Obama Administration Covering Up Abortion Data *Updated*


What are they trying to hide?

image

Let’s be clear: promoting science isn’t just about providing resources – it is also about protecting free and open inquiry. It is about letting scientists … do their jobs, free from manipulation or coercion, and listening to what they tell us, even when it’s inconvenient – especially when it’s inconvenient. It is about ensuring that scientific data is never distorted or concealed to serve a political agenda – and that we make scientific decisions based on facts, not ideology.

-President Obama, March 9, 2009.

“The Obama Administration has apparently ordered that the only Federal government report on abortion statistics … be deep-sixed.

RedState has uncovered evidence – confirmed by the CDC’s own press office – that the Obama administration is deliberately playing “hide the ball” on nationwide abortion statistics. For apparently the first time in 40 years, the CDC’s annual “Abortion Surveillance Report” was not published, and there are “no plans” for the data to be produced at this time.

Whatever you feel about abortion and its legality, virtually all people agree that transparency and factual accuracy are important in the abortion debate. That is why even Planned Parenthood spends a substantial amount of money each year funding the Guttmacher Institute’s studies on abortion statistics. While pro-life groups have long contended that Guttmacher’s methods systematically undercount abortions, that is beside the point; the Guttmacher studies have long provided a consistent source for studying abortion trends over time. Which aggregate data, we re-emphasize, is important not only for both sides of the idealogical debate, but is also important medical information.

[Editorial Note: The Guttmacher Institute emailed that Planned Parenthood does not fund it. Planned Parenthood set up the Guttmacher Institute as its research arm and Guttmacher claims it is now independent of Planned Parenthood. Apparently, Planned Parenthood does not have to fund Guttmacher, because you and I do.]

Yet, in the wake of numerous damaging disclosures about unscrupulous practices by abortionists (from Kermit Gosnell to Planned Parenthood clinics across the country), the Obama Administration has apparently ordered that the only Federal government report on abortion statistics – again, a report that has run continuously for 40 years – be deep-sixed. The immediate question this raises is: what is the Obama administration trying to hide?

Here’s the background: Beginning in 1969 the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention collected data on legal abortions carried out in the United States through its Abortion Surveillance System. The report based on this data ordinarily appeared as an article in CDC’s professional journal, The Mortality and Morbidity Weekly Report (MMWR) the week after Thanksgiving. The report lagged the data by three years, i.e., the 2006 data were printed in 2009.

The report was produced by the cooperative efforts of the Guttmacher Institute and statisticians at the CDC.

The report has never been all-encompassing because collecting data on abortions is a state function, and not every state cooperates. In the 2006 reports, California, Louisiana, and New Hampshire did not provide data. Until 2005, Alaska and Oklahoma also declined to participate.

While not comprehensive, the CDC report provided the best single estimate of abortions in the US, as well as providing detailed breakdowns: the age of the baby at the time of abortion, age of the mother, number of abortions the mother had previous to the current one, etc. People on both sides of the abortion debate have cited these statistics to make their points. Here at RedState, we frequently posted articles on this report, examining the statistical trends on abortion. We were particularly interested in this year’s report in light of the widely publicized stories indicating that over 40% of pregnancies in New York City are ended by abortion.

Last year, contrary to the long-established practice, November came and went with no report posted on the CDC’s website. Over the following weeks, multiple visits to the site proved fruitless. The possibility the report was not merely delayed, but had in fact been axed from higher up, had to be considered.

Last week, RedState began investigating by calling those in DC who might have some answers. After several attempts, we finally received confirmation from Rhonda Smith at the CDC’s press office in Atlanta that the report has been buried indefinitely; the CDC “will not have stats available at any time in the near future” and there “are no plans for them to come out any time soon.” This call took place on Jan. 27th, and we asked Ms. Smith for a reason that the report wouldn’t be issued anymore. She promised to check around and find out if there was any reason given and get back to us – as of the date of this posting, we have received no further communication from her office.

This revelation is nothing short of shocking. Most of the leg work for this study is actually done by Guttmacher – all it costs the CDC is some manpower to assemble the statistics and write up the report. In the overall scope of the CDC’s budget, this report barely even registers. So what is the CDC trying to hide? The only reasonable conclusion to be drawn here is that someone higher up has made the decision to actively eliminate the only official report on abortion statistics in the country, just because they don’t want abortion being talked about.

This action is indefensible and contrary to the Obama administration’s repeated promises of transparency and the removal of politics from accurate scientific reporting. And it is more damning than any report: it reflects the reality that the Obama Administration is afraid of the truth, afraid that the American people cannot be trusted to support legal abortion if they look closely at the facts.

Suppression of this nature doesn’t have to stand. A senate aide tells RedState that if the administration or the CDC are stonewalling on this, “Congress would have a range of options to force them to disclose this information including hearings, letters and floor amendments.”

We urge Congress to investigate this apparent cover-up. Transparency and consistency are not a partisan issue. The CDC report is objective statistical data that should be produced regardless of any potential political implications.

UPDATE: Congresswoman Vicky Hartzler (MO-4) has provided RedState with the following statement:

“This is the epitome of hypocrisy being exhibited by the Obama Administration as it hides facts and figures on abortion while claiming to want more transparency in government. This is a pattern that has become all too common with the Obama Administration, ranging from its distortion of the facts on taxpayer funding of abortions under ObamaCare to manipulated information to support repeal of the military’s Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell policy. It is time for the Obama White House to put a stop to its disregard for openness in government and to end its practice of distorting data for blatantly political purposes.”


Category: , ,

RSS feed

26 Comments Leave a comment

2012 campaign ad:

luvnthebigsites (Diary) Thursday, February 3rd at 3:15PM EST (link)

30 sec walk through of the Gosnell horror clinic, with Barry and a “transparency” sound bite, closing with abortion stat data not released for the first time in 40 years… Fade to black.

“Ask not what your candidate can do for you, but what you can do for your candidate”. Andrew Breitbart CPAC 2012.

Bingo. I hope someone really does produce that campaign ad, luvn.

heartlander (Diary) Thursday, February 3rd at 4:19PM EST (link)

“The still, small voice of God in every human soul is the greatest ally of the pro-life cause, and why it will ultimately prevail.”
–Donald R. McClarey

/salute heartlander.

luvnthebigsites (Diary) Thursday, February 3rd at 5:09PM EST (link)

The administration provides us with material for one or two ad’s a week, Maybe we should pool our ideas and submit them around election time… Saturday morning Toby Toons style, Just a thought. ;-)

“Ask not what your candidate can do for you, but what you can do for your candidate”. Andrew Breitbart CPAC 2012.

 
 
 

this is intolerable...

soopermexican Thursday, February 3rd at 3:20PM EST (link)

“I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just; that his justice cannot sleep”

 

Why Would CDC Track It?

Repair_Man_Jack (Diary) Thursday, February 3rd at 4:05PM EST (link)

We know the fatality rate is very close to 100%. Safe, legal, and commonplace. That’s exactly what Bill Clinton said.

Mr. Obama is pretending that an economic “recovery” is underway when he knows damn well that the banking system is just blowing smoke up the shredded *** of what’s left of that economy – James Howard Kunstler

 

Thank you for the heads-up, Erick!

heartlander (Diary) Thursday, February 3rd at 4:22PM EST (link)

That flashing red light sure got my attention!

I just emailed my Congressman and both senators about it.

By the way, I assume that everyone here remembers that warping the practice of science for political reasons was one of the hallmarks of the old Soviet Union….

“The still, small voice of God in every human soul is the greatest ally of the pro-life cause, and why it will ultimately prevail.”
–Donald R. McClarey

 

Maybe its part of that truce I've been hearing about?

jerry39 (Diary) Thursday, February 3rd at 5:16PM EST (link)

We agree to pretend like we arent killing babies anymore and they agree not to remind us that we are.

Sounds reasonable doesnt it?

Anyone who can still cry "Truce!" after what came to light in Philadelphia...

heartlander (Diary) Thursday, February 3rd at 5:35PM EST (link)

…should have a psychiatric evaluation.

“The still, small voice of God in every human soul is the greatest ally of the pro-life cause, and why it will ultimately prevail.”
–Donald R. McClarey

 

Gentlemen may cry "Peace, peace!"

MikeG (Diary) Thursday, February 3rd at 10:09PM EST (link)

But there is no Peace!

 
 

For Thee, but not for Me

Robin Smith (Diary) Thursday, February 3rd at 6:57PM EST (link)

A good case of the ruling class claiming a desire for open, transparent govt, with their actions showing they’re willing to ignore, change the law or procedure for their agenda.
I say Appropriators reduce their budget request at the CDC as a fine levied for each day the data has been withheld.

Robin Smith (robints)

 

Transparency, when it's convenient..

andyd (Diary) Friday, February 4th at 4:20AM EST (link)

I think it’s obvious that this administration only wants transparency when it helps them. If there is any data that proves them wrong, they want it hushed up. I think this also shows that the last think this administration wants is an open and honest debate about abortion. Get rid of “don’t ask, don’t tell” but hide any inconvenient data on abortions…

Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.

– John Adams

http://politicalfriendsblogs.com
Political debate without the name calling

Homeland Security is not replying to Issa's request

renny (Diary) Friday, February 4th at 6:49AM EST (link)

and next we can expect to hear lots of executive privilege baloney.

I just finished David Limbaugh’s Crimes Against Humanity and although not much in it was new to me, many of the details and depths of lying, obfuscation, corruption, deceit, misspeaking, and outright stupidity really sickened and appalled me–particularly as the people producing these abominations, crimes against citizens and the constitution, were shrieking and denouncing Bush for eight years for trying to protect the nation and all its population.

 
 

According to Nat Rev Online, the CDC has never been

renny (Diary) Friday, February 4th at 6:52AM EST (link)

empowered by law to maintain accurate abortion stats, up-to-date stats, and has never kept data on the numbers of botched abortions or deaths of women incurred. By design, abortion “news” from the CDC is often years late.

 

53 MILLION

bigmaude Friday, February 4th at 8:34AM EST (link)

There is some data we need to deal with. This president loves abortion. The people that surround him love abortion, remember he wouldn’t want to punish his daughters with a baby, they will grow up loving abortion. Why would be surprised if he or those in charge hide data. Why hide it anyway, the meat grinder in Philadelphia got away with it, America is too concerned about super bowl Sunday. Eh. What’s the big deal, 53 million DEAD, 54 million DEAD. just a matter of time before we get to that number. We’ve softened the facts, call it abortion, not slaughter so we don’t think it’s so bad.
May God have mercy on us, yet I’m sure he won’t, we deserve what we get and it’s coming. A Christian nation huh?

 

"...the ways of death."

Warrior (Diary) Friday, February 4th at 9:03AM EST (link)

“There is a way that seemeth right unto a man, but the ends thereof are…” Proverbs 14:12

“Racial criteria are irrational, irrelevant, [and] odious to our way of life.” — Thurgood Marshall for the NAACP Legal Defense Fund in the 1950 Supreme Court case of McLaurin v. Oklahoma

 

A page out of Rahm's book

swordofzorro Friday, February 4th at 9:10AM EST (link)

Seems there’s a crisis brewing at CDC and Planned Parenthood. Unlike Al’s warm weather theories, this one is and has killed millions of humans. Time to go on offense, have marches, investigations and congressional hearings. If the gruesome imagery is too inconvenient to look at, tough. Pro lifers need pull the black drapes aside, open the window and let some fresh air and sunshine into the room.

 

Population control or genocide?

southernpatriots (Diary) Friday, February 4th at 9:42AM EST (link)

Progressives in the U.S., advocating abortion many years ago wanted to use it to eliminate the undesirables which included to them,, those with a darker skin color. They wanted to pursue a pure race (Hitler later copied their approach with his minoritity–Jews). Now a Progressive POTUS does not want to publish the statistics of abortion. Republicans are not yet fully awake. They want to take back the government in the next “cycle” and then take their time doing things. The leftists are not taking their time in doing things. They are doing them suddenly, quickly, and not wasting time. Conservatives had better not waste time when they are back in office both POTUS and Senate in 2012….God willing and we work hard enough.

 

Better a millstone...

js1019 Friday, February 4th at 11:04AM EST (link)

The Bible says ” it is better a millstone be tied around your neck and you be thrown into the sea, than to harm one of these little ones.

This was such an important scripture it is listed in 3 of the Gospels quoted by Jesus.

We have slaughtered close to 50 million babies. Is it any wonder God is allowing this country to languish and suffer from our own selfishness.

It may not be Christian of me, but the God I know and pray to, is not the god Obama prays to, if he actually does pray, because no one is more strident a supporter of abortion and infanticide than this man.

Everything this president does goes against every principal our great country was founded on.

I only pray he is a one term president because the wreckage he has brought on this nation will take years to undo.

 

Who does this surprise?

Plumb_Bob (Diary) Friday, February 4th at 11:24AM EST (link)

We should stop feigning outrage or surprise when we discover that the Obama administration has lied to us once again, has behaved in a manner opposite its stated intentions once again, or that the Obama administration is afraid of the truth once again.

Since the man hit the national scene in 2007, there has never been any reason to believe anything about Barak Obama OTHER THAN than he is a liar at the very core of his being, and that everything he produces will be based on lies.

Calling him to a standard of truth is a waste of both time and rhetorical power. We simply need to establish, as an existential fact, that Obama is a Liar, and that his entire Presidency is based on lies.

(Unrelated to this topic, please visit my political blog, “Plumb Bob Blog: Squaring the Culture,” at http://www.plumbbobblog.com. Thanks.)

It's no surprise

eastbaylarry (Diary) Saturday, February 5th at 10:47AM EST (link)

But that doesn’t mean we need to give this administration a pass on this.

Enough of the bright sunlight of truth may yet sterilize our nations’ wounds.

2+2=4 dammit!

 
 

I suppose I should add...

Plumb_Bob (Diary) Friday, February 4th at 11:29AM EST (link)

I suppose I should add that this has been true of every Democrat nominated for President since 1992. It appears that the Democratic party has officially become The Party of Lies.

(Unrelated to this topic, please visit my political blog, “Plumb Bob Blog: Squaring the Culture,” at http://www.plumbbobblog.com. Thanks.)

 

Thank you, Vicki Hartzler-

mbriggs56 Friday, February 4th at 11:37AM EST (link)

for taking a stand on this issue, and for doing the job we elected you to do.

Your constituents are noticing-

 

One More Govt. Cut

tamu125 Friday, February 4th at 11:40AM EST (link)

Why would we need our government wasting our precious tax dollars finding statistics on issues that are already being tracked private organizations? If the Guttmacher Institute can track it, I’m sure there are others tracking it as well. Good riddance.

 

Do not trust him ever, ever

violinhunter Friday, February 4th at 1:31PM EST (link)

I have never trusted this man we call President and I never will. By extension, I do not trust his corrupt Administration. Clinton was right about him – nothing but words.

 

No data ?

dirtpyle Saturday, February 5th at 10:31AM EST (link)

NO data – means NO abortions – means NO need to fund planned parenthood

 

Evidence of the brave new world--democrat style

nerkbuckeye Saturday, February 5th at 12:19PM EST (link)

…….As it will be in the future, it was at the birth of Man
There are only four things certain since Social Progress began.
That the Dog returns to his Vomit and the Sow returns to her Mire,
And the burnt Fool’s bandaged finger goes wabbling back to the Fire;

And that after this is accomplished, and the brave new world begins
When all men are paid for existing and no man must pay for his sins,
As surely as Water will wet us, as surely as Fire will burn,
The Gods of the Copybook Headings with terror and slaughter return!

The Gods of the Copybook Headings — Rudyard Kipling–1919

Funny how the more things change– the more they stay the same…..

Work as if you were to live 100 years, Pray as if you were to die To-morrow.— Benjamin Franklin