A welcome but unnecessary defense of West Point.


Why I love America, Reason #4654908:

In Defense of West Point: A Cadet Responds to Thomas Ricks

My fellow cadets at West Point, in moments of overwhelming stress and cynicism, often compare our “rockbound highland home” to prison. Like inmates, cadets are regularly deprived of a wide range of social freedoms that “normal college students” would see as constitutional rights—we are told when, what, and where to sleep, eat, and wear. Our campus is secured on all perimeters by gates and security guards and entry into and out of West Point is tightly regulated. Most of the time, West Point feels more like the Panopticon than it does Harvard Yard. Thomas E. Ricks of the Washington Post voiced the sentiments of many of my classmates (myself included) during periods of utter exhaustion and pessimism when he declared this weekend that “we should get rid of West Point.”

So why do my classmates and I still stand proudly in the Long Gray Line? Because we think it’s worth it.

…it produces military personnel who can clearly, effectively, and courteously rebut an ‘argument’ that was (to paraphrase a colleague) extended more for notoriety’s sake than out of any real conviction. The last is probably the most important point, really: Rick’s condescending, parochial dismissal of a military tradition stretching back more than two hundred years is everything that we’ve come to expect from CNAS-style liberals. Particularly one who has graduated from Yale, a school that bans ROTC.

Personally, I’m growing tired of having to take seriously the narrow-mindedness of the Political Class.

Moe Lane

PS: Why I love America, Reason #4654909:
Check out the author blurb from TNL.

Tianyi Xin is a cadet at West Point where she double majors in International Relations and Law. She will graduate in May 2011.

Think about how that’d look to the average citizen of the United States of April 22, 1809. Or April 22, 1909. Or even April 22, 1959. Then laugh at the people who tell you how awful we are.

Crossposted to Moe Lane.


Category: , , , ,

RSS feed

6 Comments Leave a comment

A good reply to a pinhead

NRPax (Diary) Wednesday, April 22nd at 1:13PM EST (link)

and more than he deserved.

Personally, I don’t understand why folks always zero in on the military when the time comes for budget cuts. We have far more bloated programs coming out of D.C. that could stand to be excised.

 

Awesome post!

leftylurker (Diary) Wednesday, April 22nd at 1:15PM EST (link)

I love this line:

“Personally, I’m growing tired of having to take seriously the narrow-mindedness of the Political Class.”

I think I may be rubbing off on *you* a little now.

Let’s just get rid of them all. America is amazing, Americans are amazing…I’ve taken road trips all across the country, from Santa Cruz, CA to New Bryum Mississippi, and I’m proud to call pretty much everyone my countryperson.

Why can’t we find people to lead us?

 

Closing the service acadamies would be the first step.

Old_Crow (Diary) Wednesday, April 22nd at 1:20PM EST (link)

Followed by eliminating ROTC from public colleges and universities.
And then pressuring private colleges to limit / eliminate ROTC as well.

There used to be chatter discussing these goals on the Chronicle of Higher Education forums. Don’t know if that type of discussion goes on anymore since I’m not doing much work in that field any longer and haven’t logged on in years.

“Enlightened statesmen will not always be at the helm.” — James Madison

 

Down with the Political Class

Finrod (Diary) Wednesday, April 22nd at 1:42PM EST (link)

Lately Rasmussen has been polling issues and getting about the citizenry as a whole vs. the Political Class. The contrast has been very striking; just look at the following results:

On the bank and auto bailouts:

Looking back, 59% of voters nationwide believe the federal bailouts for banks and other financial institutions were a bad idea. The latest Rasmussen Reports national telephone survey found that just 26% think they were a good idea.

The numbers are similar for the bailout loans given to General Motors and Chrysler: 60% say they were a bad idea, and just 26% hold the opposite view.

But, in the end, the opinions of the Political Class mattered more than the opinions of voters. Today, by a 61% to 23% margin, the Political Class still believes the bailouts for the financial industry were a good idea. By a 64% to 23%, they say the same about the auto bailouts.

On the tea parties:

Fifty-one percent (51%) of Americans have a favorable view of the “tea parties” held nationwide last week, including 32% who say their view of the events is Very favorable.

Thirty-three percent (33%) hold an unfavorable opinion of the tea parties according to a new Rasmussen Reports national telephone survey. Fifteen percent (15%) are not sure.

While half the nation has a favorable opinion of last Wednesday’s events, the nation’s Political Class has a much dimmer view—just 13% of the political elite offered even a somewhat favorable assessment while 81% said the opposite. Among the Political Class, not a single survey respondent said they had a Very Favorable opinion of the events while 60% shared a Very Unfavorable assessment.

One-in-four adults (25%) say they personally know someone who attended a tea party protest. That figure includes just one percent (1%) of those in the Political Class.

On taxes:

With the annual ritual of filing federal income taxes just behind them, 52% of U.S. voters now believe they pay more than their fair share of taxes, up seven points from earlier this month.

But 54% of the Political Class don’t think they pay too much, according to a new Rasmussen Reports national telephone survey.

Sixty percent (60%) of voters nationwide believe tax cuts help the economy, while 15% say they hurt and 14% say they have no impact.

Similarly, most Americans (58%) say tax increases hurt the economy, but 21% believe they help and 12% say they have no impact.

Again, there is a startling divide between Mainstream America and the Political Class. While 69% of Mainstream Americans say tax cuts are economically beneficial, the Political Class is evenly divided—33% say the tax cuts help while 36% say tax cuts are bad for the economy.

Seventy-four percent (74%) of Mainstream Americans say tax increases hurt the economy. Among the Political Class, only 19% share that view. In fact, 30% of the Political Class say tax hikes are actually good for the economy and 31% say they have no economic impact at all.

With these kinds of numbers, is there any doubt that the Political Class is our enemy? We should treat them as the hostile entity they are and take every opportunity to bring them down. Only then will we get reform in Washington.

Let’s get down to brass tacks here. How much for the ape?

 

Is the Political class defined as elected politicians?

larueladue (Diary) Wednesday, April 22nd at 5:00PM EST (link)

If so, that would explain why we are in the mess we are…..

 

Thanks for bringing this to our attention, Moe

brah Wednesday, April 22nd at 5:11PM EST (link)

As a graduate of both the Coast Guard Academy and Harvard, I can tell you that my education at the Coast Guard Academy was much more fulfilling and valuable.

Mr. Ricks comes to the conclusion that academy graduates get a “community college” level of education because many instructors at the service academies don’t have PhD’s. While this may be true (although I would estimate 50-75% of my professors at the Coast Guard Academy had PhD’s), what he fails to recognize is that these professors are there primarily to teach students. Not to conduct research and submit new grants and to build and run their labs and oh, by the way, teach a class or two, like at larger universities. So, yes, their CV’s may be less impressive, but I would argue their commitment to teaching is usually much greater. And when you’re at the undergraduate level, you don’t need the expert in their field teaching you, instead you need someone who can teach you the basics well and stays committed to your understanding. I spent many hours after class one-on-one with the professors at the Coast Guard Academy…not with a graduate student TA as would usually happen at larger universities.

(And all of this is not to take anything away from community colleges where many students get a great education.)

And as we all know (and Cadet Xin makes clear), the education received at the service academies goes far beyond that learned in the classroom.