H/T Hedgehog Report
The timing of this ruling is just too rich.
Today, in the same building where Blagojevich is being tried, lawyers will gather in the courtroom of U.S. District Court Judge James F. Grady to deal with a June 16 decision handed down by the Seventh Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals, written by Judge Diane Wood.
In essence, the decision said that Burris is only a temporary appointee until an election is held to fill the Obama seat. Wood handed the matter back to Grady to figure out the details, including how nominees would be chosen and if a primary — which could cost the state millions of dollars — would have to be held.
……
At a June 23 hearing before Grady, Assistant Illinois Attorney General Thomas Ioppolo disagreed with Oberman’s argument that an election process could be streamlined and a costly primary could be avoided.
He told Grady the situation was “fraught” with the potential for voter confusion and asked for a rehearing.
Ioppolo told Grady that trying to supplant Burris “doesn’t make sense”; the appellate panel did not understand how Illinois election law works; by the time an election would be certified in December there would be maybe 30 days left to Obama’s original term, and who knows what the Senate would do because the senators ultimately decide who gets seated in the chamber.
Grady replied that all that “makes no difference whatsoever in my view. . . . There shall be an election.”
This is a very interesting development indeed. Ioppolo is griping about the fact that it wouldn’t make sense to hold a special election by a vote of the people in September to serve out the remainder of Barack Obama’s term and then hold another election in November from what I gather. Judge Grady seems resolute in firmly stating that the vacancy must be permanently filled by an election as soon as possible regardless of whatever time frame. There is a huge indirect implication of this: The vacant Senate seat of the late Robert Byrd. The West Virginia GOP could sue in federal court (appellate court would be in the 4th Circuit) for an election to be held citing both state law and federal law in regards to civil voting rights. They could use this recent decision in the 7th Circuit as precedent. The Democratic governor of West Virginia, Joe Manchin, is likely waiting until after July 3 to proclaim the vacancy though West Virginia law seems to clearly indicate that a vacancy does not have to be proclaimed but must occur. The reason why this is so key is because the Democrats don’t want a special election happening this November for Senator Byrd’s seat. This would at minimum force the Democrats to spend money on a race they didn’t figure to as GOP congressmen Shelly Moore Capito may jump in and further imperil the Democrats’ chances of holding onto the Senate.
The GOP has been very quiet on this likely in due respect until Sen. Byrd’s funeral takes place. I have to wonder what will happen after Sen. Byrd is laid to rest.
Aaron Gardner
Steve Maley
KnightsofMalta
I'm fairly surprised at this ruling
Change Jar Conservative (Diary) Thursday, July 1st at 10:40AM EST (link)Choosing replacement Senators has always been the purview of the states.
How did Wood even get involved in something like this (i.e. where does the jurisdiction come from for a federal circuit court for what is essentially (and specifically according to the constitution) a matter for the states to decide)?
********
Formerly know as “Oz” in these parts
It's the 17th Amendment to the Constitution at issue
Deskpilot (Diary) Thursday, July 1st at 11:15AM EST (link)See comment below
If you can read this, thank a teacher. If you can still read it in English, You’re Welcome
Deskpilot, AM(H)1 (AW), USN (Ret)
Join the RedState Strike Force
Popcorn, Get your Popcorn!!!
Deskpilot (Diary) Thursday, July 1st at 11:13AM EST (link)As if Illinois isn’t in bad enough financial shape, they have to have parallel elections.
Why? Because the USC says so right in the 17th Amendment. According the HRC, “Words have meanings.” what part of SHALL is so hard to understand?
“When vacancies happen in the representation of any
State in the Senate, the executive authority of such
State SHALL issue writs of election to fill such vacancies:
Provided, That the legislature of any State may empower
the executive thereof to make temporary appointments
until the people fill the vacancies by
election as the legislature may direct.”
Grady is simply upholding the Constitution of the United States and is necessarily forcing the hand of Illinois.
It just a shame that unions wasted so much money in elections that they won’t have enough “walking around money,” to buy off 2 elections in Illinois.
This could be enriching for someone, and expensive for the taxpayers.
(1) Does appointee Sen. Burris get the Senate golden parachute, or is he just a placeholder, or does the vacancy elected Senator get it?
(2) if the vacancy elected Senator does NOT run for re-election, does he/she get that retirement package too?
I’m sure someone in Illinois machine politics will figure a way to milk this for every dime.
If you can read this, thank a teacher. If you can still read it in English, You’re Welcome
Deskpilot, AM(H)1 (AW), USN (Ret)
Join the RedState Strike Force
I have a family member...
Eric Olsen (Diary) Thursday, July 1st at 4:41PM EST (link)…who works for the 7th Circuit USCA. This is a HUGE buzz issue there right now.
Popcorn time, indeed, sports fans!!!
“I need no warrant for being, and no word of sanction upon my being. I am the warrant and the sanction.” – Ayn Rand, Anthem
You really wonder?
IronDioPriest (Diary) Thursday, July 1st at 5:11PM EST (link)“The GOP has been very quiet on this likely in due respect until Sen. Byrd’s funeral takes place. I have to wonder what will happen after Sen. Byrd is laid to rest.”
We’re talking about the GOP – an institution with the killer instinct of a bunny. They will wheedle, and play the gentleman’s game, and ultimately allow the destiny of Robert Byrd’s seat to be determined by Democrats who have no compunctions about playing with knives.
“If we finally fail in this great and glorious contest, it will be by bewildering ourselves in groping for the middle way.”
-John Adams, 1776
Join in the conservative forum discussion at “It’s About Liberty”: http://www.itsaboutliberty.com