In their meeting today at the White House, President-elect Obama and President Bush discussed bailing out the auto industry. The President-elect was for it. The President wasn’t but indicated that he might agree if Congress helped pass free trade agreements between the United States and countries like Colombia. The President-elect countered that this linkage was unacceptable because “human rights abuses against unionists.”
This excuse for rejecting the U.S.-Colombia Free Trade deal is nonsensical:
The anti-FTA case in the U.S. has been built on two pillars of propaganda. The first is that under Mr. Uribe’s leadership, labor unions have suffered disproportionately as a target of assassins. This is false. Murders of labor activists have been reduced sharply under Mr. Uribe, from 196 the year he took office to 26 last year.
Why were unionists getting murdered at such a high rate prior to Mr. Uribe’s presidency? In part it had to do with the historical ties between some of the dominant public-sector unions and Colombia’s hard left. These organizations have their roots in an anti-American, antidemocratic, antimarket ideology shared with the country’s Castro-backed insurgents. Tragically, this has put the dominant unions on the left side of Colombia’s violent politics for decades. Those who took up weapons to fight guerrilla aggression have been on the other side of the conflict.
Thousands of civilians, not just left-wing labor activists, have been killed in Colombian violence over several decades and it is not over. One of the union leaders I met with last week is new to his job. His predecessor, who was pro-FTA, was murdered in November.
Even so, things are better than they have been in a long time, thanks to Mr. Uribe. He’s restored the state’s law-enforcement role, and increased the budget in the attorney general’s office to prosecute political crimes. He’s also created a special security detail for union activists. No Colombian president has done so much to protect organized labor.
It is only when free trade agreements are in the offing that quasi-protectionists like Barack Obama–and some protectionists that don’t have anything “quasi” about them–express concern for labor rights, environmental standards and domestic violence in other countries. When there are no trade agreements under discussion, such considerations disappear from the agenda of the protectionist side. In the meantime, protectionists work to sabotage American economic growth by denying free trade agreements; it should be noted anew that Colombia already has access to our markets. The purpose of the free trade agreement is to get access to Colombian markets so that we can sell our products, make money for American companies and help get the economy out of the doldrums.
Evidently, the incoming Administration is against these noble goals. Why else would they be pursuing a trade strategy whose distinguishing feature is that it is positively suicidal?
Steve Maley
Neil Stevens
Daniel Horowitz
Fine by me... How 'bout Judges (more important in long run)
JLenardDetroit (Diary) Tuesday, November 11th at 3:38AM EST (link)How about a trade!?!? We’ll see you one Auto Bailout and Raise you a Stimulus package, provided…. WE GET OUR JUDGES you communists have been illegally blocking from being appointed!!!
To quote… well… ME…
Regards from NoMoTown (the MOTORlessCITY)
“Liberals, looking to do for? America what they’ve done for? Detroit! which is DESTROY IT!”
“I think, therefore I am Conservative”
“Conservative by choice, Republican by necessity”
“You can lead a Liberal to the Truth/Facts, but you cannot make them THINK!”
“Romney [No, not my first choice] does NOT have a MORMON problem. He has a, far too many Americans; these days; are MORONS problem!”
Follow @JLenardDetroit
(RS:Help) (JLD) (Hollyweird) (Brain-deads) (SPIN-cycle) (Obamaocare) (Party of kNOw) (Conservatism) (TEApeats) (respectful) (message) (Warning: Children Will Die!!)
Heil “O” Hell No Obamao is NOT MY PRESIDENT! “No U won’t”
I want “O” to FAIL (here, here, & whole Diary (Ofail) here, is why)
“The first Liberal was Satan” – a Rush caller (other Quotes)
This may be anathema to free trade purists but...
kyle8 (Diary) Tuesday, November 11th at 6:04AM EST (link)I question the value of any trade agreement with such a chaotic and violent nation.
With all our problems, Isn’t this like number 500 on the to do list?
“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle
With allies like Obama
mdetlh (Diary) Tuesday, November 11th at 6:56AM EST (link)The Colombians can go to the Eurozone and Canada for export markets.
So whose Unions are Obamanuts trying to protect?
Why is Pelosi insisting on Green technology for the automobile industry?
Now that Green technology is really high on the priority list? There are stories our that 2008 is one of the coolest years in a while.
Heritage Foundation note on auto bailout
pilgrim (Diary) Tuesday, November 11th at 7:30AM EST (link)Cal Thomas wrote an article where he quotes Heritage Foundation.
Unions
Scope (Diary) Tuesday, November 11th at 7:52AM EST (link)I understand that UAW heads were at the meeting in Washington yesterday. Obama is beholden to the Unions as they elected him in large part. He must protect their interests, and you can’t do that with non-existent companies and non-existent union workers and their dues.
Obama said he would bankrupt the Coal industry. What will happen with all of the United Mine Workers union workers? Does he owe the unions more than the environmentalists?
Thugs
10ksnooker (Diary) Tuesday, November 11th at 8:36AM EST (link)Obamunism is nonsensical on it’s face
He is an idiot
KSig44 Tuesday, November 11th at 9:55AM EST (link)Yes, let’s bail out an industry that hasn’t done one thing right in almost 30 years thus draining their available cash to nothing. This is a poor investment, I am all about Americans working but the auto industry has no inovative ideas to draw from and will blow through whatever money is given them quickly.
If they take a bailout, then my first demand is they all hire a top japanese executive to come over and head each company. With that they will bring over engineers and in turn it will make each American comapny into a japanese company on American soil.
They can't afford to kiss of blue states
walter_hanson Tuesday, November 11th at 10:40AM EST (link)The Democrats get a large source of money from rich people who care about the environment. If you check those $100,000 plus people who say they support Obama I bet:
They are anti drilling
Want tougher emission standards
care about the polar bear.
This is the group that is help to kill the auto industry. So to keep the votes of people in Michigan, Wisconsin, Ohio, Indiana they show they care about the auto industry that they give them lots of our tax payer money.
Years ago when there was a bailout package for Chrysler at least Chrysler was given a whole lot of conditions to be asking for the money in parts.
I hear no tough conditions being given out at all.
Walter Hanson
Minneapolis, MN
Correction
Robert L. Mayo (Diary) Tuesday, November 11th at 12:09PM EST (link)Fox news is reporting that discussions on a quid pro quo between Pres. Bush and Sen. Obama of auto bailout for the Columbia free Trade agreement did not happen.
It is a false report. – FYI
Robert L. Mayo
Dream no small dreams for they have no power to move the hearts of men.
- Goethe
For argument's sake
hotran Tuesday, November 11th at 12:15PM EST (link)I don’t really think there is much impact to saying Uribe “restored the state’s law enforcement role”, while citing the fact that “only” 26 labor activists/leaders have been killed this year, as opposed to 196 before that.
The existence of rule-of-law doesn’t smell, to me, like something that’s a question of degree, it either exists or it doesn’t. It makes just as much sense to say that the reason for the lower death toll is that more people worth killing had already been eliminated, as it does to say Uribe has restored rule of law.
All I’m saying is, if one is trying to make the case for the Columbia FTA, you’ll have to do more than this to knock out the RoL argument.
This is the kind of crap
Aetius728 Tuesday, November 11th at 12:58PM EST (link)that is pulled by liberals that if the public knew about, they would kick them all out.
But they don’t, and our dopey politicians have no desire to educate people about just how truly stupid and destructive liberal policies are.
I think it's another example of how the MSM tries to influence
Bill S (Diary) Tuesday, November 11th at 1:09PM EST (link)If you read the one MSM (Business Week) article that’s out there on the Fiesta, you’ll note that they soft-pedal the environmentalist aspects of this thing.
That’s it. Nothing else. BW pegs the problem as an expense problem, and I’m sure there’s something to that. But there’s not a peep in this article about why diesel is so bloody expensive.
“It’s such a fine line between stupid, and clever.” – David St. Hubbins
The big problem for me
drohan00 (Diary) Tuesday, November 11th at 1:56PM EST (link)is throwing an American ally under the bus. That shows the same foreign policy misjudgement that led to the American hostage crisis in Iran in ’79-’81. We should fear for our national security if we have a president that wants to be liked more than respected. They’ll play him like a cheap fiddle.
I also hate the auto bailout. We should fight it all the way. Especially if we lose John Dingell. But this could also be the first fracturing of the Democratic coalition. When labor butt up against the enviro-wackos. I hope Republicans, like Reagan, would be smart enough to take advantage.