Death of a Contrarian


This little book has no ‘hidden agenda’. it is offered in the most cheerful and open polemical spirit, as an attack on a crooked president and a corrupt and reactionary administration”

With that as the opening line in the Preface of his 1999 book “No One Left To Lie To (The Triangulations of William Jefferson Clinton)“, I quickly became a fan of this author…Christopher Hitchens.

I was very sad to see the news of his death pop up on my computer screen this morning.

To be honest, I only read three of his books.  The other two – “Why Orwell Matters” and “Letters to a Young Contrarian” – made it to my bookshelf just last year.  And, even more honesty, I’m not real sure how often I really agreed with him.  There are certainly a few very Big Concepts that he and I would have never come to any kind of agreement on but that really wasn’t the point.  He was a true thinker and, whether in print or in person (on my TV), Mr. Hitchens always made me think.  His points…his arguments…were blunt and always delivered with more than sufficient force.  On many levels…around work, among friends, or even on your favorite insufficiently conservative blog site…we all need fewer talkers and more thinkers in our lives.  His contributions to serious discussions around the world will be missed.

Just because I can, here are a few random bits of wisdom…just a taste… from the underlined passages in my copy:

“I cringe every time I hear denunciations of ‘the politics of division’—as if politics was not division by definition.  Semi-educated people join cults whose whole purpose is to dull the pain of thought, or take medications that claim to abolish anxiety.  Oriental religions, with their emphasis on Nirvana and fatalism, are repackaged for Westerners as therapy, and platitudes or tautologies masquerade as wisdom. ”

“Bear in mind, however, that Utopia itself was a tyranny and that much of the talk about the analgesic and conflict-free ideal is likewise more menacing than it may appear.”

“It is only those who hope to transform humans who end up by burning them, like the waste product of a failed experiment.” (Letters to a Young Contrarian, pages 31-32)

and…

“I suggest you learn to recognize and avoid the symptoms of the zealot and the person who knows that he is right.  For the dissenter, the skeptical mentality is at least as important as any armor of principle” (Letters to a Young Contrarian, page 33)

There is much more where that came from.  I recommend you take some time away from here over the Holidays and read something…maybe even some Hitchens.

Ntrepid
Proud Redstate Member since April 2006…?

 


Category:

RSS feed

4 Comments Leave a comment

Hitchens well liked and a must read across the political spectrum...

J. Leg (Diary) Friday, December 16th at 8:55PM EST (link)

… Because he was real. That line from the preface of his book on Clinton encapsulated him perfectly. He didn’t have any sort of agenda, he was a classic pundit, giving his honest opinion on important matters of the day.

Plus, he was witty and delightful even in his most exceptionally contrarian pieces. It’s why the author of “God of is not great” had so many people of faith behind him, praying for him and wishing him the best.

I certainly will miss him.

 

ntrepid, Thanks for a great post

buddyp (Diary) Friday, December 16th at 10:07PM EST (link)

ntrepid,

In addition to your diary being thoughtful and well-written, I applaud your inclination to praise and see the value in expressions of serious thought even when you don’t agree.

There are appropriate venues for discussion and debate within a narrower band of perspectives, beliefs and opinions, for the purpose of more efficient, focused discussion — and Redstate is one such venue — but I hope we all remember to consider alternative views at least some of the time, and consider possible adjustment of some view we have on some issue, if we find merit in relevant facts or arguments.

When I was a college sophomore (decades ago) I got active in Students for Peace and went to protests and believed many of the talking points of the left. I remember some great advice my father gave me. Although he was a moderate Democrat, he told me “Just make sure you’re not spending all your time with people who think the same things.”

I agree with your praise of Hitchens. He was a real, independent thinker, thought-provoking, and made his points with a very entertaining wit and eloquence. And I think he was sincere in the passion he exhibited for his chosen issues. People like Hitchens play an important role in society, and I’m sad he’s gone, and sad for him.

Facts –> rational analysis –> conclusions –> advocacy. In that sequence.

Book I wish everyone in the world would read

 

Hitchens started on the Left

daveoconnor (Diary) Saturday, December 17th at 2:18AM EST (link)

but gradually moved away especially post 9/11.
He wrote and said that he was increasingly drawn to much of the conservative critique because debate on the Right was a vigorous counterweight to the stale orthodoxy so prevalent on the other side.
And he was very funny. RIP Mr. Hitchens.

 

Hitchens epitomized the best in opinion journalism.

Flagstaff (Diary) Monday, December 19th at 12:59AM EST (link)

Reasoned conclusions based on objective reality.

He drove Bill O’Reilly bonkers, IIRC.

“I cringe every time I hear denunciations of ‘the politics of division’—as if politics was not division by definition.”

So obvious, yet so seldom observed.

“The press is so powerful in its image-making role that it can make a criminal look like he’s the victim and make the victim look like he’s the criminal. If you aren’t careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed and loving the people who are doing the oppressing.”– Malcolm X, Audubon Ballroom, December 13, 1964