The Fog of War has Enveloped the Speaker


Having been up on the House side for the last two days, I can report that the fog of war has enveloped the Speaker and will attempt to explain why the Speaker is losing. CNN puts the Speaker down 11 votes, FireDogLake puts the Speaker down 25 — Yes at 190 — she needs 216.

This is a classic political battle: conflicting reports, disinformation and propaganda (two distinct things) moles, the light and dark roles of key operatives, overlaid with the impact of time — and those “inside the decision cycle” of their enemy.

The basic problem for the Speaker and her team is the enemy (to them, that’s us) is inside their decision cycle.

The greatest defense the Speaker has had against this happening before now has been her irrational behavior. But the predictability factor has skyrocketed because the Speaker and the White House — aka Axelrod and Valerie J. and the One — are fully committed to a knowingly destructive course of action: a vote to “pass the Senate bill without voting on it.”

This is what we know:

The Dem Leaders and White House will not acknowledge the political damage they are inflicting on their friends and colleagues. The White House and Speaker are destructively arrogant and irrational — the Joker — writ large.

They do not care, are not cognizant and really are blind to the poison they are spreading to Dems, while they insist their friends and colleagues eat it.

Second, they have created a habit of irrationality. A key part of this habit is rejecting information that shows the political damage they are doing to their friends and colleagues.

This habit of rejecting information that does not fit in their Groupthink world is well known in military history. Russia had a spy who repeatedly warned of German attack during World War II. Russia ignored, ridiculed and discredited this spy. The spy did not know his reports were ridiculed. Similarly, the Speaker and her team have ridiculed, discredited and ignored many Dems and pro-lifers when they wrote the bill.

Dem staffers report having repeated circular discussions with Leadership and Committee staff: we say the language of the bill says and means this, and the leadership staff and committee staff say, no it does not say and mean this, and we are not changing it.

Other key strategic advice rejected by the Speaker and the White House are Charlie Cook’s political and campaign analysis and Lawrence O’Donnell’s legislative strategy. Instead, they listen to the inexperienced and the dangerously Pollyanna Axelrod, Valerie J and the President. (And the Dems wonder how they got to this place.)

Part of this Groupthink pattern is that the delusionals listened to Chairman Waxman and Chairman Miller to craft their bill — and rejected writ large the suggestions of moderate Dems and completely locked out the GOP. The fact is, they have made a habit of not listening to their own members, the GOP and the public. When the Committee staff met with various factions of the Dem House, they did not take notes, they did not follow up, and universally rejected their suggestions.

Third, (and this next mistake is unforgivable in political warfare, and leads to huge, catastrophic disasters) the delusionals believe their own propaganda. Dem staff reports that the House leadership repeat the mantra that since the public has listed health care as the their number two concern in polls, ObamaCare must pass! The White House and the Leadership refuse to acknowledge that ObamaCare is hated, or is the source of their current political problems.

The leadership is wearing out their members with I-know-there-are-problems-but-we-must-pass-something-RIGHT-NOW-and-something-is-better-than-nothing.

But Members are now clued into the fact that passing nothing means that the public and the voters in my district will not be angry with me.

A visit to a Yes or Undecided office is so much more unpleasant than a visit to a No. The Yes or Undecided office is bombarded with phone calls, and while the No offices get calls and visits, they happily can tell the visitor or caller the Congressman is voting No.

Fourth, the House Leadership and the White House has no respect for their own political deadlines and they cannot stop their own march off the health care cliff. Just like they cannot change the bill in ways that can make it pass, they cannot simply punt and work on it in the background. They are greedy. They want it all. They want it now. And they are not telling their own Members the truth about the Senate, which makes them dangerous to the rank and file.

The Speaker said she will have a vote if she gets certain assurances from the Senate. They will never, ever get the assurances. They do not exist. But the Speaker will not stop her vote.

For example, Senator Bayh warned today in a speech in Washington that more Democrats than the House thinks are opposed to reconciliation. When Democratic Senators hint and intimate that the votes for the “fixes” in reconciliation do not exist in the Senate — the House Leaders do not, and will not listen to reality.

The House leadership has refused to be honest about the length of time any health care process will last in the Senate, or the political pain that it will cause in the House by another six weeks. Dem staff report they are being told there will 20 hours of debate in Senate. (The staff actually believe this.)

The Dem leadership will not acknowledge that the most likely outcome is that the reconciliation process will fail in the Senate.

The Dems themselves will pull the plug on the Senate reconciliation, especially after the public outcry if the Vice President overrules the Senate Parliamentarian and Senator Byrd, changing the rules mid-game.

No one can answer this question: why should the Senate change their own bill to fit what the House wants, when they had the opportunity to do so, and did not? And make changes they do not want under duress?

All while the One calls for “courage” for his fellow Dems to commit political suicide, and follow their fanatical leadership who are making career ending errors.



RSS feed

105 Comments Leave a comment

Great points but....

redrunner262 Wednesday, March 17th at 2:21PM EST (link)

Drudge has a headline about Cardoza and Costa flipping to “yes” after a possible water deal in Cali. Confirmed or just speculation? Seems like there is no safe “no” vote at this point and there is no deal off the table to secure 216.

The problem is that you can't add that

Change Jar Conservative (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 2:29PM EST (link)

You can’t possibly add something like that into a reconciliation bill and expect it to pass the Senate so I don’t see how a congressman could expect this would be a smar t thing to agree to.

UNLESS, it’s something that the White House can do via executive order.

********
Formerly know as “Oz” in these parts

not part of health bill

redrunner262 Wednesday, March 17th at 2:39PM EST (link)

I don’t think this has anything to do with the HC bill. I believe this is a side deal.

http://nrcc.org/blog/blogitem.aspx?id=261

seems like BO and his ilk leaned on the department of interior.

Side deals (bribes) outside of the HC deal

mavericktime Wednesday, March 17th at 3:38PM EST (link)

That’s what will be going on. In fact, some of them may be hard to trace.

They have a name for this. I think it’s called “bribing.”

According the NRCC, the Feds have agreed to turn the water back on in California for these 2 votes...

Teresa in Fort Worth, TX (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:40PM EST (link)

“Save the Planet” my ass….

Fasten your seatbelts, it’s going to be a bumpy ride…..

 

Bribing....

jerseygalnny Thursday, March 18th at 12:25PM EST (link)

Why not give a catch name, like ‘Water for Votes.’

The river of corruption flows on

sarg01 Thursday, March 18th at 1:34PM EST (link)

It’s California Schemin’

 
 
 
 
 

Costa and Cardoza voted yes in November

mavericktime Wednesday, March 17th at 3:37PM EST (link)

These people are not “flipping.” Cardoza had signified that he might be open to switching his vote to no, but I don’t show that Costa had.

If the situation were reversed what do you

earlgrey (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 3:49PM EST (link)

Think the dems would say? I say still bug them about it. They need to know the stench of corruption is sticking To them whether their hands are dirty or not.

 

Yep - There's Not a Single CA Dem That Will Vote "No" - You Can Bank On It

IJB Wednesday, March 17th at 3:57PM EST (link)

CA Dems = complete nutters

Luckily, no vote count that I’ve seen has counted on ‘No’ votes from any CA Dem as being ‘necessary’ to defeat the bill.

IOW – CA Dem votes are totally irrelevant to whether this fails or passes…

 
 
 

Yeah, I'm confused here.

stigmo Wednesday, March 17th at 2:29PM EST (link)

Things seem to be breaking rapidly toward passage. Seems to me anyone who isn’t a confirmed NO is a YES…just holding out for the right deal.

 

Again, they've got themselves between a rock and a hard place.

eburke (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 2:38PM EST (link)

If they give all these whores the payoffs they demand, the whole nine yards goes back to the Senate and needs sixty to pass. If they put it in reconciliation, these will (better be) point of ordered to death. If they ‘deem’ it passed by the Slaughter Rule, can you say lawsuit heaven and based on previous case law, there are numerous grounds on which to overturn it (and yes, I do realize that we’re dealing with a Court which decided (the first go around) that McCain-Feingold didn’t violate free speech; Something tells me there that Anthony Kennedy (who’ll provide the 5th vote either way probably didn’t appreciate getting bashed during the SOTU.)

They’re in a box and they can’t get out IMHO.

“All that need be done for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing.”

Unified Patriots

I like the tax revolt idea...........

DrC Wednesday, March 17th at 2:40PM EST (link)

Sharpen up those pitchforks………

Curious cal1178

GJ Merits (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 3:46PM EST (link)

What type of tax revolt are we talking about here?

I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents….James Madison

If you want to go fast – go alone. If you want to go far – go together.

To win against tyranny you must embrace not only novel solutions, but fear of the unknown as well.

Go to Onlinetaxrevolt

fairtaxguy (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 9:14AM EST (link)

We have over 191,000 marchers now and there will be a live protest in Washington on April 15. It involves a new technology. Check it out!

I learn more here than anywhere I have been on the net. About politics, I mean.

 
 

Well, those who believe abortion is a grave moral evil

SoulEspresso Wednesday, March 17th at 3:47PM EST (link)

are obligated not to support federal funding of said evil.

Not true for a very good reason

GJ Merits (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:03PM EST (link)

A government takeover of healthcare all but guarantees the federal funding of abortion some point in the future. If the GOP had voted present or no on Stupak in the House before the original bill, we would not be here. The only option would have been to vote for federally funded abortion or as least present. The goal was not to improve ObamaCare so it would not pass. By improving it, you help it pass and open the floodgates for tax dollars for abortion.

The fact the GOP and pro-life groups do not understand strategic voting is a mystery to me. Actually, I KNOW the GOP does, but they voted for political expediency without thinking first. This poor performance on the House side prompted many conservative groups to inform the Senators that key-votes would be scored and any vote that improved the chances of ObamaCare passing would be scored as a vote for ObamaCare.

The only solution for the unborn is to KILL the bill, even if you have to take the hard votes and go against your instincts. Play chess with these bozos, not checkers.

I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents….James Madison

If you want to go fast – go alone. If you want to go far – go together.

To win against tyranny you must embrace not only novel solutions, but fear of the unknown as well.

Check my context.

SoulEspresso Wednesday, March 17th at 4:51PM EST (link)

I was speaking of taxpayers, and tax money going to support abortions.

I agree with you on procedural issues in Congress.

Got it, thanks

GJ Merits (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:54PM EST (link)

n/t

I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents….James Madison

If you want to go fast – go alone. If you want to go far – go together.

To win against tyranny you must embrace not only novel solutions, but fear of the unknown as well.

 
 

False logic

Finrod (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 6:42PM EST (link)

Abortion is the big dividing wedge between the Senate bill and the House bill. If the Stupak amendment hadn’t been in the House bill, then the Senate might have just passed the House bill and we wouldn’t be where we are now.

Let’s get down to brass tacks here. How much for the ape?

 
 
 
 

Missing a point

tnvolunteer Wednesday, March 17th at 11:44PM EST (link)

Y’all seem to have forgotten that the process is this: the House passes the Senate bill (with promises and fixes aside) and voila! We have Obamacare. The Prez has to sign the law BEFORE the reconciliation process…which the Senate will either refuse to take up or allow to die. Either way, we’re stuck, which is why it has to be DEFEATED in the House.

Thanks, Dan, for the uplift! Fog of war, indeed.

 
 

The spy who loved me............

DrC Wednesday, March 17th at 2:39PM EST (link)

“Russia had a spy who repeatedly warned of German attack during World War II. Russia ignored, ridiculed and discredited this spy. The spy did not know his reports were ridiculed”

My guess the Dems will put their spies to death also……….

The GOP is meeting this morning

cari Thursday, March 18th at 8:46AM EST (link)

and I hope they will consider holding a press conference with 41 senators, with a wheeled-in Byrd by their side letting the house Dems know that they will CHALLENGE and do everything to stop their reconciliation bill of “fixes”. Give Byrd the mike and let him tell them how he will not have his rule perverted.

If yesterday’s CBO score is true- over a trillion- then the “fixes” do not meet the standard for a reconciliation bill and will NOT be considered.

I hope the GOP doesn’t wait too patiently for their letter to make it through the Dem leadership plexiglass they’re holding their members behind. Get out if front and get it on TV!

 
 

If they had the votes

student Wednesday, March 17th at 2:47PM EST (link)

If they had the votes they would have already passed this. It is absolutely amazing though how many Democrats have turned lemming, marching arm in arm over the cliff. Anybody who lives in the real world would understand that the wave of hatred and rejection they are inciting by deliberately spitting in the face of the majority of voters, cramming this unwanted abortion of a bill down the throats of the majority of voters will end their careers. Yet so many are content to follow the Judas Goat, perhaps the Judas Lemmings that are Obama, Pelosi and Reid as they march off the cliff.

Yeah,

cari Wednesday, March 17th at 3:49PM EST (link)

the house has reminded me of the second stanza in the poem by Alfred, Lord Tennyson:

“Forward, the Light Brigade!”
Was there a man dismay’d?
Not tho’ the soldier knew
Someone had blunder’d:
Theirs not to make reply,
Theirs not to reason why,
Theirs but to do and die:
Into the valley of Death
Rode the six hundred.

Now it’s starting to sound like Mutiny on the Bounty. At some point, the leadership can ask just so much before the underlings rebel.

Great work, Dan! Thanks for keeping hope alive!

At least the soldiers in the poem

momofthecastle (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 9:48AM EST (link)

were following orders out of honor. They had promised to follow orders and fight for the cause, and they kept that promise.
The Democrats have sworn to uphold the Constitution, and they are fighting to do anything but. They are fighting for themselves, and to for a subversion of the government of this country as defined in the Constitution.
The stanza may remind you of the House Democrats, but please do not think that there is any real comparison.

 
 
 

Call Your Representatives Now!

Sheet Anchor (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 2:50PM EST (link)

Call them now, and use their local numbers. Tell everyone you know to call them now! This is a fight for the soul and future of the United States of America; for the country we all love, and have inherited and preserved out of the blood and treasure of our forefathers.

Will the American citizens stand and fight as our great Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen, Guardsmen, and United States Marines, past and present, always stand and fight for our sacred liberty? This is a seminole moment in American history. We will live as one nation under God, or under government? Now is the time of decision! You must act now! Now is the time to let your voices be heard as never before. Where is the march on Washington? Where is the American spirit that never quits? Where is the American spirit that says “no” and “never again” to our enemies, and backs it up at all costs? Our soldiers are willing to die for this country’s preservation. Shall we not stand up on their behalf while they face bullets and bombs so we do not have to?

If you called already, call them again! If you have e-mailed them, do it again. If you have told your relatives, friends, neighbors, and co-workers, tell them to call and email, and fax them again! Stop what you’re doing and do it now! Our great republic is at stake!

Think of your children; and do it for them. Look into their faces; and then pick-up the phone and get on your computer, and let them know, we are still Americans, and we will not accept tyranny from anyone – foreign or domestic. We will never surrender to state control of our lives. Tell them that when you call and email them. Tell them we are not socialists, and we will not live under it now or ever. Tell them like Churchill “We will fight them in the air; on the land; and on the seas. We will never surrender.” Call them now! E-mail them now! Fax them now! Let them feel the people’s power. Do it now!

SheetAnchor on March 17, 2010 at 1:33 PM

 

Mr Perrin, your reporting on this throughout has been excellent

Vassar Bushmills (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 3:21PM EST (link)

Keep it up. For constant on-the-spot reporting i know of few on the blogosphere who can come close, Everyone here understands (or should) the speculative nature of the things you are reporting. What is, is. It will all unfold.

The only thing we can do is drop everything else and keep up the heat, until this plays out. You are providing most of that heat. A fever pitch, which, for our part, I hope we can pass on. That is the idea, isn’t it? We’re past looking at this like an academic exercise. Maybe later.

For fun, afterwards you may want to go back and draw a matrix of all the false leads and whispers that didn’t pan out.

If they pass out Pulitzers…

 

Andy Stern leaning on Democrats

mavericktime Wednesday, March 17th at 3:31PM EST (link)

http://www.npr.org/blogs/politicaljunkie/2010/03/todays_junkie_segment_on_totn_10.html

“Rep. Dennis Kucinich of Ohio, one of 39 Democrats who voted against the health care bill in the House last November, announced this morning that he will vote yes this time around … even though he says the bill is far from perfect.

But other Democrats who vote no may be threatened by either a primary challenge or one from an independent in November. We’ll have Andy Stern, president of the Service Employees International Union, as our special guest. Stern is ready to take on — or take out — Democrats who vote no on the bill … especially if they are responsible for it going down to defeat.”

 

I suspect the vote or lack thereof on Obamacare

dvdmsr (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 3:32PM EST (link)

may be the equivalent to a vote of no confidence for Speaker Pelosi.

Maybe, moderate Dems and Republicans ought to be secretly conspiring to push Pelosi out of the Speaker chair for a more moderate Dem. Now that’s an interesting rumor to stir up the already confused House leadership.

Personal Responsibility Conservative

What ought to be happening

SoulEspresso Wednesday, March 17th at 3:52PM EST (link)

is that all those “undecideds” who are “tipping yes” have already put their own heads together and decided to lie to the whips or POTUS … and when it comes to an actual vote (Slaughter or otherwise), they in fact send Obamacare down in flames.

They break the career of the Speaker and take a major step towards saving their own jobs in November. They also restore some of Congress’s credibility with the public.

 

I know it would never happen, but

wgsampson Wednesday, March 17th at 4:08PM EST (link)

it would be cool if a group of “moderate” Dems got together, at least 30+, and held a press conference. And if they explained how there is no way in hell they could support a piece of legislation so packed with scandal, bribes, payoffs, etc… as this one. In addition they could say that there is no way they could ever in the future support any of the current Dem leadership because of their perversion of the process and, more importantly, the Constitution. They wouldn’t have to worry about reelection then. Of course it is only a dream, it would require a politician, a Dem politician, with principals and balls.

a dream

tnvolunteer Wednesday, March 17th at 11:46PM EST (link)

wg, I do love the world you inhabit… That would be fabulous!

 
 
 

Don't Know What To Believe

crosley (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 3:37PM EST (link)

I hear different counts from both sides. I tend to now lean that the Democrats will end up passing it one way or another, but I’m still somewhat optimistic. Pelosi has such a large margin of “no” votes from the first time around that I would think peeling a few more off is very possible.

I’m an American before I’m a Republican, so I don’t want this monstrosity passed, but that being said, it would be hard to argue that Democrats will be much worse off in the coming elections, and it will almost certainly doom Obama as a one term President. If the Democrats play games like the “Slaughter” route, I could see them losing the country for a generation. It will look incredibly illegitimate, almost coup-like.

I see very little of this bill actually being enacted if it is passed. It’s completely unrealistic, and most of it will be repealed, overturned, or ignored before it really goes into effect. Not because the country will suddenly become ultra-conservative, just because it’s just not feasible without absolutely collapsing affordable health care and destroying state and federal budgets.

The Dems have NO idea

GJ Merits (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 3:52PM EST (link)

The rhetoric on the Tea Party sites is hearing up. Dan Riehl’s post on the matter has a comments section that makes me want to cheer. The Dems know they are in for now just long term gains, but possibly short term serious damage if they create a constitutional crisis. They are really walking a fine line here and the native are getting VERY restless.

Actually, I think many of them are beginning to realize this and I am predicting an avalanche in the no direction as reality begins to dawn on these guys they are in for some serious blowback.

I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents….James Madison

If you want to go fast – go alone. If you want to go far – go together.

To win against tyranny you must embrace not only novel solutions, but fear of the unknown as well.

 
 

Peelousy is like a raptor on meth

louisiana (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 3:40PM EST (link)

She is stalking her prey with meat & blood in her teeth & under her claws. Meanwhile, Oberstar (MN) is voting yes. Dan, thanks for all your hard work & dedication in keeping RS informed. I think we all need another pep talk!

 

NRO and local papers in St. Louis are reporting that Costello (D-IL) is a firm no

RealQuiet (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 3:44PM EST (link)

His staffers at his office confirm. That is a yes to no switch ladies and gents. Very good news.

Peter Roskam (my rep) today reported on WLSam

redneck_hippie (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 3:50PM EST (link)

that there are 6 undecided Illinois reps. Wonder if that makes it 5.


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

 

Costello is going to vote for this

teridavisnewman (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 10:47AM EST (link)

Costello isn’t afraid enough of me to stand up to Pelosi on this. I’ve been hammering him on his “Yes” vote for this since the primary and he may tell you that he’s not going to vote for this but he will. He doesn’t think I can beat him if he votes yes and he will use the people of East St Louis as an excuse to pass this–and he’s in the pocket of the unions who will not support him if he doesn’t vote for it. His staff has a history of telling people what they want to hear but mark my words: When Pelosi comes up with something sweet enough he will vote yes. He’s doing a Blagojevich thing: What’s it worth to you to get the vote and Pelosi will come up with something. Ole Jerry is in the catbird seat by playing both ends against the middle and he’s not afraid of me right now. I’m going to beat him in November no matter what and he’s going to cash in for a yes vote–look at his record–he always does.

Teri Davis Newman
2010 Republican Nominee for Congress
2012 Candidate for Congress
12th Congressional District of Illinois
www.terinewman.com

 
 

Dan, thank you SO MUCH for your tireless efforts on our country's behalf -

Teresa in Fort Worth, TX (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 3:49PM EST (link)

you have pulled many of us back from the brink more times than I care to count. God willing, some of these moderate Dems will realize exactly what is going on and will decide to take a chance that maybe they can save their seat in November.

Is there any way that we can get this post forwarded to the offices of the Representatives who are still undecided? If their leadership isn’t telling them these things, it’s a sure bet that reading this might make all the difference to them. If nothing else, they could have some peace in their Congressional offices….

Fasten your seatbelts, it’s going to be a bumpy ride…..

 

What Dems are doing is unconscionable

mavericktime Wednesday, March 17th at 3:55PM EST (link)

They are totally dividing the country.

 

Republican Whip Count Says Dems Have 206

mavericktime Wednesday, March 17th at 4:01PM EST (link)

According to the American Spectator:

“The House Republican whip team just held a conference call in which they said that the Democrats have 206 yes votes for the health care bill. They need 216 to pass it. There are currently 51 Democrats who are said to be undecided and the leadership can afford to lose 37 Democrats in all, which sounds like a pretty tough road for opponents of the bill (without the Stupak language on abortion, all Republicans are expected to vote no).”

http://spectator.org/blog/2010/03/17/republican-whip-team-says-dems

I guess it depends on how squishy those 51 are

stigmo Wednesday, March 17th at 4:38PM EST (link)

Are they legitimately undecided, or undecided like the jerks we knew would vote yes all along?

 

Wait a minute, that math doesn't add up

Finrod (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 6:51PM EST (link)

Even if there are no Democrats that are a solid no, there are only 253 Democrats in the House (assuming Wikipedia’s numbers are correct) and 206 + 51 is more than 253.

Let’s get down to brass tacks here. How much for the ape?

 
 

Great Post

jimbo51 (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:01PM EST (link)

I look forward to your posts and pray that you are correct. Everyone in MSM seems to think it’s going to pass. As bad as the things are that we know about this bill, there are many other nuggets hidden within that haven’t even received coverage. I just posted about a hidden single-payer provision. Lord knows what else this bill contains.

 

House to (try) and force vote TOMORROW

tngal (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:04PM EST (link)

“House Republicans leaders will attempt Thursday to force a vote on a resolution that would block Democrats from deeming the Senate health care reform bill as passed”

You can catch the full article at Roll call..

http://www.rollcall.com/news/44297-1.html

(I had posted elsewhere that republicans were planning something tomorrow and this is it apparently. Its a little confusing to me as I forget now all the different ways the dems plan on ramming hc through. So if anybody can figure out what tomorrow’s move means for us , please come back and ‘splain in english pleaze. thanks )

Awesome!!

RealQuiet (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:07PM EST (link)

I really like their timing on this

redneck_hippie (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:19PM EST (link)

It’s been just long enough for all the collectivists to be crowded together out on a shakey limb titled “Slaughter trick.” Trying to pass a resolution is a way to tell all the spectators, undecideds, and assorted lefties to “look here!” We have a saw, and though it may not be able to cut through the tree, it certainly will create more furor in your constituencies. This is the way you turn up the heat.


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

read story 3 times, still confused

tngal (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:30PM EST (link)

Here’s another graph from the article.

“The resolution, which requires the House to take an up-or-down vote on the Senate-passed health care bill, will be introduced by recent party-switcher Rep. Parker Griffith (R-La.)….. ). ”

Ok that made sense. But then this quote

“…tthe resolution would be offered as a previous question to a non-health-care-related rule on the suspension authority — a motion that is expected to hit the floor Thursday afternoon. ”

Sounds like sausage making to me. Totally lost me.

 
 

It puts the wavering Dems between a rock and a hard place.

eburke (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:31PM EST (link)

The GOP leadership has crafted a resolution which would specifically prohibit the “Slaughter Solution” from being used.

If you’re a Dem from a Red district trying to figure out a way to thread the needle between getting reelected and being fitted for a body cast courtesy of Pelosi’s goons, you’re hosed.

If you vote against the GOP resolution, you’ve just gone on record as supporting an unconstitutional, backroom, sleazy method of passing healthcare reform. If you vote for it, and it passes, the only way to move HCR forward is to vote for the Senate Bill sans the Reconciliation Bill (if and when it ever sees the light of day) which means you’re now on record as being in favor of the Cornhusker Kickback, the Louisiana Purchase, taxes on Cadillac plans, and $500 billion in Medicare cuts.

So unless you’re planning to vote “yes” to the GOP resolution, and “no” on HCR, you’re hosed. The campaign ads write themselves.

As much as I smack around the GOP Leadership for the lack of testicular fortitude when we need them the most, this was a brilliant strategic move.

“All that need be done for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing.”

Unified Patriots

thanks eburke,

tngal (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:38PM EST (link)

got it now. Why couldn’t they just say that? ( testicular fortitude notwithstanding. )

 

Call your rep and ask how they intend to vote on this resolution

stigmo Wednesday, March 17th at 4:49PM EST (link)

It gives you something new to talk about and it makes it clear you’re watching carefully.

 

Eburke, how can they bring the to the floor for a vote?

reallyfive Wednesday, March 17th at 5:10PM EST (link)

While I think this is a great idea, I thought Pelosi had control over what legislation can be brought to the floor for a vote?

They simply need to offer it as a resolution

eburke (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 6:39PM EST (link)

(see upthread) and if a majority vote to bring it to the floor, then it has to be brought to the floor. Usually these are no-brainer ‘follow your leadership’ type votes but because of the ramifications of this particular resolution, a vote against bringing it to the floor will be played (and rightly so) as a vote in favor of the Slaughter Rule and more evidence that the Dems just flat don’t want to take a vote on this steaming pile.

“All that need be done for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing.”

Unified Patriots

Thanks, Eburke, for the House 101 Lesson. n/t

reallyfive Wednesday, March 17th at 10:30PM EST (link)

Expect the bill to arrive Friday, reallyfive :-)

eburke (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 9:10AM EST (link)

Glad I could be of some semblance of help.

“All that need be done for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing.”

Unified Patriots

 
 

Thanks for the explanation, eburke.

cari Wednesday, March 17th at 10:31PM EST (link)

What a great move! Finally, the Repubs are using their brains and their spines. This will expose where they all stand. Brilliant!

 
 
 
 
 

The question for Dan

Composer_Man Wednesday, March 17th at 4:11PM EST (link)

I suspect with all this back and forth that the one question we’d all like to ask Dan is, “Given all you know and have seen over the last three days, what chance do you give the Dems of passing HCR as of today?”

If I may point out, he answered it

redneck_hippie (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:14PM EST (link)

here

http://www.redstate.com/dan_perrin/2010/03/17/slaughter-rule-gives-no-votes-cover-from-the-left-the-right/#comment-8861


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

 
 

Dan Thank You

Scope (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:26PM EST (link)

Did you take your combat Helmet and Boots with you to Washington? You deserve a medal for putting yourself right on that battlefield. This requires more than the normal hip waders.

 

This is a war for America's soul

Sheet Anchor (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:28PM EST (link)

Mavericktime, as implied by your comment, America is in a spiritual war. It is a war for the soul of the country. This health care battle is simply the foremost manifestation of the war – socialism versus capitalism; state control versus individual liberty; whether we remain one nation under God, or a nation under men.

It seems that the socialists have been on the offensive, while the forces of liberty have been on defense. The question is, whether those who believe in individual liberty are willing to fight for it with all the ferocity of the socialists.

So far, I am wondering where the million man march on Washington is, given that this is a monumental legislative act, which will fundamentally change the nature of the relationship between the Government in America, and its citizens, in a way that is likely catastrophic for the country. Why is no prominent conservative calling for a million people to show up on Capital Hill? It should be obvious that bribery and payoffs are effective in buying votes on Capital Hill. The only countervening force would be the people rising up and demonstrating in such large numbers that it scares the socialists politicians in thinking they will lose their jobs. Short of this, the socialists are for sale; and it is the peoples’ fault for tolerating such corruption among their elected representatives – by being too silent for too long. Freedom requires action to obtain it, and action to sustain it. Thus far, said action has been too littlel and may be too late. The next few days will tell. Hence, call your Congressman; and tell everyone you know to do likewise.

 

Joe Barton (R) on Facebook page says CBO score came in at over $1 trillion per his Facebook page?

RealQuiet (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:30PM EST (link)

Being reported by people over at Hot Air. http://www.facebook.com/home.php?filter=lf#!/profile.php?id=1340283369&ref=ts

Sorry, don’t use Facebook. Don’t want feds tracking me :)

RealQuiet,

redneck_hippie (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:36PM EST (link)

I re-activated my account to copy Joe’s “wall” posting from FB.

Joe Barton health care issue is still up in the air…..the Congressional budget office score has come in at over 1 trillion $..yes …..1 trillion……if the bill is not posted by 6 pm today< we cant vote on it saturday…stay tuned
about an hour ago

He posted it. Now I have to go back and de-activate my account, Again.


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

wondered what the holdup was on the CBO

tngal (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 5:58PM EST (link)

They’ve been screaming they’ll vote when the ‘final score’ came in, and it was suppose to be in days ago. Kinda figured it was going to be just a smidge over budget. No biggee. We’ll just print some more cash.

 
 

The Reconciliation Bill

dajeeps (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 6:37PM EST (link)

isn’t in yet. It doesn’t matter what the score is because they’re still bribing and for all we know the public option will be back. As Nancy says, “We have to pass it so we can see what’s in it.”

The Obama interview tonight was troubling because it sounds like the plan is to vote Slaughter Solution as to whether they will reform HC and then put whatever they want in it, even a major remake… like maybe it will be full-blown single-payer that will only have to pass the Senate with 51 votes.

…”I would quarrel with both parties and with every individual of each, before I would subjugate my understanding, or prostitute my tongue or pen to either.”
–John Adams

 
 

Do they know if there are enough votes to vote yea on the Slaughter rule change?

Scope (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:30PM EST (link)

Is that the votes that the Dems are working hard to get? rather than the vote on the Senate bill?

Right now they don't have the votes to do diddly-squat

eburke (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 4:34PM EST (link)

or they’d be voting as we speak.

The reason they haven’t outlined their ‘plan’ yet is because after all the time they’ve spent wheeling and dealing and figuring out ways to circumvent Scott Brown’s election and minor details like the US Constitution, nothing they’ve been able to cobble together gets them to 216 yet.

“All that need be done for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing.”

Unified Patriots

They still don't have their votes - as evidenced by

glorybee Wednesday, March 17th at 5:10PM EST (link)

AFL-CIO President Richard Trumka called in to discuss “excise taxes” because they need to raise the tax on ‘cadillac’ plans to offset the new $1 trillion CBO score.

 

Stupak: My 12 or 13 are not peeling off (video)

redneck_hippie (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 5:45PM EST (link)

NRCC vid post via freerepublic

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheNRCC#p/a/u/0/Lmbo1YaOXpM


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

*this* is the best news I've heard all day...or week.

eburke (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 6:48PM EST (link)

If Stupak’s dozen is holding firm, ain’t no way San Fran Nan’s got the votes to pass this thing. These 12 voted yes last time because the Stupak ammendment was added. That mean the Botox Queen’s gonna have to find 12 no’s to flip to yes to replace them. That ain’t gonna happen.

What I really like about this is the way Stupak is absolutely pwning Pelosi on this. By not releasing the names of the 12 it makes it impossible for the leadership to try and pry ‘em off one at a time. And what I *really* enjoyed was hearing Stupak say “I’ve seen those lists and they’re not even close.”

Heh.Heh.

“All that need be done for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing.”

Unified Patriots

Did it look like to you that Stupak was the

redneck_hippie (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 7:26PM EST (link)

cat who ate the canary? Just a couple of days ago he sounded bitter. This clip seemed like he had a cartoon bubble with the words, “we’re starting over again” above his head. That is what Stupak wants at this point. To start over from scratch.


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

God bless him! nt

cari Wednesday, March 17th at 8:14PM EST (link)
 
 

Daniel Lipinski was on Greta tonight ...

joayn (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 12:23AM EST (link)

and stated that he was a firm no, and as one of the Stupak dozen, told Greta they are all standing firm on no.

America is an idea; a noble idea that essentially boils down to the shocking belief that the masses are in fact not asses. John Nolte

 
 
 
 

End Game

neoavatara (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 5:10PM EST (link)

Don’t be surprised if Pelosi gets the votes, by trickery if need be.

That said, I still don’t see how it passes the Senate on reconciliation. Many of the changes are going to be struggles.

And then, what happens if the Senate changes something? It will have to go BACK to the House to be revoted.

This thing is a mess.

http://neoavatara.com/blog/?p=10387

www.neoavatara.com/blog

No, that's not right.

cwilson (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 2:08AM EST (link)

If this gets thru the house at all — “deem and pass” or otherwise — then no one cares what happens in the Senate. The bill goes to Obama’s desk and he signs it, and we have the Senate version of Obamacare. Why would ANYbody in the White House or Senate want to prolong this agony simply to help out lowly Congressmen?

They won’t.

If ye love wealth better than liberty, the tranquility of servitude than the animated contest of freedom — go home from us in peace. We ask not your counsels or arms. Crouch down and lick the hands which feed you. May your chains sit lightly upon you, and may posterity forget that you were our countrymen! –Samuel Adams

 
 

The Chicago Way

Stan(ley) Pruss (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 5:21PM EST (link)

Illinois, especially Chicago, politicians always ask,”Where’s mine?” How many bribes will it take to pass HC? See Tribune’s John Kass at http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/columnists/ct-met-kass-0317-20100316,0,4939258.column

 

If this gets through the House

DRayRaven Wednesday, March 17th at 5:32PM EST (link)

via “deem and pass,” Obama will simply sign the bill. The Senate Dems won’t waste much time on reconciliation.

It will be up to the SCOTUS to put a stop to this.

Bingo, DRayRaven!

ZootSuit (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 5:57PM EST (link)

The Senate Democrats will not waste time on reconciliation because they have much broader bases of constituencies. Once and if the House passes the Senate version, the Senators won’t touch this thing with a twenty-foot pole.

***** Unrepentant African-American nationalist, Unapologetic African-American conservative!

 
 

Actually, there is a perfectly rationale reason why the Dems are pushing ObamaCare ...

ZootSuit (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 5:55PM EST (link)

THEIR constituency wants it. And for that reason, I fear Nancy Pelosi has a better than even chance of passing the Senate version.

From everything I read and hear, across the country about half of the people oppose ObamaCare. But about a third actually support the socialist monstrosity. Indeed, some few of those who oppose it oppose HCR because it does not go far enough: like the Senate bill lacking a public-option. Consider, completely aside from her being the Speaker, Nancy Pelosi will look better to the “Lefty loonies” in her district if ObamaCare happens than if it does not. And THEY are the ones who put her and her ilk in office and keep them there, not us.

The unfortunate truth of the matter is that the majority of individual constituents of most of the Democratic Congressmen want socialized medicine. Despite the fact that a majority of Americans across the country don’t. The Democrats are simply playing to their constituents; and if they can wrangle an earmark and bacon for them, too, then they look even better.

Strangely enough, the model that Obama and the Democrats are following is almost “Karl Rovian”: appeal to your base and not the “moderate middle” for support. And I say this as someone who truly believes that George W. Bush was, at heart, nothing more than a moderate himself. But like it or not, Karl Rove’s strategy worked; at least in the short-term. My fear is that it may work for Obama and Pelosi, at least in the short-term, too.

But hey, unless I am misunderstood, I say keep fighting and keep calling in opposition to this monstrosity. Especially if you personally live in a district represented by a Democrat. Again, they are following what they reasonably think is in their best interest: we still have the opportunity to convince hem that it is not.

And more, long-term, we as conservatives need to stop the name-calling and engage in conversation with the third of the population who see nothing wrong with socialized medicine. And yes, conservatives do engage in name-calling just like the other side. (Of note, I do want to make it perfectly clear that RedState is an exceptionally erudite and civil website.) But unlike them, we have the facts, logic and reality on our side. I personally have convinced a few (not all, not even most, but a few) liberals I know who were initially in support of ObamaCare that socialized medicine will be a disaster.

Because ultimately that is the only way not only to stop ObamaCare but also get this country back on its track to renewed greatness. We must do more than win the ballots, we must win the minds. Because unless we do that, we’ll simply get more so-called “conservatives” who when they get in power, lead this country down the same path of socialism themselves.

***** Unrepentant African-American nationalist, Unapologetic African-American conservative!

I agree with this

Leopard1996 (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 6:44PM EST (link)

I also believe that they want to pass this for two other reasons.

1. They know that the reform bill as is will fail and fail miserably and have everyone start screaming for the government to save us from this failure.

2. They need to show that they can govern, Bush was far from my favorite on domestic policies, and the point from when we pushed out Hussein and up to about 2004, his policies were kind of a joke, but Bush was able to consistently get authorization for the Iraq war funding, and other things passed and signed into law. His only true failure was Social Security Reform.

“The accumluated filth of all their sex and murder will foam up about their waists and all the whores and politicians will look up and shout, “Save Us!”….and I’ll look down and whisper, “No”…The Watchmen

 
 

Don't bother coming home

gohogs Wednesday, March 17th at 7:58PM EST (link)

if you vote for this.You hear me Vick schnieder!!!!!! Probably not yet.But you will.

 

Obamacare took a dive on Intrade, 70% -> 35%

Return to Revolution (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 9:03PM EST (link)

http://www.intrade.com/?request_operation=main&request_type=action&checkHomePage=true

Out of hand Constitutional fetishist

Interesting. Last night it did the same thing

mbecker908 (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 9:24PM EST (link)

dropped to the 30′s and bounced back up to the 60′s first thing this morning.

What do you suspect this means?

Mary Beth (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 9:41PM EST (link)

Do you think this is telling about something or are you just intrigued that there’s such volatility or something else?

“A political party cannot be all things to all people. It must represent certain fundamental beliefs which must not be compromised to political expediency, or simply to swell its numbers.” ~ Ronald Reagan

 

Is Soros trying to game Intratrade?

The_Gadfly (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 11:06PM EST (link)

He made his money gaming the exchange markets, and he’s gone off the edge now that he thinks he has more money than God.

 
 

It's back up by 35 points

mavericktime Wednesday, March 17th at 10:11PM EST (link)

Now over 70.

It seems like it’s being manipulated.

I have absolutely no idea what it means.

mbecker908 (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 9:08AM EST (link)

I just thought it was an interesting couple of data points. And at 6:07 PDT it’s back to 75.

This was supposed to be a response to Mary Beth. nt

mbecker908 (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 9:08AM EST (link)
 
 
 

InTrade Cannot Be Trusted This Early

Ausonius (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 10:26PM EST (link)

We have seen too many false indicators from InTrade: in most cases, only hours before an event will it give a reliable trend.

To be sure, in some things you will not find such volatility, but yes, it can and is being manipulated by people playing games with the system.

Ausonius: 310-395 A.D. Teacher, Poet, Consul, General, Farmer.

Personal Tutor to the future St. Paulinus of Nola and to young Gratian, heir to the throne during the turbulent final years of the Western Roman Empire. When his former student Gratian was assassinated, Ausonius threw up his hands and retired to his farm in Gaul. Rome was captured by barbarians 14 years after his death.

Cato@rock.com

 

In fairness to The Big 0

The_Gadfly (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 11:10PM EST (link)

(wow, never thought I’d write that) he doesn’t really have much choice on Healthcare. His opening ante before the election was All In. If he gets stopped here, he’s a lame duck before the midterm elections. Yeah, it was an idiotic mistake and an experienced pol would have tried to walk it back, but he’s never had to even try to do that in his very short past.

That's if you believe that Obama cares at all

Michael Dugas (Diary) Wednesday, March 17th at 11:40PM EST (link)

about his standings in the polls or his “legacy”. I am beginning to believe that he and some of his cohorts in leadership want a financial disaster and constitutional conflict in the hopes it will lead to changes in both areas that suit their socialist/marxist beliefs. Their behavior has been so counter intuitive and placing their seats at the table of power in such danger that their has to be an agenda behind it all to risk it all.
I don’t think Obama cares one bit about his legacy or poll numbers if he can get this nightmare passed.

Intro to Federalist Papers; section 5;
paragraph 4.
“…dangerous ambition more often lurks behind the specious mask of zeal for the rights of the people than under the zeal for a firm and efficient government.”

Remember: A Citizen on the dole is a Liberal Vote at the Polls.
END ENTITLEMENTS!

Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum !

I'm not assuming he care about his legacy

The_Gadfly (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 6:36AM EST (link)

in the classical sense. I see it more as a two-pronged attack plan where one is as you describe. The other is that he continues to advance socialist agendas from his position as President. But to continue the prong I’m describing he can’t be a lame duck. So he really is trapped because the one thing by which he can’t abide is a failure to advance the socialist agenda.

I Don't think he looks at it as being trapped

Michael Dugas (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 7:24AM EST (link)

He’s all in on Health Care because of what it will do for advancing that
socialist agenda. Even if he loses the next election he would consider it a success as long as health care passes and sticks. The long term effects of this legislation would benefit his socialist desires and leave his party in control in the future and as always the winners write the history for a time anyways.
I so hope this abomination doesn’t pass.

Intro to Federalist Papers; section 5;
paragraph 4.
“…dangerous ambition more often lurks behind the specious mask of zeal for the rights of the people than under the zeal for a firm and efficient government.”

Remember: A Citizen on the dole is a Liberal Vote at the Polls.
END ENTITLEMENTS!

Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum !

A fish doesn't look at is being trapped in water either,

The_Gadfly (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 9:03PM EST (link)

that doesn’t change the objective reality that he is.

My primary point here is that we can’t read into his motives, because there are multiple plausible explanations for what he is doing. Even if you were to assume he was afraid of losing seats, realistically he still doesn’t have any freedom of action. If he loses on this, his signature issue, he isn’t likely to be able to advance any other issues either. He is trapped, and while it is something he may not consciously recognize, it is affecting him. Furthermore like a trapped animal, that means he’s fighting harder, meaner, and nastier than he would if there were an escape route. We need to recognize that as we fight him.

And no, I’m not advocating providing him with any escape route other than the one Republicans and the bulk of the country has given him: Start over and negotiate in good faith.

 
 
 
 
 

Allahpundit on HotAir has a good summary

mavericktime Wednesday, March 17th at 11:37PM EST (link)

http://hotair.com/archives/2010/03/17/obamacare-whip-counts-pelosi-in-trouble/

He thinks the progressive blog Firedoglake.com has the best take on where things stand.

FDL sees the count as tied at 208 each. Their assessment is that the people on the fence are by and large conservative Democrats, some of them pro-life. Five voted against the House health care bill in September, and 10 voted for it. But, of these 10, there are some Stupak Democrats.

Dick Morris says that Pelosi won’t go for the Slaughter rule vote, but will have an up or down vote on the Senate bill. However, they will have the reconciliation bill that will have all of their fixes, and with that they will be trusting that the Senate will have the votes to pass it.

I think opponents of the bill have to hope for two things. One – that the CBO score keeps coming back as too high. It came in over $1 trillion today, according to Joe Wilson. It would need to come in closer to $900 billion and have language that says that the bill will reduce the deficit. This would be needed to give Blue Dogs cover to vote for the bill.

Second, we need to hope that Waxman was serious that he wasn’t going to negotiate with the Stupak Democrats on abortion language. But, what was Pelosi’s meeting with the House pro-choice women about today? Are they going to cave in to Stupak’s demands? I don’t see Stupak or his group backing down otherwise.

In any case, House Democrats have to have assurances from Senate Democrats that they will adopt the reconciliation bill. If the Senate Democrats double-cross them, they’ll be sucker-punched again.

List

proudgop (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 8:51AM EST (link)

Does anyone have fill list of those opposing this bill ( Dems)

We have Stupak, Boren, Skeleton, Donnelly, Ellsworth, Boucher, Holden, Minnick, Edwards,

I believe Chandler and Herseth-Sandler are too but not 100% sure.

who else?

The List Is Up at "The Hill" (nt)

IJB Thursday, March 18th at 9:25AM EST (link)
 
 

Ever see a bunch of kids

laura_lee Thursday, March 18th at 9:09AM EST (link)

on the playground so crazed with adrenalin that they bowl everyone else over in their haste to continue their game? Same thing with this bunch. THeir so myopic that they don’t even notice what’s going on peripherally. But Myopia can be corrected by the lens of election day, as long as the American people are continually reminded of their sandbox bully tactics.

 

CBO Score - $940 billion - starts the clock

mavericktime Thursday, March 18th at 10:15AM EST (link)

They’ve got their CBO score and it’s more than $900 billion. I guess they’re off to the races now though.

“The CBO projects President Obama’s health care bill will cost $940 billion and cut the deficit by $130 billion over the next decade, The Hill reports.

The bill is more expensive than the House or Senate bills, ‘though the CBO said that the current bill, which builds off the Senate’s bill with changes to it, would make larger reductions in the deficit.’

‘The release of the CBO score sets into motion a 72-hour endgame on health care that could mean a vote in the House on the package as early as Sunday morning.’”

http://politicalwire.com/archives/2010/03/18/cbo_estimate_starts_the_clock_for_health_care_vote.html#ixzz0iXOB7Fms

 

"Fog of war" well put.

archer52 Thursday, March 18th at 10:36AM EST (link)

I was wondering what was happening. Either she is brilliant or she is insane.

I’m voting for insane, like should be on heavy meds and probably is, insane. God help her poor husband. He must spend nights drinking scotch and cleaning his pistol, hoping for an “accident.”

 

starting a new thread- Anyone received their Census yet? Can't believe the questions!!! Like DOB and name. ID THEFT!!!

archer52 Thursday, March 18th at 11:11AM EST (link)

Is it me or did they not ask personal questions last time??

I was going to fill it out, thinking out hard could it be, since it is the short form. Noooo. They want not only the basic stuff, but the names, DOBs, ages of EVERYONE in your home or stays in your home.

What in the world does my DOB and name have to do with any census? Or the names and dob’s of your children? They cannot justify it. Outside the issue of constitutionality, the threat of ID theft is immense. You put it back in your mailbox and you have just given a thief your kid’s ID. It happens all the time. Your kid will be “working” in the farm fields picking tomatoes, or applying for a credit card which will be run up and never paid. I WORKED THOSE CASES!!!

Frankly, this government, and I’m not only blaming the left here, has lost its collective mind. Seize land, restrict water right until people starve, force taxes and premiums on citizens, deny healthcare or fine people for getting it. Madness.

And it is our fault. They govern because we allow them to.

Archer52, the Morning Briefing is always an open thread

Achance (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 11:30AM EST (link)

for stuff like this. And, yeah, I have it sitting here at my desk and I’m thinking all thay get is the information necessary to enumerate, not identify.

In Vino Veritas

Achance, thanks for reply. I hate to be paranoid but...

archer52 Thursday, March 18th at 12:22PM EST (link)

It is not like I couldn’t find out everything about you when I was working intel. But I had to work to get it. Research local and state records, sit surveillance, run tags, etc. It wouldn’t take long to see who lived in your house or who “stayed” in your house. But that was because I thought and had probable cause to believe you were involved in crime. More importantly, and this is really important, if it turned out I was wrong or the facts proved there was nothing there, by law I had to destroy my work or secure it in a place where only a limited and cleared few could see it. I couldn’t keep it. And I certainly couldn’t mail it around.

So why does the government need the names, DOBs and ages of everyone here? I understand the sex/race issue, I don’t like it but I get it. Even the ages aren’t that bad. But names?? No.

And if they send an ACORN employee around, they won’t get it either. Especially a former felon employee. What are they nuts?

 
 

Just tell them how many...

whimsley (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 4:05PM EST (link)

Archer52, I worked the Census because I had been unemployed for over a year and needed a job…any job. When I return my form, they will have the information they need to count me. I will supply my race and gender because I don’t care who knows that. Hopefully, anyone could tell by looking at me anyway.

 

Just tell them how many...

whimsley (Diary) Thursday, March 18th at 4:05PM EST (link)

Archer52, I worked the Census because I had been unemployed for over a year and needed a job…any job. When I return my form, they will have the information they need to count me. I will supply my race and gender because I don’t care who knows that. Hopefully, anyone could tell by looking at me anyway.