I don’t know about you, but I think when proposing such bold initiatives, our senators should actually ask, “Is it constitutional?” But it is clear Bob Bennett does not respect the constitution.
[N]ot every member of the GOP opposes an individual mandate.
Sen. Bob Bennett, R-Utah, backed an individual mandate as part of a bipartisan health reform bill he pushed with Democratic Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden. Their bill had a handful of other Republican sponsors as well.
The Senate is not seriously considering the “Healthy Americans Act” at this time.
Bennett said this week that the constitutional issues never came up as they crafted their health care fix. He said he looked at the individual mandate in health care as something analogous to the requirement to have car insurance.
Bennett voted in the Senate that the individual mandate is unconstitutional, but has refused to back away from the individual mandate in his own legislation, which is pretty much the same as the one in Obamacare.
But when the constitution is outmoded, constitutionality really does not matter. I guess.
Moe Lane
Steve Maley
Dan McLaughlin
Neil Stevens
Daniel Horowitz
How Far Can I Go
saintgeorgegentile Saturday, February 27th at 11:41AM EST (link)What’s the limit in describing this smarmy, lying weasel before being censured & banned?
Freedom is the glue of capitalism, that amoral wisdom of the markets that most efficiently allots goods and services to a citizenry.
-Victor Davis Hanson
What a load
bigfix Saturday, February 27th at 12:20PM EST (link)Please find me any reference to Bennett saying the Constitution is “outmoded.” You won’t find one, because he never said it. Ever.
The Healthy Americans Act was not being seriously considered – it was a starting point for discussion. Bennett has never championed the individual mandate, and it is unlikely it would have survived into any final bill.
You guys have created a straw man and are beating the stuffing out of him, but it might be helpful if your straw man bore some resemblance to Bob Bennett.
Ahhh yes, Senator Bennett's staff is back.
mbecker908 (Diary) Saturday, February 27th at 12:38PM EST (link)So Bennett has never championed the individual mandate? Then why would he put his name on a bill that featured it? And don’t even try to sell the “starting point” crap. That might fly in your home district of Washington DC, but it sure won’t sell here.
You really should be spending your time polishing up your resume because it looks like your boss is headed for the hinterlands and I’m pretty sure his replacement will be hiring new people.
Check my IP, sir.
bigfix Monday, March 1st at 10:02AM EST (link)I don’t live in DC. It doesn’t fit your template, I know, but there are more of us out here who support Senator Bennett than the blinders-on folks here would have you believe.
Again, just saying “don’t mention the ‘starting point’ crap” isn’t a refutation – it’s just indignation masquerading as argument.
If that's so, bigfix, then why are you the only here
janis (Diary) Monday, March 1st at 10:40AM EST (link)who is supporting Bennett? No matter which diary mentions the man, you’re the only one I’ve seen who shows up to pimp for him.
The money quote, bigfix
Vegas_Rick (Diary) Saturday, February 27th at 12:58PM EST (link)is that he didn’t “look at the constitutional issues” and he ” looked at the individual mandate in health care as something analogous to the requirement to have car insurance.”
Let me clue you in: we EXPECT these idiots to look at the constitutional issues. That’s what’s wrong with progressives on both sides, including your hero, they’re not worried if the crap they push is actually constitutional.
Only a moron cannot understand that requiring auto insurance to protect the OTHER guy, when driving a car is optional, is not the same as forcing someone to buy a product simply because they live in this country.
Get a grip!
“God is great, beer is good and people are crazy.”- Billy Currington
“Nothing in this world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not; nothing is more common than unsuccessful people with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not; the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent. The slogan ‘press on’ has solved and always will solve the problems of the human race.” Calvin Coolidge.
I've gotten my grip.
bigfix Monday, March 1st at 10:06AM EST (link)What should I do with it?
Bennett supports the court case to settle the constitutional issues surrounding an individual mandate. He also wants to seriously reform health care, relying on private industry and not government-run care to do it. It’s nice to have a senator who is looking for solutions rather than screaming fiery rhetoric and accomplishing nothing.
Apples and Oranges Bennett
momo Saturday, February 27th at 3:27PM EST (link)You want to take away our freedom to choose whether or not to have health insurance. We only have to carry auto insurance when we choose to drive. If you don’t drive, you don’t have to purchase auto insurance!!!!
Bob Bennett Obsession
mavericktime Saturday, February 27th at 7:06PM EST (link)I don’t get it. Bennett’s bill isn’t even being talked about.
Exactly.
bigfix Monday, March 1st at 10:10AM EST (link)His Democratic co-sponsor has abandoned it in favor of Obamacare. And Bennett supports settling the constitutional question of the individual mandate. Erickson’s grasping at straws here.
This isn’t really about Bennett in the first place – it’s about Erick Erickson setting himself up as a kingmaker and definer of all things conservative.
For progressives, unconstitutionality is
redneck_hippie (Diary) Saturday, February 27th at 7:42PM EST (link)a feature, not a bug.
If the collectivists have their way, our governing framework will no longer exist. Woodrow Wilson was in favor of scrapping the divided powers framework in favor of a parliamentary style of government. Currently, the legislative power is being usurped by unelected bureaucrats.
The left acknowledges no limit to the power of the state. Lucky for us they decided to overreach so massively that they instigated a popular revolt. Perfectly understandable that the left is discomfitted by the tea party. They must now recognize themselves in the unfamiliar role of the reactionary defenders of the status quo.
.
mr.bennett
sarge324 Monday, March 1st at 6:13AM EST (link)please correct me if iam wrong.mr.bennett did place his hand on the bible and swore to god to protect and preserve the constitution.you that oath means nothing.progressives have no part in the country.if mr. bennett can swear on the bible,like the bible is nothing but a book and the constitution is a peice of paper than do we need him in the senate.he must go when his time is up.
Have no fear. Mr. Bennett's fealty to the Constitution...
bigfix Monday, March 1st at 10:07AM EST (link)… is much more solid than your own grasp of the fundamentals of capitalization, punctuation, and grammar.