The End Of White Guilt?


Something strange is happening in America. For the first time, a white man is standing up to a black man’s charge of racism. And he is being supported by his employer. In another first, the media coverage of this event is not employing the time worn premise that only whites can be racist.
For those of you who may have missed the unrelenting 24/7 media coverage of the latest racial tempest in a teapot, the basic facts: A white policeman in Cambridge, Massachusetts, on the alert for 2 reported black burglars, detained a prominent black professor. The black professor then proceeded to play the race card, accusing the officer of being a racist. After challenging the authority and the mother of the policeman, professor Henry Gates was arrested for disorderly conduct.
This incident may have gone the way of millions of others but for the fact that this professor was a friend of President Obama. Luckily for Henry Gates, the most powerful man in the world took time out from pressing affairs to take his call.
The President then announced publicly that the Cambridge police Department ‘acted stupidly’, even while acknowledging that he wasn’t familiar with all the details. That our president chose to get involved in the first place is a discussion for another time.
What makes this incident unique is the fact that the automatic assumption of racism on the part of the white policeman is actually being questioned. In a very public way – signaling the possibility that the ‘white guilt’ America has embraced for the last 45 years may finally be consigned to history.
White guilt is best described by author Shelby Steele, who says “White guilt is literally the same thing as black power.” Steele hypothesized that America lost its moral authority when it acknowledged and apologized for the sin of slavery in the early 60′s. This ‘moral authority’ transferred to the victims of historical racism and became their great power. The power to stigmatize one as a racist became a powerful tool. A tool that has been wielded for decades with virtually no opposition, until now.

The power to evoke white guilt and the stigma of racism has been used time and again to bring corporations, politicians and public figures to their knees. White guilt has also played a significant part in the shaping of public policy and political correctness. It has also shielded generations of blacks from accountability, with predictable and damaging results.

Because white guilt is a vacuum of moral authority, it makes the moral authority of whites dependant on proving a negative. As in, ‘Have you stopped beating your wife yet?’ For over 45 years, discussions of race in America have been constrained by the threat of being deemed racist. For over 45 years, most white Americans have been put in the impossible position of having to prove a negative. It now appears this might be changing.

As usual, the Rev. Al Sharpton weighed in with his predictable and automatic assignment of blame to whitey, calling the case an “abuse of power” by the officer. But, in yet another first, the media declined to annoint this blowhard his usual status as commentor in chief on all things racial. Poor Al failed to get his usual ‘face time’. His comments were, gasp, not news. Perhaps the media sees the writing on the wall.

The writing that seems to indicate that charges of racial oppression and racism ring false now that a black man has been elected to the Presidency. The writing that indicates that most white Americans are ever so tired of having to prove day and night that they ‘are not racist’. The writing that indicates that America has paid its debt to the black man and they are now welcome to compete, on an equal footing, with the rest of America. The writing that indicates that frivolous charges of racism will now be challenged.

Finally, Martin Luther King’s dream may become a reality – Americans may now be free to judge a man based on the content of his character instead of the color of his skin. High time.

Category: , ,

RSS feed

18 Comments Leave a comment

There are many who can't afford an end to white guilt.

deweyfromdetroit (Diary) Tuesday, July 28th at 4:00PM EST (link)

Great article. I too found this “blacklash” an encouraging sign of change in public sentiment. My concern, however, is that “the writing on the wall” will be ignored by a wide swath of people who are either genuinely angry at white America, or are so vested in the race business that they can’t afford to have it end.

As to the appropriateness of the President’s comments, Mark Steyn summed it up thusly: “The president of the United States may be reluctant to condemn Ayatollah Khamenei or Hugo Chávez or that guy in Honduras without examining all the nuances and footnotes, but sometimes there are outrages so heinous that even the famously nuanced must step up to the plate and speak truth to power. And thank God the leader of the free world had the guts to stand up and speak truth to municipal police Sgt. James Crowley.”

As long as the Commander in Chief still thinks in terms of racism, we will still have to deal with racism.

For another angle on “victimhood” you might like my
”Crazies To My Left” post.

Also blogging as
DeweyfromDetroit

 

GC Highly reccos - This is THE main effect of Obama's election - nt

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Tuesday, July 28th at 6:50PM EST (link)

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

I agree that main people who pulled the socialist lever last election hoped this would be THE main effect

The_Gadfly (Diary) Thursday, July 30th at 5:22PM EST (link)

unfortunately, I’m not so sure it will actually BE the main effect. I suspect the debt he’s been piling on will be a somewhat more far reaching effect than whatever happens on the race front. And if they do somehow manage to pass any version of “healthcare reform” that will have far more serious and long range consequences than the positives of finally getting to a post racial society.

 
 

This also reminds me of the SC decision

Scope (Diary) Wednesday, July 29th at 7:18AM EST (link)

on the white Conn. firefighters case. Our soon to be confirmed SC justice Sotomayor was overturned when she was amongst others proved that it’s not always whites that deserved to be called racist. I wonder if Obama had that in mind when he said what he did. It’s not only the fact that he called the Cambridge police “stupid”, it’s his follow up comments that “there has been a history in this country of racial profiling against blacks and Hispanics” that made my hair stand up.

 

This generation of kids may change all this...

wordsarepower (Diary) Wednesday, July 29th at 9:32AM EST (link)

believe it or not, in my high school classroom, students actually use racist claims as a joke. For instance, if I ask an Hispanic student to stop talking, and he refuses, I may move him to another seat. He’ll look at me and say something like: “You re just moving me because I’m Hispanic,” with a big grin on his face. Then another student might call out: “You’re just giving her a hard time because she’s white! That’s racist!” Nobody is serious about it.

There is so much diversity among kids and the people they hang out with and date. Racial barriers among the young are fading…it’s the grown-ups who continue to fuel the sparks that remain.

I agree.

larueladue (Diary) Wednesday, July 29th at 3:38PM EST (link)

Mainly, it is the Boomer generation that is carrying the racist banner now… No one else seems to care anymore. Unfortunately, they are the ones now in power.

 
 

Don't think this is the definition of "post-racial"

PoliPundita (Diary) Wednesday, July 29th at 6:07PM EST (link)

…that libs and the press had in mind when they hailed Obama as a post-racial candidate, yet it’s necessary if we ever are to be truly post-racial.

Whether "we" are post-racial depends on how we respond to individual acts, not the individuals acts themselves

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Wednesday, July 29th at 6:36PM EST (link)

And “we” are not equivalent to the press.

more later in upcoming column tonight

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

I dearly hope...

PoliPundita (Diary) Thursday, July 30th at 2:37PM EST (link)

…that we are not equivalent to the press. Most of them haven’t managed to move beyond their prejudices any better than Obama has. Nothing is so annoying as being lectured about racial prejudice by people who so clearly–and blindly–cling to their own.

I so tire of the drive-by's refrain that they merely "reflect" what "we" "are" and then point to ratings

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Thursday, July 30th at 5:14PM EST (link)

as if there is some magic process by which the diverse we are automatically reflected in the oh so non-diverse them.

not

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

An end to white guilt would be a devastating blow to racism

leftylurker (Diary) Friday, July 31st at 4:17PM EST (link)

White guilt isn’t good for anyone. White guilt is Speaker Pelosi saying that a prominent black leader should be proud to be able to speak to her. White guilt is an insane refusal to examine evidence if race is up in play.

But let’s be clear, racism, on all sides, is still alive and well, and that’s something that we as Americans have to pledge to fight until it is eliminated.

 
 
 
 
 

One correction though

Jaimo Wednesday, July 29th at 8:42PM EST (link)

I don’t believe that Crowley (the cop) was looking specifically for a black robber. The 911 call has come out and the dispatcher asked if the robber was black or white and the caller said she thought one might be hispanic and she couldn’t see the other one. So I don’t think racial profiling was a factor.

Even if the caller HAD described the intruder as a black individual, it wouldn't have been profiling.

randy streu (Diary) Wednesday, July 29th at 11:27PM EST (link)

If Crowley had looked for a black individual, because the caller had said it was a black individual, that’s just following up on a description. That’s not what profiling is.

 
 

Time to throw off the shackles of guilt

JustLeaveMeAlone (Diary) Thursday, July 30th at 7:41PM EST (link)

I am a white Southerner. I grew up as schools were being integrated and the issue of the day was busing. I remember seeing, as a child, white men attempt to intimidate black men and women from voting.

I’m 52. I’ve had half a century of seeing things change — and I can testify personally to the extent of that change. But now, I’ve had a bellyfull of being told that I am somehow responsible for the problems of this group or that group because of something some ancestor may or may not have done.

~I~ have never impeded anyone’s civil rights based on their race, sex, or religion.

As of right now, I will not take responsibility for anyone’s actions but my own. So I don’t plan to cut anyone any slack based on their race, sex, or religion, either.

No positive — no negative — that’s real equality. When things like sex, religion, and race are merely descriptive adjectives, and any spin the hearer wants to put on them is THEIR friggin’ problem, not mine.

I’m done with my chains — I proclaim myself emancipated from the shackles of guilt.

“To compel a man to subsidize with his taxes the propagation of ideas which he disbelieves and abhors is sinful and tyrannical.” Thomas Jefferson

Its about time 'lone! Hey, does this meet with your approval

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Thursday, July 30th at 7:51PM EST (link)

http://www.redstate.com/gamecock/2009/07/29/the-road-away-from-obamagates-hell-was-paved-by-obamas-election/

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

Indeed, my friend

JustLeaveMeAlone (Diary) Thursday, July 30th at 10:14PM EST (link)

This whole White Guilt thing is political correctness run amok. I read a book recently that opined that the thing the jihadists despise about us (i.e., “The West”) the most is our fear of being labeled racist, sexist, etc. — that it represents our Achilles’ Heel.

They may well be correct.

God forbid we should offend anyone! And “gee, some of my best friends are (fill in the blank)” makes one seem all enlightened and modern.

Bah, humbug. It’s crap.

I had plenty of problems as a woman on Wall Street in the 1980s — one that wasn’t a secretary. I got told daily, to my face, I didn’t belong there. I could have filed a lawsuit, or slunk off in tears, or blamed Evil Men in general for trying to keep me in the kitchen. I did none of the above; I kept showing up every day and doing my job.

If I had been run off, I’d have had no one to blame but ME. Life if tough. Man up, Woman up, White up, Black up, or Whatever up, and face it.

“To compel a man to subsidize with his taxes the propagation of ideas which he disbelieves and abhors is sinful and tyrannical.” Thomas Jefferson

 
 
 

well done Nancy

seesalrun (Diary) Friday, July 31st at 12:08AM EST (link)

eloquent
and completely accurate.

I believe even here in Alabama that racism is literally dead and only ones that profit from it perpetuate the corpse of it.

Mr. Gates, sadly is the poster child of the continuation of bias in our Country. He should be called to the carpet.

 

The only part of Gate-Gate not racist is Crowley.

Jason (Diary) Friday, July 31st at 3:54PM EST (link)

Absolutely amazing… but I love the point up at the top… we may have seen some sort of a tide turn here… a white man actually standing up to racism charges and not backing down. Everything about this issue was race related except for Sgt. Crowley’s actions. Gates reaction, comments, Obama’s stupidity remarks, even the beer fest. They couldn’t even get that right… might have worked had they not felt the need to break out Biden so that the picture was balanced. Obama is anything but the post-racial president.