National Security Adviser Jones: Jews Are Greedy Merchants


As the National Security Adviser, General James Jones is not known as a friend of the Jewish State. It was Jones who put together the team of Brent Scowcroft and Zbigniew Brzezinski to meet with the President and advise him to impose a solution on Israel.

Earlier this week we may have gotten some insight into why Jones is not a fan of the Jewish Homeland. He was giving the key note speech at a Washington Institute For Near East Policy and started it out with a “Joke” that borders on anti-Semitic, teaching the crowd that Jews are just greedy merchants in the same vein as Shakespeare’s Shylock:

A Taliban militant gets lost and is wandering around the desert looking for water. He finally arrives at a store run by a Jew and asks for water. The Jewish vendor tells him he doesn’t have any water but can gladly sell him a tie. The Taliban, the jokes goes on, begins to curse and yell at the Jewish storeowner. The Jew, unmoved, offers the rude militant an idea: Beyond the hill, there is a restaurant; they can sell you water. The Taliban keeps cursing and finally leaves toward the hill. An hour later he’s back at the tie store. He walks in and tells the merchant: “Your brother tells me I need a tie to get into the restaurant.

According to the Jewish Forward

After the speech, two participants suggested, in private conversations with the Forward, that Jones’ joke might have been inappropriate. After all, making jokes about greedy Jewish merchants can be seen at times as insensitive.

A prominent think-tank source who attended the event said the joke was “wrong in so many levels” and that it “demonstrated a lack of sensitivity.” The source also asked: “Can you imagine him telling a black joke at an event of African Americans?”

Was the Joke Anti-Semitic? Well, the White House must have thought so.

The White House transcript sent to reporters after the event conveniently began a couple of minutes into the speech. The video of the event posted on the Washington Institute Web site started right after the joke, you can even hear the end of the laughter.

At the very least it was an idiotic time and place to make the joke. Many of the attendees of The Washington Institute dinner were in fact Jewish. And the Jewish community is very nervous about the recent anti-Israel leanings of the Obama administration.

Its interesting that the same President that sees racism in the legitimate actions of the Cambridge Police and the State of Arizona, hides the anti-Semitic prose of its National Security Adviser.

I found the uncut video but couldn’t download it. So I contacted my friends at Breitbart and thanks to the folks at Breitbart TV, I was able to get my hands on the video of Jones’ comic delivery (if you cant see video below click here)

.

UPDATE: Tommy Christopher of Mediaite Points out that the reason the White House didn’t have the “Joke” in its official transcript is that they issued his remarks as “prepared for delivery” in other words he thought it was simply an  “ad-lib” gone bad

Jake Tapper reports that Abe Foxman felt the joke was inappropriate.

While many in the largely Jewish audience laughed, others didn’t find it so funny, including Abraham Foxman, national director of the Anti-Defamation League of B’nai B’rith.

“It’s inappropriate,” Foxman told ABC News. “it’s stereotypic. Some people believe they need to start a speech with a joke; this was about the worst kind of joke the head of the National Security Council could have told.”

UPDATE II: Jones issued a statement of apology :

I wish that I had not made this off the cuff joke at the top of my remarks, and I apologize to anyone who was offended by it. It also distracted from the larger message I carried that day: that the United States commitment to Israel’s security is sacrosanct.

At Today’s White House briefing spokesman Robert Gibbs said there “no intention to deceive” in leaving the remarks off a transcript off the event, which, as pointed out by Tommy Christopher above, was the prepared text not “as delivered.” Christopher was at the breifing and filed this report.

I have been asked over and over, “was Jones’ statement anti-Semitic?”  I can’t answer that without looking into his heart. It did use old stereotypes of Jews, as many in the Administration have used before, the most common of which is the “Jewish Lobby controls foreign policy” canard invoked by National Security Council member Samantha Power.

The NSA’s joke was at best, an insensitive remark made by a National Security Adviser who has no understanding of the “emotions” behind the Middle East Conflict, working for a President that takes existing international friendships for granted.

For more writing by Jeff Dunetz, Click Here and go to his blog THE LID


Category: ,

RSS feed

41 Comments Leave a comment

It is truly hilarious how the LIE that all Jews are rich...

JadedByPolitics (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 8:23AM EST (link)

continues unabated to this day! I worked with a very sweet young lady who was pinching her pennies to get married a few years back and she and her fiancee were paying for that wedding because their parents didn’t have the kind of money it took for the wedding she wanted :) and YES both sets of parents were Jewish! So quite like the REST OF US there are rich and poor and middle class, Jews are NOT aliens they are humans and they live and die the same way the rest of US do!

 

It will be a tragedy for America if anti-Semitism rears....

penguin2 (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 8:51AM EST (link)

its ugly head here. I believe it exists and I believe that there is more than one official in Obama’s administration who has it. Strange how there isn’t any political correctness when it comes to jokes about the Christian and Jewish people of this nation. Though, if a Republican administrative official had said such a thing, they would have hounded him out of office.

People need to be aware and concerned about these seeds…..

Resistance to tyrants is obedience to God. – Benjamin Franklin
When Good stands up to Evil, Evil blinks. – Vassar Bushmills

Conservative Education: Suggested Reading List

Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

When oh when oh when

cactusjack Monday, April 26th at 9:18AM EST (link)

will conservative Jews (both politically and denominationally speaking) in the US start voting conservative Republican? Even 30% defection from “D” would equate to about a 1% swing in a national election, something we can use. I am not Jewish, but note to my Jewish friends out there: Obama is not your friend. Harry Truman was great but he and the party he was part of, are long, long gone. Vote survival for Israel, not “tradition.” (Frustrated rant over.)

There aren't that many Jews in the United States

ammianusmarcellinus (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 12:09PM EST (link)

Between 5 or 6 million, which is only around 2 percent of the population. And, if exit polls are to be believed, McCain got 25% of the Jewish vote, which was actually the highwater mark for recent Republican nominees.

http://pewresearch.org/pubs/1022/exit-poll-analysis-religion

Given a 20 percent floor of the Jewish vote, I’m not sure how Rs will make any large gains in a national campaign with this largely urban/socially liberal demographic. We might get protest votes from some who are fed up with President Obama’s foreign policy . . .

I’m not sure George is wrong about automobiles. With all their speed forward they may be a step backward in civilization. May be that they won’t add to the beauty of the world or the life of the men’s souls. ~ The Magnificent Ambersons

Misread my own chart

ammianusmarcellinus (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 12:15PM EST (link)

Bush got 25 percent, McCain got 21. If our 2012 nominee gets 30/35 percent, thats still a shift of only a few hundred thousand votes, probably in states (NY and CA) we will only win if the election is a landslide.

I’m not sure George is wrong about automobiles. With all their speed forward they may be a step backward in civilization. May be that they won’t add to the beauty of the world or the life of the men’s souls. ~ The Magnificent Ambersons

 
 
 
 

More heh heh than offensive

freeebird (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 10:05AM EST (link)

I mean, if you’re conditioned to be hypersensitive to this sort of thing, ok, you could say the joke was built around the “greedy Jew” stereotype. If that were the case though, then it wouldn’t work if you removed the Jewish detail from it. Replaying it in my head, I think it works just fine if you remove the Jewish detail from it.

Also known as freeebird / DontBanMeBro / mallcopsaysno; registering multiple accounts is my rather sad, pathetic hobby.

Yeah... just a joke --- it's not as if it's a cartoon! nt

mikerazar (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 10:18AM EST (link)

We have a nation to save, people.

 

Idiot. Most ethnic/class based jokes work.

Tbone (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 10:19AM EST (link)

You just change the ethnicity/class of the players depending who you want to insult.

As in ,”I bet you thought you were the best door-to-door salesman ever…. when you were working for Domino’s.”

Just switch out the “you” and “replay it in your head”.

Envisioning when all that is Left is the Right.

 

Ping. [nt]

Moe Lane (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 10:20AM EST (link)

Annnnnd... HI, freeebird / DontBanMeBro / mallcopsaysno!

Moe Lane (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 10:25AM EST (link)

Can’t quit us, huh?

 

It Is Repulsive And Unacceptable

jaybo (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 10:50AM EST (link)

There is no place in our Federal Government for this kind of commentary. Gen. Jones needs to resign or be fired.

This is the kind of “subtle bigotry” that slowly dehumanizes a group of people so that it will eventually be acceptable to persecute.

You're forgetting modern media Reality here...

cactusjack Monday, April 26th at 10:56AM EST (link)

if Jones were speaking on behalf of a Republican administration, his forced resignation would be happening this morning. But since it’s a Democrat administration in power, this offense will just skate by, just like Hillary’s joke about convenience store owners a few years back.

Actually it was Ghandi...

sccrenny (Diary) Tuesday, April 27th at 9:03PM EST (link)

it was wrinkle-footed Joe (Biden) who joked about convenience store owners.

When I look at Barack Obama I don’t see black. I don’t see white. I do, however see RED! It’s the same color I see when I look at Pelosi, Reid, ACORN, SEIU…

Precinct Delegate since 2010

 
 
 
 

Video Now Playing On Glenn Beck

jaybo (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 10:53AM EST (link)

It will now finally see the light of day. The most shocking part of the video is the laughter from the crowd.

Shameful.

 

Sorry, Jeff, but I don't see it, at least here.

saltlick Monday, April 26th at 10:54AM EST (link)

I DO believe Obama hates Jews in general (“but you’re a good Jew, Rahm”), but I don’t hear anti-Semitism in Jones’ remark. In fact, that’s the kind of story I’ve heard Jewish, Armenian, Indian etc, etc, merchants tell about themselves as an example of how the hated “Other” survives through superior wit in a hostile culture.

I experienced true anti-Semitism some years ago when a long-time friend — an apparently cultured Portuguese professor — erupted into a vitriolic tirade against Israel. It was like that scene in “Lord of the Rings” where the Elfin queen or Bilbo transform for an instant into raging evil. It physically sickened me and the friendship ended.

Hmmm, No I think it's definitely anti-Semitic

WarEagle01 (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 11:42AM EST (link)

I think NSA Jones is just too stupid to realize it’s anti-Semitic, which is itself kinda scary.

“A wise, doughy leg with rich tingly experiences will always reach better conclusions than will a more tanned, muscular leg that hasn’t felt those thrills.” –Chris Matthews’ Leg

“The alternative to the awful extremity of abortion is the indispensable joy of introducing this flawed world to someone who might make it better.”–John Hayward (AKA Dr. Zero)

The worst kind of anti-anything or anti-anybody

davesinsanantonio (Diary) Tuesday, April 27th at 5:51AM EST (link)

is the kind that is so subtle that you cannot instantly recognize it and be revolted by it. If it perpetuates stereotypes it is anti, because it perpetuates stereotypes. You may not be directly offended by it, but haters will just nod their heads and think, “Yeah, that’s just like those dirty (insert slur for the targeted group here”). It is not so much the “joke” as it is the underlying message that “hey, I’m not one of THEM, I’m on YOUR side.” The haters will understand the message, and that is what is despicable in this administration, or any other that fosters such divisions in America.

 
 

Saltlick, Study German History

jaybo (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 11:46AM EST (link)

The Holocaust in Germany was the result of a long sustained process that slowly but surely dehumanized the Jewish people. It started out by making jokes like this popular. If Gen. Jones was Jewish, it might be acceptable. Further, the very nature of a joke is that there is always some truth in it. Therefore if you think that it is funny, it means that you agree that there are greedy manipulative Jewish merchants. Try that same joke by inserting no one specific race or ethnic group and see if it is funny at all.

 
 

If you've been inside college classrooms since the '70s

Achance (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 11:11AM EST (link)

you were fed a steady diet of if not anti-Israel, at least pro-”Palestinian” dogma. Yassir Arafat was a hero of the Left. Even the killing of the Israeli Olympians could be “understood.” And, of course, the poor “Palistinians” should have the land back that the militaristic Israelis took from them.

The hard left in America has always opposed Israel because their Soviet masters opposed ist creation and in the main supported the Muslims and provided their arms and munitions.

In Vino Veritas

 

Congrats, Jeff Dunetz! You're linked on Powerline.com

janis (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 11:40AM EST (link)

and they congratulate you for putting up the video. What to go!

 

This is explosive. Great work bringing it to light. nt

redneck_hippie (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 11:48AM EST (link)

Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

 

still funny without the pain?

momma Monday, April 26th at 12:50PM EST (link)

Try this version:

A Taliban militant gets lost and is wandering around the desert looking for water. He finally arrives at a store and asks the store owner for water. The vendor tells him he doesn’t have any water but can gladly sell him a tie. The Taliban, the jokes goes on, begins to curse and yell at the store owner. The vendor, unmoved, offers the rude militant an idea: Beyond the hill, there is a restaurant; they can sell you water. The Taliban keeps cursing and finally leaves toward the hill. An hour later he’s back at the tie store. He walks in and tells the merchant: “Your brother tells me I need a tie to get into the restaurant.”

Exactly, it's not funny

Neil Stevens (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 3:23PM EST (link)

The whole point of the “joke” is the bigotry against Jews.

Taking that away makes it clear there’s no humor there.

RS contributing editor, technical administrator, and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules

Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.

“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder

 
 

Lighten up

thicklugpaddy Monday, April 26th at 3:17PM EST (link)

people. The Jews I know would’nt find this offensive.Im an American of Irish desent. If I see one more cap wearing, wife beatin, whiskey swillin, crooked cop Irishman a la Hollywood I’ll…….. see him again,20 times over. You can’t imagine how the Irish were stereotyped when the first showed up here in large numbers in the 1840′s. But you don’t have to imagine; you can read it in the archivesof NY Times.Apes, pigs,Celtic savages(my favorite).So don’t worry the Jews can take it.I know it because I grew up with some tough Jews.
Shalom.

G'bye (nt)

Neil Stevens (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 3:18PM EST (link)

RS contributing editor, technical administrator, and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules

Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.

“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder

 
 

Origin of the joke (Jan Murray, 1978)

barrypopik (Diary) Monday, April 26th at 11:28PM EST (link)

The joke appears to have originated from Jewish “Borscht Belt” comedian Jan Murray in 1978.

The real question is, why is the National Security Advisor telling old, lame jokes on the record?

 

Overreaction

mikejd Tuesday, April 27th at 6:02AM EST (link)

Honestly, it seems like some of us are just sitting around looking to be outrageously outraged. The joke may have been unwise in that setting, especially if Jones doesn’t have the nuts to say “Muslim” or “Arab”. We are not keeping out eye on the ball if everyone is going to get their panties in a twist over this “joke”.

Let’s start proposing and pushing real policies and stop whining on the Internet. If we sit around looking to be offended, then we are no better than the liberals.

*** I would have preferred to hear Don Rickles tell it… and no… you do not have to be a in a protected class to tell this joke.

The real joke here is MSM

mdd1956 Tuesday, April 27th at 9:11AM EST (link)

We are talking about it on the internet because that is how we communicate broadly to our constituents.

The hypocrisy of how the left gets away with this kind of thing in the MSM is one thing……

The absolute STUNNING HYPOCRISY of the left getting a pass in the media while painting conservatives as mean, bigoted & racist for any number of common sense policies we support is the story we must tell.

( who said of regular Americans ‘they cling to their guns and religion” ?)

 

Try to imagine the reaction on the other side if ...

Martin Knight (Diary) Tuesday, April 27th at 10:09AM EST (link)

… Jones had been a high-ranking member of a Republican Administration. Every single Beltway newspaper and television show would have led off with it for the next two weeks and by weeks’ end somehow we’ll have people claiming that the joke uncovered a GOP plan to stick Jews in concentration camps and fire the ovens.

Whatever Jones’ motivation, I couldn’t possibly care less. Considering that Tea Partiers are every day being attacked as racists for incidents that never happened, sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander …

 
 

Jones Should Not Have Told the Joke

wjbryan96 (Diary) Tuesday, April 27th at 7:30AM EST (link)

especially in that setting. But I do not agree with the characterizations of the joke as “hate” or as “anti-semitism”. I watched Jones “monologue” and delivery of the joke in its entirety, so I am not just reacting to what others said Jones said.

 

It was a good joke.

tallcharlie Tuesday, April 27th at 7:55AM EST (link)

Anyone that is complaining about this joke has his head up his too sensitive butt.

The joke was funny, it denigrated no one, it had a great punchline.

Abraham Foxman, national director of the Anti-Defamation League of B’nai B’rith, is sounding more like Al Sharpton the racist ambulance chaser than a serious Jewish scholar.

I intend to tell this joke at shul this weekend.

Well then you do that, and I will wonder how many....

penguin2 (Diary) Tuesday, April 27th at 9:00AM EST (link)

of your congregation sit there quietly and cringe. Be sure to let them know the source of the telling this week, that it was on a public in a forum that does not have Israel’s interests at heart.

You may be missing one of the main points about the story. First of all, when you tell a stereotypical “joke” about a group or race you are enabling and promoting the continuation of such derogatory myths. The National Security Adviser told a joke that does just that. I guess political correctness doesn’t bother you that it is not applied to Jews and Christians in this country.

Second of all, it was unseemly for an official of the United States government to engage in such behavior.

Third, the Anti-Defamation League of B’nai B’rith is looking out for the Jewish peoples’ interests; this is certainly a concern to them, and they have every right to speak out.

Resistance to tyrants is obedience to God. – Benjamin Franklin
When Good stands up to Evil, Evil blinks. – Vassar Bushmills

Conservative Education: Suggested Reading List

Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

 

But if it was a Republican it would be racist, eh?

Martin Knight (Diary) Tuesday, April 27th at 10:19AM EST (link)

It’s amazing how the painfully sensitive Left gets all un-PC when it’s one of their own that steps in it, isn’t it?

 

Funny for a private event

charles4 Tuesday, April 27th at 1:43PM EST (link)

Not funny for the National Security Advisor broadcast on C-Span.

 
 

And still they are mostly liberal.

miroco Tuesday, April 27th at 10:21AM EST (link)

I guess the phenomena is like the folks that get kidnapped. Still, I have never understood how a Jew can vote lib, drive a Mercedes, or support anybody but Netanyahu. As a Texan, we know nearly nothing about anti semitism but we sure do recognize it now that we see it everyday in the administration.

 

Anti-semitic or Pro Israel??

ramcclain Tuesday, April 27th at 11:34AM EST (link)

I, too, thought it anti-Semitic when I first saw it, and then on Facebook, comments from another very pro Israel friend, as am I, declared that it was in fact showing how stupid the Talliban is. I think that is a distinct possibility, although coming from Zero’s administration, it could also be the other way………..

 

Cover-up

superamerican (Diary) Tuesday, April 27th at 12:01PM EST (link)

Just another disgusting example of Obama’s idiocy in selection, Obama’s cover-up attitude and — although I haven’t looked at the left-wing media over this — it’ll be downplayed as all gaffes by liberals are from Obama’s propaganda arms.

http://www.periodictablet.com

Superamerican

 

Wow, Can you imagine using this joke at a work function?

charles4 Tuesday, April 27th at 1:38PM EST (link)

This guy should be fired just for being stupid. Too bad we can’t fire his boss for being stupid. I we were able to, we would end up with someone more stupid, Joe Biden.

 

Personally, I thought it was funny...

momofthecastle (Diary) Tuesday, April 27th at 6:23PM EST (link)

and I took it as the Jewish merchant getting back at the rude Taliban jerk. To which I say, good for him! After all, most Jews know that the Taliban wish them dead.
I think we have lost our sense of perspective in this country. And on this page, sad to say….

I, too thought...

sccrenny (Diary) Tuesday, April 27th at 9:18PM EST (link)

the idea of the joke was the cleverness of the Jewish brothers in making an idiot of the Taliban militant. I would think this would be more irksome to a jihadist than a Jew.

When I look at Barack Obama I don’t see black. I don’t see white. I do, however see RED! It’s the same color I see when I look at Pelosi, Reid, ACORN, SEIU…

Precinct Delegate since 2010

Kowalski

sccrenny (Diary) Tuesday, April 27th at 9:19PM EST (link)

That being said, the point is still valid that the lamestream media would have ridden a conservative out on a rail for telling it.

When I look at Barack Obama I don’t see black. I don’t see white. I do, however see RED! It’s the same color I see when I look at Pelosi, Reid, ACORN, SEIU…

Precinct Delegate since 2010