Capturing the Sentiment of the Grassroots


For you members of Congress who voted for the bailout, consider my wife.

My wife is mad as hell that this bailout bill passed today. I mean, she won’t even rationally discuss it with me because she is so damned mad about it.

She finally said tonight that if they’d shut down Fannie and Freddie and passed the bailout, she’d be fine because at least they’d have admitted their fault, mitigated it, and moved on.

But without that, she said it’s just going to happen again and again and again.

And then she refused to talk about it any more.

In our eight years of marriage, this is the first time she’s ever been pissed about anything related to the government.

I hope John McCain and all the right-of-center 527 groups pay attention to this too. People who don’t pay much attention to politics do, in fact, pick up on the Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac boondoggle. This is not an issue to run away from.


Category:

RSS feed

25 Comments Leave a comment

Well Erick, my wife reacted differently

Dave_in_Fla (Diary) Friday, October 3rd at 10:12PM EST (link)

She was angrier than I have ever seen her after the House defeated the bill on Monday. And she is a stay at home mom with very little understanding of the financal sector. But she had read up enough on what was going on during the previous week to call “BS” on the political posturing, while the rest of us are risking our paychecks.

Now the one place where your wife and my wife agree is that the Dems caused this mess, and killing the GSEs and every corrupt politician involved should be the first order of business.

McCain can easily capitalize on both sets of anger.

“If they were merely incompetent, then at least SOME of their actions would have been to the benefit of the country.” – Joe McCarthy

 

Thank you

Shawn Gillogly (Diary) Friday, October 3rd at 10:15PM EST (link)

That’s part of what I’ve been saying this week. By keeping them open, and not dismantling them, we do nothing to solve the problem.

Bailing out Chrysler, for all the Iacocca melodrama, only put off the inevitable. What’s more, it convinced the other auto makers there was nothing fundamentally wrong with their plan. Check GM’s stock price these days, and the fact Chrysler has been bought and sold twice since, and you’ll see it solved nothing. In fact, it exasperated the problem.

Government bailouts don’t fix the problem. And with GSE’s, the problem is doubled, because they dictate to the market. So when they go under, they take everything else with, just like a giant ship sinking takes everything else under with it in the wake.

The rush to push through this plan also ensures it really could not have been worse. Everything the Founders built into our government was designed to create a deliberate process. The fear mongering of this bill ensured that was bypassed. It couldn’t have been worse, no matter who was President in January, because people could at least have THOUGHT about this until then. If it was still going to be socialized because BHO won, then at least it would’ve been a socialized solution that had a chance to work on it’s own principles.

This bill, socialism-light, doesn’t do anything right, and is guaranteed to walk us right into the same trap 10yrs down the line. Tops. And no, we cannot let the Democrats off the hook for this. McCain needs to get serious about nailing this to Obama, Frank, and the others who went to bed with FF/FM.

He promises to make pork-supporters famous. Show us how, John, make THESE people famous, please. It might be the only way you can win.

“Liberals are always talking about pluralism, but that is not what they mean. In public school, Jews don’t meet Christians. Christians don’t meet Hindus. Everybody meets nothing.”- Dennis Prager

 

Everyone Who Supports McCain/Palin

Adelthemystic Friday, October 3rd at 10:45PM EST (link)

Needs to let the anger over the Bailout go. At least for now.

What needs to happen is we all need to be channeling our energies into winning this election, instead of bickering back and forth on how best to do it, and why the bailout was right or wrong.

Here is what needs to happen, right now.

1) All of those who are going to vote McCain need to make sure we are capitalizing in our blogs, posts, emails, letters to editors of publications, the fact that the Democratic Party is, by and large, at fault for the current crisis. Are we completely clean of responsibility? No. And this will come up.

2) When the matter IS brought up that we are partly to blame. OWN UP TO IT. Yes, we have, as a party, made mistakes. Emphasize that good leaders recognize when they have made an error and are able to move past it, learn from it, and not make that mistake again.

3) Turn it around. While McCain and the RNC have accepted the responsibility in the fiasco, the Democrats have not, and instead of showing a willingness to accept responsibility and work to solve the root cause, they would have us socialize our structure, and move along with business as usual in Washington and Wall St.

4) Push the ties between those responsible, particularly the CEO’s and Golden Parachute recipients, to the Obama campaing, and the Democratic machine overall.

5) Realize that Obama comes from one of the most corrupt political areas, in practice and history, in the nation. A quick google of the scandals in his state, and his ties to some of the bigger names in these scandals produces a cornucopia of information.

6) There are four weeks left in this game. It is the fourth quarter, and the opposing team just called in their starting line up, well rested and ready to trounce you. Obama has an incredible ground campaign. Sure it is riddled with fraud, but it is impressive in scope and size. Are we going to let petty issues like being in support or opposition to a bill that has now become law interrupt and divide OUR ground effort? May I remind you that the Republican party has been sluggish to respond in the last three election cycles to an ever growing grassroots, get out the vote machine on the other side.

In summation, we need to stop convincing each other of how right we are, and start convincing the independents and apathetic voters of why we are the party to rescue this, and be the pheonix form the ashes.

 

Erick, if your wife is upset about Fannie and Freddie still existing . . .

Hancock Friday, October 3rd at 10:51PM EST (link)

. . . wait til she gets a load of this part of the bailout bill.

“The Treasury Department is authorized to “guarantee” home mortgages, essentially becoming a kind of co-signer, to reduce the number of foreclosures. If the home owner stops paying his or her mortgage, taxpayers would be on the hook. The Treasury Department can also eliminate a “reasonable” amount of a home owner’s mortgage debt, under section 109 of the new law, which would likely delay the process of house prices falling.”

Last night during the debate, my wife went nuts when she heard Biden say that he and Obama supported letting bankruptcy judges adjust the principal amount of a borrower’s mortgage interest. Her first words were ‘well, maybe we should get divorced, I could go on welfare, you can declare bankruptcy, and we can just shack up here in the house together and see our loan payments go way down’. Now she was being sarcastic of course, but as we have seen with virtually every other government handout program, if you create perverse incentives for bad behavior, people will engage in it frequently.

However, this section 109 idiocy goes even further than what Biden talked about, and even worse, it is now the law of the land!!! So the US Department of the Treasury can now guarantee your mortgage, putting taxpayers on the hook for it if you dont pay, and even better, can just come in and unilaterally reduce the principal of your mortgage by a ‘reasonable’ amount.

Of course, as usual, the legislation doesnt specify what the rules will be for getting your principal reduced — as usual, the moral cowards on the Hill have punted this issue to unelected bureaucrats in the Executive Branch to actually make the tough decisions. So what faceless bureaucrat will now decide what amount it is ‘fair’ to reduce your mortgage principal by? Who qualifies to apply? Do you have to be a deadbeat and about to default? Disadvantaged minority? Below a certain income level, so Democratic class warfare principles can be applied? Or will this be open to all Americans?

My suspiscion is that this little-talked about title will become the focus of more fraud, abuse, and ultimately litigation than the Community Reinvestment Act abuses that prompted this mess in the first place. The principal reduction provision screams out to me as being something that will benefit only the politically connected and the politically-correct. Can you imagine Barack Obama and his ACORN cronies now have it within their power, should he become President, to reward their friends and political supporters by having the Treasury reduce the amount of the mortgage balance, and send the bill to the taxpayer? How on earth any Republican could have ever voted for this is beyond me. I don’t care what the consequences would have been, there is no way this should have ever been allowed to take place.

My wife and I bought our house, in the expensive DC metro area, at nearly the peak of the market in 2005. We had 20% down in cash, and solid credit. Every lender we talked to tried to talk us into a gimmick mortgage of some sort, the kind that would have greatly lowered the payment for the first few years, which would have given us a higher montly spending budget than we otherwise should have. Every lender told us how safe it would be to take an ARM, a zero option ARM, an interest-only mortgage, so on and so forth, because of course, our house was always going to be worth $100,000 more next year than it was this year, and we can just refinance again.

We told them NO WAY. We took a 30 year, fixed rate convential mortgage. Our payments are significantly higher, actually an order of magnitude higher, than what they would have been on one of the gimmick plans. But we felt the responsible thing to do was to lock in at the historically-low rates of interest at the time, leave nothing to chance, and make sacrifices so we had a house payment that we knew would never rise out of control. I wont get into all the sacrifices we had to make, but sale of a prized possession that I had wanted for two decades, and only got to enjoy for 4 years, was one of the things that had to go, in order to get more cash down and keep our 30 year fixed payment in line with what we could afford. While these decisions were tough, we were confident we made the right ones, and time has proved us correct.

But what enrages us now is that we are stuck with our high cost monthly mortgage, which we have paid on time and as agreed for 3 1/2 years, on a house that is not worth what we paid for it, and at present, may be worth only slightly more than our mortgage balance. And on top of that, Congress has just told me and my wife that not only do we have to pay our mortgage, but we now have to pay the mortgages of those people who didn’t choose to sacrifice like we did. We have to now back the borrowers who took the lower payments of the gimmick mortgage, bought a Hummer, the 60 inch plasma TV, built the inground swimming pool, took expensive vacations, and now, when their mortgage adjusts, complain that they can’t pay it any more. Geez, I guess maybe my wife and I shouldnt have been responsible after all. Maybe we should have taken the gimmick mortgage, lived it up, and expected someone else to bail us out.

This site does not allow the words I would like to use to express my complete outrage at Congress, and particularly the GOP Members, for letting this Section 109 become law. I literally want to throw them all out — and this is coming from someone who worked on the Hill for 16 years and counts many friends there.

Never in my life would I have expected to say this, but the very first time the Treasury uses this new Section 109 authority to adjust any borrower’s mortgage principal downward, there should be a massive class action lawsuit filed on behalf of every other mortgage holder in the United States to enjoin the government to cease and desist, based on the incredible artibtrariness and unfairness of granting this extraordinary relief to some but not to others. If legal action wont work, every American should simply refuse to pay one more dime on their mortgages, period. Does anybody think that if the government is unwilling to throw deadbeats who bought more house than they can afford out of their homes, that they would allow 50 million plus mortgages to be foreclosed on at once? Now that would be a real economic crisis.

Too bad that us honest, hardworking citizens who pay our bills are just that — honest, hardworking citizens who would never walk away from their debts as a matter of honor. And because of this sense of honor, we are about to be taken advantage of by Washington once again in order to bail out the thieves, the scum, the ignorant, the greedy, the lazy, and all the others who continue to demand,decade after decade, something for nothing, courtesy of the productive members of society.

Yeah, my wife and I are d*mned mad about this bailout.

DITTO - NT

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Friday, October 3rd at 11:03PM EST (link)

5

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

^5

Pomme (Diary) Friday, October 3rd at 11:16PM EST (link)

Was gonna tell everyone you were Mr. Pomme, but then you went with the football analogy. :P

So, do I have to officially change my name to Pommethemystic? Cause I’m not, just so ya know.

Anyway, well said. (No, not biased, nuanced.)

“Liberals claim to want to give a hearing to other views, but then are shocked and offended to discover that there are other views” William F Buckley Jr.

This is probably the first

Mark Reiboldt (Diary) Friday, October 3rd at 11:17PM EST (link)

batch of recommendations that I’ve heard actually provide some solutions for moving forward in this situation rather than dwell on the same type of crap that has always hurt the GOP (see Newt et al). The most annoying thing for me is to hear the Dems talk about this situation as if they are absent from any blame … it’s just everyone else;s fault, but Barney Frank and the other half-retarded primadonnas on the Dem side of the Hill didn’t play any role. Right. That reminds me of something about the pot calling the kettle black. I can assure us all one thing though: the longer we dwell on this, the longer it will take to think about real recovery from this crisis and the further we move from being able to win the election for McCain.

As for the original post, I don’t think anyone can legitimately argue that Fannie/Freddie are worth anything. They represent the mother of all f-ups when it comes to the housing crisis. But, I don’t think we can just shut them down. Unfortunately, we’ve invested too much in them (only to see all of our perceived value go down with all the bad lending). It will take more than that to get our of this crisis, but I with everyone else share the distaste for the GSEs (and the way they were run).

I've been married 23 years

Jack_Savage (Diary) Friday, October 3rd at 11:24PM EST (link)

You haven’t SEEN pissed off until you jokingly refer to your wife as “knocked up” when someone congratulates you on being pregnant.

Not that I have done that, mind you.

Anyway, I am on the side of Erick’s wife, and my wife is much more philosophical about the situation.

 
 
 
 
 

AdeltheMystic and Hancock..these comments are diary Quality...Make them Diaries!!

speciallist (Diary) Friday, October 3rd at 11:35PM EST (link)

I will promote the best I can..bring it

my wife is a Ozombie..hates palin...

speciallist (Diary) Friday, October 3rd at 11:39PM EST (link)

And when I ask her about the Bailout Bill…she says “I thought you didn’t like Boats..”

sucks for me…

 
 

Lather, Rinse, Repeat

Robert A. Hahn (Diary) Friday, October 3rd at 11:46PM EST (link)

    she said it’s just going to happen again and again and again.

She’s right: it is going to happen again and again and again.

It is the unstated policy of the Professional Politician Party that the government shall maximize the number of Americans who are nominal “homeowners,” as this has proven to be a civilizing influence on people.

Last time it was the Savings and Loan debacle. Set up some institutions that subsidize home ownership, then keep pushing the envelope on who can qualify until the mortgage pool is polluted with crap. Then stage a public hanging (Charles Keating will do), blame everything on greedy bankers, and put in some new and different institutions that subsidize home ownership. Lather, rinse, repeat.

If the policy only crashes every twenty years, it’s considered a success.

Drink Good Coffee. You can sleep when you’re dead.

Just a hypothetical

Robert A. Hahn (Diary) Friday, October 3rd at 11:57PM EST (link)

    The Treasury Department can also eliminate a “reasonable” amount of a home owner’s mortgage debt, under section 109 of the new law, which would likely delay the process of house prices falling.”

See, this is why it is dangerous to have too high a percentage of lawyers making policy. Lawyers are always looking backwards, at specific cases. Here’s a guy, poor him, he needs help, so here’s what we’ll do to solve his case, and other cases like his.

Absent from this thinking is what happens to the minds of mortgage lenders when they realize that the contracts that the lenders sign with their borrowers may be abrogated at whim if politicians decide at some future date that the borrowers need relief.

Here’s a question for you math whizzes: what is the present value of a stream of payments, the amounts of which cannot be predicted, and which may be paused for arbitrary periods of time, or canceled altogether? For extra credit, would you or anyone you know loan a fixed sum to anyone else under these conditions?

For extra extra double-secret extra credit, what happens to ‘the process of house prices falling’ in a world where bankers will not lend money to buy houses because they can’t trust that they will ever be paid or be able to foreclose?

Drink Good Coffee. You can sleep when you’re dead.

RIGHT ON - NT

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Saturday, October 4th at 12:04AM EST (link)

5

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

Lenders and Buyers suffer...salesmen get Fat

speciallist (Diary) Saturday, October 4th at 12:11AM EST (link)

Inevitable?

Freedoms Truth (Diary) Saturday, October 4th at 12:22AM EST (link)

“Bailing out Chrysler, for all the Iacocca melodrama, only put off the inevitable. “

It was inevitable that Chrysler goes bankrupt in the early 1980s? I missed that.

Robert hits the nail on the head

Hancock Saturday, October 4th at 1:18AM EST (link)

Excellent post Robert. I couldn’t agree more. I was a non-lawyer when I worked on the Hill, and I can tell you from personal experience how right you are about lawyers writing legislation. Generally, they produce THE WORST results because they are trained to think like lawyers, not policy makers, and common sense often does not rear its head.

As far as your economic points, you are right on as well. I wish I could say as well in 10 paragraphs what you said in less than half that space. I was far more emotional than eloquent when I wrote my post. The sheer absurdity of Section 109 is classic example of how government policy designed to fix a problem will make it worse, will encourage rent-seeking and other perverse activity, penalize the law-abiding and honest, and empower the politically-connected over the people.

Just to embellish this last point, from my years of experience on the Hill and dealing with government/politics, I can guarantee you that the potential for political favor-granting and abuse by insiders on this provision is astronomical. What they have created now is a another way to pay/reduce your mortgage — be politically active and cultivate the right friends. Just like the appratchiks in the old Soviet Union were the only ones able to have cars, shop at the well-stocked stores, and get decent medical treatment, so will we now have a mortgage reduction program that will be ripe to be taken advantage of by well-connected insiders, or as a source of favor-dispensing to politically loyal groups. Sort of has the spirit of the special Countrywide Mortgage ‘friends of Mo’ list that Dodd and company benefitted from — not available to the average citizen.

Of course, that is why leftists always love big government programs like this, such as single payer health care. They assume that they will always be in control, and be able to get what they want for themselves, and dispense favors to their friends. Because they are connected, they will get all of the benefits of the government program, while suffering none of the adverse consequences personally.

 
 
 
 
 
 

Erick,

Rod_Patrick (Diary) Saturday, October 4th at 1:52AM EST (link)

Your wife and I agree on this.

Fannie and Freddie must die.

Let new institutions and new people handle the existing portfolios. Without it, NO JUSTICE HAS BEEN DONE.

All previous top and middle managers of Fannie/Freddie must be removed.

Unleashing the anger IS important.

Uma Richie (Diary) Saturday, October 4th at 4:28AM EST (link)

My husband ‘s normal 10 degree political starboard list has increased to about 30 degrees in the past few weeks. He’s never written our Congressman before, and yet he made a point of sending an e-mail regarding the bailout. He went from a casual McCain/Palin voter to an avid supporter.

For those of us already in the active in the campaign, yes, we do need to let go of our bailout fury and move on to winning the election. But, the anger of the politically inert like Erick’s wife and my husband can be tapped into for votes, volunteers and contributions.

It appears that RedState’s population has skyrocketed since the beginning of the crisis. So keep those bailout blogs coming, and use Adelthemystic’s suggestions as a guide. You never know how far your message will spread.

Agree Robert.

Rod_Patrick (Diary) Saturday, October 4th at 5:07AM EST (link)

The solution made by the Congress is nothing but a re-washed…. Same ol same ol.

Meaning, the fed money is also expected to be washed away by this solution.

In fact, the solution further exacerbated the problem.

Okey, Adelthemystic

Rod_Patrick (Diary) Saturday, October 4th at 5:10AM EST (link)

I will keep my anger for now because of your very good rationale.

I hope that RS3.0 gets back immediately to business of winning this election for McCain/Palin ticket.

But you know what my problem is?

Rod_Patrick (Diary) Saturday, October 4th at 5:21AM EST (link)

This!!!!

Democrats are smilingPelosi's smiling

Everytime Pelosi smiles, something wrong will happen.

That’s a proven theory.

Why exarcerbate the problem?

Rod_Patrick (Diary) Saturday, October 4th at 5:27AM EST (link)

Why would I pay for my mortgage…the government will back me up anyway.

This is the problem when we remove the Right of the People to LOSE?

Let's Board the Bus

Barnee (Diary) Saturday, October 4th at 8:02AM EST (link)

Eric:

I totally agree with your wife. The three of us should meet in Macon, Georgia, take a bus to Ohio and vote a couple of times to demonstrate our displeasure.

Barnee

Yep, you must be missing something...

Shawn Gillogly (Diary) Saturday, October 4th at 9:36AM EST (link)

Since Chrysler got bought and sold just like what would’ve happened with no bailout.

That the auto-industry would have had to re-invent itself and take into account the increasing costs of oil and decreasing supply. But instead they sat on this because of government subsidized cowardice until GM’s stock held worth equivalent to the average pack of baseball cards.

That the American people got bilked to aid this process of subsidized inefficiency, cowardice, and short-sightedness just as they are now.

Why FF/FM aren’t even being told to reign in their profligate loan practices. Indeed, we aren’t even holding them responsible for their roles in this catastrophe. So the stage is set for a repeat in 10years. Nice, huh?

“Liberals are always talking about pluralism, but that is not what they mean. In public school, Jews don’t meet Christians. Christians don’t meet Hindus. Everybody meets nothing.”- Dennis Prager

Frank Raines Must Become a Household Name

buckeye (Diary) Saturday, October 4th at 4:38PM EST (link)

in the same sense as Ken Lay, and tied to Obama. Anything less and McCain loses the economic issue and the election.

“Honor is self-esteem made visible in action.” – Ayn Rand, West Point, 1974