
A simulation of the 2010 House races as charted by the Cook Political Report follows, but right here is all you need to know about who’s favored:
Democrats currently have 66 seats listed as Lean or Toss Up.
Republicans currently have 7 seats listed as Lean or Toss Up.
Oh and on top of the 66, there are 2 seats held by Democrats which are given over as Likely Republican.
As usual, I will simulate the races by assigning all seats not listed as having a 0% to be given to the other party, seats listed as Likely for a party having a 1% chance of a flip, seats listed as Lean having a 10% chance, and seats listed as Toss-Up having a 50% chance.
As mentioned above, Democrats hold (or held, in the case of the NY-29 vacancy) 66 of the seats listed, while Republicans hold 7. However after simulating the race 100,000 times, Republicans gain 21 of those seats as a mean and modal outcome. This is up one from my last simulation of the Cook ratings a month ago.
For context, at this point last time Democrats were set to gain 9 or 10 seats, compared with the 21 they won in November.
Should Republicans by November double their gain to 42, as the Democrats did, it will be enough to take the House of Representatives.
Aaron Gardner
Steve Maley
KnightsofMalta
Thanks for the analysis
rdelbov Friday, July 23rd at 4:35PM EST (link)Just a couple of quick points
1. Candidates do matter and close to two dozen states have not had their primaries. That being said other then IL8 I think the GOP has good to great candidates in tossup & leaning races where candidates have been selected.
2. There is looking at elections right now and then there is thinking about November 2nd. Campaigns do matter–great candidates with winning issues can move even likely to lean to tossup status.
3. How about those possible election surprises. Here’s a question for you–Neil–what could happen that move momentum towards the democrats? I don’t see economic recovery coming anytime soon nor do I see the deficit disappearing or Obama moderating his stances. Actually I see all the possible gloomy scenerios helping the GOP. Big unemployment numbers in Oct–a hurricane shuts down gulf oil production/gas to $5 per gallon–2000 point drop in the Dow. Lots of nasty that could happen that would help the GOP
Now, you're just toying with us Neil.
tngal (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 5:06PM EST (link)And get rid of that goofy grin on your face. I know you had one while you posted the numbers. Have you no shame?
These are the numbers
Neil Stevens (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 5:51PM EST (link)If you’re thinking of the Swingometer, I bring that out for Generic Ballot polls.
RS contributing editor, technical administrator, and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules
Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.
“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder
GA-5
gwalt Friday, July 23rd at 5:07PM EST (link)Sigh.
Georgia 5th isn’t listed. There is someone Republican running though. But the crazy Liberals here love Lewis.
“A lot of briefing for a 2 hr. special with Dan Rather. Saw the show & wonder why we bothered”. –Ronald Reagan, The Reagan Diaries (January 27, 1982)
Abandon all hope
Thane_Eichenauer Monday, July 26th at 2:48AM EST (link)Are there more people who love freedom or not?
I disagree with Cook on MA-10.
swami7774 (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 5:34PM EST (link)MA-10 extends from just south of Boston down to the Cape and Islands. It went 61-39 for Scott Brown in January. Cook lists it as leaning Democrat, but I’d rate it a toss-up.
Much depends on voter enthusiasm. The assume Democrat front-runner, Bill Keating, has been all but invisible. His recent fundraising numbers are grossly inflated because of the $500K he listed as having collected, about half of it was a sleazy transfer from his state campaign funds. On the GOP side, Sandwich State Rep. Jeff Perry took about 400K this quarter, all from direct contributions.
Perry will win this seat if the primary(against former state treasurer Joe Malone) doesn’t get nastier than it already has.
Today, there is a name for the political doctrine that rejoices in scarcity of everything except government. The name is environmentalism.
OK-2 is not listed by Cook
pilgrim (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 5:34PM EST (link)This seat currently held by Dan Boren is listed at RCP as likely Dem,. Cook also lists SD-AL as leans Dem, and RCP lists this seat as leans GOP.
I'd wager that Dan Boren will be reelected
Darin_H (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 7:15PM EST (link)Even though he voted for Nancy Pelosi and that should be enough to throw him out, he’ll be reelected. He’s probably the most conservative Democrat in the House (he should be a Republican, but his dad was an old school D).
A visionary coward says that anger can be power, as long as there’s a victim on TV – Flat Top, Goo Goo Dolls
Dan Boren Isn't the most conservative D in the House.
pilgrim (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 7:32PM EST (link)That title probably goes to Bobby Bright of Alabama. Boren has not voted against any bill that increases the deficit including the most recent one on unemployment comp extension.
The last conservative Democrat retired in December 2004... nt
rbdwiggins (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 8:01PM EST (link)“Well, the trouble with our liberal friends is not that they are ignorant, but that they know so much that isn’t so.” – Ronald Reagan
I'm Not So Sure
IJB Friday, July 23rd at 9:20PM EST (link)For one thing, Boren is not particularly conservative – the most conservative House Dem (consistently) is Gene Taylor of MS (who I fear is the one Dem we definitely *won’t* beat…).
As for Boren, it will ultimately depend on the strength of his eventual Republican opponent….
here is some info on Boren's opponent
pilgrim (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 10:00PM EST (link)I did a diary on the upcoming Oklahoma primary.
http://www.redstate.com/pilgrim/2010/07/22/oklahoma/
I think Obama would love to see the House go Republican
frankieb (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 5:55PM EST (link)Maybe the Senate, too. That way he’d have a whole new bunch of people to blame for his miserable policies. Oh, and in 2012, he could say he’s all that stands between the Republicans and their ideas.
Books … the most exotic, least expensive vacation: www.DelphiBooks.us
www.DaughterOfTheGreatDepression.blogspot.com
Claire McCaskill goes in so many directions, it’s amazing she hasn’t drawn and quartered herself. www.TruthAboutClaire.com
I agree.
swami7774 (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 6:28PM EST (link)You’d think he’d view a solidly GOP Congress as a perfect foil against which to triangulate.
But to do that he’d have to moderate his positions and I don’t see him being willing or able to do that.
Today, there is a name for the political doctrine that rejoices in scarcity of everything except government. The name is environmentalism.
The Demorats are already setting up
NoDoze Friday, July 23rd at 7:50PM EST (link)mechanisms to blame the Republicans. All of these multi-thousand-page bills have most of the nasty stuff beginning later (after the Repubs take the majority).
Look at the effective dates for the tax increases, and reporting requirements (1099s, etc.). After the 2010 elections, assuming Rep. majority, expect massive legislation crammed down our throats by the lame duck Dem. congress. Guess who will be blamed for it?
NoDoze, I'm not so sure about that
lineholder (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 10:54PM EST (link)Oh, I agree with you that they’ll do everything they can to blame Republicans. It’s the lame duck Dem. congress action that I’m not sure about.
There are a few, not many but a few, of these Dems who have voted as they have because they were gullible enough to buy into the lie that it is what the American people have been waiting for all these years and here’s their chance to have courage and integrity by providing this, ya-da-ya-da-blah-blah-blah. You know the routine.
So they bought into the lie and allowed themselves to be persuaded, believing that they were going to be heroes, even when their common sense might have warned them that this wasn’t true.
If they lose the election, then Obama/Pelosi/Reid no longer have the carrot to hold in front them, right? There could be a lot of buyouts. I’m expecting that much. There could be a few who simply want a certain amount of redemption. Then there could be more than just a few who end up bitter that they let themselves get played.
If the latter is true, what’s to prevent them from voting against policies just for the sake of plain old vengeance…pay back pure and simple.
It’s going to be interesting to watch.
You could be right
NoDoze Saturday, July 24th at 12:11AM EST (link)in your analysis of the congress critters, and you are certainly right that it is going to be interesting. However, the delayed implementation of so much in these massive bills still bothers me. Those are time bombs, which if not repealed or de-funded and killed, will be disastrous.
Agree wholeheartedly on that, NoDoze. [nt]
lineholder (Diary) Saturday, July 24th at 12:30AM EST (link)I suspect
rdelbov Friday, July 23rd at 7:01PM EST (link)that for the likely and the tossup catagories –Cook flips a coin and calls one a tossup and the next one a likely. He ignores polls right now and does the coin flip thing
Do These Ratings Reflect Diferences in Voter Enthusiasm?
Locke (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 7:22PM EST (link)Cook doesn’t seem to discuss methodology.
It's the personal judgment of his team, I assume (nt)
Neil Stevens (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 7:31PM EST (link)RS contributing editor, technical administrator, and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules
Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.
“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder
I'm Nearly Positive That Almost All of It Is Based on Fund-Raising Prowess
IJB Friday, July 23rd at 9:23PM EST (link)You can tell that by which districts shift more D – the ones that did tended to be places like some of the PA districts where the GOP challengers have virtually no cash on hand.
I’m incredulous on basing some much of the ratings on fund-raising, but that seems to be a lot of what goes into Cook’s (and Rothernberg’s) ratings…
Cook is all seat of the pants
rdelbov Friday, July 23rd at 7:25PM EST (link)Its an art not a science.
When you have AL SD with the incumbent down 6 points in alikely voter poll but you list the state as likely democrat then you know its just guessing
Of course it's not science
Neil Stevens (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 9:55PM EST (link)The only way I could think of to be scientific would be to get systemic polling of every seat, and that’s just not practical.
RS contributing editor, technical administrator, and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules
Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.
“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder
A lot Great Chances
proudgop (Diary) Friday, July 23rd at 11:58PM EST (link)My only worry has been the poor fundraising by both NRCC and RNC. Some of the Republican candidates ( cough Pennsylvania had poor fundraising)
I also hope some of these bitter primaries can unify quickly ( some are pretty late in September too)
It was interesting to look at where DCCC is spending money on ads in fall. Most of the plays where typical but it seems they are only playing in 2 open house seats ( Kansas and Open Kirk seat) so it implies DCCC might be waving white flag in TN, AR, and open NY seat.
I Personally Think The NRCC Will Have Enough Funds...
IJB Saturday, July 24th at 1:57AM EST (link)…To keep a number of these districts (e.g. the PA laggards, ID-01) afloat even if the candidates don’t raise as much as hoped.
And, luckily, that’s because a lot of GOP House candidates this cycle *have* been raking in the cash. The NRCC won’t have to spend much, if anything, in those districts, so they can probably use what cash they have to keep some of these other districts afloat…
ID1 --PA10
rdelbov Saturday, July 24th at 10:00AM EST (link)are some noticable laggards on money raised but its not too late but other factors need to be considered.
1. Volunteers can overcome money–500 active and motivated people can push a candidate in a district like ID1 over the top.
2. These congressional races-like PA10-are not the only game in town. In NE PA there will be a huge GOTV effort by the GOP to elect Toomey and Corbett. There is a very active GOP local effort there and it will be very well funded. Getting GOP voters to the polls in PA will not be a problem. our candidates there for congress will need to reach out to conservative democrats and ticket splitters but the base will be going to the polls. When you go through those congressional seats there are not many with solid organizations behind them
The reason these predictions are suspect is that
mikerazar (Diary) Saturday, July 24th at 10:17AM EST (link)the outcomes aren’t really independent.
I bet if we win 25 seats, we win 40 or more.
We have a nation to save, people.
There has been
rdelbov Saturday, July 24th at 11:36AM EST (link)record Primary turnouts for non Presidential years for the GOP in ME-SC-GA-AL-KY-IN-AR-TX-NM-UT-NV–gives you a sense of voter passion.
How about those states setting democratic turnouts for non Presidential year primary turnout. A big O or zero or Obama nothing. That’s right not a single state has set a democratic turnout record this year.
I might add that I can already forecast a record GOP turnout here in TN–looks likely for KS next month–maybe OK as well. democrat numbers look to be down across the board.
Cook's Recipe
lukematthews (Diary) Saturday, July 24th at 12:26PM EST (link)He’s still got the 2008 results ramped up on his old mainframe, keeping the Democratic numbers close by, just in case. There are many races that are in flux that Cook is not including. That’s okay. The skewed polls are not bad either. Information, good reliable information allows political operatives to target the most vulnerable races and funnel money and talent into those areas. The more the Democrats rely on poorly calculated results and hopey changey standards, the more likely we can turn some more of these districts they think are ‘safe’. If we really pour on the efforts, we could see some really big surprises in November. The Democratic Party is suffering under the Ostrich Effect right now with Nancy taking little Bobby Gibbs out to the woodshed. The longer they live in delusional stupor, the more ground we can make up this summer.
I just hope the Bamster starts politicking in some of these districts while Rome burns. It makes him look even more inept.
cnn generic ballot
rdelbov Saturday, July 24th at 12:46PM EST (link)49%R–44% D–registered voters–looks alot like Rasmussen +9 R generic among likely voters
If we see net job losses over the next three months–it will be brutal for the democrats
New Poll
proudgop (Diary) Monday, July 26th at 10:59PM EST (link)http://www.kob.com/article/stories/S1669545.shtml?cat=500
Republicans lead in the split district in New Mexico formally held by Heather Wilson
51-45% Barela over Heinrich