Faith in Gettysburg


From the Diaries by Leon.

 

     This past October on Lincoln Square in Gettysburg, my family participated in the annual “Life Chain,” a prayerful hour of silent witness against abortion. The prayer on Lincoln Square was part of the larger national Life Chain effort on the same day, with participants in over 1500 cities (1). The reaction we received was largely positive, as passing motorists smiled, waved, or gave us the thumbs up. Only one detractor yelled out his car window, “I can’t believe you brought children to this!” Because he seemed to be pro-abortion, I’m not sure if he opposed the presence of children at the Life Chain specifically, or the world outside the womb in general.

 

     When I reviewed local coverage of the event the next day, I was delighted to read a story sympathetic to the pro-life movement (2). The reporter wrote from the perspective of two demonstrators who regretted having abortions. The article even provided information on Silent No More Awareness, an organization that helps post-abortive men and women cope with the loss of their child(ren) (3).

 

      What is interesting is that this demonstration could have been stopped if Gettysburg had wanted to suppress it. The day of the Life Chain coincided with Gettysburg College’s alumni homecoming weekend, a (hopefully) busy time for downtown businesses, and a passable excuse for Gettysburg borough council to reject the Life Chain’s permit application. But the permit was granted, the businesses on the square were gracious, and about 100 of us, holding signs and praying quietly, lined the sidewalks in the heart of Gettysburg.

 

     Having exercised my First Amendment rights in Gettysburg recently, I was bewildered by allegations on both Fox Nation and RedState that Gettysburg was trying to “kick God out of town” through code enforcement action against the Civil War Chapel, a bivouac-type gathering place built by the US Christian Commission (4), (5). The subsequent destruction of the chapel by arsonists amplified the claims and triggered an accusation that the town leadership had desecrated Gettysburg’s hallowed ground (6).  

 

     If you are reading this, you are probably among the Americans who, heeding President Lincoln’s words, have dedicated yourself to the unfinished task of giving “this nation under God…a new birth of freedom.” For you, any intimation that Gettysburg has forsaken God would be most distressing. Rest assured, the reports of His eviction are grossly exaggerated.

 

     Today, this 7500-citizen town is home to 34 religious congregations (7). Tablets bearing the Ten Commandments remain the cornerstone of the courthouse. Today, the US Christian Commission renovates a new museum space to accommodate growing receptiveness to its ministry to visitors (8). Today at the Lutheran Theological Seminary at Gettysburg, over 250 men and women prepare for a life of service to God (9). Today, construction continues on St. Francis Xavier Catholic Church’s new school and parish life center because the existing facilities are bursting with the faithful (10). As snow falls on Gettysburg today, the Adams Rescue Mission shelters 6 families and 33 single men, in Jesus’ name (11). Today, a petition bearing the signatures of 66 local religious leaders implores the Pennsylvania State Gaming Control Board not to grant a license to the proposed Gettysburg casino (12). Today, Prince of Peace Episcopal Church plans for a permanent move of its soup kitchen to a larger venue (13). Today a Christmas tree stands alone in the center of town, hailing the upcoming celebration of Christ’s birth.

 

     In short, the people of Gettysburg freely exercise their religious beliefs. In doing so, they have proclaimed God’s Good News. They have let their children come unto Jesus. They have provided for Him when He was hungry and homeless. Please have faith in Gettysburg, because, as far as I can see, Gettysburg is keeping its faith in God.

 

1. http://www.nationallifechain.org/

2. Katharine Harmon. ‘A silent witness.’ Evening Sun (Hanover, PA) – Sunday, October 3, 2010.

3. http://www.silentnomoreawareness.org/

4. http://nation.foxnews.com/culture/2010/11/22/gettysburg-wants-kick-god-out-town

5. http://www.redstate.com/ladyimpactohio/2010/11/19/gettysburg-wants-to-kick-god-out-of-town-threatens-historic-civil-war-chapel/

6. http://www.redstate.com/ladyimpactohio/2010/12/07/arson-officially-ruled-as-cause-of-fire-which-destroyed-gettysburg-chapel-burned-god-out-of-town/

7. http://www.gettysburg.com/communit/church.htm

8. http://www.usccgettysburg.org/museum.asp

9. http://www.ltsg.edu/Prospective-Students/files/Gettysburgseminary_Viewbook

10. Craig K. Paskoski. ‘Sneak preview for new school.’ Evening Sun (Hanover, PA) – Wednesday, November 3, 2010.

11. http://adamsrescuemission.org/

12. http://nocasinogettysburg.ning.com/notes/Casino_Comments_closed,_NCG_Delivers_

Petitions

13. http://www.gettysburgsoupkitchen.org/


Category: , , , ,

RSS feed

31 Comments Leave a comment

Uma

Leon H. Wolf (Diary) Friday, December 10th at 9:22PM EST (link)

Great piece and thanks for doing it. You know, they have these things called “links” that all the kids are using these days… :)

Seriously, if you need help learning how to do them, lemme know.

————
We can’t stop here. This is bat country.

Thanks, Leon.

Uma Richie (Diary) Friday, December 10th at 11:05PM EST (link)

I used to type my diaries in html. I felt like this diary was overdue and wanted to get it out there.

Thanks Uma Richie and Leon

jimmyg Friday, December 10th at 11:38PM EST (link)

I am ashamed of myself. This nonsense went on for three diaries before Leon and yourself challenged the contention made by the writer of the original diaries. I am reluctant to challenge much of what passes as fact in some of these diaries. Opinion is one thing, the writer of the diaries in question rendered her opinions as though they were fact, and many, if not most of the regulars encouraged her without differentiating fact from her opinion. This allowed the Town of Gettysburg to be slandered without any blowback. Why am I ashamed? I knew this, I knew that this was a story made of whole cloth, but feared rendereing a contrary opinion, and stayed silent. As of late, at least the last several months, opinons contrary to some of the regulars, lead to piling on and name calling, which I try to avoid. For this I apologize.

No kidding

scorpio0679 (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 3:18AM EST (link)

jimmyg, I feel your pain.

@OP: thanks for this wonderful read. The only thing I love hearing about more than conservatives beating liberals is the work of Christ in the hearts of men. It is truly an amazing thing.

jimmy and scorpio

Uma Richie (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 11:50AM EST (link)

Thanks for your comments. I think the outrage expressed was justified, but the targeting needed more precision. My personal opinion is that the church arson was more than a reckless act by three teenagers.

 
 
 
 
 

Thanks

rdelbov Friday, December 10th at 10:50PM EST (link)

for the message.

May God Bless

Our Church is a week away from our annual food basket (actually a box now) program. We will assemble 1200 baskets for those folks who are in need. From Maine to Hawaii there private efforts aimed at helping those folks who are down and out. Times are a little tough right now so its not a good time to cut back on charity. My wife and I try to spend as much on those folks in need as we do on presents for ourselves or our family. As Uma’s story shows there is a “reason for the season”.

There was a post earlier today on Bill Buckley. I wanted to comment on it but felt inadequate. Here is perhaps a better place for a comment on WFB. He was a man of God. William Buckley had no problem reconciling God and Conservatism. In his life he apparently lived by the motto “what would it profit a man if he gained the whole world and lost his life”.

I believe in Providence- whether its in Gettysburg PA or Rhode Island. We all live imperfectly in this life. Yet I believe we are placed here for a reason and in a condidtion that we cannot fully understand.

So whether Providence has placed in a position of need or a place of plenty. May God Bless you during this time of year.

Thank you, rdelbov.

Uma Richie (Diary) Friday, December 10th at 11:35PM EST (link)

That’s a lot of mouths to feed. May God bless you and your family.

 
 

God will never be driven out of any town that has one faithful person in it

SoulEspresso Saturday, December 11th at 12:25AM EST (link)

even if arsonists burn all the churches to the ground.

But it doesn’t sound like that’s a danger in Gettysburg. Thanks to Uma for writing this and Leon for promoting it.

Folks, there’s a time for scorched-earth tactics in politics. Some occasions might even call for sensationalist promotion.

But when it comes to the faith delivered to the saints, we’re talking a long game–one that carries us into eternity. Christians who are led to become political activists can never have an “ends justify the means” attitude in religious liberty issues, because the ends are never in our hands; we only have the means. If those means are not the means of Christ we cannot expect His blessing.

So true, SoulEspresso.

Uma Richie (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 11:52AM EST (link)

Thank you so much for your comments.

 
 

I lost my job this week for what

wethepeoplevstheprogressives (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 1:35AM EST (link)

I can only in Gods eyes, see as a wake up call because I chose to ignore and/or put-off all the relatively gracious other signs! Thank you for being a leader in many things not the least of which is the reason for the season. I would only like to add the following….we have heard far too many times recently that elections have consequences…I also am living proof IMO that stubborness, inaction, fear, and selfishness have grave consequences as well. God bless all you who read this

Thank you, wethepeople.

Uma Richie (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 11:54AM EST (link)

God bless you too, and I hope that God will open a window of opportunity for you soon.

 
 

That was lovely.

elizabeth bennet Saturday, December 11th at 4:48AM EST (link)

Thank you for posting.

Thank you elizabeth. (nt)

Uma Richie (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 11:55AM EST (link)
 

Uma, thank you for this wonderful piece.

Danielle Davis (ocleverone) (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 10:16AM EST (link)

I was bewildered at the original thread, but having only a passing knowledge of Gettysburg (visiting a few times with a 14 year old history buff) I didn’t know if my surface observations were valid.

Thank you for writing this. Beautifully done.

To me, “consensus” seems to be the process of abandoning all beliefs, principles, values and policies. So it is something in which no one believes and to which no one objects … There are still people in my party who believe in “consensus” politics. I regard them as Quislings, as traitors … I mean it. — Margaret Thatcher

Thank you, ocleverone.

Uma Richie (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 12:16PM EST (link)

Keep bringing the kiddos back.

 
 

The real import of the story was...

Ron Robinson (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 10:36AM EST (link)

… really about a couple of arsonists who unilaterally made a ‘decision’ on behalf of others in the community and thereby deprived many – even the authorities – of their right to decide. IE; the actions of a few subsumed and violated the rights of the many.

At least to me that’s what it was about.

________________________________________
Ron Robinson
Chair, AD 49 Republican Central Committee
California Republican Central Committee
PROCINCT Author/ Founder
The Precinct Project
Unified Patriots – How-To: Activists Taking Action!
Follow Ron on Twitter

Ron, there is so much more to write.

Uma Richie (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 12:23PM EST (link)

My first priority was to correct the record regarding Gettysburg’s honor.

As for everything else, including the code enforcement actions and the possible motives of the arsonists, I need to write another diary and lay it out for debate.

 
 

Thank you for writing this.

runner12 (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 11:14AM EST (link)

I am still wary that the code violations were legitimate regarding the chapel, but I understand where you are coming from and would probably be offended if someone characterized my hometown in a negative light based on the actions of a few. Thank you for sharing with us this wonderful story and giving everyone a different perspective of Gettysburg.

Thank you, runner12.

Uma Richie (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 12:30PM EST (link)

I hope to write another diary in the next week outlining some local issues that I didn’t even know existed, but very well may have influenced the council’s actions.

What I will tell you quickly is that in 2005, local businesses started an organization to hold council accountable for arbitrary code enforcement. In 2007, council rewrote much of the town ordinance to try to streamline it. In 2009, a serial litigant started suing a bunch of Gettysburg businesses over Americans With Disabilties Act violations. This is an ongoing nightmare, as the businesses can’t satisfy both the ADA and the Gburg Historic Architectural Board at the same time. And that’s on top of the casino, and the property tax reassessment, and the new NPS visitor center.

 
 

Thanks, Uma.

Loren Heal (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 1:51PM EST (link)

As someone who helped pass around the original story, I always assumed two things were given. I regret not having said anything until now.

First, I understood the phrase “kicking God out of town” after the pattern of “kicking God out of the classroom”. Obviously God is not leaving town, as long as two are gathered in His name. It was an attention-getting device that went too far.

Second, implicit in the story is a disconnect between the people of Gettysburg and its government, or a faction (or even lone actor) in it. Beyond the fact of Gettysburg’s historical significance, that is the unstated importance of the story. We right-wing bloggers believe that outside the big cities, the people are mostly on our side, while local governments tend to attract the loony left agitators.

I figured that there was a misunderstanding of the necessity of the battlefield replica chapel retaining its primitive character. Bringing the place up to code, with (for example) properly wheelchair-accessible restrooms and GFCI electrical outlets would have ruined the place as an historical replica.

I wondered all along why the demand wasn’t that people stop using the museum-piece chapel as a worship facility, and keep it as a static, velvet-rope display. That still would have been overzealous government busibodiness, but it at least would have fit the government’s stated goal of public safety.

But as the demand was to tear the structure down, well, of such small escalations are conflagrations made.

It’s good to emphasize that God is still in town, and will not be mocked. To the extent that I was involved in that, I apologize.


Join the Concord Project, and follow @lheal, if you dare.

Socrates, I owe RS another diary on the subject.

Uma Richie (Diary) Saturday, December 11th at 3:05PM EST (link)

There seems to be a lot of interest in figuring out whether or not the town leadership was out of line. I live in the same region (South Central PA) as Gettysburg, but I had to go into local newspaper databases to get a feel for the issue. I hope to have something posted within a week.

But for the near term, I’d like to give you a short timeline:
Jan 2004 – Faith-based homeless shelter burns. Investigation into cause of fire cancelled because building is unstructurally sound.
2004 – Lot sits empty, becomes blighted.
2005 – USCC builds canvas-roofed field chapel on lot.
2005-2009 – Chapel operates without newsworthy incident. (As far as I can tell)
Jan 2010 – Too much snow destroys chapel canvas roof.
Spring 2010 – Chapel roof rebuilt with tin panels. Steeple with bell is added.
June 2010 – Town notifies USCC that roof improvements make chapel subject to permanent structure ordinances.

I hope this sheds some light on the subject.

Looking forward to news

SoulEspresso Saturday, December 11th at 9:31PM EST (link)

Far be it from me to question LadyImpactOhio’s motives. That’s happened to me on this site and it’s no fun. Perusing some of the links involved demonstrated thoroughly to me that the story had a lot of moving parts. I rather questioned her tactics as I thought the sensationalism was unhelpful.

The real issues involved may be more “boring” but of longer-term interest: government overreach or inconsistency, the need for competent, conservative local government, etc. I wouldn’t be surprised if this turns out to be a cautionary tale about the need for competent conservatives in local government.

 

agree with Socrates and bravo to you Uma for responding to my suggestion

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Monday, December 13th at 1:45AM EST (link)

that you defend the honor of the majority in Gettysburg. Great job gal.

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson