10 Questions for Sotomayor


(Editor’s Note:  Since Sonia Sotomayor will almost certainly NOT be answering questions next week about future cases likely to face SCOTUS, I’m leaving them out of my list of 10.  Below are a list of questions phrased softly enough and hypothetical enough that she’ll likely feel safe answering.  Hopefully, she’ll like to hear herself talk and get into enough detail to hang herself expose her judicial mindset to America.)

  1. What role should public opinion play, if any, in Constitutional adjudication?  (Followup:  Why do you believe that?)
  2. Thinking back about the neighborhood you grew up in, are you still proud of it even today?  (She’ll obviously answer ‘Yes’.)  Followup:  Even though its economically lacking?  (She’ll get defensive and answer ‘Yes’ again, likely more emphatically, perhaps even defending the Puerto Rican cultural background of her ‘hood.)  Followup:  Why not replace some of the more run-down, albeit cultural, areas of your neighborhood with new businesses, like a shopping center?  (It’d be nice to see if she takes the bait or not.  If she does, it’d be a great way in front of the cameras to force her to rethink Kelo vs. New London)
  3. If there are minor areas of the Constitution which seem arcane, but Congress hasn’t gotten around to amending, is it OK in extraordinary instances for SCOTUS to ignore them?  (If she asks for specific examples, cite the Saxbe fix or even better, the Exceptions clause.)  (The purpose of this question is really designed to see how much of an activist she truly is.  If she actually answers “Yes” to this, alarm bells should be going off across the Fox Nation!)
  4. Are Constitutional privacy rights ever absolute?   (I’d be stunned if she takes the bait here, but if she’s dumb enough to, and extreme enough to answer ‘Yes’, ask for her to cite some broad examples.  This will be an excellent way to determine if she’s gonna crush any War on Terror efforts.)
  5. Is the Interstate Commerce clause being manipulated by Congress?  (She’s way too smart to answer this, I would imagine.  Nothing, though, would sink her nomination faster than for her to say ‘Yes’, but that’s why you have to ask.)
  6. What are your tiebreakers?  (She’ll say ‘I don’t follow.’)  Well, certainly, there must have been times in your career when deciding on a case was extraordinarily difficult and the facts and Constitutional issues were about even for both sides, right?  (Her answer here oughta be entertaining.)  Well, in those cases, certainly you had a list of tiebreakers you used to determine your outcome?  Was public opinion one of those?
  7. What does it say about America in 2009 that we’re still arguing about affirmative action?
  8. Does the Court ever have a right to try to stop a war, especially if it was started on clearly false grounds?  (Again, she likely won’t take the bait, but who knows?  If she says Yes, she’s going to be a gift to Code Pink.)
  9. Should the Court, in an effort to reduce itself as a lightning rod and perhaps to reduce the number of cases it faces, start getting into the business of issuing advisory opinions to let all potential parties to a case know upfron the Court’s thoughts on issues?  (If she says Yes, alarm bells.)
  10. Do you find the term “activist judge” offensive?  (If she says Yes, alarm bells.)

Well, those are my 10.  I think at least 8 of them she’ll answer.  If they’re asked in a soft tone and done right, I think she’ll realise she’s not being asked to prejudge a future case.  We desperately need to know upfront, in the one democratic moment we have with her next week, to realise just how bad a justice we’re facing.

With a minority as small as ours right now, that may be the best we can do.  Expose her for the radical she is to the public, and hope that it places some pressure on Senate Dems up for election in 2010.


Category: , , ,

RSS feed

5 Comments Leave a comment

Submit your Sotomayor questions here:

ColdWarrior (Diary) Saturday, July 11th at 11:23PM EST (link)

www.ProtectTheCourts.com

I’m sure our courageous, steel-spined Republican “leaders” on the Judiciary Committee will ask Sotomayor tough questions.

Or not.

I’m prepared to be sorely disappointed.

Thank you.

In 2012, will YOU become a “voting member” of the Republican Party in your precinct?

Where it all started. Twitter @kaltkrieger
Learn how to GOTV at The Concord Project and at Procinct and Unified Patriots.

 

Question #1

Britcom (Diary) Sunday, July 12th at 1:17AM EST (link)

“Are you now, or have you ever been, a member of any Communist groups or factions?”

“The opposite of courage in our society is not cowardice, it is conformity.” – Rollo May

Is America a Democracy or a Republic?

Click here to check out my Blog.

I don't have any questions for Soto. She has already answered my questions thru her rulings and statements.

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Sunday, July 12th at 9:41AM EST (link)

The GOP should simply accurately quote her racist statements and her desire that Euro opinion inform constitutional decisions and let her ramble on and further bury herself. The more her racist statements are quoted on TV, the better chance that the American people get aroused with anger and call their dem senators and the more the dems own the label of racist elitists and the better we do in 2010 and 2012.

What we must not do is pretend that we can’t read the English language and that all Soto has to do is “explain” her past words.

We have the answers.

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

To Dems, its all a word game

Britcom (Diary) Sunday, July 12th at 11:40AM EST (link)

the true meaning of words spoken by Dems:

Racist = White oppressor

Affirmative action = hiring quotas as bribery for votes

Democracy = Marxist/Socialist/Communist dictatorship

Capitalism = Robbery

Business = Robbery

Free trade = Robbery

Government = Gravy train

Murder = Social justice for the oppressed

War = Spreading Democracy (see above)

Freedom = Legalized vice

Christian = Thought criminal

Abortion = Eugenics

Israel = North Korea

News = Indoctrination

Education = Indoctrination

Church = Enemy

Evil = (an unknown concept)

“The opposite of courage in our society is not cowardice, it is conformity.” – Rollo May

Is America a Democracy or a Republic?

Click here to check out my Blog.

amen Brit', dems lie everytime they utter a sound - nt

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Sunday, July 12th at 1:55PM EST (link)

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson