Sarah Palin – A 21st Century Duchess of Devonshire?


In September 2008 the movie, The Dutchess, was released.

A chronicle of the life of 18th century aristocrat Georgiana, duchess of Devonshire, an ancestor of Princess Diana who was alternately celebrated and reviled for her extravagant political and personal lives.

Now I have not yet actually seen this movie, but I have read a review of this movie that has moved me to ask the question in my title. I encourage you to read the review and draw your own conclusions. I also do not presume that the author of this review intended any comparison, so just blame me for the suggestion. I will provide some excerpts of this review that I think bolster my suggestion.

I did not expect that, amid the romance, costumes, and drama, I would strike libertarian gold!
It was one pivotal scene in particular that piqued my curiosity. When Charles Fox (played by Simon McBurney), who was Georgiana’s mentor and the leader of the Whig party, argues for the importance of “freedom in moderation,” Georgiana responds quickly and firmly that there cannot be scales of freedom. Rather, the “concept of freedom is an absolute.”

The Duchess of Devonshire lived in a time that bears striking similarities to our own. In the late 18th century, England was rife with tensions between an increasingly powerful state and a swelling grassroots opposition. The frustrated Whigs were becoming increasingly radicalized in their defense of liberty against the corrupt, ever-expanding powers of King George III.

I think you could replace the word Whigs with Republicans and replace the words King George III with President Obama and it would describe early 21st Century US.

But Georgiana was not a shrinking violet. She was fiercely passionate about her party’s ideals. Her favorite book was Vertot’s Revolutions of Sweden, which is about, as she put it, a “[h]ero fighting for liberty of his country and to revenge the memory of an injur’d friend against lawless cruelty and oppressive tyranny.”

Georgiana recognized that liberal ideals could only be spread through dedicated organizing and savvy marketing.

Georgiana was a marketing genius, one of the first to refine political messages for mass communication. She was an image-maker who understood the necessity for public relations, and she became adept at the manipulation of political symbols and the dissemination of party propaganda. She was simultaneously a public figurehead for the Whigs and an effective politician within the party.
To keep morale alive, she held vibrant, theatrical parties, dinners, and rallies.

Georgiana was a powerful asset for the Whigs, serving as campaign manager, strategist, advisor, inspiration, and symbol of the movement. She brought Whig ideals back into fashion with her costumes, balls, and events. She helped shape the strategy and direction of the party, and she charged along when her comrades lost steam.

Driven by strong convictions and a fervent belief in freedom, Georgiana was a master political propagandist, a powerful negotiator, an impassioned orator, and a keen political strategist. In many ways, she was the woman behind the men of the Enlightenment.

So that’s it. These parts of this review are what made me think of Sarah Palin. I know some people think that Sarah Palin can do no wrong while other people think she can do nothing right. The truth is somewhere in between. This is not a pro-Palin nor an anti-Palin diary. It is just my personal observation that Sarah Palin can refine political messages for mass communication, and Sarah charges forward when her political comrades lose steam.

Cross-posted at The Minority Report


Category: , ,

RSS feed

19 Comments Leave a comment

Whigs redux?

Beaglescout (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 2:48PM EST (link)

I have read several places people who say that modern conservatism is resurrecting many of the themes of Whiggism. They say that as if those old Whiggish ways went by the wayside for good reason. But I wonder.

Perhaps, as socialism and communism resurrected the oligarchic tyranny of Greek city states for a new age, so the eternal struggle for freedom has reawakened the Whigs who are buried beneath our political grounds. Much worse things (Aztec sacrificial cult) could be resurrected. That is for certain.

“A nation which can prefer disgrace to danger is prepared for a master, and deserves one.”

–Alexander Hamilton
 

This is too far a stretch.

KathW (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 3:07PM EST (link)

The late 18th century saw American independence, the French Revolution, guillotining of royals and the rise of Napoleon. Blessedly, I don’t think our country has anywhere near the troubles England had then. Also, women in society were just testing their wings. (See the Bronte sisters writing under male pseudonyms and Jane Austen’s success as an early female novelist.) The Duchess (I have not seen the movie) appears to be part of this feminine vanguard. Although no woman has yet been elected president here I don’t see Sarah as breaking feminist ground. Also, any suggestion that she is the woman behind the men of today’s “Enlightenment” is vaguely insulting nonsense. Sarah is a hard-working politician. So are Bachmann, Demint, Rubio, etc. Seeing special powers in Sarah doesn’t help her or Republicans.

KathW, I think one could say that Sarah is part of...

penguin2 (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 5:34PM EST (link)

of a feminine vanguard, because that is exactly what women/politicians like Michele Bachmann, Marsha Blackburn and yes, Sarah, are doing for the Conservative movement. Historians will look back and discuss the movements and the players of our time.

Resistance to tyrants is obedience to God. – Benjamin Franklin
When Good stands up to Evil, Evil blinks. – Vassar Bushmills

Conservative Education: Suggested Reading List

Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

Isn't Olympia Snowe a woman? (no, srsly)

KathW (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 7:06PM EST (link)

Snowe and Collins may only dip a toe in the conservative water but they still count. What about KBH, who sometimes reeks, but still counts as a conservative? I think it’s more important to group Sarah (and Michele and Paul Ryan, etc) as a critical fresh face to conservatism., regardless of gender. I completely agree that historians will see all these people as part of a critical turning point. It was the whole Duchess thing that set me off. Woman behind the power, symbol of the movement — blech.

Good point, KathW, I made the mistake of only thinking....

penguin2 (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 7:26PM EST (link)

of the good guys for our side. LOL. You are right, better to stay out of the gender focus, though I do think history will tell its own tale.

Resistance to tyrants is obedience to God. – Benjamin Franklin
When Good stands up to Evil, Evil blinks. – Vassar Bushmills

Conservative Education: Suggested Reading List

Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

It was not my intent to fixate on gender

pilgrim (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 7:52PM EST (link)

The point I was trying to suggest is that there are times throughout history when somebody really generates a buzz when they say something. I am in no way putting down Paul Ryan or Tim Pawlenty. I’m just saying when they put out a press release it is ignored for the most part. I’m not seeing Sarah Palin being ignored…at least not yet.


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

'Pil that's funny, because I was thinking entirely by....

penguin2 (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 8:40PM EST (link)

gender in this story. I thought that was why you noted that there could be some similarities between the Duchess of Devonshire and Sarah. I should quit while I am ahead, but maybe I took it this way because there are differences in how males and females perceive things. IOW, if you had tried to match up Ryan or Pawlenty to the Duchess, it wouldn’t have connected with me; need a duke in there for them. :)

Resistance to tyrants is obedience to God. – Benjamin Franklin
When Good stands up to Evil, Evil blinks. – Vassar Bushmills

Conservative Education: Suggested Reading List

Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

 
 
 
 
 
 

The part those struck me and of course made ME think of...

JadedByPolitics (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 3:08PM EST (link)

Sarah Palin was

“Driven by strong convictions and a fervent belief in freedom, Georgiana was a master political propagandist, a powerful negotiator, an impassioned orator, and a keen political strategist. In many ways, she was the woman behind the men of the Enlightenment.”

She is nothing if not the master of Conservative ideals. She may not have pleased all in her state and she definitely does not please all in her new role but there is NO MISTAKING she is generating buzz and MOVING the Conservative Cause forward!

thanks Jaded

pilgrim (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 3:19PM EST (link)

I do not understand how any conservative can be insulted by the campaigning efforts Sarah Palin provided for Saxbe Chambliss toward winning his election to the US Senate in Dec. 2008. Instead of being insulted why are they not pleased?


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

good one pil' and my bottom line of palin is that she is

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 4:10PM EST (link)

right on most every issue

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

thanks gamecock

pilgrim (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 4:59PM EST (link)

For me the observation is that when she has something to say about most every issue it attracts a buzz and is not ignored. Some other good conservatives do not get paid as much attention. Getting a conservative message delivered in such a manner that it is not ignored is a very good thing in my opinion.


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

Nobody gets the 'message delivered' like Palin...

speciallist (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 9:14PM EST (link)

NOBODY…..she is doing what R leadership refuses to do

the time is ripe for Mitch and the Eunuchs to pounce….but no, it’s pathetic

Gee, seems to me that's exactly why the Left

mbecker908 (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 10:01PM EST (link)

fell in love with Obama.

Yep, and now it's "President Obama"

Tbone (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 10:04PM EST (link)

isn’t it?

Envisioning when all that is Left is the Right.

Actually it's President Obama the

mbecker908 (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 10:09PM EST (link)

totally incompetent but smooth tongued scoundrel.

exactly..Sarah isn't lying..

speciallist (Diary) Tuesday, February 9th at 10:16PM EST (link)

Zero is

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Props for mentioning the Duchess of Devonshire

aesthete (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 12:20AM EST (link)

Interestingly enough, it was her lover, Charles Grey, I believe, who went on to abolish slavery. If only the US Whig Party hadn’t been so philosophically detached from its English antecedent…

The act of defending any of the cardinal virtues has today all the exhilaration of a vice – G.K. Chesterton

thanks aesthete. you're correct about Grey & US whigs nt

pilgrim (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 2:23AM EST (link)

Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

 
 

"The truth is somewhere in between."

Steph C (Diary) Wednesday, February 10th at 10:18AM EST (link)

Not many paid attention to that little line in the diary. This is where I sit. And Sarah, herself, if anybody listened to her TEA party speech. “There is no perfect candidate…”

As far as breaking feminist ground, don’t wrap it up in the tangible (no woman has been elected president, yet) as much as the intangible. It’s the intangible that will be far more important in the long run. Palin has, along with Bachmann and Blackburn, that success isn’t wrapped up in having indiscriminate sex and equally indiscriminate abortions because they’re an inconvenience to the modern concept of success as a woman. While the side that is supposed to be the women’s side objectifies them, then ridicules them, they push forward and show the lies of the feminist movement, which has a become a culture of death and a loss of freedom rather than life and freedom.

“[I]f the public are bound to yield obedience to laws to which they cannot give their approbation, they are slaves to those who make such laws and enforce them.” –Candidus in the Boston Gazette, 1772
Hillbilly Politics