Steven F. Hayward, writing in the Washington Post today, postulates that the conservative movement is currently brain dead.
It is a fashionable statement among those living in Washington, D.C. housed at think tanks. And I guess it is when think tannkers are pushing out columns on the lack of ideas rather than pushing out columns with ideas. Nonetheless, I generally agree with Steven Hayward that the movement needs to be reminded of its intellectual foundations. Hayward does, however, miss some critical points and flubs a few along the way.
I have a column on this in the Washington Examiner. My position is not that the tea party movement is brain dead, but that it reflects the conservative movement at an instinctual level.
What we see across the country are more and more people standing up realizing the direction we are headed is wrong. They are unorganized. They are unfocused. But they do not lack a “connection to a concrete ideology,” they just are not skilled or trained in the ideology.
There is no greater conservative sentiment than “stop.” Bernard Bailyn’s influential The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution laid out how conservative the American Revolution was.
The popular messages of “freedom” and “liberty” were not slogans of propaganda put forward by the 18th century equivalent of a 501(c)(4), but were very real and meaningful to the colonists on the street and in the fields.
While no one should expect a revolution against government from the tea parties, we should expect and hope for a revolution in conservative thought and an upheaval of at least the Republican Party as the tea party activists start putting down their protest signs and picking up campaign signs. Then, perhaps, they will move on to taking over their local political party.
“[T]he right must do better than merely invoking ‘markets’ and ‘liberty,’” Hayward writes. I agree. But I do not think it is the right per se invoking those words. Like the colonists in the late 1700s, it is the people invoking those words. The people have a fundamental understanding that those principles are good things and things on which the freedoms we enjoy in this country are premised.
You can read the whole thing here.
Steve Maley
Daniel Horowitz
Jake Walker
Victoria Coates
If a poll of 500,000 tea party protesters was taken....
americanmale Monday, October 5th at 1:10AM EST (link)one would get 500,000 different reasons for protest. And the reality is that each answer would be correct. There is something fundamentally broken in the core elements of our America. I liken it to that mysterious noise you hear in an engine….you just can’t put your finger on it.
The conservative movement is no where near brain dead. Actually, the conservative movement is quite a bit more sensitive to a change in the fundamentals of society…..because the conservative is more constitutionally centric than the liberal.
The majority of america is conservative….and thus there is a lot of headshaking going on out there….a lot of double takes if you will. That is what is being seen out in america. Something is woefully broken…and a lot of people are noticing.
Agree 1000% percent
bobbymike (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 2:32AM EST (link)I have no trouble, as a layman, navigating the web and finding excellent poicy positions and other studies for conservatives or libertarians on every issue under the Sun. In fact the volume of information exceeds my ability to absorb it. How this can be defined as “lacking ideas” is beyond me.
I have a felling “lacking ideas” means “centrist meet the dems halfway garbage” that got Republicans and conservatives in trouble in the first place.
Let’s not forget the MSM plays a little trick on Republicans and conservatives. They love to say “Republicans disagree or are against a certain liberal policy” but then ALWAYS fail to tell their audience what the Republican alternative is. You still have media people saying – or letting the liberal commentator say – the conservatives in Congress have no healthcare plan when I personally have read accounts of at least SIX Republican alternatives.
To anyone that thinks Conservatives 'lack ideas'
speciallist (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 2:17AM EST (link)Read this….
http://pajamasmedia.com/victordavishanson/change-and-hope/2/
VDH is one of the most serious and principaled thinkers today.
davo119 Monday, October 5th at 6:35AM EST (link)He doesn’t pander to any of the elites nor does he soft pedal the impossible situation we find ourselves in, to wit , collapse of moral standards, the threat of world terrorism supplied with weapons of mass destruction, utter lack of leadership for anything but special interest payback, clueless approach to financial stability… The list is nearly endless. Suffice it to say that the term “chaos” finds a reasonable home in any description of the world today.
This is precisely the goal of those threatening our civilization and the very fact that is so stubbornly denied by those in power and the elites who support them. Energetic engagement is seen as being ham fisted and barbaric. Instead, nuanced diplomacy and compassion for the other party’s position is pursued at the expense of our own core values like human life and freedom and individual liberty. And failure is termed progress, ie. the 10 year EU nuclear negotiations with Iran.
Looking for the concrete expression of conservative values one needs to look no further than the village pillory. That is where today’s conservative leaders are to be found. The collective Medea has branded them as being stupid, racist throwbacks to a bygone era void of any useful contribution, nay, a solid threat to progress in building the Universal State.
And even with the most recent blunder, the visit to Copenhagen by BHO, the leaders of the attack on Western civilization can only be thrilled and confident that everything is going to plan.
Never give in! Never! Never! Never!
I have several of his history books
kyle8 (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 7:11AM EST (link)Even my most recent Uber lefty history professor respected Hanson’s work, even though he didn’t agree with him.
“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle
I read the article, too...
basalt_conservative (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 2:20AM EST (link)…and I thought it was a big crock of cow dung. This guy came across as an “intellectual” looking down on us “rednecks”.
Sorry, Erick…I am sick of being condescended to by a bunch of elites who think they “know” how “proper” conservatism should act.
DON”T TREAD ON ME is a slogan that is short, simple and to the point, and it doesn’t take a person with all the right edumacation to get it!
Life is hard; it’s harder if you’re stupid. – John Wayne
Man is not free unless government is limited. – President Ronald Reagan
My sentiment
basalt_conservative (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 2:27AM EST (link)My sentiments are with Lori Roman, who wrote in the Washington Examiner in this article: Are conservative elitists brain dead?
While I give due deference to Hayward and his PhD, I suggest that he is asking the wrong question. The question is not whether conservatism is brain-dead; it is whether conservative elitists are brain dead.
I’ve been in meetings where conservative elitists bemoan the fact that they must tolerate the “regular folks” like Sarah Palin, Rush Limbaugh and Glenn Beck.
They look down their noses at principled, articulate job applicants because they don’t have the correct pedigree—an Ivy League education or the family or money connections to make up for the lack of one.
By behaving in this manner and, frankly, by writing editorials insulting average Americans not fond of reading Hayek on weekends, the elitists in the conservative ranks may entertain themselves splendidly at cocktail parties, but they are doing little to bring liberty to people thirsty for it.
Life is hard; it’s harder if you’re stupid. – John Wayne
Man is not free unless government is limited. – President Ronald Reagan
I'm with basalt conservative
BAW Monday, October 5th at 4:41AM EST (link)and Lori Roman.
I'm with basalt conservative
BAW Monday, October 5th at 4:41AM EST (link)and Lori Roman.
Hayward would like the National GOP to look like New Jersey...
H (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 1:47PM EST (link)The worst offense a statewide Republican candidate can commit in New Jersey is to have been successful in lower office and bringing democrat voters with him. It’s the kiss of death. The socially liberal Country Club GOP bosses just won’t abide a popular conservative candidate. Just ask Schundler and Lonergan. TH NJ GOP has proven that they would throw a gubernatorial race to the democrats before they would allow a working class populist with an R after his name hold the office.
basalt_conservative...
Aaron Gardner (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 8:08AM EST (link)I read the article and didn’t feel as though Hayward’s intent was to talk down to us “rednecks”. Rather I saw it as a chastisement of the current crop of “conservative” intellectuals.
In fact, the one person who Hayward actually gives credit to is Glenn Beck. Although Hayward does mention Beck’s crying, he also points out that Beck is one of the only ones out their on T.V. making the intellectual arguments against liberalism instead of mere cheer leading based purely in partisanship.
Smagar, in his comment below, nails it.
And as implied by Erick in this post, the cure for the intellectual side of conservatism is for those engaged in the Tea Party movement to bridge the gap between the instinctual conservatism and intellectual conservatism. In affect joining the positive forces of the two by renewing the leadership of the latter.
conform and celebrate diversity….or else!!!
“We’d be much better off if We The People had desired small government enough to keep it.” acat
Follow @Aaron_RS
Why?
basalt_conservative (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 6:48PM EST (link)With the highest regard for you, Aaron, and Great Americans like Erick, why should the Tea Party movement take action to bridge the gap, when it is the intellectuals who are basically part of the problem? Namely, elitists versus the rest of us?!
I say to Hayward and his ilk…either get with the program or at least step out of the way so that freedom-loving Americans can clean up the Beltway mess. As Smagar put it, contributions by people like “Brooks, Christopher Buckley, Parker, Frum, Noonan” have brought little “to the conservative movement in recent years”
Until these so-called…no…self-called intellectuals are willing to step down off their ivory thrones, grab brooms and help us do the dirty work, they will never be anything else but “nattering nabobs of negativism” against those who they claim share common values.
Life is hard; it’s harder if you’re stupid. – John Wayne
Man is not free unless government is limited. – President Ronald Reagan
basalt, you totally missed the point of what I wrote...
Aaron Gardner (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 7:35PM EST (link)We, the Tea Party activists, must become the intellectuals. Right now many are running on the guttural/instinctual side of the canyon. By US>/strong> bridging the gap we, in affect, take over the intellectual side of the canyon. At that point we end up controlling both.
Get it?
conform and celebrate diversity….or else!!!
“We’d be much better off if We The People had desired small government enough to keep it.” acat
Follow @Aaron_RS
ahh...blown tag.
Aaron Gardner (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 7:37PM EST (link)second try:
We, the Tea Party activists, must become the intellectuals. Right now many are running on the guttural/instinctual side of the canyon. By US bridging the gap we, in affect, take over the intellectual side of the canyon. At that point we end up controlling both.
Get it?
conform and celebrate diversity….or else!!!
“We’d be much better off if We The People had desired small government enough to keep it.” acat
Follow @Aaron_RS
Somehow I missed your point
basalt_conservative (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 9:32PM EST (link)Somehow I missed your point…you explained it more clearly on your second try!
…and I hate those blown tags, too…no way to edit…
Life is hard; it’s harder if you’re stupid. – John Wayne
Man is not free unless government is limited. – President Ronald Reagan
They said the same thing about Reagan
Husker (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 3:52AM EST (link)I believe many of here are old enough to remember the same pedigreed individuals of that era dismissing Reagan as an intellectual lightweight and a firebrand. I believe they used the phrase ‘amiable dunce’ once.
I believe this is more of a fight to remain in their status as kingmakers of the party. Look at how these individuals reacted to the choice of Sarah Palin – whether right or wrong can be debated – to be the choice as VP. The self proclaimed intellectuals were acting like pseudo-intellectuals foaming at the mouth, and in some cases hurling obscenities at her when they thought the mics were turned off after an interview.
Before criticizing anyone else, maybe they should take a hard look at their own despicable conduct and their part in creating divisions within the ranks.
Idiot Conservatives
VinceP1974 (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 4:51AM EST (link)As the Left becomes more and more irrational, uninformed, mired in Groupthink, and increasingly isolated from the real world, where everything can be reduced to a charge of racism… . it’s only natural that they view thier opponent to be just as stupid as they are.
Total Pyschological Warfare Vs Right
VinceP1974 (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 4:56AM EST (link)How come the following questions and comments are never made about the Democrats. [Some of these are things the Democrats used to be called, that they now manipl
Questions and comments about Conservatives and GOP:
- GOP is too angry
- Part y of No
- Who is the leader
- Where are thier grand ideas
- They have no ideas
- They are traitors
- They are political racists
and on and on and on
Many of our "thinkers" let us down in 2008
smagar (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 7:52AM EST (link)Brooks, Christopher Buckley, Parker, Frum, Noonan… Talk about a shallow, gullible bunch. After seeing what the Ivy League did for this bunch, my son will attend a state university.
Personally, I’m ready for the “doers” to step forward in the conservative movement.
Color me way-less-than-impressed with the value the thinking, chattering class has brought to the conservative movement in recent years.
“Who will stand/On either hand/And guard this bridge with me?” (Macaulay)
5 5 5 5 5 nt
pilgrim (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 8:33AM EST (link)MEGA 5, Smagar!
basalt_conservative (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 6:49PM EST (link)…….
Life is hard; it’s harder if you’re stupid. – John Wayne
Man is not free unless government is limited. – President Ronald Reagan
Good Oped, Erick - as usual
yoyo (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 8:51AM EST (link)“I told you so.”
‘:o)~
Nemo me impune lacesset
“No one will provoke me with impunity!”
=============================
Pukin’ Dogs – The Fighting 143
Sans Reproache
=============================
The ‘yoyo’ replaced my cigarettes January 22, 2006….
Not 'conservatism', but 'republicanism'
nixfu Monday, October 5th at 9:01AM EST (link)That fact is that its republicanism that is dead.
Conservatism is alive and well as shown in the recent zogby national poll showing that 1 in 5 Americans are so suck of it that they are clearly in favor of SECESSION and forming a new country.
But guess, what….they want away from the Republicans as much as they want away from the Democrats.
The conservative train is gaining steam and ready to roll down the tracks, and the Republicans don’t have tickets.
A small disagreement with Erick's article.
Steph C (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 2:04PM EST (link)I don’t believe it’s that we aren’t skilled or trained in the ideology. Conservative principles are simple and direct while encompassing enough nuances to make a liberal shudder with delight at the word.
We are, however, like our ideology, simple in deeds, actions, and words. Perhaps, rather than trained in ideology, what most need is to be trained in how to expand on our ideology to meet the needs of the “intellectuals” ?
Yes, it is instinctual in the beginning but understanding soon follows. We are, however, often at a loss to explain that understanding in the words often needed to help others understand the same. We humans are not good at sharing our heart of hearts with anyone else. That, too, is instinctual because to lay one’s heart bare before another is to invite injury to it.
“[I]f the public are bound to yield obedience to laws to which they cannot give their approbation, they are slaves to those who make such laws and enforce them.” –Candidus in the Boston Gazette, 1772
Hillbilly Politics
Viguerie & Allen weigh in
Bill S (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 9:17PM EST (link)in the Washington Examiner:
“Brain-dead Conservatives:” Whose side are you on, the populists or the elitists?
“It’s such a fine line between stupid, and clever.” – David St. Hubbins
5, bs!
basalt_conservative (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 9:36PM EST (link)This article is a great contribution to this discussion!
Life is hard; it’s harder if you’re stupid. – John Wayne
Man is not free unless government is limited. – President Ronald Reagan
Viquerie and Allen wrote a nice piece, but I think they miss something...
Aaron Gardner (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 10:13PM EST (link)There is no reason that the players in the new conservative movement can’t play on both sides of the ball, and maybe even make appearances on Special teams.
Intellectuals, activists and politicians don’t have to be mutually exclusive. One could say that Reagan was a good bit of all three, a pity that Viquerie and Allen don’t see it that way. Also a pity that they didn’t see Reagan as an intellectual, because the fact is, he was.
conform and celebrate diversity….or else!!!
“We’d be much better off if We The People had desired small government enough to keep it.” acat
Follow @Aaron_RS
I can see why you'd read that from that article...
Bill S (Diary) Monday, October 5th at 10:37PM EST (link)as the latter part sort of reads that way. However, early on in the piece, they make it plain that the “roles” are not mutually exclusive:
“It’s such a fine line between stupid, and clever.” – David St. Hubbins
bs...yes and no...
Aaron Gardner (Diary) Tuesday, October 6th at 9:55PM EST (link)Reagan was all three, yet they only give him credit for two. And yes they did mention that “the movement” is most successful when it is strong in all three, but I hope to inspire individuals to be all three. I think this is a subtle, yet important difference. I wasn’t meaning to criticize the piece, I meant to expand on it.
conform and celebrate diversity….or else!!!
“We’d be much better off if We The People had desired small government enough to keep it.” acat
Follow @Aaron_RS