Rumsfeld sees and raises on Afghanistan.


Walking through this one:

  • Last week former Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld reacted strongly to the White House’s allegation that military commanders in Afghanistan were denied troop requests under the previous administration.  Actually, that’s too weak a statement: Rumsfeld denied that anything of the sort had happened under his watch.
  • Which, in point of fact, it did not: the administration was referring to events in 2008 – under Rumsfeld’s successor, Robert Gates (who is also the current SecDef, by the way) – and said events can be more accurately described as a ‘delay,’ not a ‘refusal.’  The requests were made by General David McKiernan.
  • Yes, the David McKiernan that Gates fired.
  • When pressed on this, current White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs must have felt backed into a corner.  After all, he was trying to justify the White House sneering at a policy implemented by a Secretary of Defense that the new administration had retained, and at the expense of a military general that the new administration had sacked.  Gibbs being Gibbs, he took the opportunity to try to change the subject by sniping at Rumsfeld some more.
  • Because, of course, this administration is terrified of ever, ever admitting being wrong about anything.  Sort of like what the Left pretended that the previous administration was like, only for real.

All of this is context for the response from Rumsfeld’s office:

The administration now claims President Obama was actually referring to denials of troops by his own Secretary of Defense in 2008.  This is obviously not what the President meant.  If it is what the President meant, he owes an apology to General McKiernan for dismissing him, for it was General McKiernan who sought additional forces in 2008.

This looseness with the facts seems to be a pattern in the current administration’s efforts to blame their challenges on their predecessors.  Nearly one year into this administration, that approach is wearing thin.

My only quibble with that is the use of the phrase  ‘wearing thin.’  It wore bare months ago.

Full statement after the fold.

Statement by Keith Urbahn
Office of Donald Rumsfeld
December 4, 2009

Washington D.C. –

“White House officials are not credible in denying President Obama’s intended meaning when he said on Wednesday night that ‘commanders’ were ‘repeatedly’ denied additional troops and resources in Afghanistan.

The administration now claims President Obama was actually referring to denials of troops by his own Secretary of Defense in 2008. This is obviously not what the President meant. If it is what the President meant, he owes an apology to General McKiernan for dismissing him, for it was General McKiernan who sought additional forces in 2008.

This looseness with the facts seems to be a pattern in the current administration’s efforts to blame their challenges on their predecessors. Nearly one year into this administration, that approach is wearing thin.

Afghanistan has always posed challenges, but in the judgment of the commanders at the time, Afghanistan was properly resourced for at least the first five years of the conflict. Those resources were aligned with proper and achievable goals: eliminating an al-Qaida sanctuary and preventing further terrorist attacks against the United States.”

Moe Lane

Crossposted to Moe Lane.


Category: , , ,

RSS feed

8 Comments Leave a comment

Redefinition

bkeyser Monday, December 7th at 3:11PM EST (link)

Gee, I hope some future administration doesn’t look back on the Obama administration and the decisions being made within, by redefining their current mission/directives/agenda based on the facts, ideology, and hindsight available at the time. That would almost seem unfair…

Should some future Administration look back and place blame,

USNJIMRET (Diary) Monday, December 7th at 4:45PM EST (link)

you just KNOW there are going to be so very many who declare it “racism, straight up”.

 
 

No need to wait to be "unfair"

merryj1 Monday, December 7th at 3:24PM EST (link)

All other factors and/or ideological disagreements notwithstanding, I really miss the former Administration and President Bush’s refusal to point fingers at “the last guy” or “the other guy,” even when it would’ve been entirely accurate and appropriate to do so.

That alone, as far as I’m concerned, makes George W. one of the two greatest presidents of this century: Basic honesty, integrity and decency.

 

Oops

merryj1 Monday, December 7th at 3:26PM EST (link)

I meant the 20th Century — not quite accurate, but you get my point.

Bush is clearly the greatest president

Loren Heal (Diary) Monday, December 7th at 3:47PM EST (link)

of the 21st century. On that the science is settled.


Join the Concord Project, and follow @lheal, if you dare.

 
 

World of lies

Dr. Botkin Monday, December 7th at 3:52PM EST (link)

An extremely cogent and articulate discussion of the manmade “global warming” fraud, ESPECIALLY TODAY. Please read, digest and FORWARD(before one of algore’s people erases it from YouTube)!! (New. Just recently posted.)

http://www.youtube.com/watch_popup?v=bKrw6ih8Gto

 

Barry 0zero's speech writers need to be fired

WarEagle01 (Diary) Monday, December 7th at 3:58PM EST (link)

With their pat, overused, phrases (“let me be clear” “a false choice between X and Y”), tired invocations of the historicalness of the One, and penchant for MSU (making stuff up), they are about the most incompetent group of clueless hacks to inhabit the WH since the Carter administration (and maybe even the Harding administration.)

“A wise, doughy leg with rich tingly experiences will always reach better conclusions than will a more tanned, muscular leg that hasn’t felt those thrills.” –Chris Matthews’ Leg

“The alternative to the awful extremity of abortion is the indispensable joy of introducing this flawed world to someone who might make it better.”–John Hayward (AKA Dr. Zero)

 

I just LOVE Rumsfeld.....

JadedByPolitics (Diary) Monday, December 7th at 4:30PM EST (link)

He is truly a fine upstanding American and I THANK HIM for his service to our country! and the fact that he can SMACK around the IDIOTS in the WH just adds to his already substantial resume!