Hesitating in the face of volley fire.


Back in the day – which is to say, the days before reliable automatic weapons were present on the battlefield – armies relied pretty heavily on volley fire and rigid discipline to win battles.  There were two reasons for this: first, of course, the more missiles you have in the air at once, the harder it is to get out of their way.  The second reason was psychological: charging in the face of steady fire – even essentially unaimed fire – is extremely difficult.  Armies and their generals simply had to accept that there would be casualties, and that the proper response was to keep moving forward and return fire.  So it usually came down to determination versus determination.  Sometimes the one side broke and ran… and sometimes one side simply hesitated in the face of a sustained series of volleys.  It sounds counter-intuitive, but that can happen when your troops are braver than your generals.  Or when your generals simply don’t know what to do next, and don’t have the capacity to improvise.

Why am I bringing this up?

The White House privately anticipates health care talks to slip into February — past President Barack Obama’s first State of the Union address — and then plans to make a “very hard pivot” to a new jobs bill, according to senior administration officials.

[snip]

Internally, White House aides are plunging into a 2010 plan calling for an early focus on creating jobs, especially in the energy sector, along with starting a conversation about deficit reduction measures, the administration officials said.

Ed Morrissey has more.  Bottom line: this will probably work out well enough for the President, but only because he has over two years before he has to start worrying about getting re-elected.  Democratic Members of Congress have eleven months, and they’ll need every second of it to handle the problem of their unpopular support of an unpopular health care rationing bill.  Put another way: either health care is an immediate crisis, or it is not.  If it is the crisis that we were told, then the President needs to get his fellow-Democrats in Congress to press on through and pass something with the urgency that they’ve been claiming all along was necessary.  If it is not the crisis that we were told, then the President needs to pull his fellow-Democrats out of this particular fight before retreat becomes impossible (but rout does not).  Letting Democrats in Congress take fire on health care rationing in the same way that they’ve been taking fire on cap-and-trade will simply get more of them fired in November for no good reason*.

But that assumes that the President is loyal enough to his party to take the personal hit to what’s left to his reputation for competence.

Moe Lane

*Which is fine with me, of course.

Crossposted to Moe Lane.


Category: , ,

RSS feed

16 Comments Leave a comment

...assumes that the President is loyal enough to his party

izoneguy (Diary) Wednesday, December 23rd at 1:12PM EST (link)

do you mean the democratic party?

Or the CPUSA?

The point cannot be made often enough: Modern liberalism, as embodied in the Obama presidency, is the defender of the status quo. And the status quo is a road to economic ruin. Political forces cannot redistribute the wealth that the economic system does not produce.

He is loyal to himself. Any other appearance of loyalty is just that, 'appearance'. An illusion. NT

USNJIMRET (Diary) Wednesday, December 23rd at 1:54PM EST (link)

Good one!

merryj1 Thursday, December 24th at 5:32AM EST (link)

Well..

soljerblue Thursday, December 24th at 4:46PM EST (link)

it’s starting to look like six of one, half a dozen of the other.

 
 

I Think Its By Design

Swamp_Yankee (Diary) Wednesday, December 23rd at 1:21PM EST (link)

Hence the sense of urgency all year. They wanted to get as much of their radical agenda done in 2009 as possible, and maybe early 2010. But they want to leave a window to repair their moderate image.

I bet the schedule a populist anti wall street, regulatory reform for the summer. Its one of the only things that unites Blue Dogs and radicals and appeals to many populist oriented independents.

 

GOP Volley Fire = Vorgons

jimmuy8 (Diary) Wednesday, December 23rd at 1:45PM EST (link)

Oh, sure: There are a lot of shots being fired–they just aren’t particularly aimed at anything. And there’s really no interest in improving the aim. It’s the message you see, “We will fire! (maybe not in your direction, maybe not at anything at all but, we will shoot.)”

The Congressional GOP isn't relevant in this context.

Moe Lane (Diary) Wednesday, December 23rd at 1:48PM EST (link)

It’s the people in the individual CDs that are giving Democrats grief.

 
 

Heh. Good One, Moe. (nt)

IJB Wednesday, December 23rd at 2:01PM EST (link)

This is exactly why the Republican senators should have adopted a delaying strategy

ColdWarrior (Diary) Wednesday, December 23rd at 2:10PM EST (link)

Obama’s speech writers kept putting words on the teleprompter that we were in a “health care crisis.”

We’re not.

The Republican senators could have used their delaying tactics to explain to the American people all the reasons why we are not in a crisis, why the bill is unconstitutional, about all the earmarks, about all the horrible things in it, etc., etc., etc. Recall, polls showed 85 per cent of the American people were satisfied with the “healthcare system.”

The longer the debate had been drawn out, the more the American people would have learned about the horrible aspects of this bill. The Republicans could have used the time to explain to the American people their alternatives that make so much more sense.

Now DeMint is fighting. Good. I only wish he and others would have bucked McConnell’s idiotic “strategy” long ago.

If a delaying strategy had been employed, maybe we would be seeing more of these kinds of attacks from the left, which I posted here:

http://www.redstate.com/avgamerican/2009/12/23/barack-you-lie-obama/#comment-42

Indeed, if we’re in a crisis, why doesn’t any of this kick in until after the 2012 election?

Thank you.
ColdWarrior

In 2012, will YOU become a “voting member” of the Republican Party in your precinct?

Where it all started. Twitter @kaltkrieger
Learn how to GOTV at The Concord Project and at Procinct and Unified Patriots.

But we might still dodge this bullet anyway. :)

clowngirl (Diary) Wednesday, December 23rd at 10:52PM EST (link)

The Senate Republicans have played their strategy and there’s no changing the past, but there is now time to convince them to act differently for the next vote (and in dealing with the Democrats in general)

And time for the new media/ Fox News to expose fresh reasons for killing this 2700 page disaster.

And to dissect and totally discredit the bogus premises that lead to such a flattering CBO report.

And for Nelson (and others) to get pummelled by the citizens of their states.

And for citizens to (continue to) make their views known to “blue dogs” in the House who were not expecting to have to vote on a stupendously unpopular bill in an election year.

And to run adds to pressure key Congressman/Senators.

And for the Pro-Lifers to embolden the members of the Stupak coalition.

Besides that, there’s also the chance that the left will get more organized in its opposition to an Obamacare that doesn’t include any sort of public option (though it is also possible they will calm down)

Public support for Obamacare is likely to continue to drop. (it could conceivably get to the point where opposition to support is 70/30 nationally)

Obama’s approval rating is likely to continue to drop.

Whatever this “jobs bill” is going to be it’s likely to be unpopular

Obama’s State of the Union is likely to be so ridiculous it will actually hurt him.

All your precinct committeemen posts have got me considering checking out my local NYC GOP chapter in late January or early Ferbruary, btw.

 
 

True measure of crisis

Kyle-MI (Diary) Wednesday, December 23rd at 2:35PM EST (link)

It does not depend on how fast they push this bill through. The full provisions don’t kick in until a few years down the road. (Although the taxes ramp up faster – funny that.) If it really were a crisis it would ramp up faster. For example, whatever your feelings on TARP, it would be as if they passed TARP but the banks wouldn’t have been allowed to barrow more money until 2011.

Republicans need to keep hamming that all of this health care crisis talk is completely and utterly phony.

 

I'm worried they're going to "let" unemployment to continue to slip to garner public support..

Veronica (Diary) Wednesday, December 23rd at 6:15PM EST (link)

… and the crisis will materialize if it hasn’t already.

Remember. We’re not just talking about the 10%.

There’s those figured into the actual unemployment that puts it above 16% — those who’ve stopped looking for work.

THEN who thinks of the countless 1-income families who’ve been out of the job market and are now trying to find work to shore up slipping savings.

THEN there are those December ’09, THEN May ’10 graduates (undergrad & from prof-schools) who aren’t getting offers before they graduate and who are anticipating having to look for weeks, months.

It’s a mess.

I’m under the suspicion Obama doesn’t give a damn about the economy so that the countless unemployed — without healthcare — will help force this thing through one way or another.

Just venting..

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Pray as if everything depends on God, and work as if everything depends on us. – St. Augustine

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

 

There just might be some volleys...

merryj1 Thursday, December 24th at 5:52AM EST (link)

… from behind their lines. I received an e-mail “forward” yesterday from an (very liberal) acquaintance in Wisconsin (we keep trying to convert each other), that is a “Kill the health care bill” petition from a far-left activist outfit.

The messaging was angry (“we’ve been sold out”) and nasty, in other words, typiical left (“the Republicans oppose it too, but for the wrong reasons”). A main objection seems to be omission of the ‘public option.’ I replied with a subtle “told you so” and didn’t check the site, but if anyone’s interested, its:

http://www.peaceteam.net/action/pnum1024.php

 

The 3 d's

olddog Thursday, December 24th at 6:15AM EST (link)

In the Democratic war chest are dismiss, denigrate, destroy. Perhaps we should follow Lt. Col Allen West’s post, in Atlas shrugs. We should use their tactics,and fight harder and harder. never giving up, Our Freedom is at stake. ( my words not his). He is a reputable man, by most accounts.
Support our Troops,
Especially at this time of year.
One Old Dog

 

freedom

sarge324 Thursday, December 24th at 12:14PM EST (link)

are freedom is a stake at ever turn.health care,cap and trade,stimulus,taking over banks,auto industry.obama and the radical left destroying free enterprise.they want us on your knees and praising him like the childern are doing.we must stay mad as hell all through 2010.to stay mad keep listening to fox and limbaugh and remember the constitution.beware of the usurpers in government that like to get rid of that piece of paper we call the constitution.

 

freedom x2

scubadiver49er Thursday, December 24th at 3:32PM EST (link)

Right on Sarge!!!! I am mad as he** what Barry, Nancy and Harry, etc. has done to us, and I intend to remain so until they ares gone (not if, but when) and repir the damage done. Whatever it takes!!

“I Just Can’t Wait to be King” – Simba from “The Lion King”, 1994
Barry Soetoro – ???