Freedom From Fear


Germany, where there\'s always a whiff of totalitarianism in the air

Why is this family smiling?

They just received political asylum.

From Germany.

No, it isn’t 1933.

Meet Uwe and Hannelore Romeike and their five children. They are evangelical Christians and they did not like the cultural lessons being taught in public schools in Germany (::shudder).

The parents identify themselves as evangelical Christians and say religion was the primary reason why they chose to homeschool their children. Hannelore Romeike said public education can never be neutral.

“During the last 10-20 years the curriculum in public schools has been more and more against Christian values,” she told the Associated Press. “We communicate our values, the teachers communicate theirs, and if the kids are at school, we cannot have an influence on what they learn.”

They applied to homeschool their children and were threatened with fines and jail and losing custody of their children. In response, in June 2008 they moved to Tennessee and applied for political asylum on the grounds of a well founded fear of persecution. Last Tuesday Immigration Judge Lawrence Burman agreed and granted the Romeike’s political asylum.

Burman opined:

“We can’t expect every country to follow our constitution,” said Judge Burman. “The world might be a better place if it did. However, the rights being violated here are basic human rights that no country has a right to violate.”

Burman added, “Homeschoolers are a particular social group that the German government is trying to suppress. This family has a well-founded fear of persecution…therefore, they are eligible for asylum…and the court will grant asylum.”

In his ruling, Burman said that the scariest thing about this case was the motivation of the government. He noted it appeared that rather than being concerned about the welfare of the children, the government was trying to stamp out parallel societies—something the judge called “odd” and just plain “silly.” In his order the judge expressed concern that while Germany is a democratic country and is an ally, he noted that this particular policy of persecuting homeschoolers is “repellent to everything we believe as Americans.”

Lest one think this is a judge run amok, let’s turn to the coverage given the case by Deutsche Welle.

The German laws mandating public-school attendance date back to Germany’s first experiment with democracy in 1919, according to Hans Bruegelmann, an education professor at the University of Siegen.

Bruegelmann said previously private education was only available to the elite, and that the public-school mandate was a clear political choice.

“The school is an embryonic democracy and will help to integrate children and young people coming from different backgrounds into the democratic culture,” he said.

Integration into democracy and learning to get along with those who hold opposing opinions are important skills that children cannot learn when homeschooled, Bruegelmann said, and that is especially true with highly religious parents.

“They should not have the right to indoctrinate their children,” he said. “It’s important for children, besides the experience they make at home, which is respected, to have access to other sources of understanding the world.”

I would hasten to point out to Dr. Bruegelmann that drawing upon legislation derived in Weimar Germany to defend anything is not exactly a killer argument and as German experience with democracy really begins in 1955 they are hardly in the position of having the knowledge necessary to know what contributes to a successful democracy much less develop laws to that end. But the argument made by Bruegelmann that rationalizes the state seizing children because the parents object to what their children are being taught is eerily similar made by large numbers of so-called educators in America today. The purpose of public education is no longer to provide education but rather to indoctrinate children with cultural values because there are, to reiterate Bruegelmann’s argument

skills that children cannot learn when homeschooled, Bruegelmann said, and that is especially true with highly religious parents [my ephasis]

Lest we feel too smug, one only has to read the files of the Home School Legal Defense Fund to realize how perilously close we all are to being just like the Romeikes.

This lesson is not lost on many Europeans. Gerald Warner writing in the Telegraph observes:

[Judge Burman's remarks] offers a useful insight into how Americans, living in a free country, view the creeping totalitarianism that has engulfed Europe. For this is not just a German issue: we are all helots under state control. Why did the German homeschoolers not seek political asylum in Britain? Because our rulers subscribe to the same tyrannical statist philosophy, is the answer. Every possible obstacle is put in the way of homeschooling parents in Britain.

The mentality is that the state – not parents – is the natural controller and shaper of children’s lives and beliefs. When a schoolgirl can be given an abortion without her parents’ knowledge, we know that, while public utilities may have been privatised, children have been nationalised. The Romeikes who fled from Germany objected to their children being forced to follow a curriculum that they believed was anti-Christian. The same would apply in British state schools, where pornographic sex education is increasingly being made compulsory.

Is that a new idea? Not at all. It was first implemented as government policy in 1919, during the short-lived communist dictatorship of Bela Kun in Hungary, when Georg Lukacs, as deputy commissar for “culture”, enforced his system of Cultural Terrorism, force-feeding children pornographic sex education, teaching them to laugh at their parents and at monogamy and to reject the family and religion. Lukacs was a founder of the Frankfurt School of Marxism, later popularised by Herbert Marcuse, whose demented notions are today called Political Correctness and, as such, have colonised Western governments.

It takes the forthright remarks of an American judge, in a country where the culture war has not yet been lost, to bring home to us in Europe that we already inhabit the Gulag. The Berlin Wall did not “fall” – it was just moved further west.

.



RSS feed

34 Comments Leave a comment

"The Berlin wall did not 'fall' - it was just moved further west."

kyoufuu (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 8:16AM EST (link)

That quote alone is the most poignant comment. Europe fought so hard to free itself of communism, and look where they’re ending up. Previously authoritarianism was defined by the presence of one ruler, one dictator… Now I think the realization is becoming that a nation can be a “democracy” yet still edge towards totalitarianism through the existence of a self sustaining state, whose rules are enforced free of one dictatorial leader.

Wasn’t there a similar story of two parents in Sweden who had their child taken away because they homeschooled?

“There are more instances of the abridgment of the freedom of the people by gradual and silent encroachments of those in power than by violent and sudden usurpations.” — James Madison

“I swear by my life, and my love of it, that I will never live for the sake of another man, nor ask another man to live for mine.”

Europe on the whole did NOT fight so hard to free itself of communism

JSobieski (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 9:42AM EST (link)

and it would appear that the European appreciation for liberty, even in places such as England or France, is being overwhelmed by fatigue, mutil-culturalism, self-loathing, and the beauracratic non-democratic EU super-structure.

Very sad. For a time, England and France were in their own time, keepers of the flame of what is known as the West, an inheritance they received from Jerusalem and Athens. They have squandered that inheritance. Hopefully, we will not follow their example.

My rules of the road for primary season.
Rule #1: Vote for YOUR first choice in the primaries
Rule #2: Vote for the R in the general.
Rule #3: Don’t let anyone convince you to violate Rule #1 or Rule #2
Rule #4: When in a center-right argument, reaffirm Rules #1-#3–it will help us all to get along better.
Rule #5: If you are using the language of the left, you probably aren’t furthering conservativism
Rule #6: The priority is issues first, candidates second, and supporters third. Nobody is bigger than the issues. Conversely, if you spend your time focusing on supporters, you are wasting everyone’s time.

STOP THE MADNESS!

A reduction in the rate of spending increases is NOT a cut!
In-state tuition for illegals is NOT amnesty!
Requiring someone to pay their medical bills is NOT an individual mandate!
Reducing tax rates is NOT a tax increase!

East vs. West

JoeG Friday, February 5th at 10:06AM EST (link)

A few years ago I attended a industry conference that was well attended by Europeans, with better than half of them from behind the former Iron Curtain, particularly Hungary and Poland.

I ended up watching a fairly heated conversation about Reagan. As far as the Western Europeans were concerned he was a hothead that almost got them killed. The Eastern Europeans viewed him as the savior that freed them from tyranny.

By the end of it some of the Eastern Europeans considered the Americans as kin and the Western Europeans willing to give up freedom for security.

Eastern Europe has become the last bastion of free markets... and I'll freely admit I have a man crush on Vaclas Klaus (nt)

kyoufuu (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 12:24PM EST (link)

“There are more instances of the abridgment of the freedom of the people by gradual and silent encroachments of those in power than by violent and sudden usurpations.” — James Madison

“I swear by my life, and my love of it, that I will never live for the sake of another man, nor ask another man to live for mine.”

In Poland, the two largest parties are Center-Right

JSobieski (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 12:40PM EST (link)

one is more right on economics (the PM’s party) and the other is more right on social and foreign policy (President’s party).

My uncle asked my mom the other way when she was planning to move back.

Strange days indeed!

My rules of the road for primary season.
Rule #1: Vote for YOUR first choice in the primaries
Rule #2: Vote for the R in the general.
Rule #3: Don’t let anyone convince you to violate Rule #1 or Rule #2
Rule #4: When in a center-right argument, reaffirm Rules #1-#3–it will help us all to get along better.
Rule #5: If you are using the language of the left, you probably aren’t furthering conservativism
Rule #6: The priority is issues first, candidates second, and supporters third. Nobody is bigger than the issues. Conversely, if you spend your time focusing on supporters, you are wasting everyone’s time.

STOP THE MADNESS!

A reduction in the rate of spending increases is NOT a cut!
In-state tuition for illegals is NOT amnesty!
Requiring someone to pay their medical bills is NOT an individual mandate!
Reducing tax rates is NOT a tax increase!

 
 
 
 
 

Give it a few more months and home schooling here will be.......

Kenny Solomon (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 8:22AM EST (link)

…….treated as a child abuse and a crime against humanity.

The current administration will make home schooling illegal (even though it’s 100% a state issue).

Either that, or they’ll force all home school parents into joining their local teacher’s union.

California already tried that

Raven (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 9:08AM EST (link)

Got closer to rioting in the streets over that than with the ban on gay marriage.

“If you do not have a sword, sell your cloak and buy one.”
Luke 22:36

America is not lost perhaps after all

tankertodd (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 10:08AM EST (link)

When Californians riot against statist policies that Pelosi and Obama would embrace without a second thought, I think perhaps conservatism is alive and well in all 50 states. Scott Brown is another data point – people just want to be left the hell alone and government out of their lives. That is the winning formula. That is what the GOP should embrace and never forget. We can’t over-emphasize this.

———————————
The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race – Chief Justice Roberts

Government off my back and out of my pocket works

Achance (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 1:01PM EST (link)

just as well today as it did in ’80 or in ’94.

In Vino Veritas

 
 
 

Off base

JoeG Friday, February 5th at 10:12AM EST (link)

The teacher’s unions are certainly a core constituency of the democrat party. They pour a lot into getting 0 elected. But Obama is definitely not highly loyal to them. The one has stated that we spend more than any other country on education and we have 50th place to show for it, so money certainly isn’t the problem. The NEA / NFT got pretty pissed on that comment. His Ed secretary is a school choice guy too.

This is one place were I’ll give some light praise.

Giving any praise would be a mistake.

The_Gadfly (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 12:51PM EST (link)

Note Ausonius’s post below. If either The Big 0 or his Education Czar actually gave any credence to school choice, the DC voucher program would not be dead. Hell, you’ve got socialist Dems who have been elected to the DC government demanding the reinstatement of the Federal voucher program. Granted they aren’t willing to fund it from DC funds, but even they recognize the complete hash the teachers unions have made of schooling in the district.

 
 
 

BIG BRObama and The Teachers' Unions

Ausonius (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 8:27AM EST (link)

are on the same page as the German Socialists: nobody can be too different, especially obvious religious fanatics (they have 5 – FIVE – children! Do they not realize how such a lifestyle damages the environment?).

We note BIG BRObama’s assault on the D.C. voucher program in this same aspect: central-state control, not parental control, not even local control.

What was heartening also were the comments under the Telegraph’s article about how America still stands for freedom and is a refuge for those trying to exercise basic freedoms, which are endangered even in “free, democratic” Europe.

Just more proof that even “moderate” Socialism is inimical to basic human rights.

Ausonius: 310-395 A.D. Teacher, Poet, Consul, General, Farmer.

Personal Tutor to the future St. Paulinus of Nola and to young Gratian, heir to the throne during the turbulent final years of the Western Roman Empire. When his former student Gratian was assassinated, Ausonius threw up his hands and retired to his farm in Gaul. Rome was captured by barbarians 14 years after his death.

Cato@rock.com

 

HSLDA

Wretched_Dog Friday, February 5th at 8:34AM EST (link)

For those interested, the Home School Legal Defense Association represents home-schooling parents in the defense of their religious liberty and exercise of conscience in the education of their children.

HSLDA was instrumental in assisting this family.

Contact at: http://www.hslda.org/Default.asp?bhcp=1

Wretched Dog

 

Yep, the only difference between Europe and America is a few years time

RedBeard Friday, February 5th at 8:44AM EST (link)

The U.S. lefties just need a few more years or a few more SCOTUS justices.

Standard-bearer for grouchy curmudgeonry since, oh, 1975 or so.

Which brings up the question:

throwback59 Friday, February 5th at 9:15AM EST (link)

Where are we supposed to go for asylum?

Couple of possibilities

RedBeard Friday, February 5th at 9:34AM EST (link)

FA (Free America)

Galt’s Gulch

Fictional now, but maybe not in the near future.

Standard-bearer for grouchy curmudgeonry since, oh, 1975 or so.

Here you go:

larueladue (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 11:40AM EST (link)
 

Alaska wants you! nt

jayburd (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 3:36PM EST (link)

One of my heroes- Ralph Smeed’s blog- http://smeedonstate-ism.com/index.htm

“What’s the matter? Don’t you want to win the war?” – Capt. John Birch

“If the Nation can issue a dollar bond it can issue a dollar bill.
The element that makes the bond good makes the bill good also. The
difference between the bond and the bill is that the bond lets the
money broker collect twice the amount of the bond and an additional 20%.Whereas the currency, the honest sort provided by the Constitution pays nobody but those who contribute in some useful way. It is absurd to say our Country can issue bonds and cannot issue currency. Both are promises to pay, but one fattens the usurer and the other helps the People.” – Thomas A. Edison

 
 
 

As a homeschooling parent, I understand why governments fear us.

archer52 Friday, February 5th at 8:46AM EST (link)

http://truthandcommonsense.com/2010/01/28/good-news-for-tennessee-bad-news-for-germany-homeschoolers-get-protection/

I follow some of the international activities concerning homeschooling. Believe me when I say that when given the chance, this government will shut it down. Obama hates and fears homeschoolers because they are not getting the indoctrination he and people like him want children to get. In my post I point out my daughter, fifteen now, is taking a course on the Constitution. She can now see what Obama is doing (as well as many others on both sides of the aisle) and can comment on how it is violating the principles of our founding.

Compare that to the thousands of kids I dealt with over the years in law enforcement who were publicly educated and even after graduation from high school had no idea who our founding fathers were or how this nation was created.

Think about it for a second, if you have no idea of history, then anyone that comes along can tell you a story and you would buy it. The Soviets were pros at doing this.

In our area of the country we had a lot of drugs, violence, leftist agenda driven studies, etc. When we decided to homeschool, I told my wife this- “If we put our brilliant daughter into public school, we might as well put a crack pipe in her mouth now and get it over with.”

It is not been easy, but I can say it has been phenomenally rewarding! My daughter is taking Latin, Geometry, Constitutional classes, literature and through me a basic world history. She is focused, respectful and driven to excel. She will be someone someday, if the elites will get out of her way.

Congratulations on your daughter's success

H (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 7:35PM EST (link)

We cannot home school. It just wouldn’t work for us due to some very hard realities in our family life. But I sacrifice some luxuries to send our son to parochial school. At 9, his math and reading and especially his fascination with science are all exceptional. He figured out the first time he watched an AGW public service spot on TV that someone was trying to slip fear into his mind where he knew he should be getting information. After seeing that spot, he calls the AGW fear mongers the “tic tic people” after the dramatic “tic tic tic” soundtrack with worried children wagging their fingers at the adults.

As I said to a couple of coworkers bragging about the “great public education” their kids were getting in the local school system – both of these guys strong Christians: “If you justify sending your kids to public school because you pay for it with your taxes anyway, would you burn your house down because you pay for the fire departmment with your taxes anyway?”

 
 

Repeating history

Marcus_Traianus (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 8:52AM EST (link)

Under the guise of “not repeating history” Germans are hurtling towards a complete societal disaster. They carelessly use the aforementioned meme to drill a whole host of socialist ideas into a society already having a predisposed cultural proclivity for homogeneity and order.

Few contemporary Germans have taken the time to intellectually determine these ideas are faulty and should not to be followed blindly. Instead, they should be challenged and resolved through democratic debate – not heavy handed, kingly academic proclamations based on outdated legal precepts whose initial intent was completely unrelated to current day German society. That they accept such fiats and reasoning is deeply troubling.

The socialist-totalitarian wing is a very destructive force in German society today and frankly reminds me of the pre-war environment. They try to distance themselves from the past by opining the cause for their historical transgressions was rampant nationalism. But nothing could be further from the truth. It was moreover, a lack of German intellectual exploration and questioning of fundamental ideas, laws and the accompanying emotions that previously sent Germany down the road to World War II. To think they are not headed down the same socially destructive road again because nobody is waving flags or possesses guns would be a monumental mistake.

“Both of our political parties, at least the honest portion of them, agree conscientiously in the same object—the public good; but they differ essentially in what they deem the means of promoting that good. One side believes it best done by one composition of the governing powers; the other, by a different one. One fears most the ignorance of the people; the other, the selfishness of rulers independent of them. Which is right, time and experience will prove.”.Thomas Jefferson

I have to wonder about the footsoldiers of the progressives here...

nessa (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 11:44AM EST (link)

…as they are thrilled by each of their victories over their neighbors, forcefully lessening our liberty, further limiting and restricting our rights with each incremental incursion. Do they not see that it will be their necks that next are fitted for a noose? Merely because they do not own a gun, or appreciate our speech, or want to pass on their values to their children, instead trusting the state to do it for them, they strive to restrict our rights, never realizing that theirs will be next. There is pure unadulterated evil at the top, Soros, Obama, Pelosi, Reid, Jennings… But the evil doesn’t permeate all the way to the bottom, it can’t. Can it?

“If you love wealth more than liberty, the tranquility of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, depart from us in peace. We ask not your counsel nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feeds you. May your chains rest lightly upon you and may posterity forget that you were our countrymen.”—Samuel Adams

Contributor to Unified Patriots

teh twitter

Yes, it can, because it's all about CONTROL...

furious (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 2:04PM EST (link)

…the footsoldiers and their leaders don’t really care about outcomes, all that matters to them is that, should everything come crashing down, it is they who are squatting atop the rubble.

And permeating the bureaucracies, ensuring their permanence in elective office, and limiting the options of the people who pay their salaries is the best means of doing so. Lower down the bureaucratic pyramid the pay s*cks and they don’t get to shop in the “hard currency” stores, but at least they get to lord it over their fellow citizens (e.g., Chavez’ “Bolivarian Circles” or Castro’s “Block Committees”).

Besides, where outside of the public sector is there a market for their skills? Your average gadfly City Councilman or County Diversity Co-ordinator wouldn’t last a week as a McDonald’s shift manager.

–furious

“I find your lack of faith disturbing.” — Darth Vader

 

Don't forget; Bolsheviks also thought the "end justified the means"

Marcus_Traianus (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 3:26PM EST (link)

As much as Trotsky tried to later erase the connection of this criminal aphorism to Stalinists and their terrible crimes, the connection remains.

Stalin and his followers were also ideologues. The didn’t care about rational thoughts or arguments. In fact they also thought that destroying moral order was central to achieving their success. Sound familiar? It should.

The followers of modern liberalism are the same type of adherents. They focus on ideology, which they truly believe will achieve an ideal society for their children. They feel the pain is temporary and transitional in nature- until their goal is achieved. But history and human experience has already proved them wrong.

The primary problem is ideologues operate under false premises; that democracy and capitalism are destructive forces. They only find out after undermining and murdering a society that it’s too late and their cause s futile. Which is why they need to be stopped. Now. For our collective sake.

“Both of our political parties, at least the honest portion of them, agree conscientiously in the same object—the public good; but they differ essentially in what they deem the means of promoting that good. One side believes it best done by one composition of the governing powers; the other, by a different one. One fears most the ignorance of the people; the other, the selfishness of rulers independent of them. Which is right, time and experience will prove.”.Thomas Jefferson

 
 
 

Again

rick554 Friday, February 5th at 9:02AM EST (link)

Again, a Brit gets it . I guess clearer thinking comes when you are staring at the Wall. Thank God we still have judges like Lawrence Burman.

Rick554

Good thing they got a decent judge.

4life (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 10:24AM EST (link)

I’m sure there are many who would not have granted assylum. At least in the U.S. we have the right to educate our own children apart from the state, whether it be in a private school, Christian school, or home school. This has not been without a fight, but where would this country be without these options? We owe a big thanks to all who have worked to make sure parents are the final authority in our kids education.

 
 

“They should not have the right to indoctrinate their children,”

spim Friday, February 5th at 9:06AM EST (link)

… for me, this is the most chilling bit from above.

let me get this straight … the child’s *parents* don’t have the right to instill beliefs and values in their own children … but the state does

I shouldn’t be surprised at this … but I always am.

I’m so lucky and blessed to have been born here.

Don't get too comfortable; most of the people

Achance (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 11:05AM EST (link)

charged with “educating” your children here in the US don’t believe you have the right to control or instill beliefs or values in your children either. They just don’t have the total backing of the government in every state yet.

In Vino Veritas

 
 

Germany, one less country to flee to.

johnt Friday, February 5th at 10:10AM EST (link)

How the West has fallen. Corruption, moral exhaustion, ignorance, and State power, the poisons that are killing what is left of a culture.
The barbarians are watching and taking note, they being the ones that we are urged to show tolerance to.
And what do we have in the White House ?

“a man’s admiration for absolute government is proportinate to the contempt he feels for those around him”. Tocqueville

 

To Paraphrase Animal House

maddog (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 10:58AM EST (link)

The statist government view is:
They cannot indoctrinate their children.
Only we can indoctrinate their children.

5 (n/t)

Finrod (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 10:10PM EST (link)

.

Let’s get down to brass tacks here. How much for the ape?

 
 

"The purpose of public education...

furious (Diary) Friday, February 5th at 1:31PM EST (link)

…is to perpetuate and tighten the control of the stakeholders that matter (to themselves): the educrats (funding) and the teachers’ unions (tenure). Indoctrinating children and denying them options like charter- and homeschooling is a means to those ends.

In this case the parodic New York Times subtitle certainly applies: “Women and Minorities Hardest Hit”.

–furious

“I find your lack of faith disturbing.” — Darth Vader

 

Here again, Orwell was ahead of his time

RedBeard Friday, February 5th at 2:44PM EST (link)

Read how the state reared the children of Winston Smith’s time, and the words below become all the more frightening:

“Integration into democracy and learning to get along with those who hold opposing opinions are important skills that children cannot learn when homeschooled, Bruegelmann said, and that is especially true with highly religious parents. They should not have the right to indoctrinate their children.”

Standard-bearer for grouchy curmudgeonry since, oh, 1975 or so.

 

My German Friend

revolutionary Friday, February 5th at 3:12PM EST (link)

My Dad was stationed in Germany during my senior year. We lived in a German community and I went to a DOD school, but I had German friends in the community. I will never forget the end of our friendship due to a heated arguement over the Holocaust. The Holocaust is a part of History, but it is not my history and even I knew more about it than she did. She vehemently denied what I said was true when we talked about it. I was stunned when she revealed to me just how little she really knew. Her version of the account (taught to her by German schools) was so far from true events I thought she was making it up, at first.

I wonder if the fear of the German government in parents homeschooling their children is because they will not be able to raise generation after generation that rewrites history. Not saying that this is the reason they are adamant about public education, but it makes me wonder if they are hiding other beliefs in “education”.

-For in reason, all government without the consent of the governed is the very definition of slavery.
Jonathan Swift-

-Majority rule only works if you’re also considering individual rights. Because you can’t have five wolves and one sheep voting on what to have for supper.
Larry Flynt-

-I had reasoned this out in my mind, there was one of two things I had a right to, liberty or death; if I could not have one, I would have the other.
Harriet Tubman-