s what I saw. No hope, no chance, just another day of miserable existence, flat, emotionless eyes, no glint, nothing just a bottomless pit where a soul used to be.
But, I saw a change come over many of those eyes before I left in 2004, I saw the same hope glimmer in eyes in Afghanistan in 07-08. They had gotten a taste of hope, they could see a possibility on the distant horizon. Some of those eyes had walked or ridden a donkey for three days to reach a Jirga (townhall meeting) in Khost Province. Being a part of their own future was what had put the life back into their eyes. That was enough to convince me that we were doing the right thing there. By all rights America should be supporting the people of Iran as well, at the very least the same kind of support Reagan gave the Poles in the 80s. It doesn’t require troops and billions of dollars. The voice of the Nation that “opened all eyes to the rights of man” can be a powerful weapon and a great friend in the darkness of tyranny. Ask the Poles.
But I guess the best we can hope is that some other Nation steps forward and does what we should.
“If you love wealth more than liberty, the tranquility of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, depart from us in peace. We ask not your counsel nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feeds you. May your chains rest lightly upon you and may posterity forget that you were our countrymen.”—Samuel Adams
Contributor to Unified Patriots
teh twitter
Then you know, Nessa...
Vassar Bushmills (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 6:50AM EST (link)(Great post on Murtha, by the way. )
There are only two powers in the region who can be that “other” nation, Russia and France. OK, maybe Britain. But Russia’s playing from the bottom of the deck, Britain is as feckless as we are and France, well, actually has a leader who has a pair. When’s the last time you saw that?
No matter what you say nice about George Bush, I’ll agree. But I think history in the end will record all the shoulda’s and coulda’s that he didn’t do as his final legacy. He and Cheney split over Iran, specifically taking out their nuclear capability on his watch, rather than passing it off. Just like turning the other cheek and passing off the Constitution, along with my ass, and my children’s ass to Barack Obama, he passed over the surefire needless deaths of thousands of Iranians, also to the inaction of Barack Obama, and possibly at the hands of the Israelis.
Israel will do what has to be done, but the aftermath will prove they really needed a surrogate in this. It should have george Bush.
Neither the American people...
rbdwiggins (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 7:10PM EST (link)nor the majority party had the appetite to do what was necessary and proper regarding Iran’s nuclear program.
And a group of senate Democrats, flexing their new-found muscle, clearly intended to make it even harder, if not impossible, for President Bush to use military force against Iran.
And a month later we “learned” that in the fall of 2003, Tehran halted its nuclear weapons program. Although many thought otherwise at the time (myself included), now we’re certain that wasn’t the case.
I believe that given the chance for a do-over, President Bush would have followed Cheney’s advice.
The “cost” would have been much less then, than it will now.
“Well, the trouble with our liberal friends is not that they are ignorant, but that they know so much that isn’t so.” – Ronald Reagan
We need to wait 3 years
E Pluribus Unum (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 7:05PM EST (link)I am so not kidding. If the US is not the muscle behind it, it will fail. And with Marxist Bambi calling the shots, the official policy of the United States may well be to be the cheerleaders for the evil dictators, just like it was in Honduras.
If it is win or die, the Iranian people need, respectfully, to simmer, to plan, to hide their hand, for nearly exactly 3 years. Specifically, till about Feb 1, 2013, when the new Republican president has had enough time to at least form a coherent government voice.
Kill the Terrorists
Protect the Borders
Punch the Hippies h/t IMAO
Which is why Iran is moving now.
Steph C (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 8:44AM EST (link)It has always been the U.S. never more so than during and after WWII.
Ahmedinejad might be a totalitarian nutcase but he’s not stupid. Some of the worst dictators in history were extremely intelligent.
“[I]f the public are bound to yield obedience to laws to which they cannot give their approbation, they are slaves to those who make such laws and enforce them.” –Candidus in the Boston Gazette, 1772
Hillbilly Politics
Iran is an easy problem to solve now
David123 (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 7:56PM EST (link)Germany was an easy problem to solve in 1934
David123
Germany plays its cards close to its chest these days.
Steph C (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 8:47AM EST (link)I wouldn’t discount them as the “wild” card. It might seem unlikely right now but …
“[I]f the public are bound to yield obedience to laws to which they cannot give their approbation, they are slaves to those who make such laws and enforce them.” –Candidus in the Boston Gazette, 1772
Hillbilly Politics
Nobody ever went broke underestimating...
Vassar Bushmills (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 9:26AM EST (link)…the cupidity of the League of Nations/UN.
What was true in Geneva in 1933 is true today at One UN Plaza. And I think it’s catching.
Can't disagree with that. nt
Steph C (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 10:52AM EST (link)“[I]f the public are bound to yield obedience to laws to which they cannot give their approbation, they are slaves to those who make such laws and enforce them.” –Candidus in the Boston Gazette, 1772
Hillbilly Politics