Before Obama was elected Republicans were going to defend a lot more seats then they are now. Now it is almost even.Colorado, Illinois are possible pickups. New York is tough but money will be tight for Dems when the Gov and BOTH Senate seats are up in 2010.
Here is a rundown that is not complete since some have announced or there are rumors of retirements.
Arkansas Linclon (D) 56-44 (Might be close with a good candidate)
California Boxer ( D ) 58-38
Colorado Salizar (D) out pretty much open
Connecticut Dodd ( D ) 66-32 (hear they are getting fed up with him)
Delaware Biden (D) gone pretty much open
Hawaii Inouye ( D ) 76-21 (Not seeking Re-election?)
Indiana Bye (D) 62-37
Illinois ( D ) Pretty much open if not moved Republican in election
Maryland Mikulski ( D ) 65-34
New York Schumer 71-24
New York (Hillary) Appointed replacement
ND Dorgan ( D ) 68-32
Nevada Reid ( D ) 61-35 Very beatable
Oregon Wyden ( D ) 63-32
Vermont Leahy 71-25
Washington Murray ( D ) 55-43 (Senates #1 dimwit, needs a competitor)
Wisconson Feingold ( D ) 56-44
Alaska Murkowski ( R ) 49-36
Alabama Shelby ( R ) 68-23
Arizona McCain (?) 77-20 We need a primary
Florida Martinez (R) open winnable seat
Georgia Isacson ( R ) 58-40
Idaho Crapo ( R )
Iowa Grassley ( R )70-28
Kansas Brownback (R) 69-28 (Is he running again?)
Kentucky Bunning ( R ) 51-49 (Is he running again?)
Louisiana Vitter ( R ) 51-29 (Problems with prostitutes, get General Honore)
Missouri Bond ( R ) 56-43
N Carolina Burr (R) 52-47
Oklahoma Coburn ( R ) 53-41
Ohio Voinavich ( R ) 63-36
Pennsylvania Specter ( R ) 53-42
S Carolina De Mint ( R ) 54 – 44
New Hampshire Gregg ( R ) 66-34
S Dakota Thune ( R ) 51-49
Utah Bennet ( R ) 69-28
Wild card: Robert Byrd (KKK) He isn’t up for election but his health is so bad that they may be using the sheet hanging in his closet. He may expire before his term in office does.
Steve Maley
Neil Stevens
Daniel Horowitz
Correction
Finrod (Diary) Sunday, December 28th at 3:15AM EST (link)Indiana’s Dem Senator is Evan Bayh, the son of former senator Birch Bayh.
Let’s get down to brass tacks here. How much for the ape?
Bayh
SeriousLaff (Diary) Sunday, December 28th at 4:06AM EST (link)Right. Typo. He actually is a fairly good Senator for a Democrat and would be very tough to beat.
My thoughts:
baseketball (Diary) Sunday, December 28th at 6:31PM EST (link)Arkansas Linclon (D) 56-44 (Might be close with a good candidate)
Huckabee could make it close, but that’s about it.
California Boxer (D) 58-38
Not happening. Safe seat.
Colorado Salazar (D) out pretty much open
Most important race of the cycle.
Connecticut Dodd (D) 66-32 (hear they are getting fed up with him)
If the current Governor runs, she could make it close, but she’s all they’ve got.
Delaware Biden (D) gone pretty much open
Highly unlikely, especially if another Biden is on the ticket. Safe seat.
Hawaii Inouye (D) 76-21 (Not seeking Re-election?)
Democrats hold this one either way. Safe seat.
Indiana Bayh (D) 62-37
Virtually impossible, the man’s a state institution unto himself. Safe seat.
Illinois (D) Pretty much open if not moved Republican in election
Still, that’s Obama’s seat. Republicans won’t take it. Safe seat.
Maryland Mikulski (D) 65-34
Safe seat.
New York Schumer (D) 71-24
Safe seat.
New York (Hillary) Appointed replacement
Kennedy and Cuomo would both be pretty safe.
ND Dorgan (D) 68-32
Safe seat.
Nevada Reid (D) 61-35 Very beatable
Beatable by whom? Safe until a competitive challenger appears.
Oregon Wyden (D) 63-32
Safe seat.
Vermont Leahy (D) 71-25
Safe seat.
Washington Murray (D) 55-43 (Senates #1 dimwit, needs a competitor)
Safe seat.
Wisconson Feingold (D) 56-44
Safe seat.
Moving on to the Republicans:
Alaska Murkowski (R) 49-36
Safe seat, for her or Palin.
Alabama Shelby (R) 68-23
Safe seat.
Arizona McCain (R) 77-20 We need a primary
If he gets primaried, it’s a real race. Safe seat otherwise.
Florida Martinez (R) open winnable seat
If Bush gets in the race, probably safe. Otherwise, a real nailbiter.
Georgia Isacson (R) 58-40
Safe seat.
Idaho Crapo (R)
Safe seat.
Iowa Grassley (R) 70-28
Safe seat.
Kansas Brownback (R) 69-28 (Is he running again?)
Sibelius could make this one interesting. Otherwise safe.
Kentucky Bunning (R) 51-49 (Is he running again?)
Either way, this one’s a toss-up
Louisiana Vitter (R) 51-29 (Problems with prostitutes, get General Honore)
This one could go pretty much anywhere. For now let’s leave it as leans Republican.
Missouri Bond (R) 56-43
Likely Republican, except in another wave.
N Carolina Burr (R) 52-47
NC is moving toward the Democrats, and Burr doesn’t have a huge margin of error. Toss-up.
Oklahoma Coburn (R) 53-41
No Democratic bench, and OK is moving further red. Safe seat.
Ohio Voinavich (R) 63-36
Safe seat.
Pennsylvania Specter (R) 53-42
Toss-up if he wins his primary. Leans Democratic if he loses it. Another seat to watch.
S Carolina De Mint (R) 54 – 44
Likely Republican, unless 2010 is another wave year.
New Hampshire Gregg (R) 66-34
New Hampshire moved sharply blue in 2008. Toss-up.
S Dakota Thune (R) 51-49
Toss-up.
Utah Bennet (R) 69-28
Safe seat.
So I count 17 seats for the Democrats and 19 seats for the Republicans. As usual, the vast majority (13 Democratic seats and 10 Republican seats) are safe pretty much no matter what happens. That whittles us down to 9 Republican seats and 4 Democratic seats that are really competitive.
Schwarzenegger could take out Boxer in CA (n/t)
Finrod (Diary) Sunday, December 28th at 9:07PM EST (link)..
Let’s get down to brass tacks here. How much for the ape?
Doubt it
Neil Stevens (Diary) Sunday, December 28th at 9:09PM EST (link)Even if he could win the primary, which I question, why should people vote for him? Anyone who’s pro-abort is better off voting for the incumbent. But Republicans have precious little reason to vote for Arnie, who is bad on judges, bad on taxes, bad on spending, bad on being a reliable Republican, bad on marriage, bad on abortion, and bad on globowarmism.
RS contributing editor, technical administrator, and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules
Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.
“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder
Don't be so sure
Finrod (Diary) Sunday, December 28th at 10:01PM EST (link)The president’s party usually loses seats in the mid-term elections; after 2 years of Obamanomics it may be enough to win a Senate seat just to be a celebrity and to not be a Democrat.
I’d prefer Dennis Miller up against Barbara Boxer myself, but I think Schwarzenegger would have a slightly better chance.
Let’s get down to brass tacks here. How much for the ape?
Is there any difference
zuiko (Diary) Sunday, December 28th at 10:04PM EST (link)Between Obamanomics and Arnoldnomics? How does he run on that? The celebrity factor would have been a lot more compelling if people weren’t sick of the guy after years of sucking it up in office.
Underlying most arguments against the free market is a lack of belief in freedom itself. – Milton Friedman
He can't run against what he himself favors
Neil Stevens (Diary) Sunday, December 28th at 10:29PM EST (link)Arnold Schwarzenegger is more of a tax and spend lefty than Gray Davis was. He can’t run against Obamanomics.
RS contributing editor, technical administrator, and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules
Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.
“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder
He would have had a much better shot
zuiko (Diary) Sunday, December 28th at 9:55PM EST (link)Before he turned into a walking Gray Davis impersonation.
Underlying most arguments against the free market is a lack of belief in freedom itself. – Milton Friedman
Arnie might be able to beat Boxer in the General....
J. Leg (Diary) Monday, December 29th at 1:32AM EST (link)….if he could get through the primary.
If we wants it, he’s got to throw a bone to the conservative base (notice I did not use “his”) of the Republican Party, otherwise there’s just no point in him even trying. Despite being deemed a “blue state” as Governor Palin reminded everyone during her rally here in Southern California, California is Reagan country, and some California Republicans are some of the most conservative.
I doubt he could even do that
zuiko (Diary) Monday, December 29th at 3:03AM EST (link)In order to win in the general he’d still have to turn out the base. There are decent sized portions of the base that are beyond fed up with him. Fed up enough with him that they won’t even vote for him in the general again. They’ve already seen how they are rewarded for holding their noses and supporting that man just because he’s a “Republican.”
Underlying most arguments against the free market is a lack of belief in freedom itself. – Milton Friedman
Arnold should remind voters he is a Kennedy
SeriousLaff (Diary) Monday, December 29th at 3:32AM EST (link)He should be appointed to the seat.
In Arizona...
mbecker908 (Diary) Sunday, December 28th at 9:19PM EST (link)McCain won’t get a primary opponent.
Unless Janet comes back from DC to run for the Senate McCain will have to spend about $1.20 (price of an all day Valley Metro Bus Pass for a Senior Citizen) to win the general. There is no Dem with even decent statewide name recognition. And the governor’s race could be contested given that our Republican SoS will move up to Gov (no LtGov in AZ) if Janet goes to DC and she’s no real ball of fire. Given a desire for statewide office, running against a nobody for Gov beats getting the tar beaten out of you by McCain.
Bottom line, McCain won’t have to spend any money to win the general. He can spend it all to win a primary against an as-yet-to-be-named-player who has marginal, at best, statewide recognition and no money.
McCain will be a Senator representing the interests of the DC Beltway for as long as he wants to be.
No such thing as a "safe seat." [nt]
Martin Knight (Diary) Monday, December 29th at 1:14AM EST (link)Can't speak for many on this list
Bob_Frazier (Diary) Monday, December 29th at 11:17AM EST (link)Can’t speak for many on this list, but Voinovich in Ohio is a sure loser and it really does not matter who runs against him. Ohio has turned hard blue (thanks Bob Taft!) and even Republicans will abandon him as they did Mike Dewine because he is a classic RINO.
I think Specter in PA is toast as well. These are the “moderate” Republicans who are going down all over the country.
A republican should be able to win the KY senate seat if that man or woman is a true conservative.
Concerned About Retirements
dld1717 (Diary) Sunday, December 28th at 10:28PM EST (link)I am not sure Grassley in IA will run again and if he does not its a tough seat for us to hold
KS Open Seat will be tough to hold
Voinovich, Specter, Bunning (he already announced he is running) and Burr will be tough races for us to hold
Gregg in NH is popular but Congressman Hodes is making some noise he may challenge him
Florida Open Seat will be a race probably
Vitter in LA is likely to face Melancon due to redistricting and him seeing the fact he will be one who loses his seat but I think Vitter damage is done
Reid is number #1 Race for us to pickup or….
They can pick up CO, NY (possibly), or ND if we can get solid challenger. CA if Arnold makes the run, AR only if Huckabee runs, DE if only Castle runs, and IL is still a matter we have to face.
ND
zuiko (Diary) Monday, December 29th at 3:07AM EST (link)I am expecting us to take a bye there again. We never seem to be able to get a serious contender for the Senate there, for some reason.
Underlying most arguments against the free market is a lack of belief in freedom itself. – Milton Friedman
Yes it is
Sean (SIConservative) (Diary) Tuesday, December 30th at 1:19AM EST (link)Right now, 2010 is that bleak. It’s possible that the Obama administration will crash and burn, and likely that the economy will get worse, so the Republican electoral outlook could improve considerably. As it stands now, though, we’re looking at losses that are possibly bigger than the ones we suffered this year.
Arkansas will only be close with Huckabee, and he already passed on a Senate bid this year. He sees himself as an executive.
North Dakota is only competitive with Gov. Hoeven, who has already passed on several opportunities to run for Senate.
Wisconsin is only competitive with Thompson, who has, like the others, passed on opportunities to run for Senate in the past.
In Nevada, our top candidate is, rightfully or wrongfully, under indictment.
Illinois could be competitive if the Blago scandal severely harms the Party rather than just the individuals involved, but I’m not sure it will.
All other Dem seats are safe.
As for Republican held seats:
In Arizona, McCain is our strongest candidate. As much as I’d like to see him replaced, I have a feeling that any other Republican would lose. McCain himself may well do the same if the Democrats land a strong recruit.
In Alaska, there’s some chatter, I don’t know how serious, about Palin challenging Murkowski in the primary. If she does so successfully, Democrats are likely to target this seat, and the money will be there for their challenger in the general election if Palin wins the primary.
We’ll probably hold Florida if Bush runs. If he doesn’t, though, this seat will be a toss-up at best.
In Iowa, Grassley could be vulnerable to a challenge from one of the state’s Democrat Congressmen, but would enter that race a favorite. He may well choose to pack it in, though, in which case the Democrats will be favored to take over the seat.
In Kansas, Sen. Brownback is retiring. If Gov. Sebelius runs, she will be heavily favored. If not, it will depend on candidate recruitment, though the state’s Republican lean on the national level would probably give us an early edge.
Sen. Bunning crashed and burned in a solidly Republican year, apparently suffering some sort of breakdown in the final stages of the campaign. I don’t know if he has recovered, but if he only won by 2% in 2004, he is certainly vulnerable to another challenge, possibly from the same candidate whose fundraising would be much stronger given his performance the first time around.
Sen. Vitter, for all his problems, can’t be written off, but he is certainly in trouble. This one is probably the least predictable race of the cycle.
Sen. Bond is highly vulnerable to a challenge from one of the Carnahans.
New Hampshire is turning hard left, and Gregg will likely face one of the toughest elections of the cycle. He starts out in better shape than his counterpart, but he’s still vulnerable to either the Governor or one of the state’s two Democrat Congressmen. His 2004 numbers are not indicative of anything, as the Democrats did not run a serious candidate.
Sen. Burr could face a very tough race if Gov. Easley enters the race. He has stronger ties to the Tarheel state than Sen. Dole, but Dole also lost to a second-tier candidate.
Sen. Voinovich is more popular among the state’s conservatives than Sen. DeWine was, but that’s not saying much. The state GOP was run into the ground by Gov. Taft, and the voters aren’t over that yet. I wouldn’t say that Voinovich is finished, but if he runs for reelection, he starts out even at best. I expect, though, that he’ll call it quits, which would give the Democrats a solid, if not prohibitive, advantage.
In Pennsylvania, Sen. Specter is highly vulnerable to a top-tier challenge. He may first have to fend off another primary challenge first. In either case, his health could become a major issue, as would be the state’s hard left movement. He’d probably start out favored against any Democrat with the possible exception of Gov. Rendell, but his edge would not be what it has been in the past.
I don’t see it happening, but if Rep. Herseth decides to challenge Sen. Thune, that could be a race.
All in all, things don’t look good.