School Choice = Selling Children


On Wednesday morning I threw on a tie and trudged down to the Virginia General Assembly Building to attend hearings on a few bills before the Senate Finance Committee.  Among them was Henrico Del. Jimmie Massie’s education tax credit bill. The bill would have allowed private donors to contribute money into a scholarship fund that, in turn, would help poor and low-income students attend the schools of their choice.

The bill had passed the House a week before, though, like similar bills in previous sessions, the margins were close (because a few Virginia Republicans, for whatever reason, really do have a thing for government schools).

The Senate, though, has generally been hostile to the idea of school choice. And this time, the hostility turned weird.

There was state Sen. Henry Marsh (D-Richmond) practically eating his microphone in the process of showing his disgust for the measure.  There was state Sen. Yvonne Miller (D-Norfolk) growling that the bill had nasty overtones of “selling children.” And there was Senate majority leader Dick Saslaw (D-Fairfax) proving to the world (again) that he really is a few bricks shy of a load.

Fortunately, the Family Foundation was on hand to capture it all on video.

All of this comes on the heels of Gov. McDonnell’s proposals to reform Virginia’s sclerotic charter school law, which has prevented, rather than encouraged, the creation of charters in the commonwealth. Earlier in the week, the legislative black caucus issued a scathing deunciation of the whole concept, with Sen. Marsh among those thundering that this tentative step toward wider education reform was the greatest threat to Virginia’s public schools since Massive Resistance.

Outrageous? Sure. But it’s standard rhetorical practice for Marsh & Co.

Some time ago at an education reform conference here in Richmond,  Marsh charged that school choice was just a way to re-segregate the public schools. Gerard Robinson (the commonwealth’s new Secretary of Education) then stood up to say that where once George Wallace stood in the schoolhouse doorway to keep black kids out, some politicians (like Marsh) were now standing in the doorway to keep them from leaving.

Marsh left the meeting very soon afterwards…exercising a freedom he and his Democratic colleagues are determined to deny to poor kids in their own Senatorial districts.


Category: ,

RSS feed

2 Comments Leave a comment

A friend of mine teaches at a school in NJ...

kyoufuu (Diary) Thursday, February 25th at 4:26PM EST (link)

Which has a predominantly minority makeup. She was regaling me recently with a story from Martin Luther King day, where she asked her all African-American class of students, “would we be here without Martin Luther King?”

The goal was that the answer was supposedly “no.”

I didn’t have the heart to tell her that the inherent problems in the public school system have essentially moved time back, for her school at least, to pre-MLK days. Basically, all of his work had proven to be meaningless for these children.

School choice is the only way to fix the problem. It provides opportunity for students in failing districts who would normally be stuck with a poor education.

“There are more instances of the abridgment of the freedom of the people by gradual and silent encroachments of those in power than by violent and sudden usurpations.” — James Madison

“I swear by my life, and my love of it, that I will never live for the sake of another man, nor ask another man to live for mine.”

 

Wow. Usually, at least you can pretend, if you really want to, that their rhetoric makes a little sense.

randy streu (Diary) Thursday, February 25th at 4:34PM EST (link)

What sad, sad idiots those people are. They are damning children to pathetic educations, all in the name of “fairness.”

Stupid.