McCain Being McCain


Tonight’s speech was not the stick of dynamite that last night’s speech by Sarah Palin was. It was not supposed to be. It accomplished everything it set out to accomplish. It established McCain’s personal story of heroism, but above that, it put that story in the context of his vision for the entire country. His delivery dragged and was a bit awkward at points – McCain has never been the greatest orator, but he oddly turned that into a strength by appearing almost painfully humble throughout the speech.

McCain’s message was simple: everything he does is motivated by service to his country, not himself. It was a message he hit on repeatedly, and delivered more effectively than any of the speakers earlier in the evening (who were, quite frankly, horribly droll). He talked passionately about a number of topics, including education, Iraq, and energy, but his mission tonight was clear: to rebuild the Republican brand that has been hurt by corruption and spending by emphasizing his willingness to put his country above himself.

It was an effective message. It was a necessary message. And for whatever disagreements we may have here at RedState with McCain (and they are many), we must confess that McCain alone among the candidates this year has put himself uniquely in the position to speak with authority on this issue. Let us be clear: no other candidate we have could have given this necessary speech tonight and made it stick.

McCain’s speech may not have played as well in the hall and on RedState as Palin’s speech. But I think, by and large, that it may have gone as well or better with the voters on TV, particularly the strong ending, for those who stuck around to watch.

Now, with the end of the convention, the race has truly begun. John McCain and Sarah Palin head out on the campaign trail tomorrow. They go having made their point to the American people in the best way possible. If they have returned the race to the status quo ante the Democratic Convention, this will have ultimately been a success.


Category: ,

RSS feed

14 Comments Leave a comment

Commordores are better than Gamecocks. I know.

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 11:14PM EST (link)

I watched the game.

Let McCain be McCain until Palin takes over.

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

 

Leon

Commodore Thursday, September 4th at 11:21PM EST (link)

Will Gamecock show his face here after our Dores embarassed his team?

oops

Commodore Thursday, September 4th at 11:22PM EST (link)

speak of the devil

I thought about adding a note

Leon H. Wolf (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 11:23PM EST (link)

But I thought maybe this might not have been the piece.

I give gamecock credit, he shows up to eat his crow like a man!

————
We can’t stop here. This is bat country.

 
 
 

It's so strange...

kowalski (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 11:30PM EST (link)

I had just the opposite impression of the speech, because I deliberately turned off the computer at about 9:30 and watched the speech itself, the old fashioned way, with no attempt made to blog it, live or otherwise.

I really enjoyed it. I even enjoyed the way he handled the protestors. I decided this time to sit back and let the speech talk to me instead of my trying to engage in some kind of a running dialogue with it.

I was really pleased by almost everything he had to say, I thought it was substantive and moving. The end was absolutely electrifying and I was choked up there and at several times during his biography.

I don’t know what it says about me, but McCain brought me around tonight. I didn’t read the liveblog comments but I take it it got a lukewarm reception? I had just the opposite take:

After hearing the speech I really want to work to help John McCain succeed, and help America succeed. I think he articulated a vision of what America needs to do together beautifully.

The internet isn’t all it’s cracked up to be. I was glad I didn’t liveblog it, I was much more pensive and attentive just watching him speak this time. I found after the speech that I was less cynical about politics and America, and I’m more convinced now that there’s much more work to be done in “the real world” than there is online. Along with Palin, McCain has inspired me, but the Internet isn’t where I want to do most of the work: I accepted his call tonight, his speech made me a believer in the man, he made me want to make America more of the place he described so well. I was truly inspired by his words about believing in a calling larger than ourselves; it resonated with me.

A bit of a different reaction than people had here, I gather. I’m beginning to think — no swipe or offense to anyone present — that the internet isn’t where it’s at when it comes to fulfilling a higher purpose. It’s going to be the actions in the real world that matter.

 

He finished strong...

zuiko (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 11:31PM EST (link)

But halfway through I had the feeling I was listening to a Bill Clinton State of the Union address. I definitely could have lived without all the “I feel your pain and here is what the government is going to spend money on to make you feel better” moments.

Underlying most arguments against the free market is a lack of belief in freedom itself. – Milton Friedman

 

My main thought...

Matthew Morris (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 11:35PM EST (link)

My main thought was, if he was going to go ahead and say those McCain-ish things to appeal to the Democrats, independents, and I guess the “disaffected”- he should have gone ahead and talked a little bit more about the things that will appeal to them. A little more emphasis and a little more policy detail on some of “their” issues. If you are going to sock-it to the Republicans, you might as well close the deal by talking about what they want to hear about.

Although I must say, they should have liked all the talk about training for the jobs of tomorrow that will last “forever” after losing a job that isn’t coming back, not never.


“I AM WHO I AM”; and He said, “Thus you shall say to the sons of Israel, ‘I AM has sent me to you.’”

Ipsum esse subsistens

I second the sentiments of the honorable Kowalski

RedFox84 Thursday, September 4th at 11:39PM EST (link)

It’s a thought that’s been going on in my head for quite some time as well.

John McCain’s call was very stirring and I pray it moves some people. It is a call to service on par with JFK’s “Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country,” except better because it is addressed to me and my generation, not the grainy old black-and-white world.

All of which is a very marked difference from Barack Obama who doesn’t call on you to do anything, except vote for him in order to redeem your soul and “prove” you’re not a racist.

 
 

The ending was great

bk (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 11:45PM EST (link)

He obviously struggled here and there with the TelePrompTer, but we pretty much expected that. He did pretty decently in general. I heard one of the talking heads say that he seems more comfortable talking about others than about himself. That may be true.

Me also kowalski

Matthew Morris (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 11:51PM EST (link)

I have to say, one of the other main thoughts I came away with after watching the speech in a similarly unplugged fashion is that:

Man, this guy really did go through a lot. Thanks for reminding me. In fact, These themes resonating here over the last few days about service and sacrifice, and how much this is embodied in McCain’s story, in his life- maybe these themes and experiences really are at the root of all those things he has done over the years that make me scratch my head. Maybe I needn’t question his ultimate motives any longer, when the maverick tendencies come to life. Maybe now -in the 4 years ahead- When President McCain is a’ maverick’n and i may wish to scratch my head- I can now find rest in the fact that he is doing it with a servant’s heart.


“I AM WHO I AM”; and He said, “Thus you shall say to the sons of Israel, ‘I AM has sent me to you.’”

Ipsum esse subsistens

Look, let's be honest

kowalski (Diary) Friday, September 5th at 12:14AM EST (link)

John McCain isn’t and wasn’t the blogosphere’s Mr. Congeniality historically. Also there’s a generational difference there: I think he’s trying to connect with the non-wired (or not primarily wired) people in the country as well.

And frankly, having been around on the internet (and its precursors) since before “back in the day” was a pop-culture term, I’ve got a certain weariness of it that comes from knowing it a little too well.

I needed a break, and I decided I’d listen to John McCain more on his own terms tonight, and do it the old-fashioned way. And I found that by shifting out of my internet-centric mindset for a couple of hours, the speech was really good, and I enjoyed watching and listening to it the old-fashioned way. I felt more in touch with McCain tonight than I have since he started the campaign, and I feel a lot better about him winning the primary campaign.

Of course, I’ll blog about it tomorrow some more. Everyone knows that I’m addicted, that’s not going to change. But there will be a shift in emphasis, I think. I feel like I got what he was trying to say, and I appreciated it.

And the end was really something that I want to find a clip of and keep as a motivational reminder. I had the chills and the tingles and the tears in the corners of the eyes and he got to me there. I felt genuinely good about his Presidency, and optimistic, and hopeful for our country, and I was reminded of the reasons why I’m proud to be an American.

Who knew you didn’t need a liveblog to do that? ;)

Me three, kowalski.

CincoSolas_del_Bronx (Diary) Friday, September 5th at 12:15AM EST (link)

Sincere thanks for sharing your reactions, which I shared while watching con la esposa y las niñas (el niño was, alas, asleep–but he can’t vote until January…).

The internet, including this well-run site, can be a great source of immediate information and commentary of varying degrees of substance, but it most assuredly is not friendly to substantive dialogue “in the real world”.

And I am assured that a significant number of people in that very real world saw and heard a very real man tonight and know more strongly than they did earlier that he is ready to lead their, that is our, nation.

Those dreading urbanization should remember that though the Kingdom of God first appeared in a temporal Garden, at the end of the book it is established in an eternal City. (paraphrase, James M. Boice)

soli Deo gloria

I agree, Mr. Kowalski.

Rod_Patrick (Diary) Friday, September 5th at 12:19AM EST (link)

Protestors-

Chief_Runamok (Diary) Friday, September 5th at 7:50AM EST (link)

I hope you respect that some of still dare the concept told to us in second grade that there is no such thing as a ‘stupid’ question. Consider that if you answer.

What is up with the “pink shirts?”