Disgusting. Disgusting. Disgusting


The Federal Reserve will own 80% of AIG.

It is disgusting and dangerous that a government institution would, in one fell swoop, own so much of a private institution. It provides an advantage to AIG that other corporations do not have — government backing.

It provides incentive to other major corporations to be irresponsible knowing that the Feds will bail them out.

Bernanke should be dragged into the street, flogged, and exiled to some communist country where he can see the end result of his grand scheme toward nationalization.

Today is a dark, dark day for the free market. And we can thank President Bush too.

Disgusting.


Category:

RSS feed

66 Comments Leave a comment

$20 billion Friday, $85 billion today?

Hammer2008 (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 8:33PM EST (link)

Flipping through the channels just now and Suzie Orman was on Larry King saying how, had the Fed done this on Friday, the cost would have been $55 billion less (*before AIG’s rating was downgraded).

P A T H E T I C

So Sen. McCain is proposing a national commission to study this (and other issues) in the same vein as the 9-11 commission. Is there really any reason to wait for 2009 for this???

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Too much noise! “Noise! You’ll have noise enough before long. The Regulars are coming out.” ~ Paul Revere (April 18th, 1775′s eve…)

 

What's the Big Deal?

Steve Maley (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 8:47PM EST (link)

All the Fed has to do is turn on the printing press, and poof –all problems disappear!

Worked so well in Zimbabwe.

The blogger formerly known as ‘Vladimir’.

 

One wonders

Reaper0Bot0 (formerly Han_Pritcher) (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 8:47PM EST (link)

How much longer we intend to put off the pain.

 

I Saw This Coming

BigGator5 (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 8:48PM EST (link)

Yeah, I saw this coming. There was nothing we could have done. I guess I’m would have like to seen AIG die a horrible death only Jigsaw would have been proud of, no one else wanted to see them go down.

This is all the more reason to elect people who will never do this again.

Educated (About The Issues Facing Us Today), Dedicated (To Making A Difference), And Highly Motivated (To Getting Things Done)
@biggator5

 

However,

TomOConnor Tuesday, September 16th at 8:50PM EST (link)

What would the cost of doing nothing have been to customers and counter parties of AIG’s that traded or dealt with AIG in a fair and ethical matter.

Should they be punished for the mistakes of AIG?

 

Buy Low Sell High

Mike (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 8:53PM EST (link)

It seems the Fed has forgotten the prime rule of business. Buy low, sell high. Does Mr. Bernanke think for a minute anyone is going to want to buy any of the 80% stake we all now have in AIG?

If he does, bring back Paul Volcker.

Centrist

manner not matter

TomOConnor Tuesday, September 16th at 8:54PM EST (link)

Brain cramp

Caveat Emptor (nt)

Neil Stevens (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 8:54PM EST (link)

RS contributing editor, technical administrator, and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules

Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.

“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder

 
 
 

At least this kid can get some sleep

BlogWatcher Tuesday, September 16th at 8:58PM EST (link)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-1-m7nYm7s

 

At least this kid can get some sleep

BlogWatcher Tuesday, September 16th at 8:59PM EST (link)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-1-m7nYm7s

manner not matter

TomOConnor Tuesday, September 16th at 9:00PM EST (link)

sorry, brain cramp

 
 

I totally agree...

MSU_Charles Tuesday, September 16th at 9:00PM EST (link)

with Erick. Over the weekend, I thought the Fed and Treasury finally “got it” in letting Lehman Bros. collapse not offering a bailout. The AIG bailout now makes the federal government a direct participant in the insurance business, when they are already in the housing business with the Fannie and Freddie bailouts.

Until they quit interfering with financial markets, the true economic recovery cannot begin. Sad indeed.

 

Adam Smith is rolling in his grave

Ronald Daniels (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:03PM EST (link)

The invisible hand was not meant to be Bush’s hand. This is only going to perpetuate the problem, not solve it.

Well...

mbecker908 (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:07PM EST (link)
  1. What would the cost of doing nothing… Nothing.
  2. Since when is it the responsibility of the Federal Government to “protect” every consumer, every investor from every “bad” decision?

This is utter crap. Now, to top my day off all McCain has to do is throw in with the Gang of 20.

Don’t look now, we are damn near Europe.

 
 

The New Business Paradigm

Nick Haynes (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:11PM EST (link)

1.) Start a business.
2.) Get enough customers to be considered a staple.
3.) Go vacation while Big Brother watches over your affairs for you.

Now all I need is a product. Can one charge a fee for sarcasm?

If you’re not networking, you’re not helping.

 

oh to be a fly on the wall of Jim Rogers....

MrSandman (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:11PM EST (link)

…..although I’m guessing would be adult rated.

“Americans can no longer trust the economic information they are getting from this Administration.”

— Republican Senator Jim DeMint

 

I'm really worried.

weave (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:14PM EST (link)

I fear the economy is being propped up until after the elections. I fear that no matter who wins, we are going to have a collapse. McCain saying the fundamentals of the economy are strong yesterday doesn’t help my paranoia either.

I’m starting to think Obama should win since it will tank anyway — and hopefully a new Reagan will emerge for 2012. If McCain wins and this gets worse, Dems will decimate us in 2010 mid-terms and probably take over everything in 2012 with a filibuster proof majority.

I’ve always believed that the free market can correct any problem — but there’s very little free-market at work here. It’s not being given a chance.

I’m going to bed. Someone please tell me I’m full of it and cheer me up! Maybe tomorrow will be better.

 

The New Business Paradigm

Nick Haynes (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:16PM EST (link)

1.) Start a business.
2.) Get enough customers to be considered a staple.
3.) Go vacation while Big Brother watches over your affairs for you.

Now all I need is a product. Can one charge a fee for sarcasm?

If you’re not networking, you’re not helping.

 

I can hardly wait to hear what Jim Rogers has to say.

MrSandman (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:22PM EST (link)

http://www.moneymorning.com/2008/08/19/jim-rogers/

Tuesday, August 19th, 2008

Exclusive Interview: Jim Rogers Predicts Bigger Financial Shocks Loom, Fueling a Malaise That May Last for Years

This is bad for the GOP. The timing really couldn’t be worse. It’s a known fact that wall street is infested with dems….I’m not saying that is being orchestrated….I’m just saying….

“Americans can no longer trust the economic information they are getting from this Administration.”

— Republican Senator Jim DeMint

 

Government Created Mess that Only Government Can Fix

quill67 (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:24PM EST (link)

The markets are spooked. Only the Fed is large enough to restore calm. Many of the assets whose values have plummeted are performing assets and there is no reason for them to be taking this big hit except fear. Once calm is restored, the Fed can get back out of the market.

 

I can hardly wait to hear what Jim Rogers has to say.

MrSandman (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:25PM EST (link)

http://www.moneymorning.com/2008/08/19/jim-rogers/

Tuesday, August 19th, 2008

Exclusive Interview: Jim Rogers Predicts Bigger Financial Shocks Loom, Fueling a Malaise That May Last for Years

This is bad for the GOP. The timing really couldn’t be worse. It’s a known fact that wall street is infested with dems….I’m not saying that this is being orchestrated for political reasons….I’m just saying….

“Americans can no longer trust the economic information they are getting from this Administration.”

— Republican Senator Jim DeMint

You pretty much have it right

olderthangandalf Tuesday, September 16th at 9:27PM EST (link)
 

Four words: Too. Big. To. Fail.

St_Louis_Conservative (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:28PM EST (link)

I don’t like it any more than you do, but what would be the consequences for the economy and financial system if AIG was allowed to go under? AIG is a massive financial services company with their tentacles deeply extended throughout the economy. As much as I despise a bailout, I believe that it probably had to be done.

Second, is this really a bailout? I think the shareholders are getting hosed on this deal. I’m hearing that it is a loan to help AIG meet its debt obligations, not an infusion of cash with no strings attached. AIG has to pay the loan back I believe – the government doesn’t want to be in the insurance business.

“…..women and minorities hardest hit”

Your little rant

TomOConnor Tuesday, September 16th at 9:32PM EST (link)

Doesn’t answer the question. Why should companies that traded with AIG be punished? There was nothing done by all these companies.They entered into good faith arrangements with AIG.

It’s my feeling that this “bailout” was for the counter parties of AIG, of which there are thousands.

Customers would have been ok

olderthangandalf Tuesday, September 16th at 9:33PM EST (link)

Insurance is a highly regulated business. Typically, the policies issue from subsidiaries that have adequate capital. Beyond that, there are programs in place to take care of insureds if their company goes down the tubes.

As for the bond purchasers, they are big boys and girls. A lot of them bought the bonds on a gamble that the government would step in and not allow them or AIG to lose. They should take a haircut; instead, they are taking your money.

 
 
 

Ironic

wiseprince (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:34PM EST (link)

I hope the irony is not lost on anyone. The largest insurance brokers in the world didn’t plan for a rainy day.

Companies that are too big to fail:

Walmart
Halliburton
US Airlines
Dell
Microsoft

This is really getting outrageous

[Subscribe Now](http://feeds.feedburner.com/~r/voicesinthewilderness/UQcm/~6/1)![Voices in the Wilderness](http://feeds.feedburner.com/voicesinthewilderness/UQcm.1.gif)

 

The best kind of corporate regulation...

Bill S (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:39PM EST (link)

is risk. The government has just proved that a company can do whatever they darned well please with no concern for the consequences. All this talk of overhauling regulation of the financial services industry could be avoided if the gov’t would just allow these companies to die the death they deserve, and in the future the boards, CEOs, AND customers, etc. would understand that no one is gonna save their bacon if they screw up.

“It’s such a fine line between stupid, and clever.” – David St. Hubbins

From the Fed

TomOConnor Tuesday, September 16th at 9:39PM EST (link)

Fed Invokes ‘Unusual and Exigent’ Clause — Again

In lending up to $85 billion at a hefty interest rate –- LIBOR plus 8.5 percentage points –- to insurer AIG, the Federal Reserve once again relied on its rarely used legal authority under Section 13(3) of the Federal Reserve Act to lend to “any individual, partnership or corporation” in “unusual and exigent circumstance” provided the borrower “is unable to secure adequate credit accommodations from other banking institutions.”

http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2008/09/16/fed-invokes-unusual-and-exigent-clause-again/

If the Feds reformed mark to market accounting rules

red_oakster (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:40PM EST (link)

they would have been able to solve much of this problem at much lower cost.

Just because an asset is illiquid should not require the owner to value it at the level of a lowball or even non-existent bid.

That’s a reform that is desperately needed.

Two words: moral. hazard.

Brian Simpson (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:41PM EST (link)

It’s completely gone now.


| My RedState archive |
Important principles may and must be inflexible. ~ Abraham Lincoln

Correct

wiseprince (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:49PM EST (link)

Risk Regulates

Do you think we’ll be hearing McCain hammer home this point? Somehow I doubt it as it doesn’t make for a great sound byte…or does it?

[Subscribe Now](http://feeds.feedburner.com/~r/voicesinthewilderness/UQcm/~6/1)![Voices in the Wilderness](http://feeds.feedburner.com/voicesinthewilderness/UQcm.1.gif)

 
 
 
 
 

Do do we get a stock certificate?

Jack_Savage (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 9:52PM EST (link)

Or dividends? Or maybe a break on an annuity?

I am so damn sick and tired of every bad decision, from dropping out of high school to Ivy Leaguers running 160 year old financial institutions into the ground being subsidized by the government.

Why not the auot makers? Why not airlines? Why not the corner grocery? It is getting less and less attractive to be a normal, stable, play-by-the-rules individual or company. Bet big and win – keep the money. Bet big and lose – get bailed out. What are they going to do when people like us say “to hell with it”? I am so close right now I may do it just so I can right a frigging blog on it two years from now.

Disgusting is the mildest word I can think of right now. And I do not give a rat’s ass if the markets are spooked so much that the Fed NEEDS to intervene. I say pry the windows on Wall Street open, let whoever needs to jump have at it, and start over. I’m serious.

re: Good faith arrangements...

mbecker908 (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 10:02PM EST (link)

Bull. They entered into business dealings with AIG. They have no inherent right to be protected from harm.

Just where would you draw the line?

 
 

Yeah, it's disgusting

kowalski (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 10:05PM EST (link)

But you could see one coming a mile away. The Fed wasn’t going to let AIG fail precisely because it is NOT like Microsoft or Dell or any of the airlines or (heh) Halliburton. If Microsoft goes belly up, the value of people’s homes isn’t going to plummet. If an airline goes bankrupt, some other airline will buy its planes and hire its pilots and cabin crews, and the airports will still be there. And so on and so on.

But AIG, through its financial services divisions insinuated and ramified itself throughout the foundations of the economy. Letting it fail would have been like letting someone set off explosive charges on the bolts holding together the trusses of a bridge.

The big question for everyone to be asking while they stand here on this bridge is: “How did AIG get to become so important for holding this bridge up?”

The real problem is that the exotic financial instruments that were traded virtually without regulation through the free market have become so central to the functioning of the world’s economy and yet they are so arcane and incomprehensible that we dare not let them come unraveled. The taxpayer is now being forced to hold up the bridge while everyone gets under there and figures out what kind of exotic bolts are keeping the trusses together, and how they got there, and who should inspect them.

But make no mistake about it: I’m with the realists here — letting AIG fail today would have been something close to the end of the world.

I don’t know what kind of penalty should be given to the people who created this situation, because in a way, all of us did. Certainly anyone who owns insurance through AIG did. The Fed broke the rules today because the rules have been bent and warped for so long now that it almost doesn’t matter any more.

 

AIG has actual assets

TomOConnor Tuesday, September 16th at 10:13PM EST (link)

Unlike the paper of Lehman and the others.

Their 1 trillion in assets just aren’t liquid.

An 85 billion dollar loan at 11% is hardly a bailout.

 

Confused

sturner Tuesday, September 16th at 10:18PM EST (link)

So let me get this straight. We paid $80 billion dollars for 80% of a company that stocks show is worth $10 billion on paper? A company that none of the financial giants would touch with a 10 foot pole.

I have not been this mad about something our government has done in a long time. I’m actually surprised we don’t have people lining up in the streets over this. Our federal government is using OUR tax dollars to prop up failing companies.

As someone mentioned earlier, this gives a huge advantage to AIG over their competitors. It also essentially nationalizes the insurance industry. That makes a nice pair with our nationalized mortgage industry. With the car companies lining up next asking for $50 billion, along with airlines and energy, we are starting to have a tough time separating ourselves from those foreign economies that we’ve decried for decades.

I know it won’t matter, but I’m calling my representatives tomorrow to voice my displeasure for MY tax dollars being used to bail out companies who made bad mistakes. As a small business owner, I don’t get that same luxury.

The other song of the day

kowalski (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 10:23PM EST (link)

Is Bob Dylan’s “Everything Is Broken” from Oh Mercy

Everything Is Broken
Broken lines, broken strings,
Broken threads, broken springs,
Broken idols, broken heads,
People sleeping in broken beds.
Ain’t no use jiving
Ain’t no use joking
Everything is broken.

Broken bottles, broken plates,
Broken switches, broken gates,
Broken dishes, broken parts,
Streets are filled with broken hearts.
Broken words never meant to be spoken,
Everything is broken.

Seem like every time you stop and turn around
Something else just hit the ground

Broken cutters, broken saws,
Broken buckles, broken laws,
Broken bodies, broken bones,
Broken voices on broken phones.
Take a deep breath, feel like you’re chokin’,
Everything is broken.

Every time you leave and go off someplace
Things fall to pieces in my face

Broken hands on broken ploughs,
Broken treaties, broken vows,
Broken pipes, broken tools,
People bending broken rules.
Hound dog howling, bull frog croaking,
Everything is broken.

 
 

Blackhedd will have to read the tea leaves on this one.

streetwise (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 10:39PM EST (link)

The feds, having done the big banks so many favors, tried to get them to step up to the plate. They failed. Somehow I think the old adage “revenge is a dish that people of taste prefer to have cold” will apply to this day eventually.

Not exactly

TomOConnor Tuesday, September 16th at 10:49PM EST (link)

We, through the Fed, are loaning AIG 85 billion dollars for a period of two years, at 11% interest.

AIG has assets of over 1 trillion dollars.

This is socialism...

liberalrepublican (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 10:51PM EST (link)

Our economy is going to be stagnant for years to come if we keep going down this road.

Is Bush responsible?

“Broadly speaking, liberalism emphasizes individual rights and equality of opportunity. … including extensive freedom of thought and speech, limitations on the power of governments, the rule of law, the free exchange of ideas, a market or mixed economy”

 
 
 

I'm moving to Argentina...

enrique Tuesday, September 16th at 10:56PM EST (link)

… where there are fewer nationalized industries. So now within the span of a few weeks the Fed (using our tax money/credit) put of hundreds of billions to nationalized the mortgage industry, most of the insurance industry, and bailed out huge banks (even Lehman’s by providing the subsidy of easy credit).

Where’s the outrage in Congress? Does the executive branch even have the authority to nationalize industries like this with no public debate? Can they just add $80 billion in debt overnight without discussing it with ‘the people’?

Heck, this crisis is making Ron Paul look like some sort of savant. What are they going to do next – confiscate gold bullion?

I’d rather have the health care industry nationalized than all of these financial bailouts. These will only prolong and intensify the magnitude of the ‘ultimate margin call’ and create a cataclysmic end to our economy.

Someday soon the Fed will seek a bailout for their idiotic schemes from you and me because they are ‘too big to fail’. The downturn and correction of the market cannot be avoided forever by the Federal Reserve. Any more than they can make water flow uphill.

“There are a thousand hacking at the branches of evil to one striking at the root.” Henry David Thoreau

 

What Has Been Lost In All This...

cmugrad Tuesday, September 16th at 11:07PM EST (link)

….is that one of the oldest money market funds put a 7 day hold on redemptions and broke the buck today. That could make a lot of people nervous about where they have their money parked and cause some uncomfortable days ahead if people rush for the exits for less risk.

Which business exactly is being Nationalized?

TomOConnor Tuesday, September 16th at 11:09PM EST (link)

BUSINESS SUMMARY
American International Group, Inc., through its subsidiaries, provides insurance and financial services in the United States and internationally. It operates in four segments: General Insurance, Life Insurance and Retirement Services, Financial Services, and Asset Management. The General Insurance segment underwrites various business insurance products, including large commercial or industrial property insurance, excess liability, inland marine, environmental, workers compensation, and excess and umbrella coverages. This segment also offers various specialized forms of insurance, such as aviation, accident and health, equipment breakdown, directors and officers liability, difference-in-conditions, kidnap-ransom, export credit and political risk, and professional errors and omissions coverages. In addition, it provides property and casualty reinsurance products to insurers; automobile insurance products; residential mortgage guaranty insurance products; and second-lien and private student loan guaranty insurance products. The Life Insurance and Retirement Services segment offers individual and group life, payout annuities, endowment, and accident and health policies, as well as retirement savings products consisting of fixed and variable annuities. The Financial Services segment provides aircraft and equipment leasing, capital market transactions, consumer finance, and insurance premium financing. The Asset Management segment operations comprise investment-related services and investment products, including institutional and retail asset management, broker-dealer services, and spread-based investment products. The company was founded in 1967 and is based in New York, New York.

Bad Loan

sturner Tuesday, September 16th at 11:13PM EST (link)

Why wasn’t it selling some of its 1 trillion in assets to raise this money? Why are our tax dollars at risk to save a company that made bad business decisions?

And if this loan is so safe, so full proof, why did not one single bank or financial institution want to touch it with a 10 foot pole? Why are we the only ones in the world willing to pony up this loan? I get the feeling all we did here was put an $80 billion dollar bandaid on a gash to save Wall Street from another 500 point drop.

 
 
 

Maybe Republicans really are facists.

Buzz Brockway (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 11:23PM EST (link)

First the mortgage industry now AIG. This is really really bad.

11% makes it a subprime loan.

mbecker908 (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 11:26PM EST (link)

That's not what really happened

kowalski (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 11:31PM EST (link)

What really happened was that the Fed gave AIG a line of credit so that it can fulfill its obligations in an orderly way instead of in a spectacular, explosive, violently destructive and catastrophic way.

In exchange for that it owns 79.9% of a (mostly) profitable conglomerate with a balance sheet of 1.04 Trillion dollars. That’s with a T. AIG won’t be around in its current form a year from now, but the likelihood of a major catastrophe went waaaaay down with this action. Nobody was going to be served well by an AIG collapse, from mom and pop mutual fund investors to big time global institutional investors.

In fact the more I read about the deal the Fed took today, the more I realize that it wasn’t only wise, it could even wind up being profitable for taxpayers.

People need to calm down.

Well...

sturner Tuesday, September 16th at 11:35PM EST (link)

It beats my credit card’s rate.

Maybe you're really about to leave

kowalski (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 11:36PM EST (link)
 
 
 
 

As someone who was (mostly) against the Bear Sterns bailout

ZootSuit (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 11:47PM EST (link)

This is one that I can live with.

In some ways, AIG has no competitors but performs a unique service in the marketplace as the “insurer of insurers” or the insurer of last resorts. If it failed abruptly, it could cause a chain reaction. What the Fed did was provide a (high-interest) line of credit that will (or at least, should) be used to restructure their business.

***** Unrepentant African-American nationalist, Unapologetic African-American conservative!

 

As someone who was (mostly) against the Bear Sterns bailout

ZootSuit (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 11:49PM EST (link)

This is one that I can live with.

In some ways, AIG has no competitors but performs a unique service in the marketplace as the “insurer of insurers” or the insurer of last resorts. If it failed abruptly, it could cause a chain reaction. What the Fed did was provide a (high-interest) line of credit that will (or at least, should) be used to restructure their business. It’s almost like what the Fed already does for Banks, provide short terms of credit.

***** Unrepentant African-American nationalist, Unapologetic African-American conservative!

Question

sturner Tuesday, September 16th at 11:58PM EST (link)

If this deal is going to end up profitable for us, why did every bank and financial institution balk at the idea of loaning them money? Why did no other country step in and jump on board? It just seems odd to me that all these brilliant financial minds would run away from a great deal.

But that isn’t even the biggest issue. I could care less if it is profitable for the government. We should not be picking sides in the business world. We should not be favoring one company over another. We should not be playing roulette with tax dollars.

And maybe I am going overboard on it, but maybe it’s because I’m a small business owner. I don’t get these privileges. When I take a risk that backfires, I pay for it. There is no one I can cry to and beg to be saved. My business has to survive in the free market, their business doesn’t.

It's not much of a stretch....

Buzz Brockway (Diary) Wednesday, September 17th at 12:00AM EST (link)

Hitler took over key industries in Germany. Our government has now taken over Freddie Mac, Fannie Mae and now the largest insurance company in AIG as Democrats and “experts” applaud.

If Obama is elected will he and a Pelosi/Reid run Congress really sell these companies back to the private sector?

 
 
 

Suddenly Fiscon?

DonPMitchell (Diary) Wednesday, September 17th at 12:24AM EST (link)

Suddenly everyone is a fiscal conservative? Does this mean we are ready to talk about the budget deficit?

I don’t believe AIG is particularly one of the bad guys in the credit crisis. They are taking collateral damage, and many experts believe they will be fine with a fairly short-term bridge in their financing. The government had to make a pragmatic decision — nobody is reading from the Herbert Hoover strategy book of non-intervention.

Lehmann brothers is another story. They got what they deserved, and I’m with McCain on going after the CEO’s and executives who bailed out with golden parachutes. You’d think after the Savings & Loan fiasco in the 1980s, people would learn. Margin trading in stock market has been carefully regulated since it caused the 1929 market meltdown. And now we had people buying mortgage instruments on 90 percent margin!

Borrowing money to buy loans…from people who should never have been given the loans in the first place. What could possibly go wrong?

Goldwater: In your heart, you know he’s right

I run a small business too....

kowalski (Diary) Wednesday, September 17th at 12:26AM EST (link)

And what you say makes a lot of sense to me, very poignantly right now in fact. But looking at it a different way, if AIG couldn’t meet its insurance obligations and the rest of the economy took a drastic hit as a result, my business would also be swept away. Fat lot of good that would have done me.

Look, AIG has a lot of profitable businesses but the proximate cause of them being unable to raise the money in the private sector was a unique run of bad luck. Their stock price plummeted and they got downgraded. All the other companies that might have invested to save them couldn’t come up with enough money at this particular moment in time: there was nobody who had an extra pair of hands to tie the torniquet. They had to loan $20 billion to themselves, for Pete’s sake. The next step was a truly catastrophic and panicked series of events.

I don’t know what else to say except that these are some extraordinary days. As a small business owner I can take righteous umbrage, I suppose, that nobody would step in to save me. On the other hand, I don’t know what kind of world I would have woken up to tomorrow morning if they had been allowed to fail. It might have been a lot worse than tomorrow is looking now.

And the Government and the U.S. Taxpayer, in the words of the Wall Street Journal, “drove a hard bargain” — this two year loan is at 8.5%+LIBOR (the interbank offered rate.)

The next hammer to fall if AIG failed looked to have been money market funds:

In bailing out AIG, the Federal Reserve appeared to be motivated in part by worries that Wall Street’s financial crisis could begin to spill over into seemingly safe investments held by small investors, such as money-market funds that invest in AIG debt.

Money-market funds are supposed to be among the safest investments available. No fund in the $3.6 trillion money-market industry has lost money since 1994, when Orange County, Calif., went bankrupt. A number of money-market funds own securities issued by AIG. The firm is also a big insurer of some money-market instruments.

You want to talk about some real hell to pay if they started going sour? You want to talk about millions of small investors losing their skin? Is that what the U.S. Treasury Department under the Bush Administration wanted to be remembered for allowing to transpire instead? I think not.

Who would be left for me to do business with?

 
 

Its too early to tell if

Illinicon (Diary) Wednesday, September 17th at 12:45AM EST (link)

this was a good or bad move. I think the reason it was done was to avoid market panic in the money-market fund sector. If people are worried about their safest investments they will inturn cut their spending which would hasten the slow growth the economy has seen in the last couple of years. Atleast this bailout makes some sense unlike Bear and Fredie/Fanie.

My Potus shortlist

declared candidates:

1. Tim Pawlenty
2. Herman Cain
3. Gary Johnson
4. Rick Santorum

among declared and rumored candidates:

1. Rick Perry
2. Tim Pawlenty
3. Rudy Giuilani
4. Herman Cain

 

Please. Calm. Down.

Jlerner Wednesday, September 17th at 1:31AM EST (link)

The Fed, although usually an arbiter of malignant and repugnant actions in the financial markets, did the only thing it could do to prevent a collapse of supposedly safe Money Market Funds. This would Directly affect every small business owner in America and would drastically deter future investment into our Financials. It is morally repellent to allow companies to grow to this size, with uninsurable assets spread out over numerous interconnected fields, and then to save them from their own mistakes but if Bernanke and Paulson had let this behemoth fail, the crisis would have been ungodly. This would have mirrored the failure of the Bank of the United States in 1931, in that it would represent an underlying crisis of liquidity in the financial market itself (although the fundamentals of our economy–production, jobs, income, ineterst rates, etc.– are infinitely stronger). Read Milton Friedman’s The Great Contraction for an understanding of what the Fed should and shouldn’t do in a time of a prolonged liquidity contraction; AIG will no longer be nearly as powerful or as expansive in two years, and it may not survive the next decade, but the government will recoup its loan, and AIG’s crash will be slow and predictable; there will not be a run this way. And that’s what the Fed ultimately is trying to do. If only Milton Friedman were still alive; he could ameliorate the concerns of us freemarketeers without sounding like a Fed whore. God I miss that man.

Kowalski, your voice of reasoned calm is truly appreciated

CincoSolas_del_Bronx (Diary) Wednesday, September 17th at 1:34AM EST (link)

by one who has no clue about the machinations of what happens 11.6 miles SSW of my house–except when I could see and soon smell smoke from fires there that would burn for 3 months–and who would like to reserve the terms “dark” and “disgusting” for such events and those who brought them upon us, and who cannot conceive that public upbraiding of a sitting Executive over lesser matters will serve the process of selecting his replacement.

Those dreading urbanization should remember that though the Kingdom of God first appeared in a temporal Garden, at the end of the book it is established in an eternal City. (paraphrase, James M. Boice)

soli Deo gloria

I understand

sturner Wednesday, September 17th at 1:35AM EST (link)

I completely understand the ramifications of the AIG mess. I know it would have been a disaster for the markets and our economy. While I do think some of the “great depression” predictions were overblown, there is no doubt this would have had a big effect on our country.

But my frustration comes from the perspective of someone who plays by the rules. Who makes smart decisions and quantifies the risks involved. We are the ones who are being put on the hook for everyone else. I chose not to sign a bad mortgage, but I will end up having to pay for those who did. It’s this sinking feeling inside that makes you wonder when the country shifted to a point when doing the right thing didn’t matter anymore.

You’re correct that there would be millions of small investors hurt by AIG going under. But investing has risks. Perhaps it’s time that this country had some tough love and learned that there are no sure things when you buy a stock or sign a mortgage. That it’s up to you to determine whether those risks are worth the investment.

This is nothing more than free market for profits and socialism for losses. It’s welfare, just for different people and under different names. We had a chance to make a statement and show people that bad risks have bad consequences. The message is clear now though. If your business is big enough that it can have an effect on our economy, the tax payers will make sure it never fails. Your bad risks are covered.

As I said, I understand the decision and our economy is in better shape for it today. The same can’t be said for our principles.

Ahem....

Shawn Gillogly (Diary) Wednesday, September 17th at 2:43AM EST (link)

Every small business person and taxpayer is going to have to pay for this ‘anyway.’ The federal deficit next year, regardless of who is President, will be $1 trillion. That was BEFORE this fiasco.

I do enjoy how everyone says we need to “calm down” about these things. I didn’t know I was agitated. This is bad economics, bad in the long term for business, and will fix ‘none’ of the underlying problems. And no, they aren’t a good risk for taxpayer dollars either, or someone would’ve white knighted their way in on this.

As for being a fiscal conservative, I’ve always been one. The federal gov’t intruding into the markets like this only props up poor business decisions in the future. Same with protectionism. The Chrysler bailout solved nothing in the long term. Instead the autodealers kept thinking they could make non-cost effective vehicles right up until they found their shares @ $4 per.

This is the same thing in the financial markets. And listening the Greenspan, the architect of this disaster, try to deflect blame is ludicrous.

“Liberals are always talking about pluralism, but that is not what they mean. In public school, Jews don’t meet Christians. Christians don’t meet Hindus. Everybody meets nothing.”- Dennis Prager

EXACTLY

Jack_Savage (Diary) Wednesday, September 17th at 6:16AM EST (link)

“The big question for everyone to be asking while they stand here on this bridge is: “How did AIG get to become so important for holding this bridge up?”‘

Someone was asleep at the switch. Or maybe it is time for a new bridge.

Jack Savage, totally off topic here, but man

c17wife (Diary) Wednesday, September 17th at 6:31AM EST (link)

you have been on a roll lately!
Keep it up!
Hopefully you are doing the same in NC. :>)

Duty is ours, outcomes belong to God.~Mike Pence

Good point, Tom!

Rod_Patrick (Diary) Wednesday, September 17th at 7:04AM EST (link)
 
 
 
 
 
 

Can't fix anything

IndependentfrMI (Diary) Wednesday, September 17th at 8:14AM EST (link)

Government is not the answer to all the Wall Street ails.
How many takeovers or bailouts, (it’s all about semantics) that leave the government running things in our so called FREE market before it becomes socialist government?

 

They laughed at me!!!!

madtrapper (Diary) Wednesday, September 17th at 9:11AM EST (link)

I called Clintons office and asked when I would be recieving my AIG stocks. The Lady on the other end laughed at me!! This is not a joke, this is our money.

We just invested $85 billion of our money, what do we get?

McCain blew the whistle on all these meltdowns back in 2005 with the housing reform bill. Nobody listened and the dems shot it down.

Funny how all this implosion is taking place now with a Democratic controlled Congress???

Missing

JakePrime (Diary) Wednesday, September 17th at 10:07PM EST (link)

You seem to be missing the consequences of this for AIG. AIG will not exist as it is in 2 years. The stockholders lost everything and the leadership got tanked. In that sense, this is not a bailout. No one is being saved.