McCain’s Route to 270 Electoral Votes


Pennsylvania as the Alamo

As best as I can tell, the McCain campaign’s strategy for winning in the electoral college has altered significantly over the past month.

Previously, the conventional wisdom held that he would attempt to win all of the Bush 04 Eastern and Midwestern States except for Iowa, and then pick up two out of three of Nevada, Colorado, and New Mexico. Conceivably, if he lost Nevada and New Mexico, he could also win Colorado + 1 electoral vote in Maine’s relatively conservative 2nd District to reach the magic number of 270.

The new strategy, however, is different. It still relies on holding onto Ohio and Florida, Missouri, and North Carolina (states which are all within in the margin of error in most polls). But with Colorado, New Mexico, and even the former GOP stalwart of Virginia showing serious problems, McCain appears to taking a bold new strategy: waging an all out war for Pennsylvania.

Based on what I’m seeing in Virginia, where the current McCain effort seems perfunctory at best, his campaign seems to be preparing for the eventuality of Virginia turning blue. And perhaps even working under that assumption.

This Virginia problem, I realize, is fairly bewildering to my GOP friends outside of the state–after all, this is a state that Bush won by 8 points in 2004. Unfortunately, however, despite whatever legitimate gripes are raised about the accuracy of current polling, the changes in Virginia over the past four years are very real. You can see them with your own two eyes.

In pastures and on farmland where’d you’d have seen giant Bush/Cheney signs four years ago, there are now vast housing developments populated with government workers who commute to DC. Furthermore, our African-American population is much greater than the national average, and we have many, many, universities which are not only hotbeds of liberal politics but from which the Democrats are drawing armies of activists who spend their weekends marching up and down the streets, knocking on doors, etc.

Does Virginia have a large military population? Is the majority of the state conservative? Yes and yes. But these demographics are fairly static–they certainly haven’t exploded out of all proportion in the way the North Virginia suburbs have recently.

While I believe that the state of Virginia is probably undergoing an extremely rapid transition from a reliably red state to at least a light blue one, the transformation is not yet complete during this election cycle. So while I’m disappointed to see that we’re possibly conceding the state, I don’t believe McCain’s strategy of attempting to swap Pennsylvania (with its 21 EV) for Virginia (and its 13 EV) is an unreasonable gamble.

Despite what current polling might say in Pennsylvania, the demographics of the state are arguably much for favorable than those in Virginia. It seems far more likely that we could see significant movement towards McCain there, as a result of these demographics, than in the state of Virginia.

Pennsylvania has an older, and more stable, more blue-collar population. It has about half as many African-Americans as Virginia, and by some estimates, it’s over 50% Roman Catholic.

It’s still, I must say, an uphill battle. It’s been twenty years since Pennsylvania voted for a Republican presidential candidate, but a concentration of campaign resources there, strategic use of Governor Palin who shares a strong cultural connection with a large percentage of its residents, together with Obama’s “clinging to guns and religion” gaffe and Murtha’s branding them as racists and rednecks, could all make a difference. There’s a real opportunity there at least that should be pursued.

According to what I believe to be the current McCain victory scenario, this is how election night could look (focusing on the battleground states). It would be nerve-racking to say the least.

  • 7 EST. Polls close in Virginia and New Hampshire. Both states are called for Obama sometime thereafter. Democrats pop their champaign corks, believing that seals the deal.

  • 7:30 EST. Polls close in WV, NC, OH. Sometime thereafter, all three states are called for McCain. “Whatever,” the Democrats say, and open more bottles.

  • 8:00 EST. Polls close in the Florida Panhandle, Missouri, and Pennsylvania. Sometime within the next hour–shocker! Florida, Missouri, and Pennsylvania have all gone for McCain. Shock and horror spreads through the Democratic ranks. They’re all drunk now. So am I.

  • 9:00 EST. Polls close in Colorado, Michigan, Minnesota, New Mexico, and Wisconsin. All five states are called for Obama. Democrats renew their celebrations. Republicans groan.

  • 10:00 EST. Nevada and Iowa polls close, with Iowa immediately being called for Obama. All eyes turn to Nevada as the results start coming in. The networks hesitate for a very long time before calling the state. Everyone in the country is drunk. Nevada is called for McCain, pushing him to 273 electoral votes.

  • Midnight: Governors around the country call out the National Guard.


Category: , , ,

RSS feed

7 Comments Leave a comment

I made the mistake...

DrOldSchool (Diary) Tuesday, October 21st at 10:16PM EST (link)

Of agreeing to co-host an election night party for the students with my colleagues on campus. I felt I pretty much had to since there would be no other voice of reason if I didn’t.

If you’re scenario plays out, while I hope you are right (or even underestimating McCain) I’d give it around 9:25ET when I come on here to post asking for 911 to be called before a fight breaks out.

“Is it a third party we need, or is it a new and revitalized second party, raising a banner of no pale pastels, but bold colors which make it unmistakably clear where we stand on all of the issues troubling the people?”

- Ronald Reagan, 1975 Speech to CPAC

 

right ok

Ithk4myslf (Diary) Tuesday, October 21st at 10:25PM EST (link)

McCain has no ground game in Va, the VA GOP party and the McCain campaign are having problems.

McCain’s brother called NoVa communists, a Senior adviser said the southern half of the state is the ‘real’ Va.

without a ground game he will lose, Va.

or anyone wanna link some stories of McCains Virgina groundgame?

 

Awesome, pass that positive spirit around

Kevin Lobo (Diary) Tuesday, October 21st at 10:26PM EST (link)

Your enthusiasm, optimism and firm belief in our Victory is awesome. Pass the word around and post something daily. Everyone needs lots of that optimistic spirit.
Did you see CNN today? The PA Governer is nervous of losing PS to McCain and wants Obama back in PA.
Even more, there is a hidden panic in the Obama ranks with respect to the Palin effect.

 

I think there will be millions of gutchecks

Tim_Schieferecke (Diary) Tuesday, October 21st at 10:55PM EST (link)

when people actually enter the voting booth and the reasonable doubt of voting for The One hits them. Gutchecks are instinctive, like lighting a lighter with one hand and holding an open gas can with the other. When you get close to putting the two together, it gives you pause to reconsider. Obama is the fire, a Democrat controlled House and Senate is the gas. That’s enough to make anyone change their shorts that isn’t a dyed in the wool marxist.

Tim Schieferecke

 

Hey my wife was for Obama during the summer...

izoneguy (Diary) Tuesday, October 21st at 11:16PM EST (link)

…once I had serious discussions with facts she finally realized that Obama could do serious damage to her free-wheeling, tennis wife does not have to work lifestyle. She is a giving person and she donates more to our church than Biden gives to charities in a year!!! Once you look at the character of the people running it is clear!! It was to my wife – she voted for McCain/Palin today and will tomorrow!!

The point cannot be made often enough: Modern liberalism, as embodied in the Obama presidency, is the defender of the status quo. And the status quo is a road to economic ruin. Political forces cannot redistribute the wealth that the economic system does not produce.

 

I don't believe all the polls

Andy Smith (Diary) Tuesday, October 21st at 11:18PM EST (link)

that say he is that far behing in Pennsylvania or North Carolina. I belive my Tar Heel home state will be red on election night, as Florida will be as well.

“Let us have faith that right makes might, and in that faith, let us, to the end, dare to do our duty as we understand it.”-Abraham Lincoln

 

Write a letter to editor to religious newspapers

Sunnie57 Thursday, October 23rd at 1:06AM EST (link)

I ask my fellow Catholics to write a letter to the editor to diocese newspapers in their state, especially the battleground states.

Catholics can make or break an election, and they need to know that the Church is making abortion a top priority when we vote.

Some Catholics who are more liberal than I am, use the war, poverty, etc. as an excuse to vote Democrat, but they are kidding themselves. Even Bishop Burke called the Dem Party, the party of death. Almost 50 million abortions since Roe, far more lives lost than war, poverty, etc..

You can even include a pro-life quote from the Pope in your letter from this link:

http://www.usccb.org/prolife/tdocs/popebquotes2008.shtml

I recommend the letters be as short as possible.