It’s like he just won’t go away.
After the National Council for a New America (NCNA), led by Eric Cantor and other prominent conservatives, has undertaken an effort to listen and respond to the concerns of Americans disaffected with the GOP, they proceeded to get nearly every major player in the Republican Party to get on board with the undertaking.
Cantor’s in. McCain’s in. Palin’s in. Romney’s in. Barbour’s in. Jindal’s in.
Conspicuously absent, however, is one former Arkansas governor.
Former Governor Mike Huckabee, writing in a column of Foxnews.com, has not only turned down an invitation from the group to join in the discussion, but now seems openly hostile to the group.
“A new group was recently formed that is calling itself a group of experts for the purpose of making the Republican Party attractive to voters again,” the former Republican presidential candidate wrote in a column posted Monday on the Fox News website. “The strategy is supposedly to go on a listening tour so they can talk to the American people and hear what people are concerned about.”
“It’s hard to keep from laughing out loud when people living in the bubble of the Beltway suddenly wake up one day and think they ought to have a listening tour; even funnier when their first earful expedition takes them all the way to the suburbs of Washington, D.C.”
So, what is it about the NCNA that has led Huckabee to deem its creation “a sad day in Republican politics”? Partly the fact that, of the five major policy areas being discussed, none of them are the primary hot-button issues of social politics – gay marriage, abortion, or immigration. Huckabee continued, saying “If the party elite want to abandon principled leadership to protect life, support traditional marriage while going along with deficit exploding spending, interference and micro-managing of private business and failing to police corruption and govern competently, then hearing aids or a panel of experts won’t help.”
While a principled argument, people like Palin, Cantor, and Jindal are hardly “party elite”. If anything, they are anathema to much of the party elite, people like the Rockefeller Republicans in the beltway who are more concerned about getting along with others in hopes of cutting a deal than to either lead with principle or to represent the concerns of their constituents. While a listening tour may not be the solution to all of the GOP’s ills, the open hostility to it seems to indicate that Gov. Huckabee’s priorities lie elsewhere.
My personal take is that, while social issues are important to a large amount of the Republican Party base, they also aren’t necessarily the issues that will allow the party to attract new voters in the coming years, for the main reason that people tend to be quite recalcitrant about their positions on those issues; either they’re with you or they’re not.
But giving up the ghost on them isn’t what is needed, either; what appears to be called for in this difficult electoral climate is to get out on point and say “We are Republicans. We aren’t supporters of the profligate spending of the past or present, be it the Bush administration’s or the Obama administration’s. We are in favor of government easing its iron grip on your pocketbook as well as over your daily life. We don’t want to see the government picking winners and losers in business based on who the leadership’s friends are. We support your ability to live without interference from forces domestic or abroad. And, in addition, we support traditional American values on the grounds that our Christian upbringing and respect for tradition and the rule of law will bring the same degree of discipline and principle to our leadership.”
Hopefully what we see going forward will allow us to come together based on what unites us, rather than letting us divide ourselves based on what we’d like to see in addition.
Neil Stevens
Steve Maley
mikefisk- you really have to be kidding me, right!
Scope (Diary) Tuesday, May 12th at 7:43PM EST (link)This diary has so many problems, I don’t know where to start. For example, Cantor could in any way be considered a fiscal Conservative???????? He voted for TARP, he voted for the 90% tax on Bonuses, and it goes on an on. Apparently you aren’t from Virginia, nor have you read much on who has been voting which way. On our local radio station this morning, hosted by Joe Thomas, who is not a die hard, brought up a letter that Cantor co-signed, where he said that the government is here to help small businesses, with GOVERNMENT HELP! Where are you coming from???? Cantor is not a Conservative, period.
Nobody's completely clean on our side...
mikefisk (Diary) Tuesday, May 12th at 10:24PM EST (link)…the difference is who is trying to do something and who is making fun of those who do.
That aside, TARP, as it was originally outlined by the Treasury Department, should not have been much of an issue at all. It was only a few months into the game that the rules changed to turn the program into a gigantic financial black hole (if managed properly, the original plan may have ultimately turned a net profit for the government!). I can’t really fault that, although the tax on the AIG bonuses is rather curious. Possibly bad political instincts (which would make him indistinguishable from most politicians)?
It sounds like your logic is meeting the same issue that Huckabee’s has, in my opinion… letting the perfect be the enemy of the good. Sure, Cantor isn’t perfect, or even close. But I’d rather have him be purportedly working in the same direction as us than being vociferously opposed to those who try because they aren’t trying in the way that they’d like.
“Once within the maw of Leviathan, degree of digestion is irrelevant.” – Michael Fisk
9.25, -4.77
This isn't about social issues with Huck, primarily. Its about
Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Tuesday, May 12th at 11:31PM EST (link)the fact that we shouldn’t have to listen now. We should have been listening and learning before now and should be ready to lead now against the Obamanation, now.
Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson
That being said, what can it hurt?
mikefisk (Diary) Tuesday, May 12th at 11:50PM EST (link)I agree completely with what you’re saying, although I wonder what the point of denigrating a positive step forward is.
Point taken, though… I’d rather see somebody start taking point and putting forward a coherent plan, and the sooner the better. I almost feel like some of these leaders are trying to be “too clever by half” in trying to pose as the “loyal opposition” in search of a better opening… one that may or may not materialize before 2010 or 2012.
But to take potshots doesn’t seem to be a good way to go forward, either. As much as I’d love to fire both barrels into Huckabee on this issue (considering he’s becoming a personal nemesis of mine), I can’t; I don’t think he’s wrong for what he’s doing, just being counter-productive.
“Once within the maw of Leviathan, degree of digestion is irrelevant.” – Michael Fisk
9.25, -4.77
Cantor is still way more conservative that Huckabee ever was or ever will be...
Aaron Gardner (Diary) Wednesday, May 13th at 10:55AM EST (link)Cantor has a 96.25% ACU Rating over 8 years. Huckabee was a progressive taxer who is now trying to play like he is the conservative choice…when in reality he is nothing more than a glam queen…just another Geraldo on FOX….charlatan.
conform and celebrate diversity….or else!!!
“We’d be much better off if We The People had desired small government enough to keep it.” acat
Follow @Aaron_RS
I can appreciate Huckabee's snark because....
JadedByPolitics (Diary) Tuesday, May 12th at 11:21PM EST (link)they are so insulated that they have to have a listening tour? come on WE ALL know what the problems are BIG GOVERNMENT!!! and to not talk about abortion, illegal immigration or gay marriage is just downright silly…all of those issue’s can be defined quite quickly with a we believe that they should be handled by the States and we believe that illegal immigration is something states should handle individually with the backing and full faith of the government ie: funding and holding to current law!
I don’t like Huckabee NEVER have but I again get his snark on this stupid venture….start getting in front of the camera and SAY WHAT YOU MEAN and people will follow BUT to get a “feel” for where people are just makes you as bad as the Democrats….I want some LEADERS who walk their talk PERIOD!
Unified Patriots – How-To:
Activists Taking Action
Huckabee's just the next Arlen Specter or John McCain
Neil Stevens (Diary) Wednesday, May 13th at 7:05AM EST (link)It’s All About Him™.
He *despises* conservatives, which is why he joins Specter and McCain in trashing Club for Growth, a group that challenges ‘moderates’ in primaries.
So let him rant. We know what he’s really like.
RS contributing editor, technical administrator, and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules
Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.
“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder
Huckabee doesn't have any of their
mbecker908 (Diary) Wednesday, May 13th at 8:41AM EST (link)good qualities.
Huckabee knows he is in a bad position for 2012 and he's desperate to change the game somehow
red_oakster (Diary) Wednesday, May 13th at 9:58AM EST (link)The guy has a low ceiling of growth. At best, he will be the mop with which the eventual nominee cleans up during the primaries. He already has seen some of his social conservative supporters drift towards Palin. And if a Jindal or a Sanford get in, he’ll lose a few more points. He is feeling what Kerry and Edwards experienced in 07-08: the political world has moved on to other candidates.
He’s out of power and lacks a platform; he is mistrusted by economic and foreign policy conservatives, and competitors are chipping away at his base of social conservative support.
He looks like a loser from here.
well he has a platform
kyle8 (Diary) Wednesday, May 13th at 10:51AM EST (link)he has a weekly series on Fox after all.
But the thing he cannot change is that he is just not genuine.
(even less so than most politicians)
“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle
Huckabee is the next W
TxCon (Diary) Wednesday, May 13th at 10:02AM EST (link)A big government, social conservative. PASS
What's the difference between Ron Paul and the Huckster...
Diogenes314 (Diary) Wednesday, May 13th at 10:29AM EST (link)The Huckster reminds me of a joke I heard…
“The difference between Hitler and my ex-girlfriend?
At least Hitler had the decency to let you know he was insane right from the start.”
Good diary MikeFisk...reco'd.....nt
Aaron Gardner (Diary) Wednesday, May 13th at 11:04AM EST (link)conform and celebrate diversity….or else!!!
“We’d be much better off if We The People had desired small government enough to keep it.” acat
Follow @Aaron_RS