Hurricane Katrina killed over 1,800 people. The September 11, 2001 attacks killed some 3,000 people. The oil spill killed 11.
Hurricane Katrina was a natural disaster. The oil spill is a man-made catastrophe.
Hurricane Katrina flooded 80% of a major American city and displaced, oh, let’s say about 1,000,000 people. The oil spill has displaced 0 people.
No one but the government and insurance companies could compensate the victims of Hurricane Katrina. No one but the government and insurance companies could respond to the September 11 attacks. BP can compensate the victims of the oil spill. So can the US Coast Guard, through the National Pollution Funds Center.
The earthquake in Haiti killed over 200,000 people. It made, oh, about 1,000,000 people homeless. It rendered a government completely incapable of functioning. No one could help those people, no one was to blame. So we helped.
The tsunami in the Indian Ocean killed over 200,000 people in FOURTEEN COUNTRIES. No one could help those people, no one was to blame. So we helped.
This is not the President’s Katrina, it’s not the President’s 9/11, and it SURE AS HELL is not the MOST IMPORTANT THING EVAR. There are some 50,000+ wells/bore holes in the Gulf of Mexico (as of May 2010). Exactly 1 has produced this mess. In 2008, federal leases in the Gulf produced some 400+ million barrels of oil. That means this leak would have been about 0.06% of total 2008 production in the Gulf.
Is it a lot? Yes. Is it environmentally bad? Yes. Is a moratorium required? No. Does this require the President’s undivided attention? Hell, no – we have a Coast Guard, a DOI, a NOAA, an EPA.
Neil Stevens
Caleb Howe
Daniel Horowitz
Lori Ziganto