Americans need to understand the devastating significance of the House vote on the Senate health care bill set for March 18th. The Democrats have–by design–created the perfect storm to take over the US healthcare system, while providing an ideal distraction–reconciliation.
First, let’s examine exactly how we got here. In late December, while Americans were arguing that no one had read the bill, Leiberman was posturing to vote against the bill with a public option, and the debate on abortion continued, Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) took an existing HOUSE-passed bill, H.R.3950–the Service Members Home Ownership Tax Act of 2009–and here’s how it unfolded:
10/8/2009:
Received in the Senate. Read the first time. Placed on Senate Legislative Calendar under Read the First Time.
10/13/2009: Read the second time. Placed on Senate Legislative Calendar under General Orders. Calendar No. 175.
11/19/2009: Motion to proceed to consideration of measure made in Senate. (consideration: CR S11578)
11/19/2009: Cloture motion on the motion to proceed to the bill presented in Senate. (consideration: CR S11578; text: CR S11578)
11/20/2009: Motion to proceed to consideration of measure considered in Senate. (consideration: CR S11826-11879, S11888-11903)
11/21/2009: Motion to proceed to consideration of measure considered in Senate. (consideration: CR S11907-11967)
11/21/2009: Cloture on the motion to proceed to the bill invoked in Senate by Yea-Nay Vote. 60 – 39. Record Vote Number: 353. (consideration: CR S11967; text: CR S11967)
11/21/2009: Motion to proceed to consideration of measure agreed to in Senate by Unanimous Consent.
11/21/2009: Measure laid before Senate by motion. (consideration: CR S11967)
11/21/2009: S.AMDT.2786 Amendment SA 2786 proposed by Senator Reid. (consideration: CR S11967)
In the nature of a substitute. emphasis mine
The GOP must have known what was about to happen next because they were united in voting “Nay” against this bill on November 21, 2009. Additionally, the Senate Amendment offered by Reid was none other than the Senate version of the healthcare bill.
Reid HAD to do this. Why? Because all legislation that raises taxes MUST originate in the House of Representatives and H.R. 3590 satisfies that requirement.
I will repeat that, Harry Reid switched the language in H.R. 3590 and replaced it with the Senate’s version of the health care system takeover in order to satisfy the requirement for all legislation raising taxes to originate in the House. The bill summary outlines the evolution of this bill:
OFFICIAL TITLE AS INTRODUCED:
To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to modify the first-time homebuyers credit in the case of members of the Armed Forces and certain other Federal employees, and for other purposes.OFFICIAL TITLE AS AMENDED BY SENATE:
An act entitled The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act.
For the record, Republicans did challenge this amendment substitution, but were defeated. The simple fact that the Democrats voted on Reid’s “amendment” is appalling and demonstrates their condoning of the abuses we are seeing unfold. Democrat Senators are now willing accomplices to the destruction and socialization of the US health system.
The deceptive practices to pass a government takeover of healthcare can be summed up as the ultimate betrayal by the Democrats against the American people in order to ram through their progressive, socialistic, freedom-stripping policies.
Furthermore, the Democrats talk of “reconciliation” or the nuclear option is nothing more than a diversion from what the real goal is–to pass the Senate version through the House and then have Obama sign it into law.
And once signed into law, does anyone really think that Obama will keep his promises of the “fixes” through the reconciliation process after he got what he wanted via the Senate bill? Seriously, he will have the healthcare takeover he wants, so why make the House and Senate suffer more.
In addition, I don’t think that the House will hold the bill to work out differences between the two chambers as is being floated. While it may be an optional maneuver, the Democrats need the tax increases to take effect now so they can offset some of their rabid spending.
The House Democrats have a choice: either stand with the American people and kill the bill or endorse the deception, betrayal, and bribes of Harry Reid, Obama, Pelosi, and the Senate Democrats, in addition to the destruction of the US health system. Either way, the American people will never forget.
KnightsofMalta
Steve Maley
Caleb Howe
All eyes should be on the House because that is where the action is...nt
JadedByPolitics (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 2:41PM EST (link)….
Unified Patriots – How-To:
Activists Taking Action
How much of this Obamacare battle reminds you of the knife fight scene from Saving Private Ryan?
MacAoidh (Diary) Saturday, March 6th at 12:57AM EST (link)I’ve been mulling this one over all day.
Check out MacAoidh’s commentary on Louisiana and national politics at TheHayride.com
I've been saying all along
Steph C (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 2:59PM EST (link)that all they’re doing is shuffling papers and pages around and presenting them as “new” with the expectation of us being too dumb to know that.
I agree with Jaded, all eyes should be on the House right now and the phone lines crashed if necessary. How many members can they bribe when they’re simultaneously bankrupting the country? With what can they bribe them?
“[I]f the public are bound to yield obedience to laws to which they cannot give their approbation, they are slaves to those who make such laws and enforce them.” –Candidus in the Boston Gazette, 1772
Hillbilly Politics
Stepf C- Speaking of Bribes
Scope (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 3:49PM EST (link)The House Dems that got nothing more than evil threats if they didn’t vote for the bill last time around, must be seething that they weren’t offered Corn Husker Kickbacks, or Louisianna Purchases for their yes votes. Now they have no opportunity (with the Obamacare bill at least), to be rewarded for their aye, because if one word of Senate bill is changed, it would have to go back to the Senate for another vote. That will never happen. And, there aren’t enough open judgeships to promise to all the fence sitters family members.
like the phony zip codes for the stimulus...
larryp Friday, March 5th at 4:11PM EST (link)they will make up judgeships. There is no more important bill or house seat or even Obama’s Presidential seat than the passge of the proto-commie /Euro centric Obama bill. We can’t repeal it. Face it.
It is in the bill that business can dump all health care of their employees into the Plan for an 8% charge. They will. Happens right a way too, (From Rush this am)
Some how it has to be stopped.
The donks will spend every dime of the front-loaded taxes and when 2013 comes to set up and pay for the obiecare there willbe no money and the Govt will fall. It has to fall. and will be replaced by some totalitarian garbage regime, a ruling junta.
With what can they bribe them?
rwlungren Sunday, March 7th at 3:02AM EST (link)Just over a year ago, We were told this “Stimulus Bill” HAD to be passed ‘IMMEDIATELY’ or the U.S. economy ‘WOULD’ collapse and unemployment would hit 8%. One year later, They have only spent 36.96% ($283,700,000,000)* and unemployment is 9.7% for Feb 2010*. That leaves 63.04% ($503,300,000,000).
I pose this question; Could it be ‘The Administration’ will spend the other $503, 300,000,000 of LAST YEAR’S ‘IMMEDIATELY’ needed Stimulus Money in Districts/States where a DEMOCRAT Seat is in trouble?
‘Just Askin’
source*: www.recovery.gov/ on 03/05/2010
This is why Sen Bunning suggested using this "Stimulus Money"
voxoreason Monday, March 8th at 12:20PM EST (link)>>We were told this “Stimulus Bill” HAD to be passed ‘IMMEDIATELY’ or the U.S. economy ‘WOULD’ collapse and unemployment would hit 8%. One year later, They have only spent 36.96% ($283,700,000,000)* and unemployment is 9.7% for Feb 2010*. That leaves 63.04% ($503,300,000,000).
Congress passed the faux “pay-go” bill (no new spending without a cut in existing spending), then promptly violated it with the bill that Sen Bunning (R-KY) put the brakes on. Why COULDN’T this money have come out of the $503,300,000,000 that’s just sitting there, thereby obeying a law so recently passed?
They’re obviously saving the Stimulus money to stimulate dem voter turnout in November. See what happens this summer. While it will no doubt be hidden carefully in some unreadable legalese bill, someone like Rep Paul Ryan (R-WI) will actually read this mess and publicize it.
BTW, why isn’t my Senator, Richard Burr, on your “vote for these guys” list? He’s got a 100% approval rating from the American Conservative Union, as does S Dakota’s John Thune, also up for re-election in Nov.
Constitutionally speaking ...
Timothy Morella Friday, March 5th at 3:44PM EST (link)… although HR 3950 began in the House, as required, does the amendment in the Senate eliminate that requirement, inasmuch as the taxes that were to be raised by HR 3950 are now no longer in the Senate Bill (and, any tax raises that are now in the Senate Bill were introduced in the Senate for the first time)?
Unfortunately...
fredrik Saturday, March 6th at 12:22AM EST (link)… this is both quite common and perfectly kosher.
Keith Hennessey has been doing a stellar job explaining these things; see http://keithhennessey.com/2010/03/01/two-bill-challenges/ and http://keithhennessey.com/2010/03/01/two-bill-mechanics/
This Bill Needs to be stopped
Black River Wolf (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 3:52PM EST (link)And needs to be stopped now.
This is all about how the GOV can control our lives, it has nothing ti do with HC. If they wanted to reform HC, they would at least try and stop all the stupid lawsuits and make it so doctors do not need to do preventative medicine. Not to prevent sickness, to prevent any kind of lawsuit. But that would mean no more cash cows from the Trial Lawyers to the Democrats.
Where I live almost all OB/GYNs have left because of all the lawsuits and the cost of malpractice insurance.
Get GOV out of HC and let the free market lower costs. Let people decide if they want comprehensive or catastrophic insurance, not the one size fits all cap we have now. Let them buy across state lines also, why is it that it is $4 in TX and FL for the same $43 policy in MO????
We do not get car insurance to pay for oil changes, why does HC pay for every doctor visit and pill we buy, If people actually paid out of pocket for all this stuff, prices will go down because people will not pay the outrageous prices for this, but since someone else pays, no one even knows how much they are actually paying for the doctor visit.
“In my many years I have come to a conclusion that one useless man is a shame,
two is a law firm, and three or more is a congress.”—-John Adams
Good work SusanAnne, that might have snuck past us
Brian Hibbert (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 3:56PM EST (link)if you weren’t paying attention. The sneaky SOB Reid is willing to bend any rules to get what he wants.
Candidate for Trustee of Illinois Central College
Socialism doesn’t work. It looks nice on paper, but it’s been tried and it’s failed miserably every time (usually accompanied by widespread death and suffering).
Proud member of the V.R.W.C.
Take back our party!
Check out Unified Patriots
Rush has been all over this the last 2 shows
peg_c (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 4:35PM EST (link)Reconciliation is a head feint. Right now, the Senate is irrelevant – everything of importance is happening in the House. All our pressure must be brought to bear on THEM.
This is obscene, it is grotesquely unconstitutional, and it violates all concept of good faith and trust between the governors and the governed. It is beyond appalling.
Every Democrat in the House who votes for this should be removed from office in November and horsewhipped in front of the Capitol and in front of 2 million patriots in person and many millions more on live TV. For starters.
Government cannot be the solution when government is the problem.
I'm not sure about the first part of this diary,
Flagstaff (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 4:36PM EST (link)but the final four paragraphs say it all.
After the House passes it, it will not be changed by this Congress or President.
All the talk about reconciliation is just that–talk.
“The press is so powerful in its image-making role that it can make a criminal look like he’s the victim and make the victim look like he’s the criminal. If you aren’t careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.”– Malcolm X, Audubon Ballroom, December 13, 1964
"The Dog Ate My Sword"
redneck_hippie (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 5:00PM EST (link)That’s what every representative being pressured to fall on their sword should tell Pelosi and Obama.
Strange game. The only winning move
texasgalt (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 5:03PM EST (link)is not to play.
For the sake of the country I hope voters can make enough noise so wavering D’s learn the futility of a yes vote on this health care monster.
Can anyone explain ?
Jonas Parker Friday, March 5th at 6:09PM EST (link)And not just speculate ?….. I find this thoroughly confusing. Stupak said last night that he could not say how he will vote because he hasn’t seen the language in the bill. I’ve heard talk about CBO scoring a(nother) bill ? So what is going on ? Isn’t the Senate bill available with precise language ? What is he talking about that he ‘doesn’t know what the language will be’ ? Is he talking about the reconciliation hogwash that will never be attempted anyway ?
Yes...
fredrik Saturday, March 6th at 12:30AM EST (link)You do have the basic idea right. The strategy being discussed is:
1. The house passes the Senate bill (#1) unchanged.
2. The house passes a second bill (#2) amending the Senate bill (#1) under reconciliation rules.
3. The senate passes the same bill (#2).
4. Obama signs #1 and #2 into law.
At the moment, #2 doesn’t exist. Perhaps it will come into existence in the next few days, perhaps not. The suspicion (which I share) is that steps 2 through 4 above are just a clever ruse. What I expect to happen is that as soon as the House passes the Senate bill (#1), Pelosi will send it to the President, and Obama will sign it into law.
Reconcilation will not be required in step 2
PrecinctPatriot (Diary) Saturday, March 6th at 12:49PM EST (link)Which Republican will not vote for an amendment to restrict funding abortion? Or reduce costs?
Stupak is not concerned about the bill being passed through Reconcilation. He does not trust Reid, Pelosi or Obama. Any of them could kill the amendment deal after step 1 is complete.
Who is John Galt?
http://thefloridaprecinctproject.wordpress.com/
Bork'em
renny (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 6:30PM EST (link)Don’t complain hear. Wear out the phone lines. 202-224/225-3121.
Reid 202-224-3542
Pelosi 202-225-0100
If Joe Friday was here He would have one word for the crooks, BOOKEM.NT
bobojake (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 7:13PM EST (link)Whip operation being implemented
mavericktime Friday, March 5th at 7:42PM EST (link)According to the Huffington Post:
“Huffington Post’s Sam Stein reports that Democratic leaders estimate they are short between 6-12 votes in the House, so “To convince these lawmakers, House leadership is preparing a whip operation described as “all hands on deck.” Pelosi and Rep. James Clyburn (D-S.C.) will dispatch loyal lieutenants to help rub elbows and twist arms. Once the party settles on a final set of reconciliation changes, leaders in the labor community are set to launch a major campaign to help with the whipping, officials say.”
"leaders in the labor community are set to launch a major campaign to help with the whipping,.."
redneck_hippie (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 8:28PM EST (link)Well, whips are an innovation, for SEIU usually makes do with fists and boots.
I'd wager that not 5% of the money for that "whipping" is legal.
Achance (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 8:34PM EST (link)They spend dues money on politics with impunity. I understand it in the Blue States; Blue State government is merely a conspiracy between the Democrats and the unions. But, in the RedStates, we should be able to have some AG’s perp walk some union heads.
In Vino Veritas
Dems will blame Repubs for no reconciliation
GregInFla (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 8:22PM EST (link)Obama will say that the Repubs will not go along with breaking the rules for reconciliation, so even though the bill is nto what he likes, he is stuck with it.
And then somehow he’ll blame it on Bush.
– A true evolutionist would let endangered species die off. Think about it.
– The sign outside the courthouse said no signs allowed. So I took it down.
– Atlas Shrugged is now on the non-fiction aisle at Amazon.
Staten Island asks for pressure on McMahon
renny (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 8:45PM EST (link)Staten Island tea party is ask for demonstrators to join them in St. Patrick’s Day Parade to pressure McMahon.
1. Pressure Congressman McMahon. He has already voted “no” but on the theory that we should never take anything for granted, contact his office remind him that we are counting on him . Contact Congressman McMahon, visit this page http://www.teapartyinfo.com/contact-congressman-mcmahon.html
2. March with us on Sunday in the St. Pat’s Day Parade! This is critical – numbers, like words, mean something. Remember, this is the third largest parade in the United States.
For details on the St. Patrick’s Day Parade this Sunday
http://www.teapartyinfo.com/
our country
sarge324 Monday, March 8th at 7:01AM EST (link)tis unfortunate that our country is in the hands of obamas band of deaf legislators.they might not hear the people,but god and the country can hear.vote them out in 2010 and 2012.stay mad and show them in november.
My very first act.....
teridavisnewman (Diary) Monday, March 8th at 9:36AM EST (link)I will have the bill to Repeal OBAMA-CARE in my hand when they swear me in to the House of Representatives on January 3, 2011. I will go from the ceremony to the hopper to drop it in and I will not rest until the House votes to repeal it. It will be my signature issue. I do need your help–while my opponent is widely viewed as a corrupt Chicago machine politician, he has a huge war chest. I need your help to win this election–not just for Illinois, but for America!
Teri Davis Newman
2010 Republican Nominee for Congress
2012 Candidate for Congress
12th Congressional District of Illinois
www.terinewman.com
Hi Teri, Please!!! Get someone to fix up your web site.
Brian Hibbert (Diary) Monday, March 8th at 9:55AM EST (link)It look amateurish and web sites DO matter these days. For example, try to move everything off the main page into separate category pages. You’ve already got things divided into categories, but not in their own pages with links.
Also, I did some quick searching on IL-12 (I’m in IL-18) and found among other things a wikipedia entry on your opponent, Jerry Costello.
I didn’t find a similar Wikipedia entry for you. I suggest getting someone on your campaign staff to write a biography and submit it to Wikipedia for a web page on you. (And again, yes these things matter).
I was happy to see that the comments on him included ONLY this for the 2010 election:
If you don’t have anyone on your staff who can do it, contact me BrianHibbert@comcast.net and I’ll try to help.
Candidate for Trustee of Illinois Central College
Socialism doesn’t work. It looks nice on paper, but it’s been tried and it’s failed miserably every time (usually accompanied by widespread death and suffering).
Proud member of the V.R.W.C.
Take back our party!
Check out Unified Patriots
The Promise of Change
ihateliberals Monday, March 8th at 11:25AM EST (link)Obama promised change in his campaign speeches. what the people forgot to ask is “What Kind of Change?”. Obama and the left have had the agenda to take over Health Care and start the process of taking over private industry and socializing the country. These misguide people chose to ignore the failures of all other socialist and communist countries. They believe that they can do it right this time. What they don’t get is that socialism is a pyramid scheme. no matter how much you try to control it eventually it will crash in on itself. The liberals are trying to scare everyone in beleiving that with out the government run health care system the cost of health care will continue to skyrocket. what they don’t tell you is that by change just a few rules with very littel cost to the tax payers health care cost can be brought under control. The lies about health care reform all come for the left-wing. I am afraid now that no matter what we do they will pas this bill as is and Obama will sign it. Then the Dem’s will find out just how honest Hussein Obama is. he has never kept a promise that he has made since he has been in public office. Why would he start mow? We got Change alright but i don’t think it was the change we wanted.
Call the House till the Phones Burn!
danielbdp (Diary) Monday, March 8th at 11:32AM EST (link)Agree 100% with SusanAnn & her article. Though I live in NJ and the ruling elites here don’t care one bit about my repeated phone calls, faxes & e-mails, I keep sending them (on the hope some staffer is at least keeping statistics). Their standard boiler plate responses have not made me quit yet.
In a freedom-loving nation that on every recent poll rejects this monstruosity by a 3 to 1 margin, we can’t allow these Progressive ideologues to blatantly impose their will on us.
Those of us in the relevant states:
Call Bart Stupak and his pro-life colleagues daily and thank them for staving off this immoral, oppressive legislation for as long as they have despite the enormous pressure they’re under
Call the Dem “undecideds” in your state and get them to decide for the good of the nation, to trash the 2,700-page monster and START OVER, gradually, in incremental steps, in a truly bi-partisan way and maybe, just maybe they’ll get to keep their seats in November!
Done Deal
chabsentia Monday, March 8th at 11:40AM EST (link)It is a done deal. I told you this last year. Pelosi and Obama have convinced the Democrats that if they dont vote for it that it wiill be worse as the people expect a bill and will look on them as failures. There is also the fact that for the last twenty years that people have returned over 90% of the incumbents to office and son they think that Novemeber will not be any diffferent. This is what happens when there is twenty years of Apathy and people are gullible, mis-informed and un-informed, Our Culture has evolved to people getting their information from David Letterman and SNL, They cant separate fantasy from reality or Satire and comedy from the real deal because they dont have the basics to interpret it. They dont see that home prices increased 100% between 2000-2007 but wages only increased 2% and the population increase was flat or little and the bubble burst, They dont see that the tipping point for it was in 1999 under Clinton. They have been brainwashed to believe it was the Bush tax cuts, They alos believed the last 8 year myth even though the Demcrats were the majority party since January 2007. The transformation from well informed etc to dummy was completed in 2008 and the deal is done.
question?
olddog Monday, March 8th at 12:56PM EST (link)Isn’t it a fact that, this is not a power enumerated to the federal government , it actually belongs to the states, that they are co-opting, so why can’t the states pass laws nullifying it?
We know Congress has been stealing power from the states via the commerce clause for years. This furthers the need for term limits, and restoring to the states, their powers as the founders intended.
The chains of slavery, will lie heavier on the shoulders of our children, the way this is shaping up, educate them teach them our history and get active in every way you can, to stop these fascists.Our history expects no less from every generation!
Su7pport Our Troops!
One Old Dog
Your diary was linked to by Instapundit...
JadedByPolitics (Diary) Monday, March 8th at 2:29PM EST (link)aren’t you made of teh AWESOME!!! Its the 2nd link on his page, I like to check him out during the day as well and imagine my surprise when It brought me to your diary. It is a GREAT diary btw
Unified Patriots – How-To:
Activists Taking Action
Well, Darn Suz,...
Repair_Man_Jack (Diary) Monday, March 8th at 2:34PM EST (link)This site won’t work for the rest of today! Congrats on the Instalanche. I hope Eric’s servers can handle it!
” I side impenitently with the human race against the modern reformer.” – C.S. Lewis