For all the talk about the Republicans having used reconciliation more than the Democrats, it is important to remember a few things:
- Each time reconciliation was used, it was used to fix legislation already enacted into law.
- What the Democrats want to do is use reconciliation to fix legislation before it is enacted into law.
And guess what? The Senate Parliamentarian is telling everybody that won’t work. According to the Parliamentarian, reconciliation can only apply to fix legislation already signed into law by the President.
In other words, Blue Dogs in the House are going to have to actually pass the Senate legislation, have Barack Obama sign it into law, then hope the Democrats still want to fix the legislation and that the fix is deemed only a deficit neutral financial fix for purposes of reconciliation.
There are a lot of ifs in that scenario.
Steve Maley
KnightsofMalta
Reconciliation
neoavatara (Diary) Thursday, March 4th at 10:32AM EST (link)First, the House won’t pass the Senate bill. Stupak has said, as of last night, he has 12 ‘No’ votes. Not to mention, there are plenty of liberals (i.e. Anthony Weiner) who won’t vote for the Senate bill.
Additionally, there is no way that reconciliation can be used to fix the abortion language, as far as I can tell.
This should be fun to watch.
http://neoavatara.com/blog/?p=10154
www.neoavatara.com/blog
My fear...
stigmo Thursday, March 4th at 10:34AM EST (link)Is that the public misunderstanding of reconciliation gives the tepid Democrats enough cover to vote yes.
Bingo!
Maureenthetemp Thursday, March 4th at 11:15AM EST (link)That’s what I think: “Oh, I would never have voted for this if I thought it would actually become LAW, my goodness! I thought the Senate would fix all this!” There is absolutely nothing keeping Pelosi from sending the bill on to the White House anytime she pleases — I think she has until the last day of the 111th Congress to send passed legislation to the White House. If it passes the House, it’s over, no matter what exotic fan dances the Senate does or does not do.
Then They Get Voted Out By Their Constituents for Total Incompetence
IJB Thursday, March 4th at 3:46PM EST (link)Either way, they’re still gone from Congress.
There’s basically no ‘upside’ for a House Dem to vote for the Senate bill, no matter how you look at it.
This is what I have wondered.
oldprospector Thursday, March 4th at 10:41AM EST (link)Everything that this President and Congress has done to this point has been “trust us” with a wink and a nod. What would happen if they passed the Senate bill and then sabotaged the reconciliation legislation on the grounds that it is simply too unpopular with the American public? We would be stuck with a bill that would open a liberal Pandora’s Box of health care.
did I read something correctly previously about the VP position in the Senate
spim Thursday, March 4th at 10:57AM EST (link)… that he can (to paraphrase) tell the Senate Parliamentarian, “Thank you very much Mr. Senate Parliamentarian for your input, but we’re going to do it *this* way.”
??
can’t remember where I read that …. perhaps only a nightmare …
Biden is About to Be Used
Spartan4Life (Diary) Thursday, March 4th at 11:07AM EST (link)When he trumps the Senate Parliamentarian, and he will because he has to, it will rightly be seen as the closest this country has ever come to fascism.
He will be sacrificed on the altar of Progressivism.
Yes, Slow Joe can overrule the parliamentarian
WarEagle01 (Diary) Thursday, March 4th at 12:25PM EST (link)and unfortunately it has been done before, by a Republican VP. But it wasn’t nearly as high profile as this. Will Slow Joe do it? Besides being slow, feckless, and dishonest, Slow Joe can also be unpredictable. So, I think the best we can say is, “we’ll see.”
“A wise, doughy leg with rich tingly experiences will always reach better conclusions than will a more tanned, muscular leg that hasn’t felt those thrills.” –Chris Matthews’ Leg
“The alternative to the awful extremity of abortion is the indispensable joy of introducing this flawed world to someone who might make it better.”–John Hayward (AKA Dr. Zero)
What lives by Reconciliation, will die by it
Marcus_Traianus (Diary) Thursday, March 4th at 11:33AM EST (link)My read of the rules is that if Democrats bring this to life by Reconciliation, once Republicans control Congress and the Presidency it can be killed the same way.
One way or another, the American people will be heard.
“Both of our political parties, at least the honest portion of them, agree conscientiously in the same object—the public good; but they differ essentially in what they deem the means of promoting that good. One side believes it best done by one composition of the governing powers; the other, by a different one. One fears most the ignorance of the people; the other, the selfishness of rulers independent of them. Which is right, time and experience will prove.”.Thomas Jefferson
Whoa!
RealQuiet (Diary) Thursday, March 4th at 11:38AM EST (link)I didn’t know that! So it is really House votes for Senate bill or bust. So the House is going to have to pass the Senate bill with reassurance from the Senate that they will fix it later? Hmmmm…290 acts of legislation that the House has passed that are tabled by the Senate. Tough sell for Pelosi to make to her caucus. Rely on the Senate not to let them down. Yeah, that’s going to work.
Liberals have no loyalty even to their own
Heffalump Thursday, March 4th at 12:00PM EST (link)This would require that the house pass the senate bill without changes based on the understanding that the senate would amend the law to accommodate what the house dems want in it (or out of it). I’d be willing to make book that as soon as the house passes the bill the senate flips them the bird and says “it’s the bill we want.. don’t care what you want” .
Is there anyone in DC bold enough to yell, "YOU LIE!" ?
Common_Cents (Diary) Thursday, March 4th at 12:01PM EST (link)Is there no bottom to the lies, deception, and lack of integrity? It’s sad to see the elected elite of this great country stoop to such lows to lie directly to Americans, and the MSM support the propaganda.
I could never comprehend how it was possible to allow millions of Jews to be slaughtered, but now see how it could happen with radicals in charge, a complicit propaganda machine and years of brainwashing in the education system.
Here’s some latest stats about health care:
The Bottom Line
There is no single factor responsible for rising health
care costs. Our system is complex and the cost drivers
are numerous.
• 95 cents of every $1 cost increase is driven by health care
providers and related services.
• Hospitals, physicians and prescription drugs cause 75% of the increase in spending.
• 67% of the increase in national health spending is accounted for by rising prices charged by providers, not increased use of health care.
• But treatment volumes are increasing too – partly because of the rise of chronic conditions and obesity.
It’s obvious our big govt monopoly cares nothing about health care costs, but only cares about the money and control of the money. There is virtually nothing in any DEM proposal to attack costs and efficiency but its all about control.
Obama=Golfer in Chief, Leading from,
behind, the Back Nine.Leaders don’t create movements. Movements create leaders. Get involved. Your future depends on it.
Govt “invests” YOUR tax money for POLITICAL return rather than economic return.
Reconciliation is Futile: If Passed, Eminently Contestable
reaganiterepublicanresistance Thursday, March 4th at 12:09PM EST (link)Like a good salesman, he acts as though passing some kind of HC bill he likes is inevitable (“what do you mean, you’re not buying a car today?)- while it’s surely not.
Linked at Reaganite Republican-
http://reaganiterepublicanresistance.blogspot.com/2010/03/passing-obamacare-chicago-way-will-not.htm
The Reaganite Republican
Kossacks have been played like a fiddle by Obama/Pelosi/Reid
RealQuiet (Diary) Thursday, March 4th at 12:16PM EST (link)You know, it is amazing to see how uninformed and naive the Kossacks really are. Wanting Senators to sign a letter saying they will push for the public option via reconciliation. Even worse is you see just how diabolical these Democratic politicians are in leading them on by saying “Yeah, we’ll sign it” while probably laughing their collective butts off in a seperate room. So it really is the Senate bill or bust that the House will pass. No public option, unions will have their cadillac plans taxed, etc. The Cornhusker kickback and the Louisiana purchase stay in. Ben Nelson and Mary Landrieu no wonder are staying steadfast in their support while trying to look sanctimonious. Wow, just wow. Talk about public relations misdirection tactics by Obama/Pelosi/Reid. The Machievellian character of these people is to a degree that is beyond shocking.
the cat is out of the bag.....
speciallist (Diary) Thursday, March 4th at 12:37PM EST (link)Why does anyone continue to assume that the Obama Administration
Tbone (Diary) Thursday, March 4th at 12:44PM EST (link)is not a full blown dictatorial coup being imposed on the United States? Wake TFU!
Envisioning when all that is Left is the Right.
And remember, the Senate bill has a no repeal provision.
Vegas_Rick (Diary) Thursday, March 4th at 12:59PM EST (link)Even tho most think it is unconstitutional, the Dims don’t seem to give much thought to that old rag.
“God is great, beer is good and people are crazy.”- Billy Currington
“Nothing in this world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not; nothing is more common than unsuccessful people with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not; the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent. The slogan ‘press on’ has solved and always will solve the problems of the human race.” Calvin Coolidge.
Gergen said on CNN that
earlgrey (Diary) Thursday, March 4th at 1:23PM EST (link)If opponents keep up the pressure HCR could fail. Keep calling and have family members in districts of blue dogs call as well. I just gave my mom her marching orders. She wasn’t happy about it, but I believe she’ll make the calls.
Pelosi says abortion won't stop the bill
stigmo Thursday, March 4th at 2:21PM EST (link)http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20100304/pl_nm/us_usa_healthcare_pelosi
Will this scenario work?
grinlap Thursday, March 4th at 5:29PM EST (link)House or Senate passes the “corrective” bill that makes the agreed changes to the existing Senate bill that hasn’t yet been passed by the House. The other house passes this same corrective bill.
House passes existing Senate bill. Both bills are sent to the President who signs the existing Senate bill first then the corrective bill. The corrective bill is legal because it is correcting something that is already law (by a few seconds at least).
This of course requires faith on the part of the House members that the President will, in fact, sign the corrective bill and not veto it leaving the existing Senate bill as the law of the land.
The truly sad part is:
anotherindyfilmguy (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 2:31AM EST (link)That all this talk “using reconciliation” has gotten this far and continues to be pushed for in the face of all facts about it.
Aside from the sad truth that even the lawmakers are expressing their ignorance over the valid use of reconciliation when something so wrong legally is being pushed by a so-called “constitutional scholar” does that not bring to mind the question “why”?
Just more proof that the Alinsky lefties think that rules are only for suckers and meant to be broken to get what they want…
Even sadder is having to choose between active willing destruction of America and the very likely rank incompetence of Biden should the term impeachment get used for the O… at this point I think I’d rather have the insurance policy known as V.P. Biden running things than the O…
Santorum? Well, at least he’s not Romney…
http://www.zazzle.com/enemy_of_the_statist_tshirt-235977043035297478
PIMF
anotherindyfilmguy (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 2:33AM EST (link)By valid use I mean what it is meant for because it is in no way shape or form valid to use it in the way they are proposing to do…
PIMF etc..
Santorum? Well, at least he’s not Romney…
http://www.zazzle.com/enemy_of_the_statist_tshirt-235977043035297478
Overrule
Tom Lesser (Diary) Friday, March 5th at 5:23PM EST (link)Is this a point on whichthe Senate Parliamentarian can be overruled by the president of the Senate?